Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Would Getting A Woman's Tubes Tied..


Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm not sure if this is the right location for this topic..

For a while, I've been thinking about not having children. I can't say that I don't think God is calling me not to, but it's just a personal opinion.

I'm not married, and I don't think I will be anytime soon, but I was just wondering about this.[b] Would it be sinful and/or selfish for me to get my tubes tied so I could not have children?[/b] I don't want to do it just so I can have unprotected sex or be guaranteed to not get pregnant, if that makes any sense.

Posted (edited)

Yes, it would be wrong. By closing yourself off to the possibility of being open to life, you would really be closing yourself off to Marriage and its procreative nature. You say you may never marry, but you never know. And if you end up doing this and then wish to get married, then I think that would be a very real impediment to Marriage, because you would not be able to say, when you take your vows, that you would welcome children lovingly, because you would clearly not be able to have children.

But regardless of whether you would marry one day or not, I think it would be wrong. I'm not sure why this would be an issue if you wouldn't marry anyway. Maybe someone can help me out with this with official teaching?

[quote]I don't want to do it just so I can have unprotected sex or be guaranteed to not get pregnant, if that makes any sense.[/quote]
What other reason would you have?

Edited by Colleen
Posted

This is sensitive, but I would need to ask what reasons would you want to do this.

Tubal ligation (what I assume you are speaking of here) is a serious surgury. It is a laparoscopy, so the scar is small, but it is still messing with some tender equipement.

Morally, there are some issues. The difference in something like this and NFP is that you are causing an un natural barrier between yourself and your fertility. This is dehumanizing, and defeminisng, basically casterating yourself. That is why medically this is called a sterilazation.

To my understanding the only time that it would be considered morally permitable for a woman to undergo a treatment like this would be a case where a BRCA(1 or 2, commonly 2) is involved. That is ovarian cancer. where surgery is the only option for life. The type of surgery depends upon how widespread the cancer is when diagnosed (the cancer stage), as well as the type and grade of cancer. The surgeon may remove one (unilateral oophorectomy) or both ovaries (bilateral oophorectomy), the fallopian tubes (salpingectomy), and the uterus (hysterectomy).

For some very early tumors (stage 1, low grade or low-risk disease), only the involved ovary and fallopian tube will be removed (called a "unilateral salpingo-oophorectomy," USO), especially in young females who wish to preserve their fertility.

Is that your situation? Cause a Tubal Ligation wont help much there.

Posted

So would a marriage be valid if both partners found out down the line that they are not able to have children?

Posted

are you asking me?

If so I would say of course. If both partners forced themselves to be sterile then you are in mucky water. But lets say my wife was naturally infertile, our marriage would be just as valid as anyone else because WE did not damage or deny the gift God gave humanity in the form of children. I, as the husband, am not denying a portion of my wife, her fertitlity, I am accepting the whole of my wife including her fertilitiy. Or in your question, her apparent lack therefore of.

Children is a primary purpose in marriage, as is unity, but that does not mean that a marriage in invalid if the couple cannot have children.

As always, I am not a militant. Just someone who is trying and cares.

Posted

I'm sorry, I hope I did not come across as insensitive. :( It was not my intention if I did.

VeniteAdoremus
Posted

[quote name='desertwoman' post='1165885' date='Jan 15 2007, 09:25 PM']
So would a marriage be valid if both partners found out down the line that they are not able to have children?
[/quote]

It's valid, but if one of the partners knows in advance that they're infertile it can be a ground for annullment.

And regarding the first question: the Church sees this as intentional mutilation, which is NOT allowed, unless on "medical indication of strictly therapeutical nature".

I don't know what your reasons are for wanting this, and it's none of my bussiness :) But the Church' stance is pretty clear, in my opinion.

Maybe you can talk it over with your parish priest?

Posted

I just don't want to have children. I don't know if that's God's will or not, but it's something that I don't want to do.

Would I still be closing myself off if I did that then decided to adopt?

