Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Irony Of Anti-catholicism


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I was reading the anticatholicism thread and thinking about some of the things I have read here. These are just a few thoughts I thought I would mention. No offense is intended.

I think it's funny that I have learned more about Protestant anti-Catholicism from Catholics than I have from most Protestants. And Jack Chic, like most Protestants actually mention him? Seriously, those are probably the few fundamentalist freaks that when they post online make it only things like that fundies say the darnedest things website. And that we are Protestants because we are protesting the Catholic Church? I thought you considered any churches that broke off from the reformation as Protestant. Yeah, most of us--not all that hung up an y'all.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

that was a little confusing but i think i understood it all

Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' post='1163377' date='Jan 13 2007, 01:40 AM']
I was reading the anticatholicism thread and thinking about some of the things I have read here. These are just a few thoughts I thought I would mention. No offense is intended.

I think it's funny that I have learned more about Protestant anti-Catholicism from Catholics than I have from most Protestants. And Jack Chic, like most Protestants actually mention him? Seriously, those are probably the few fundamentalist freaks that when they post online make it only things like that fundies say the darnedest things website. And that we are Protestants because we are protesting the Catholic Church? I thought you considered any churches that broke off from the reformation as Protestant. Yeah, most of us--not all that hung up an y'all.
[/quote]
Well, i have had people tell me i am going to hell cause i am Catholic. I have had people not talk to me or look me in the eye cause i am Catholic. I had a girl i dated not want to tell her family that i was Catholic. I have been to Churches and heard pastors preach anti-Catholic things. So, i guess you are lucky you haven't ran into it.

Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' post='1163377' date='Jan 13 2007, 04:10 AM']
I was reading the anticatholicism thread and thinking about some of the things I have read here. These are just a few thoughts I thought I would mention. No offense is intended.

I think it's funny that I have learned more about Protestant anti-Catholicism from Catholics than I have from most Protestants. And Jack Chic, like most Protestants actually mention him? Seriously, those are probably the few fundamentalist freaks that when they post online make it only things like that fundies say the darnedest things website. And that we are Protestants because we are protesting the Catholic Church? I thought you considered any churches that broke off from the reformation as Protestant. Yeah, most of us--not all that hung up an y'all.
[/quote]


Light and Truth,

I am having a hard time understanding some of your words.
I guess you are saying that you are Protestant and that anti-Catholicism is not as prevalent in Protestantism as some Catholics apparently think.
If that is what you are saying, then I think you have a good point. As far as the meaning of the word Protestant.....The root meaning of 'Protestant' can simply mean 'to bear public witness.' In that sense, it is an attractive term like Catholic or Orthodox.

Peace,
Paddington (non-Christian)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Paddington' post='1163406' date='Jan 12 2007, 10:52 PM']
Light and Truth,

I am having a hard time understanding some of your words.
I guess you are saying that you are Protestant and that anti-Catholicism is not as prevalent in Protestantism as some Catholics apparently think.
If that is what you are saying, then I think you have a good point. [/quote]
Yeah, pretty much.

[quote name='Paddington' post='1163406' date='Jan 12 2007, 10:52 PM']As far as the meaning of the word Protestant.....The root meaning of 'Protestant' can simply mean 'to bear public witness.'[/quote]
What I said was something I read on a Catholic forum. I think it might have been here, but I cannot remember where exactly I saw that.

[quote name='Paddington' post='1163406' date='Jan 12 2007, 10:52 PM'] In that sense, it is an attractive term like Catholic or Orthodox.[/quote]
But sadly what most Protestants really are are (according to one person here theologically egotistical) people who each have their own ideas about what the Bible says and have almost as many denominations as there are Protestants because obviously so many people would not have exactly the same nuanced faith, unlike Catholics. This is why there are so many thousands of denominations which is in fact highly unattractive.

[quote name='Paddington' post='1163406' date='Jan 12 2007, 10:52 PM']Peace,
Paddington (non-Christian)
[/quote]
Romans 8:14 For as many as are led by the Spirit of God, these are sons of God.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

BTW, that last post includes sarcasm.

Posted

Whoever hates you and persecutes you all because of me, then blessed, blessed are you.

Posted

i have lots of Protestant friends with negative views on Catholicism, but fortunately they don't really bash my views. They mostly ask questions. I went with one Protestant friend to an event and the pastor was saying nice things, but then he had to start bashing the Church! He went on and on for a while and it was totally uncalled for...how is that going to bring people closer to Christ?!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' post='1163377' date='Jan 13 2007, 01:40 AM']
I was reading the anticatholicism thread and thinking about some of the things I have read here. These are just a few thoughts I thought I would mention. No offense is intended.

