Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 14, 2007 Posted January 14, 2007 Hey everyone, the following is a response I wrote on my friend's blog to an observation he made regarding faith and liberal arts education. He was not making any sort of polemical attacks on Christians, but merely some observations, to which I responded. I would love to hear thoughts on the response: Here is the original post: [quote]I actually had to talk to Christians for this. At the end of assembly, which my elementary school had at the beginning of every week, we all had to sing Father Abraham. Because of this, every Monday for five years, I joined in with an unruly mass of kids between the ages of six and 11 while we sang along to a song we kind-of-but-not-really knew. Afterwards, we ran around in angry circles until we got dizzy and fell down. Sometimes, teachers gave us ice cream. We also had to attend Bible-study classes three times a week. Since most of the assignments involved drawing animals we would have brought with us onto Noah’s ark—I chose the butterfly, because nobody ever suspects the butterfly—we didn’t take them seriously That was the extent of the religious training I received at my Methodist elementary school. But even if teachers didn’t make us memorize catechism, or whatever its Methodist equivalent is—see, bad school—religion insinuated itself into our lives. When I turned 10 and had my first pretentious existential crisis, I turned to the person I respected most in the world for help: my school’s principal, who was also its pastor. Columbia reminds me of elementary school in many respects, but not this one. Although deeply religious students come here, they tend to isolate themselves from the broader community for understandable, and perhaps necessary, reasons. Moreover, the rest of student body, whose attitudes tend to range between apathy and slightly more apathy, don’t usually provide the most supportive atmosphere. Some want to change this. A recent article in The New York Times detailed the efforts of a group of students supported by Christian activist groups across the country to, in their words, “reclaim the Ivy League for Christ.” They take their work seriously. As one explained in a grammatically mind-blowing sentence that, coming from an advocate of family values, still makes me giggle, religious students in the Ivy League today act as “a finger in the dike of keeping back the flood of immorality.” Must... not... laugh... To add some fingers, they rely on the financial support of people like “Julian L. McPhillips Jr., a wealthy Princeton alumnus,” who believes he “cured an employee’s migraine headaches just by praying for him.” Apparently, they “joke in [his] office that we don’t need health insurance.” It’s a funny joke. Others have given up on redeeming the Ivies altogether. Instead, they flock to established religious colleges. Most of these schools are Christian, for the simple reason that most Americans are as well. They include Bob Jones, for Fundamentalists; Brigham Young, for Mormons; and Thomas Aquinas, for Catholics. It’s very easy, from our heavily guarded citadel deep in the heart of Blue America, to look askance at these schools, all of which describe themselves as “the Harvard of” whatever, even though they admit students who got a check for participation on their SATs. Okay, that is pretty funny, and not creepy “God told me you don’t need health insurance” funny. But the stereotypes, as usual, conceal more than they reveal. Bob Jones, for instance, has an amazing gallery of religious art that comprises work from artists like Rubens and Botticelli. And for every slack-jawed Cletus in training, an admissions official can point to someone who got a 2400 on her boards back when they still went to only 1600 and turned down the Harvard of the Ivy League, Princeton. More importantly, the students themselves seem happy. Compelled by God, who for some reason cares about this kind of thing, they approach learning with a purposefulness many of their Sparknotes-skimming counterparts in secular colleges lack. They have lower rates of drug use and depression. Despite their largely lily-white student body, minority students say they feel integrated into the university community. One problem, though, afflicts students at both religious and secular colleges. When a reporter asked a professor at Thomas Aquinas, “If Nietzsche is taught with the same consideration as, say Thomas Aquinas, isn’t it likely that at least some of the students will come away doubting the existence of God,” the professor answered by “clench[ing] her hands around the edge of the table” and “rais[ing] her voice,” before becoming frustrated and leaving abruptly. The professor had difficulty responding to the question because the answer was so obvious: of course some students will doubt. At its best, a liberal arts education challenges students’ most fundamental beliefs—even their belief in God. The people who get the most out of a college education are those willing to lose everything they ever had so they can get more. Luckily none of them have started their real lives yet, so they can afford to do so. Except for people who take their beliefs and their education seriously. Knowledge can be more important for them, but it’s also more dangerous, because they have already found something they can’t afford to lose. Nietzsche, or any secular thinker, may be wrong. But unless students endanger their faith, they can’t seriously entertain the proposition that he may be right. Whether they do so at Bob Jones or at Brown, those who regard their religion as more than an excuse to get ice cream have to decide what they can sacrifice for their intellectual life. Unfortunately, so does everyone else.