Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Canon Of The Bible


Recommended Posts

JesusITrustInYou
Posted

I'm a bit confused. I'm doing some research to find out when the Church selected the canon of the Bible, but I've found two separate dates. One source says it was at the Council of Carthage in 397 AD (http://www.angelfire.com/ms/seanie/deuteros/graham4.html), but another says it was at the Council of Hippo in 390 AD (http://www.catholicapologetics.net/apolo_14.htm). What is the correct date?

Also...a Protestant told me that there was "immensely common agreement" in the early days of the Church as to what books/writings were inspired, but I also read somewhere else (I forget whether the source was Catholic or Protestant) that there was much disagreement about certain books. ? This Protestant told me to search online for the Muratorian Fragment, which I did. If I got the right idea, it is a list of books that were believed to be inspired...it was authored in the second century. Interesting to note that the author of the document refers to Pius I, bishop of Rome, aka Pope Saint Pius I...

This is what the Protestant I'm talking to had to say: [quote]"The Bible came together a lot earlier than most people think. By the middle of the 2nd century AD what we have now was almost complete. See Justin Martyr, Origen and others; also google "The Muratorian Fragment." As for the everyday life of the church, check out "The Didache"--you can find it online. Books that were clearly apostolic were never really in question, nor were the four Gospels. There was immensely common agreement well before the first church council of Nicea, in 325 AD; and that council wasn't about the content of the Bible. "[/quote]

...I've read some quotes from Justin Martyr, Origen, and other early Christians/early Church Fathers...and they certainly sound like they were [i][b]Catholics[/b][/i] to me! Justin Martyr speaks [i]quite[/i] plainly about the Real Presence of Jesus in the Eucharist...but apparently this Protestant doesn't know about that or would like to twist what Justin Martyr says to make it mean something else...? I just don't understand the way Protestants think. :idontknow:

Any information/help would be much appreciated! God bless!

  • 5 weeks later...
Posted

moved for response

Posted (edited)

Hippo and Carthage did define the canon but were not binding on the whole Church because they were not ecumenical councils. They are of great value however because they show that the Church was working to come together on this matter. Some say Pope Damasus was the first to state the canon in the late 4th century but it is not clear whether he actually wrote the statement that is attributed to him. Pope Leo the Great definitely defined the canon, though likely in a non-infallible way. I would consider the papal promulgation of the vulgate by the Pope to be pretty definitive, though perhaps in an indirect manner. The Statement by the Council of Flourence ratifies the long standing canon and so does trent. Some say trent is the only infallibly declared statement. At any rate all these canons agree with one another and not with Protestants.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

By the way, with regard to his fragment it is of little importance since the NT is not in dispute. There were conflicts in the NT canon however, some did not want revelations and some objected to Peter and Hebrews. Someone had to sort this out and that is what the Church did. That some of the canon was known is a rather unimportant fact. Who settles disputes is the question. I think Mt 16, 18 and acts 15 give a pretty clear answer. The fact is that they have benefited from those who settled the disputes long ago. They do not normally question the canon or go about proving that the books that are there should be. They accept the authority of those who have decided and settled the disputes.

Posted

I know this doesn't specifically answer the question, but I seem to recall that Athanasius was the first to state the NT in its final form in his Easter Letter in 367.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...