I think it's funny that I have learned more about Protestant anti-Catholicism from Catholics than I have from most Protestants. And Jack Chic, like most Protestants actually mention him? Seriously, those are probably the few fundamentalist freaks that when they post online make it only things like that fundies say the darnedest things website. And that we are Protestants because we are protesting the Catholic Church? I thought you considered any churches that broke off from the reformation as Protestant. Yeah, most of us--not all that hung up an y'all.
[/quote]
We must run into different people then.

Posted

I think it really depends on who you talk to. There are PLENTY of anti-Catholics around here that voice their opinions.

Posted (edited)

There are of course many protestants who are not hostile toward Catholicism. But I can show you online many anti-catholic radio programs in the minneapolis area that distort Catholic teaching. John MacArthur has one that came out recently that basically says Catholics are pagans and going to hell. It was aired on way of the master radio, the Kirk Cameron, Ray Comfort, Todd Friel group that is so popular among Evangelical Christians these days. MacArthur is hardly fringe. Nor are Comfort and Cameron. If you want me to link you two his two hours of biggotry I would be glad to do so. No doudt they have influenced many people on this station. Hank Hanagraph, hardly fringe either, has had Eric Svedson, James White, and William Webster on his program in the last couple of years. Protestantism has difficulty having an identity without Catholicism, for it has to show more what it is not in order to legitimize what it is. Otherwise there is no protest. What are you protesting? God bless you for not buying in to it all. But I think your being a bit nieve in this.

Blessings

Edited by thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1163776' date='Jan 13 2007, 02:44 PM']
There are of course many protestants who are not hostile toward Catholicism. But I can show you online many anti-catholic radio programs in the minneapolis area that distort Catholic teaching. John MacArthur has one that came out recently that basically says Catholics are pagans and going to hell. It was aired on way of the master radio, the Kirk Cameron, Ray Comfort, Todd Friel group that is so popular among Evangelical Christians these days. MacArthur is hardly fringe. Nor are Comfort and Cameron.[/quote]
Yes, but for the record, I know Protestants on another board who don't take Cameron super seriously, only give some sort of consideration to his techniques. This is also the guy on a youtube video sitting with a guy explaining how the shape of a banana proves there is a god and then some viewers are like "what the heck?"

I have not actually met someone like that in real life as far as I can remember, so they have been few and far between in my experience.
[quote name='thessalonian' post='1163776' date='Jan 13 2007, 02:44 PM']If you want me to link you two his two hours of biggotry I would be glad to do so. No doudt they have influenced many people on this station. Hank Hanagraph, hardly fringe either, has had Eric Svedson, James White, and William Webster on his program in the last couple of years. [/quote]
Can you PM it to me?

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1163776' date='Jan 13 2007, 02:44 PM']Protestantism has difficulty having an identity without Catholicism, for it has to show more what it is not in order to legitimize what it is. Otherwise there is no protest. What are you protesting?[/quote]
I do not define my faith in any way that bears a clear connection to the Catholic church. I don't know what I am protesting, but I am considered a Protestant because I go to a church whose definition as Protestant exists only in the historical development of Christianity through the western churches. So yeah, what am I protesting? As far as my faith is concerned, does it even matter that much? :idontknow: I define my faith more by what I am for than by what I am against.

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1163776' date='Jan 13 2007, 02:44 PM']God bless you for not buying in to it all. But I think your being a bit nieve in this.

Blessings
[/quote]
The other major theologywebsite that I post on only has a couple rabit anti-Catholic/anti-Protestant people. Most are fairly moderate, be they Protestant, Catholic, Orthodox, or otherwise.

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1163763' date='Jan 13 2007, 02:35 PM']
We must run into different people then.
[/quote]
We clearly do, even if both are Protestants.

[quote name='mariahLVzJP2' post='1163733' date='Jan 13 2007, 01:43 PM']
i have lots of Protestant friends with negative views on Catholicism, but fortunately they don't really bash my views. They mostly ask questions. I went with one Protestant friend to an event and the pastor was saying nice things, but then he had to start bashing the Church! He went on and on for a while and it was totally uncalled for...how is that going to bring people closer to Christ?!
[/quote]
You would like the pastor of the church I started going to last year. He said right in the middle of service one time that he likes Catholics. What is important to him and to others in the church are whether or not people know and have a relationship with Jesus, not what church they go to. Course maybe we are a bit different in SoCal.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

I think, to be fair, that many, if not most, protestants are more concerned with their own salvation than the Catholic Church. So, I think many know nothing about Catholicism or anti-Catholicism, just like the average Catholic knows little about protestantism (am I making up words??).

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1163809' date='Jan 13 2007, 03:11 PM']
I think, to be fair, that many, if not most, protestants are more concerned with their own salvation than the Catholic Church. So, I think many know nothing about Catholicism or anti-Catholicism, just like the average Catholic knows little about protestantism (am I making up words??).
[/quote]
I think protestantism is a word. If not, it should be.