[/quote] And here is my response: [quote]Tim, this is my first response to your blog (very sad, I know, especially considering I'm replying to something you posted over a year ago). I hope you'll forgive the shameless bias you are about to read... Blind Faith or Liberating Submission? A liberal arts education is about exposure. The whole endeavor is one that takes as an assumption the thought that there is value in learning things that may not necessarily be one's primary interest. It isn't just a matter of being "well-rounded" either (Jim and I have a leg up on you there). Exposing oneself to a variety of subject matters changes the way people understand the world and approach problems. It is assumed that this change is a desireable one. I believe that this is true. However, as you pointed out, this presents someone like me with a problem. Doesn't open exposure to heretics, infidels, and the generally damned put my soul in danger? Shouldn't I, as a genuinely committed (and priesthood-headed) Christian, avoid at all costs such demon-touched and hellfire-bound books as Bertrand Russell's "Why I Am Not A Christian"? First, all joking and sarcasm aside, it is very true that Christians at a liberal arts university will be exposed to materials and readings that may challenge their faith. However, it should also be pointed out that if the liberal arts university is an intellectually honest institution, then the agnostic and atheistic students will also be exposed to materials and readings that may challenge their lack of faith. But so far, all I've done is restate the problem that you observe. You end by noting that "unless students endanger their faith, they can’t seriously entertain the proposition that [Nietzsche] may be right... those who regard their religion as more than an excuse to get ice cream have to decide what they can sacrifice for their intellectual life. Unfortunately, so does everyone else." I am neither proselytizing nor trying to argue that Catholic students do not undergo those challenges to faith that you mentioned above. Moreover, this is not intended to be polemical in any way. Rather, I am reflecting on what I have found to be a personal treasure given to me by my Catholic faith in this regard. Any individual who makes an act of faith is committing to the truth of that in which he or she believes. Now isn't this commitment of faith antithetical to the outlook of a liberal arts education, which sees value in exposing its students to arguments that call that faith into question? Doesn't faith involve an implicit duty to preserve that same faith, and if so, doesn't this contradict the endangering of the faith that comes along with a liberal arts education? Ironically, for an adherent of the intellectually-oppressive, inquisitorial, and hyper-dogmatic Catholic Church, the answer is no. The doctrine of Sola Scriptura, which denies the authority of the Church to interpret Scripture, has made each individual Protestant his or her own authority. In a very real sense then, each individual Protestant has become the measure of his or her own faith, because that faith is ultimately defined by him or her. Ironically, far from being a "liberating" position, this stance seems to make the problem in question an unbearable one. If the individual is the sole interpreter and judge of his or her own faith, then it is up to the individual to answer every problem and reconcile every contradiction - a burden too heavy for any person to carry (and something extremely prideful to even attempt). But the true Catholic, whether he or she knows it or not, is not caught in such a dilemma. The act of faith made by a Catholic is not in something defined and interpreted (created?) by the individual, but in something defined and interpreted by the Church. Since the Catholic is not responsible for defining and interpreting that in which he or she places faith, the responsibility does not lie with the individual in order to answer all questions and solve all difficulties. Now, does this mean that Catholics should just shrug there shoulder at anything that calls their faith into question and simply say "the Church will answer that?" No. We should always, as St. Peter says, strive to "give an account of our hope." However, what it does mean is that when we struggle with intellectual challenges, our faith need not be shaken, because our faith is grounded in something (the Mystical Body of Christ that is the Church) that we recognize is independent of us and transcends us. All of this having been said, it helps to put it in the concrete. Let us imagine that, taking up your example, I am struggling with Nietzsche. His arguments seem persuasive, and to make everything worse I've just finished reading The Grand Inquisitor. However, unsettling not having answers to give Nietzsche