Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Anglican Rift And Catholicism


Recommended Posts

Posted

As some of you may know I have great interest in the worldwide Anglican communion, not because would ever consider joining them but because I find their church predicament and global reach in many ways similar to Catholicism very interesting. So with all of the recent deveolpments in Anglicanism I think us as Catholics would do well to discuss and learn about them particularly, as it looks that perhaps God willing they may move more towards a schismatic (although I understand not completly due to Holy Orders) as opposed to heretical relationship with Rome. What are everyones thoughts here on what looks like a sure Anglican split between orthodox and heterdox factions as well as the effect that will have on their relationship with the True Church? Just on a side note that is semi-relavent I once saw a political cartoon that I thought was hilarious, becauase of its truth. It had old tired white western anglican vicars in a meeting room not wearing their traditional clerical habits while on the outside there was a group of black african Bishops dressed in almost medieval bishoporic vestments with the heading above them that stated "The New Missionaries". I thought that was very clever. Even within the true Mother Church I am finding that in our western world our church is weak and in many places very corrupt. However, in Africa and the third world where the faith is thriving that perhaps they will come to help us, it is my sincere hope. That as my ancestors went out to convert them from their pagan ways they will now come back to us like St. Jean Brebeuf, Patrick, and Boniface. Perhaps then as the Anglican church sorts this out us in Rome can learn from them and tend our ears towards our more outspoken third world bishops who imho are tending to be more orhtodox than any bishops here in Canada with a few notable exceptions. Just some thoughts, I am looking forward to reading your views.

-Will

PS if anyone knows where I could find that cartoon I had mentioned I would be very grateful.

Posted

It doesn't really matter what happens with the Angies, since all Protestant Anglicans (I'm using the term "Protestant" to distinguish them from anyone who lives in England, which is what "Anglican" actually means) already deny the Dogmata of the Holy Catholic Church and All Protestant Anglicans are in schism with the Vicar of Christ. I'm kind of hoping they go into schism with eachother just because it will entertain me.

Posted

I do think it matters because of how many souls are under the church of England. I am not suggesting they are of any authority compared to the holy Mother Church. However, due to their global dimensions and current situations I think we can learn from their experiences.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

The Anglicans need prayer and a welcome for any who wants to join our Anglican-use churches, their struggles should not be fodder for entertainment.
The split is inherent in their system since it lacks any central authority with any real power.
If you which to read about their stuggles I suggest [url="http://www.anglican.tk/"]http://www.anglican.tk/[/url]
Watching the disintegration of part of the Body of Christ is not pleasant. Who knows if we could share their fate in the future?

Posted

This topic is also of great concern to me beacuse the parish I was accepted into is a joint Catholic/Anglican church. They split the physical buildings and have their own side chapels etc to minimize costs among other things, It also allows the chance in my opinnion (I am not suggesting the arrangement is the ideal) for a deepers sense of understanding and Ecumencial dialogue in the truest sense of the word (reconciliation with Rome).

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='Crusader_4' post='1166558' date='Jan 16 2007, 02:10 AM']
What are everyones thoughts here on what looks like a sure Anglican split between orthodox and heterdox factions as well as the effect that will have on their relationship with the True Church?[/quote]

You may have read recently that a number of Episcopalian churches in Virginia split off from their diocese and attached themselves to the Convocation of the Nigerian Anglican Church in North America due to their disagreement with ordaining openly homosexual priests. My thought upon reading that was, "why not just join the RC Church?" In terms of the historic orthodoxy the above-mentioned split implies, the RC Church offers it all. The hard part, I think, is marriage of the clergy, and Rome.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1168216' date='Jan 17 2007, 02:16 PM']
You may have read recently that a number of Episcopalian churches in Virginia split off from their diocese and attached themselves to the Convocation of the Nigerian Anglican Church in North America due to their disagreement with ordaining openly homosexual priests. My thought upon reading that was, "why not just join the RC Church?" In terms of the historic orthodoxy the above-mentioned split implies, the RC Church offers it all. The hard part, I think, is marriage of the clergy, and Rome.
[/quote]
Since we re-ordain their married clergy as catholic priests, it think there are other issues concerning crossing the Tiber. Check out the link I posted, it leads to the faithful side of the discussion.