Posted

[quote name='The LorFish' post='1166807' date='Jan 16 2007, 01:57 PM']
I just don't want to have children. I don't know if that's God's will or not, but it's something that I don't want to do.

Would I still be closing myself off if I did that then decided to adopt?
[/quote]
Yes.

If you don't want to have children, then don't have sex. (Blunt, I know, but that's the bottom line.)

And as others have pointed out, if, as you said, the point is not wanting to have sex without "danger" of children, then why on earth would you possibly want your tubes tied???

You may not like the answer, but you asked for the Catholic moral answer, and you've got it.

Posted

I'm not "not happy" with what everyone here is saying. After all, I wouldn't have posted this topic without wanting to have responses and ideas and opinions.

I don't think that people [not necessarily me] should be denied sex just because they don't want to have children.

Guest Rick777
Posted (edited)

[quote name='The LorFish' post='1167977' date='Jan 17 2007, 02:21 AM']
I don't think that people [not necessarily me] should be denied sex just because they don't want to have children.
[/quote]

The point of having sex is having children. :cool: I found this in the PM Defense Directory, maybe it could help you out.

[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=3416"]http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=3416[/url]

Edited by Rick777
VeniteAdoremus
Posted

[quote name='Rick777' post='1168012' date='Jan 17 2007, 11:58 AM']
The point of having sex is having children. :cool: I found this in the PM Defense Directory, maybe it could help you out.

<a href="http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Periodicals/Faith/11-12-98/Virtues.html" target="_blank">http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Periodicals/Fa...98/Virtues.html</a>
[/quote]

That url gives me a 404... :idontknow:

Is there any specific reason why you don't want children? Natural family planning is allowed if you're not able to raise them at the moment, for example.

Guest Rick777
Posted

[quote name='VeniteAdoremus' post='1168016' date='Jan 17 2007, 05:03 AM']
That url gives me a 404... :idontknow:

Is there any specific reason why you don't want children? Natural family planning is allowed if you're not able to raise them at the moment, for example.
[/quote]

Yah sorry about that. For some reason that link wouldn't work. :idontknow:

Posted

My offhand $.02 is...

When you voluntarily sterilize yourself, it says a lot and it isn't good. I'm going to be blunt. It's basically saying to God, the world, and your spouse "I'm junk. I don't want anyone else to be cursed with my genes." You're either denying your capacity to raise children or you're saying that you can't be bothered. It also poisons the act of sexual intercourse itself. If you ever find that you are married, and wanting children, reversing it is not always successful.

As others have mentioned, getting your tubes tied does not protect you from disease. It will only prevent conception. If you're planning on not having sex before marriage, then why would you need it? If you're planning on getting married, procreation is one of the primary ends of marriage. If you get married, but have your tubes tied, what's the point? Other couples would love to have the fertility that you seem to think isn't worth having. The desire for sex is intrinsically linked to the desire to reproduce. Sexual intercourse is pleasurable because it seeks to acquire a good end: union of the spouses and the begetting of children. It is like the pleasure of eating. Eating is pleasurable because it acquires nutrients and energy from the food.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='The LorFish' post='1167977' date='Jan 17 2007, 03:21 AM']

I don't think that people [not necessarily me] should be denied sex just because they don't want to have children.
[/quote]

The main reason you have sex is to have children :)
It is a chemical physical emotional psychological spiritual act best set in a permanent loving bond designed to give life.

Otherwise in the long run its a hunt for unfulfilling meaningless release.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='The LorFish' post='1167977' date='Jan 17 2007, 03:21 AM']
I don't think that people [not necessarily me] should be denied sex just because they don't want to have children.
[/quote]
Sex is designed so that two people who love each other can come as closely together as possible in union and preserve that union of their very selves in another person, who is a union of father and mother. If you love someone, it only makes sense that you want more of them in the world...if you want to be in union with someone, it only makes sense that you want that union to be permanent. In children, the union of love is manifested forever. In general, you can't seek union without also seeking children. Now, for the sake of the family, there may be serious circumstances where NFP may be used to avoid for a time, but not overall.