Posted

[quote]I do not define my faith in any way that bears a clear connection to the Catholic church[/quote]

You may not have, but if you look at the pastors whom you were taught by who were taught by others who trace back to the reformation, they were protesting the Catholic Church and in general much of what developed as Protestant theology was based on what the Catholic Church taught, and opposing it. Heck purgatory actually makes more sense in a protestant framework than in a Catholic one, or at least as much because of the doctrine of imputed righteousness, rather than infused (which we believe). If you want me to explain this further I would be glad to.

Posted

I have only dealt with the street corner zealots who tell me that I am going to hell because I am Catholic. My friends and acquaintances do not say these things to me. However, the largest church in town televises their services and I have seen Catholic bashing on there. With 28000 people hearing that message directly and more than that hearing it on TV, I would be naive to think that there isn't anti-Catholicism out there.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1163885' date='Jan 13 2007, 08:51 PM']
You may not have, but if you look at the pastors whom you were taught by who were taught by others who trace back to the reformation, they were protesting the Catholic Church and in general much of what developed as Protestant theology was based on what the Catholic Church taught, and opposing it. Heck purgatory actually makes more sense in a protestant framework than in a Catholic one, or at least as much because of the doctrine of imputed righteousness, rather than infused (which we believe). If you want me to explain this further I would be glad to.
[/quote]

explain for me at least

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1164174' date='Jan 14 2007, 12:22 AM']
explain for me at least
[/quote]
Yes, that could be interesting; but do you think it could be in a different thread so as not to hijack the topic?

I have asked about anti-Catholicism on another board and will see what they say. Untill then, I have read more insults to and negative comments about Protestants on this board than I have anti-Catholicism that I have heard from any real (non-internet) person that I have met.

Please recognize that your experiences may differ from others even if some of you here have the same experience of being insulted/offended for being Catholic. There are a lot of us who are may disagree with you but are not going to just go bashing Catholics.

Please note that many Protestants only have a historic connection to Catholicism in the derivision of their faith and not in their present religious sense if identity.

Please read what Paddington posted in the 30,000 denomination thread.

Even if there were that many denominations of us, then you really wouldn't know what half of us believe because there would be too many variations.

Please never generalize us Protestants except in what makes us not

Posted

This post isn't to generalize protestants as Catholic bashers. . .but, I've had a lot of anti-Catholicism bashing experiences.

I've had two different people on two different college campuses curse me, tell me I was going to hell because I was wearing a Marian Medal. One accused me of goddess worship, and no matter how hard I tried to negate that little falsehood, he wasn't swayed. One screamed at me, when I had the audacity of saying 'Our Blessed Mother', saying 'she's not MY mother! Don't call her OUR blessed Mother!' I looked at him, with such pity and sadness and said. . 'it's too bad you deride her like that. If she was good enough to be the mother of Christ, she's good enough for me to have her as a motherly role model. I wonder what Jesus will say when you finally meet face to face. . .will He deride you for being so offensive about His mother?'

When I first saw the thread's title about ironies, it made me think of this experience. A couple of years ago, I had a friend/co-worker who goes to one of those super large auditorium style 'Bible-based' churches. I was having some internal struggles, as our (now-former/retired) bishop had committed that hit and run and it was going through the news: his jail time, his trial, etc. Combined that with the rehashing of the allegedly (as some were later found innocent) sexually abusive priests and another priest in the diocese who was accused of some irregularities not only with parish funds but then also allowing a protestant minister to co-officiate at a wedding Mass. . .yea, I was in turmoil for a while and feeling not more than a little alone.

One day, this friend said, that while there was 'nothing wrong with Catholicism' perhaps I'd like to see her church, which is so friendly, welcoming newcomers, allowing for a lot of fellowship. I'll meet a lot of like minded people, and the church services themselves were just wonderful for worship, reverent, etc. She said that perhaps I'd like to be in a church where things weren't so dogmatic, and wasn't in so much turmoil with the corruption of priests. She said, I think, what she needed to say, to try to 'convert' me. Well, I thought, why not? Can't hurt to go to one of their services (although I still fulfilled my own Sunday obligation by going to Mass).

At any rate, I have to say that during their communion time, even though it's merely a symbol for them, there was more quiet, more reverence, even among the children who were allowed to participate, than I've seen at many parishes. I was impressed with that aspect (although this woman said that it's primarily at this one service she goes to, where reverence is more noticed).

However, this 'nice, holy, kind, wonderful' pastor? The main topic of his sermon was on how Catholicism was wrong, how Jesus never founded His church on the authority/leadership of one man, a man named Peter, and how Catholics got it all wrong in their translations, and how the early church was split from the word go, by those who followed Peter, and the rest of Christianity (so they could say that 'their' church was the same for all time, since Christ). I know it was a coincidence, in that my friend did not tell the pastor I was coming so it would be all about my faith, but I don't believe in coincidence. It was anti-catholic bashing at its best (worst?).

