Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Could somebody let me know about some good Thomistic or Augustinian or some other knowledgeable Catholic source on the nature of sin?

I'm inclined to say that: [list]
[*]a 'sin' is simply a violation of the natural law.
[*]because nature, being without a free will, cannot violate the natural law, only man (who possesses a free will) can violate the natural law.
[*]therefore, only man can sin.
[/list]
My question comes in here. If sin is simply a violation of the natural law that, as it happens to be, only a person with a free will can commit, does a 'sin' always require consent?
I'm not questioning the degree of culpability here, I'm asking: if a human violates the natural law, knowing it or not, is that a sin. (?) (Again, I'm NOT asking about culpability). :)

Is my premise wrong just altogether?

Thanks in advance :)

Edited by DAF
Theologian in Training
Posted

It wouldn't be a sin otherwise. The nature of sin always requires consent, on some level, I cannot think of anytime when it would be otherwise.

Hope that helps

God Bless

Posted (edited)

Thanks Fr., but that doesn't really answer my question.

What is a sin-by its nature? Is it SIMPLY a violation of the natural law? If that is the case, then couldn't one posit that a sin could come to be without the 'sinner' being in full knowledge that the action is a sin, and therefore that a 'sin' could come to be without full consent by the sinner?

I suppose what I'm asking is: is a sin purely external to the actions of the sinner, or is a sin no longer a sin unless it was committed with full knowledge and consent.

I'm coming to one conclusion, but I'd like a better opinion, preferably an official source 'ex corde Ecclesiae.'

Edited by DAF
Theologian in Training
Posted

Ok, let me try to be clearer :)


[quote name='DAF' post='1165974' date='Jan 15 2007, 04:38 PM']
Thanks Fr., but that doesn't really answer my question.

What is a sin-by its nature? Is it SIMPLY a violation of the natural law? If that is the case, then couldn't one posit that a sin could come to be without the 'sinner' being in full knowledge that the action is a sin, and therefore that a 'sin' could come to be without full consent by the sinner?[/quote]

No, sin is not simply a violation of natural law, in fact, the CCC defines it as “An offense against God as well as a fault against reason, truth, and right conscience. Sin is a deliberate thought, word, deed, or omission contrary to the [b]eternal law[/b] of God.” ephasis mine. So, while it may be a violation of the natural law it is contrary to the eternal law.

[quote]I suppose what I'm asking is: is a sin purely external to the actions of the sinner, or is a sin no longer a sin unless it was committed with full knowledge and consent.[/quote]

Sin needs someone to commit the sin, there has never been a sin that was committed without someone commiting it. The nature of sin depends upon a sinner :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...