Do you see why never wanting children would keep one from ever truly achieving union?

Posted

+

Are you afraid of the pain (most women are!)?

Posted

[quote name='Veritas' post='1168332' date='Jan 17 2007, 02:01 PM']
+

Are you afraid of the pain (most women are!)?
[/quote]

No, I'm not :cool:


After all this, I am.. more aware, I guess I could say.

I don't think that I'm denying that I'm not worthy to have children. Children are great.. I just don't want to have any of my own because there are other children that need to be taken care of. I'd rather adopt and raise a child without any parents than have my own. Just how I feel.

I'm starting to think more about things. I had no plan/intention on taking any action regarding this; it was merely an idea/question that I wanted to throw out there. But once I develop a new opinion, I will surely let you all know = ]

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='The LorFish' post='1168550' date='Jan 17 2007, 08:19 PM']
No, I'm not :cool:
After all this, I am.. more aware, I guess I could say.

I don't think that I'm denying that I'm not worthy to have children. Children are great.. I just don't want to have any of my own because there are other children that need to be taken care of. I'd rather adopt and raise a child without any parents than have my own. Just how I feel.

I'm starting to think more about things. I had no plan/intention on taking any action regarding this; it was merely an idea/question that I wanted to throw out there. But once I develop a new opinion, I will surely let you all know = ]
[/quote]
You're right that there are other children that need to be taken care of, but think of it in a heavenly way. Remember that Christ said, "the poor you will always have with you." You won't be able to care for all of the homeless or unloved children, though you can and should help in whatever way you feel called, but sexual union is by its nature bound up with procreation. We are called to be responsible. It is irresponsible to bring children into this world who will not be provided for with the basic necessities of life. It is equally irresponsible to avoid procreation, even if one means to be responsible by opening one's home to unwanted children, because that abuses the sexual act. Now, given that some are irresponsible in the first way, others are called to take over that responsibility, but you cannot be responsible in one way by being neglectful in another (not calling you neglectful). In short, if you find yourself in the situation that you are trying to procreate, but need some spacing between children for, say, physical reasons, you can always adopt a child in the time between having your own children (of course, if you were spacing children for financial reasons, that might not be wise). Or else consider those who are unable to have children or who are too old or who have the means to have their own children without any limits as well as adopt additional children...it seems to me that all of these are reasonable and responsible ideas.

My fiancee and I have discussed adopting children if, for some reason, we are unable to conceive. Although, it would be irresponsible for us to adopt too many, as we will likely never make enough money for a large family (over 6, for instance, though, if we can, we'd both love to have more).

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='The LorFish' post='1167977' date='Jan 17 2007, 03:21 AM']
I don't think that people [not necessarily me] should be denied sex just because they don't want to have children.
[/quote]

Everyone is free to choose how they live their lives, but the basic point behind the Catholic teaching is that sex is fulfilling only when it is truely unitive, and to be truely unitive, it must remain open and respectful towards procreation.

Sounds old fashioned, yet all around us are people who are dissatisfied with their sex lives, who get hurt again and again because they think there's freedom in avoiding the "burden" of marriage, or end up divorced. Society wants to emphasize that sex doesn't need to be procreative to unite two people (or three?) while at the same time accepting breakup, divorce, and heartbreak as just a part of life. This isn't what Jesus has in mind when he invites us to "live life to the full."

I know some couples use contraception and yet remain together and happy (my parents are probably one of them, although I haven't bothered inquiring into that), even there they still miss out on some of the beauty of how God designed sex, put themselves under certain health risks, have to deal with the side effects (like decreased libido... hmm, how ironic), while contributing to the social sins that are a direct result of widespread contraceptive use (as prophesied in the papal document "Humanae Vitae," particularly paragraph 17 if you want to check it out for yourself).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...