He asked me later, when he was told that I was a visitor, how I liked the service. I told him that, while I'm not a canon atty, or a theologian, if he wanted to have some 'real' discussions in re: Catholicism to give me a call, as I felt that many of the opinions he was asserting was not based on fact. He got this uncomfortable look on his face, and the greeting line kept moving. Needless to say, I didn't receive a call, nor did I ever return.

The office where I work is pretty large, but the area where I work is only 5 of us. One is Catholic, but no longer practicing (will probably start going back to Mass now that she has children). Three of us are practicing Catholic. And one is Baptist, but doesn't go to church. I don't know why this Baptist always chooses the times when someone is talking to me about my faith. Whenever any of the others are talking about theirs, even though it's the same faith, she doesn't say anything, but when it's me? She always finds something nasty to say, how 'thank God' she's not Catholic, or how screwed up Catholics are. I've, of course, learned my lesson, and say nothing about my faith near her. (It doesn't matter how many times I try to invite her to Mass to 'show' her how wonderful our church is, how many times I invite her to call me after work, to ask me whatever she'd like about my faith, etc. . . it doesn't make it better in her eyes. She's so intolerant of Catholicism in particular, as there are 3 doctors in our office, one is Jewish and the other two are muslim and this woman is so sensitive to their prayer times, their days of fasting, the foods they cannot eat, etc.) I just pray for her, and leave her alone.

Now, all the above had to do with protestants, in general. I say, in general because I don't know, with the exception of the one church experience, which churches the others belonged to. However, I think the 'worst' of the bashing came when I was discerning religious life. There were agnostics, mormons, lutherans, 'non-denoms', etc. . . all telling me that 'God didn't mean for people to not be married, and to 'hole themselves up in a monastery', that Catholics were 'all messed up' when it came to priests and nuns. . .and those were just the 'polite' things that were mentioned.

Perhaps, 'most' non-Catholics, are too occupied with themselves, their own salvation, to be so overtly concerned/intolerant as to bash those of other faiths, but it IS out there, more prevalent in some places or in some experiences, than in others. But it happens. I recall reading in the paper, and I'd have to do some serious digging to find this online, but one, non-Catholic senator was once asked which group of people were the most governmentally persecuted: blacks, muslims, women, gays, etc. This senator replied none of the above. .Catholics. I can't recall all his reasons for saying this except: that if a Catholic priest/nun/official within the Church says/does anything wrong/illegal/politically incorrect, it makes front page news. If any other religion or denomination does so, it makes page 12 or some other back page item. That stuck in my head, because it really seems to be true. I could write examples, that I've found in the media, but I won't at this time. The bottom line is, everyone waxes, in today's society, about being tolerant of others, and yet, it's almost like being Christian, being Catholic is that one exception.

The only other thing I'll mention here before signing off on this book I've written, is that it was mentioned in another post that there's more anti-Protestanism on this board than anti-Catholicism on another board. I don't think this is a anti-Protestant board per se, but this IS a Catholic board, where Catholics can meet with other Catholics, to fellowship, to learn, to grow. And yes, even to vent about the way non-Catholics bash Catholics, as this is, while not a primary, certainly an existing experience we face. Protestants are always welcome. At least, I believe that was Dust's intentions. . .but also to learn about Catholicism as we Catholics 'preach holy apostolic Truth'. Go PHATmass!

God bless you.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='HisChild' post='1164310' date='Jan 14 2007, 09:59 AM']I don't think this is a anti-Protestant board per se, but this IS a Catholic board, where Catholics can meet with other Catholics, to fellowship, to learn, to grow. And yes, even to vent about the way non-Catholics bash Catholics, as this is, while not a primary, certainly an existing experience we face. Protestants are always welcome. At least, I believe that was Dust's intentions. . .but also to learn about Catholicism as we Catholics 'preach holy apostolic Truth'. Go PHATmass!

God bless you.
[/quote]
I agree with most of that. Here my faith has been called theologically egotistical with most of us having our own different faith enough to be our own denomination. Our most common ecclesiology was totally disregarded when it came up, I believe several times. Sometimes I feel like my faith as a Protestant was more respected when I was in the Catholic Newman club at my old college than here. I guess that is part of why most evangelism is best done in person though.

Our faith still appears to be defined by you based on where it came from and not what we believe or how we define ourselves, i.e. that part about us still protesting something that really doesn't have much bearing on how most of us define or identify our faith, even with the emergence of bodies of faith that came out of and are not a part of the reformation churches and could even be considered protestants against those churches too.

Edited by Light and Truth

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...