Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Ethics Of Bottled Water


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.christiancentury.org/article.lasso?id=2783"]Christian Century[/url]
[quote]Thou shalt not murder. Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife. Thou shalt not . . . drink bottled water?

Rooted in the notion that clean drinking water, like air, is a God-given resource that shouldn't be packaged and sold, a fledgling campaign against the bottling of water has sprung up among religious groups.

And though the campaign is at a relative trickle and confined mostly to left-leaning religious groups, activists hope to build a broad-based coalition to carry the message that access to water should not be restricted to those who can afford it.

Cassandra Carmichael, director of eco-justice programs for the National Council of Churches, said she has noted an increasing number of religious groups that consider the bottling of water a wrongful—perhaps immoral—act. "We're just beginning to recognize the issue as people of faith," Carmichael said.

In October, the National Coalition of American Nuns, a progressive group representing 1,200 U.S. nuns, adopted a resolution asking members to refrain from purchasing bottled water unless necessary.

Likewise, Presbyterians for Restoring Creation, a grassroots group within the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), launched a campaign in May urging individuals to sign a pledge against drinking bottled water and to take the message to their churches.

The United Church of Christ, partnering with the National Council of Churches, produced a documentary, Troubled Waters, that looks at the dangers of water privatization around the world, including the bottling of water for sale in poor areas. The documentary aired on ABC television in October.

In the developing world, Carmichael said, water is being sold as a commodity where the resource is scarce. On the rationale that bottling water takes water resources away from the poor, the environmental issue has become an important one for people of faith, Carmichael said. "The moral call for us is not to privatize water. Water should be free for all."

Americans consume more bottled water than any other type of beverage except carbonated soft drinks, according to the Beverage Marketing Corporation, a New York-based research organization. In 2005, Americans drank about 7.5 billion gallons of bottled water, a 10.4 percent increase from 2004. The U.S. leads the world in bottled-water consumption.

At the same time, one-third of the world's population lives in water-stressed conditions. That proportion will double by 2025, according to a 2006 United Nations report on water scarcity. Water is scarcest in arid developing countries plagued by drought and pollution, such as South Africa, where agriculture fuels demand.

Sister Mary Ann Coyle, the National Coalition of American Nuns board member who introduced the measure against bottled water, said the fear is that as water becomes a commodity, access to it will no longer remain a right for all people.

Coyle regards drinking bottled water as a sin. She said that in the U.S., people are paying for bottled water when the country's tap water is among the safest in the world.

"The use of bottled water in the U.S. is more a lifestyle issue than a necessity," Coyle said. "In this country, we should do more to push [avoidance of] bottled water unless we need it."

But Stephen Kay, spokesperson for the International Bottled Water Association, said targeting bottled water among the hundreds of other products that use water will not lead to long-term solutions in poor areas. Arguing that bottled-water providers are actually a minimal user of ground water, Kay said better solutions would come from determining how to get clean water into areas struggling with access. "It narrows the focus with what I imagine is good intent," he said.

The Coca-Cola Company, a leading provider of bottled water with its Dasani brand, recognizes the serious nature of water issues and is working on several community initiatives in developing countries, said spokesperson Lisa Manley. "From our perspective, water solutions require the efforts of multiple organizations, nonprofits, governments, community organizations and the like," Manley said. "I hope we'd work toward the same purpose of making safe water accessible to all people of the world."

Nonetheless, Rebecca Barnes-Davies, coordinator of Presbyterians for Restoring Creation, said she hopes that boycotting bottled water would apply pressure on companies marketing it to act responsibly in the U.S. and the rest of the world. -Rebecca U. Cho, Religion News Service[/quote]

I, by the way, drink bottled water almost every day ...

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I pay a substantial amount of money to my local water authority and half again as much to the local seweage authority every month.
I see no point in paying for more water in a bottle just to be stylish.

Posted

Not all of us live where there is decent drinking water.

Posted

I haven't drunk tap water for years ... hate the taste of it.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Balthazor' post='1161414' date='Jan 11 2007, 12:25 PM']
Not all of us live where there is decent drinking water.
[/quote]
But if you are in USA the law requires clean drinking water to be available.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1161410' date='Jan 11 2007, 11:20 AM']
I pay a substantial amount of money to my local water authority and half again as much to the local seweage authority every month.
I see no point in paying for more water in a bottle just to be stylish.
[/quote]
It does make it easy to tote around, though.

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1161419' date='Jan 11 2007, 11:29 AM']
I haven't drunk tap water for years ... hate the taste of it.
[/quote]
Minnesota water is great... tastes just like bottled water.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I grew up on well water so when I go someplace that is hooked up to city water systems I drink bottled (I can taste the chemicals in it). I also like the convenience of it, like HSmom said, its easy to tote around. Instead of filling bottles or what-have-you with water I can just grab a bottle and go. Even here at my mom's house with well water I often buy a case of bottled water so I can have some with me when I head out the door. I really don't see what the big deal is, if they're really going to protest this ("water should be free") shouldn't they be protesting having to pay for city supplied water, too? :idontknow:

Posted

sounds like they're making a big issue out of nothing. it's not like people are forced to buy bottled water. if they want to spend more money for the convenience, so what?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1161476' date='Jan 11 2007, 01:48 PM']
sounds like they're making a big issue out of nothing. it's not like people are forced to buy bottled water. if they want to spend more money for the convenience, so what?
[/quote]
I don't think it matters in developed countries, but in poor countries it could be life-threatening.

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1161476' date='Jan 11 2007, 12:48 PM']
sounds like they're making a big issue out of nothing.
[/quote]

when aren't they?

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1161481' date='Jan 11 2007, 12:52 PM']
I don't think it matters in developed countries, but in poor countries it could be life-threatening.
[/quote]

True.

