Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Miss The Children's Questions


Recommended Posts

Theologian in Training
Posted

I just received this not too long ago...an adult question, as you can clearly tell ;)

[quote]Fr. Brian --

Here 's something I've often wondered about. The beginning of Luke's
gospel deals with John the Baptist. John tells people "I am baptizing
you with water" but that the one who's coming will "baptize you with
the Holy Spirit and fire.

So here's the first of two questions. When John spoke of baptism, his
audience obviously knew what baptism was. Baptism wasn't something he
just invented. That would lead one to believe that baptism existed in
some form in the Jewish tradition back then. Can you tell us
something about the Judaic or other origins of this ritual of baptism
which is so central to Christian belief?

And here's the second question. John speaks of Baptizing with the
Holy Spirit. Once again, one is led to assume that his audience would
know what he's talking about.

My impression has always been that Jews believe not only in a single
God, but in a God who only manifests himself in a single way. I've
always thought that the idea of three persons (or aspects, or
manifestations) in one God was a strictly Christian tenet.

So my question, I guess, is this: when John spoke to the people of
the Holy Spirit, what did they understand him to mean?

I look forward to hearig your answers.[/quote]

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

Dear Father,

I hope that I can be of some assistance with these questions.

We do have evidence of pre-Christian Judaic "Baptism," though the degree to which it was widespread is still unknown. As a practice it was most widespread in the Essene Jewish communities: a group of "Enochic" Jews according to the scholar Boccaccini. The ideology of these essenes was heavily messianic, and it is likely that what started out as a ritual washing to keep in accordance with universal Jewish laws regarding purity was "spiritualized" in the Essene community to take on a moral dimension - namely, baptism for the cleansing of sin.

The concept of the "Holy Spirit" is not a hypostatized person for Jews as it is for trinitarian Christians. The term in Hebrew is the "Ruah Haqodesh" (רוח הקודש) or "Breath of God." This word "breath" in greek is pneuma and translates equally well into "spirit" or "breath." The Jews at the time most likely interpreted John's words in this way - that the one coming after him would baptise with the Holy Spirit, in the sense that the Ruah Haqodesh would be given to the people, as it is often said of the Prophets that the spirit came upon them.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

phatcatholic
Posted

Jeff.........you are my freakin dawg :cool:

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

lol, anyone who's taken the classes I have would have been able to give the same answer, and probably better. But hey, this is what education is for, right? ^_^

Posted

Even if that's what the Jews thought, St. John clearly meant the third person of the Blessed Trinity.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1159396' date='Jan 8 2007, 09:03 PM']
lol, anyone who's taken the classes I have would have been able to give the same answer, and probably better. But hey, this is what education is for, right? ^_^
[/quote]
What classes have you taken? I would like to take them as well :topsy: .

Theologian in Training
Posted

Jeff,

That is incredibly helpful, and I will be sure to use this for next week. I really appreciate it.

thank you and God Bless

Fr. Brian

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

thank you very much Father, I pray that everything goes well!

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

Making changes...

Edited by Theologian in Training
Theologian in Training
Posted

Here is it. Thanks Jeff, I hope you don't mind that I quoted you direct, because I don't have time to do all the great research you did. Thanks again and God Bless
_________________________________

I would like to thank those who have given me some questions to answer, and I will be sure to answer them all in the coming weeks. However, since we celebrated the Baptism of the Lord not too long ago, I felt the following questions to be quite relevant. I will warn you, these questions are a little more theological, so the answers will reflect that, and, in fact, I am going to copy and paste exactly what was said in order to contextualize these questions. Here is the first of the two questions:

Here 's something I've often wondered about. The beginning of Luke's
gospel deals with John the Baptist. John tells people "I am baptizing
you with water" but that the one who's coming will "baptize you with
the Holy Spirit and fire.

So here's the first of two questions. When John spoke of baptism, his
audience obviously knew what baptism was. Baptism wasn't something he
just invented. That would lead one to believe that baptism existed in
some form in the Jewish tradition back then. Can you tell us
something about the Judaic or other origins of this ritual of baptism
which is so central to Christian belief?

The sacrament of Baptism, as we have it today, does have some of its early origins in Jewish tradition, and they did have some form of what we would call a Baptism and, in fact, there is evidence of a pre-Christian Judaic “Baptism,” though it is not entirely clear how well known it actually was. What is known, however, is that in the Jewish tradition there existed something known as “mikva” which was a type of ceremonial cleansing. It was used as both a means of upholding laws of purity and purification as well as for preparation for those things that merited a full cleansing, as it were. In fact, a great example of this can be found in Exodus 19:10, where a great cleansing ritual was done before the giving of the covenant on Mt. Sinai: And the LORD said to Moses, "Go to the people and consecrate them today and tomorrow, and let them wash their garments. An indication that not just the garments of the person was washed, but the entirety of the person.

Many Jewish sects would practice this cleansing ritual, however, it is believed that the Essenes were among those who placed the greatest importance upon this need for cleansing. In fact, some would go so far as to say that they were incredibly scrupulous in their upholding of these rituals. Given this, and the fact that their belief system was heavily messianic, it is believed that these same cleansing rituals became spiritualized and took on a moral dimension as not just an outward cleansing but an inward cleansing of sins as well. Incidentally, this is one of the reasons many would contend John the Baptist was an Essene, however, there is no evidence of this to validate such a claim.

And here's the second question. John speaks of Baptizing with the
Holy Spirit. Once again, one is led to assume that his audience would
know what he's talking about.

My impression has always been that Jews believe not only in a single
God, but in a God who only manifests himself in a single way. I've
always thought that the idea of three persons (or aspects, or
manifestations) in one God was a strictly Christian tenet.

So my question, I guess, is this: when John spoke to the people of
the Holy Spirit, what did they understand him to mean?

I asked this question of someone else, and he gave me an excellent answer. So rather than me re-hashing exactly what he said, I am going to give it to you. I take absolutely no credit for the answer and thank Jeff for his very clear and concise answer.

The concept of the "Holy Spirit" is not a hypostatized person for Jews as it is for Trinitarian Christians. The term in Hebrew is the "Ruah Haqodesh"or "Breath of God." This word "breath" in Greek is pneuma and translates equally well into "spirit" or "breath." The Jews at the time most likely interpreted John's words in this way - that the one coming after him would baptize with the Holy Spirit, in the sense that the Ruah Haqodesh would be given to the people, as it is often said of the Prophets that the Spirit came upon them.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...