may be, there is a difference, which you alluded to, between not having answers and there not being answers. I can struggle with the former without fearing the latter. For a Catholic, struggling with Nietzsche is like struggling with a Sudoku. It may be frustrating and difficult, and a certain individual may simply not be able to solve it, but whether there is a solution has never been in question. How is this solution not open to the Protestant as well? Recalling the observation made earlier, Sola Scriptura renders each individual his or her own authority when it comes to the interpretation of Scripture. Moreover, that same doctrine posits that everything necessary for salvation is to be found within scripture. Thus, it is the individual believer who is the judge and interpreter of all that is necessary for salvation. Thus, there is no aspect of faith that is objective and seperate from the individual believer. As such, the recourse used by Catholics (Truth resides in the Church even when it may not reside in me) is unavailable to Protestants. So, to close these thoughts, it seems to me that atheists, agnostics, and protestants are all in the same boat. With Protagoras, they must say that "man is the measure of all things," and in doing so, they do face serious challenges that force them to call into question their beliefs. Catholics too, face these same challenges, but they need not endanger their faith in doing so. Rather, they need only understand that the God in whom they believe is an objective God who measures them - through the Church - and not the other way around. Thus humbled, we are able to, like Job, keep faith in God without having all the answers. Fides quaerens intellectum, not because Faith depends on understanding for its existence, but because true faith motivates us to seek as far as we are able to go, and rest satisfied when we can go no further. - Jeff[/quote]
morostheos Posted January 14, 2007 Posted January 14, 2007 bravo!! :applause: Beautifully written, Jeff. Although, wouldn't you say that's quite a long comment? :
cmotherofpirl Posted January 14, 2007 Posted January 14, 2007 When a child learns to walk he starts so by standing and holding on to mama. He holds on to furniture, pulls himself up, moves a bit away, but mama is right there as the foundation of his journey. If he gets in trouble, mama is always there, she is the "rock", and will solve all the big problems - I am stuck, I can't reach my bottle etc. He doesn't have to do it all by himself. Secure in the knowledge that someone else who is bigger and wiser -been there and done that - the child ventures forth. Imagine trying to figure out all of life's questions and decisions, to start from square one and figure it out by yourself without the Mama - Holy Mother Church
Justified Saint Posted January 14, 2007 Posted January 14, 2007 Interesting exchange, except I can't quite understand why comparing Protestants to atheists is at all very helpful or honest.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 14, 2007 Posted January 14, 2007 there was not intended to be a comparison at all, nor was it intended as a polemic, as I stated. Rather, I was merely reflecting that both Protestants and atheists, as well as agnostics, are all in the same boat. The friend with whom I was having the exchange is an agnostic, and his reflections seemed to take a viewpoint of two groups: Christians vs. Non-religious. My reflections simply made the observation that, really, Protestants are in the same situation of existential crisis as are the non-religious, and it is really only the Catholics who have a unique blessing in the manner in which they can meaningfully engage without endangering their faith or assumptions.
journeyman Posted January 15, 2007 Posted January 15, 2007 for those of us who need smaller words, Jeff, is what you were saying something along the lines of "Protestants, atheists and agnostics decided for themselves what was 'true' and thus could be dissuaded in their beliefs by a fast-talking huckster."? is your agnostic friend a spell check fiend? I noticed two typos and one dangling participle: shrug there shoulder which you alluded to, seperate from the individual
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 15, 2007 Posted January 15, 2007 the jist of the reflection was the fact that because Sola Scriptura renders each individual protestant the sole judge and interpreted of the Scriptures, then there is no aspect of their faith that does not ultimately return to that individual for validation. Thus, if a problem or contradiction or paradox arises, the responsibility is on that individual believer - as sole judge and interpreted of the Scripture in which they find everything necessary for their salvation - to resolve the paradox and solve the problem. This can be very trying on a person's faith, and so ultimately the protestant is in the same boat as an atheist or agnostic at a liberal arts school: they all may feel themselves drowning in doubt. The Catholic, however, (Blessed be God) does not have to feel this drowning, because, since he or she is not the interpreter and judge of his or her own faith, we have an objectively existing entity (the Church) in which we can place our trust, even while we struggle with questions.