Do you think these "left-leaning religious groups" would feel better if the companies bottling the water shipped some overseas to such areas where clean water is scarce?



Personally, I think they just like to find issue with anything they can. If there wasn't any issue, they wouldn't be left-leaning.. they'd just [b]be[/b]. They preach freedom, yet they want to put ties everywhere they can. And for all the wrong reasons.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1161481' date='Jan 11 2007, 07:52 PM']
I don't think it matters in developed countries, but in poor countries it could be life-threatening.
[/quote]

I definitely agree that the commodinization of water is a huge issue in terms of global development. Bottled water on it's own though isn't where the problem lies. It's when tap water is no longer cheaply available.

btw, while living in Italy, I've noticed a few things about bottled water here:
1) They've been only drinking bottled water for a really long time - it's certainly nothing new here.
2) It's cheap - a 2 liter bottle of water is usually between 15 and 40 cents - fizzy or natural, doesn't make a difference.

The crazy bottled water prices and craze seem to me to be a mostly American phenomenon.

oh, and the smaller bottles are about the same price as the big ones - it's just in touristy places that they charge 1.50 to 2 euros for a bottle of water

let_go_let_God
Posted

Minnesota water is great. I absolutely love our water, however, well water is another story, silly iron ore deposits. :P:

Here's the old water tower of a local town.

[img]http://www.ohiobarns.com/othersites/watertowers/mn/23-69buhl.jpeg[/img]

The town actually sells the water and makes the same claim. We always got it for when we went camping, to me it just tastes like normal water but, if it's advertised as such it must be true. ;)

God bless-
LGLG

Posted

Although it may be required by law that the impurities and pollutants in tap water only reach certain limits, there are times when water quality pushes these limits and there are times when even in this limits the chemicals in the water can harm human health. This was the experience of my mom when our cities water source shifts periodically. This health impact goes back the concept of total load (total chemical and other stressors that the body must adapt to either in large quantity or [I]over time[I]) in the area of chemical sensitivities. Even in developed countries, tap water may have negative health consequences to some people who might drink it.

It is true that everyone should have the opportunity to drink water without being charged an arm or a leg for it, but that water must be and remain clean water. For this to happen, we need to ensure the strictest clean water possible in developed countries for us and those we impact ( what will be in the Colorado River which runs through part of the US to part of Mexico) and in other countries.

This would be best done in third world countries with the development of technology that can be used to make/keep water clean while allowing third-world countries to develop their industry and agriculture without too much artificial regulation or extreme expense payments. Governmental, non-profit/aid, or corporate involvement can help this happen. Governments will probably want to require certain bargains to be kept or alliances made and corporations should not always be left to do that stuff because of the tendency of corporations to operate almost exclusively on the basis of profit. Naturally, Christians should not be happy with corporate actions taking advantage of those in less developed areas.

So since stuff in water can be a unhealthy for those in developed countries and even more so for those in third world countries, merely ceasing the production of bottled water will not be enough to solve such water problems. Those bothered by bottled water should rather look beyond the action to why is this happening and what they can do about it. Cleaning and preserving clean water for all of us to enjoy more like God intended for us should be the call of people who care for God’s creation.

Cleaning water and keeping water sources clean should be an issue that all Christians care at least a little about, both as a matter of caring for the world God gave us and also as a matter of preserving human life through maintaining health.

Posted

I think our Holy Father Pope John Paul II said once that we need to learn to conserve water better.

DiscerningSoul
Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1163155' date='Jan 12 2007, 11:07 PM']
I think our Holy Father Pope John Paul II said once that we need to learn to conserve water better.
[/quote]

I think this is a good idea, I just hate when others fon't follow that same mindset. a co-worker of mine at the vet would continuosly leave the tap running and of course anytime I turned it off I got yelled at. but anyway I do belive in saving water.

Jessica
[url="http://www.xanga.com/ADiscerningSoul"]http://www.xanga.com/ADiscerningSoul[/url]
[url="http://blog.myspace.com/147329732"]http://blog.myspace.com/147329732[/url]

Posted

[color="#330099"] [font="Garamond"][size=3]Well, if you are paying your city or who ever provides your tap water, then that, too, is a commodity. I fiddler our tap water (the smell of the chlorine from it unfiltered is overpowering), and drink bottled water when I am away from home. Seems to me that if you pay for water AT ALL, it is a commodity. :idontknow: [/color][/font][/size]

Posted

forget the fact that 3000 babies are murdered each day in the womb............

we must take out the real heathens---- bottled water drinkers!

Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1161419' date='Jan 11 2007, 12:29 PM']
I haven't drunk tap water for years ... hate the taste of it.
[/quote]

Wow... I simply cannot stand the taste of bottled water.

Posted

[quote name='BrookeLove' post='1163848' date='Jan 14 2007, 01:55 AM']
[color="#330099"] [font="Garamond"][size=3]Well, if you are paying your city or who ever provides your tap water, then that, too, is a commodity. I fiddler our tap water (the smell of the chlorine from it unfiltered is overpowering), and drink bottled water when I am away from home. Seems to me that if you pay for water AT ALL, it is a commodity. :idontknow: [/color][/font][/size]
[/quote]

No, there's a difference between paying for the costs of treatment and distribution to your house (what you pay on a normal water bill) and paying for the water itself. The price difference is enormous.

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='curtins' post='1163856' date='Jan 13 2007, 07:07 PM']
forget the fact that 3000 babies are murdered each day in the womb............

we must take out the real heathens---- bottled water drinkers!
[/quote]
Actually it's 4000 in the US every day.



And I didn't say anything either way on my opinion in regards to this subject. :ninja: Simply clarifying... :unsure:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...