Socrates Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 (edited) Your response was good, but to be frank, your friend's blog was largely a load of bigoted, condescending, ignorant nonsense. In fact, in was hard to tell what the point of it was, other than the blogger wallowing in his (her?) own self-perceived "cleverness." [quote]Others have given up on redeeming the Ivies altogether. Instead, they flock to established religious colleges. Most of these schools are Christian, for the simple reason that most Americans are as well. They include Bob Jones, for Fundamentalists; Brigham Young, for Mormons; and Thomas Aquinas, for Catholics. It’s very easy, from our heavily guarded citadel deep in the heart of Blue America, to look askance at these schools, all of which describe themselves as “the Harvard of” whatever, even though they admit students who got a check for participation on their SATs. Okay, that is pretty funny, and not creepy “God told me you don’t need health insurance” funny.[/quote] Actually that wasn't funny, so much as ignorant. Though the blogger goes on to talk about "stereotypes concealing more than they reveal," he seems to believe the idea that all explicitly religious colleges have lower academic standards, though they may admit some individual bright students. I can't speak for Brigham Young or Bob Jones university, but the blogger does throw Thomas Aquinas College into this category. I myself graduated from [url="http://www.christendom.edu/"]Christendom College[/url], a strongly Catholic liberal arts college, which is rather similar to Thomas Aquinas College, and has comparable academic standards. Christendom is ranked in the top 10% of colleges for incoming freshmen SAT scores. [quote]Barron's Compact Guide to Colleges and Best Buys in College Education defines Christendom as "very competitive" with a "demanding workload." Christendom College was acknowledged by The Princeton Review in the 2001 edition of Time Magazine's "The Best College for You." Peterson's Competitive Colleges (2000-2001) placed Christendom in the top ten percent of colleges in the United States based on Freshmen SAT scores. In the ISI's College Guide, Choosing the Right College, Christendom was listed as one of the top 110 schools in the U.S. Regarding the curriculum, Choosing writes,"Christendom's core goes far beyond what even many ‘good' liberal arts colleges require....With an all-encompassing vision of the liberal arts driving the curriculum, the faculty and administration are at pains to create an educational experience in which each course, major, and rule for community life contributes to an integrated Catholic worldview." [/quote] [url="http://www.christendom.edu/alumni/endorsements.shtml"]http://www.christendom.edu/alumni/endorsements.shtml[/url] As for [url="http://www.thomasaquinas.edu/"]Thomas Aquinas College[/url], written about so condescendingly by this blogger, it has the following statistics: [quote]2006 student body's average SAT score is 1296. Ranked a “Top College” (73rd among top 111 National Liberal Arts Colleges). --US News and World Report’s 2007 edition of America’s Best Colleges. The only Catholic college included among the 40 “Great Schools, Great Price” rankings. --US News and World Report’s 2007 edition of America’s Best Colleges. [/quote] [url="http://www.thomasaquinas.edu/about/profile.htm"]http://www.thomasaquinas.edu/about/profile.htm[/url] These Catholic colleges have demanding admissions and academic standards, and turn down many applicants because of not having high enough SAT and academic scores, and many more flunk out. Yet so many, having no knowledge whatsoever of these schools, are quick to dismiss them as academically substandard, simply because they are strongly religious. That is simple bigoted nonsense. This blogger then goes on with the typical line of how students must "endanger their faith" to be truly educated, and goes on to criticize professors at religious colleges of basically proselytizing. This reflects the usual line of thought that religious faith is incompatible with intellectual development. Yet how many professors at mainstream and "ivy-league" schools basically proselytize their students with left-wing p.c. secularist propaganda? I've seen first hand at a secular state university a prof giving his kids class credit to literally shout down a conservative lecturer invited by a student conservative group. This is the sort of nonsense that regularly passes for "education" at many institutions of "higher learning." Yet people keep insisting that those of us who attended religious colleges are brainwashed slack-jawed morons that must have been too dumb to make it in a "real college." Edited January 16, 2007 by Socrates
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 lol, woah there, big guy. Just to clarify a few points: First, he was quoting the story about the professor at the religious institution, so that wasn't him being accusatory with regards to proselytizing - in fact, if you re-read he was quoting it because he was making a point about faith and liberal arts education, not about proselytizing. Second, you have to realize that both he and I have a very tongue-in-cheek kind of humor. So if you are going to object to his painting religious schools as letting in people with low SAT scores, you should be objecting even more to me painting all non-religious people as "heretics, infidels, and the generally damned." Third, I understand that he was painting in broad strokes, but there is no need to take it personally. His post was a general reflection on faith and the liberal arts, and so the point wasn't whether or not a certain religious school has low standards or whether a certain school has proselytizing professors. The point was that at least sometimes faith and a liberal arts education seem to conflict. You've got to at least grant that. Just to close, I know that this was just a gut-reaction, and I definately do feel you on being frustrating with ppl caricaturing the religious. However, I do think its important that we not be overly-defensive. He really is very open to religious thought, and being overly-defensive can often make us mistake the genuinely-open for the bigotted and absolutely biased. Your Brother in Christ, Jeff
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now