Posted (edited)

As cmp indicates married clergy is not as big an impediment as you think. In the 90's nearly 500 priests came in from the Anglican Church when they started ordaining women. Most of them were ordained as married Catholic priests. My guess is there was more pressing issues that kept the recent ones from joining the Catholic Church.

Edited by cmotherofpirl
kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1168220' date='Jan 17 2007, 02:19 PM']
Since we re-ordain their married clergy as catholic priests, it think their are other issues concerning crossing the Tiber. Check out the link I posted, it leads to the faithful side of the discussion.
[/quote]


[quote name='thessalonian' post='1168229' date='Jan 17 2007, 02:28 PM']
As cmp indicates married clergy is not as big an impediment as you think. In the 90's nearly 500 priests came in from the Anglican Church when they started ordaining women. Most of them were ordained as married Catholic priests. My guess is there was more pressing issues that kept the recent ones from joinging the Catholic Church.
[/quote]

So it's got to be Rome, then, i.e. central authority, although I'm sure that historical "baggage" plays a part as well. Along those lines, the Anglican Communion is part of the Reformed Tradition, [i]nicht wahr[/i] ? One that holds that we can all read and interpret the Bible for ourselves?

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1167358' date='Jan 16 2007, 06:28 PM']
The Anglicans need prayer and a welcome for any who wants to join our Anglican-use churches, their struggles should not be fodder for entertainment.
The split is inherent in their system since it lacks any central authority with any real power.
If you which to read about their stuggles I suggest [url="http://www.anglican.tk/"]http://www.anglican.tk/[/url]
Watching the disintegration of part of the Body of Christ is not pleasant. Who knows if we could share their fate in the future?
[/quote]

The Protestant Anglicans are not a part of the Mystical Body of Christ. Only those visibly or invisibly within the Holy Catholic Church are members of the Mystical Body of Christ.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

When you are baptised in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit you become a member of the Body of Christ.

she_who_is_not
Posted

As an Anglican who has struggled and continues to struggle to enter the Roman church, I have a deep investment in this issue. As silly as this sounds, my issues are not doctrinal. I have read and studied the catechism and would have no problem making a profession of faith or any other act of unity. However, my personal struggle has been to find a parish that can be concurrently loving and reverent. I attend a Rite 1 Solemn high mass at an ECUSA parish but do not recieve the sacraments. I make a spiritual communion and spend time in adoration. When I attend mass at Catholic parishes I find myself to distracted by various things (bad music, ridiculously dumbed down homilies, liturgical novelty) that I can not worship. The Anglican rite allows me to worship in the beauty of holiness and while I understand that unification and reception of the sacraments is most important, I am not yet willing to make the sacrifice. I have been in RCIA classed twice, and if I am not ready, I'm not. I'm sure many others are in the same boat. I have faith that in my lifetime, in one way or another I will be in communion with Rome but these things take time. Pray that God will humble me and my brethren and pray that one day we all may be ONE holy. Catholic, and apostolic church.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1169070' date='Jan 18 2007, 02:09 PM']
As an Anglican who has struggled and continues to struggle to enter the Roman church, I have a deep investment in this issue. As silly as this sounds, my issues are not doctrinal. I have read and studied the catechism and would have no problem making a profession of faith or any other act of unity. However, my personal struggle has been to find a parish that can be concurrently loving and reverent. I attend a Rite 1 Solemn high mass at an ECUSA parish but do not recieve the sacraments. I make a spiritual communion and spend time in adoration. When I attend mass at Catholic parishes I find myself to distracted by various things (bad music, ridiculously dumbed down homilies, liturgical novelty) that I can not worship. The Anglican rite allows me to worship in the beauty of holiness and while I understand that unification and reception of the sacraments is most important, I am not yet willing to make the sacrifice. I have been in RCIA classed twice, and if I am not ready, I'm not. I'm sure many others are in the same boat. I have faith that in my lifetime, in one way or another I will be in communion with Rome but these things take time. Pray that God will humble me and my brethren and pray that one day we all may be ONE holy. Catholic, and apostolic church.
[/quote]
God bless you on your journey. :) Can you get to an Anglican usuage church?

she_who_is_not
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1169091' date='Jan 18 2007, 02:35 PM']
God bless you on your journey. :) Can you get to an Anglican usuage church?
[/quote]

Unfortunately, no. That would be, of course, the best option. I live in a small city with only 3 RC parishes.

she_who_is_not
Posted

I have a quick question. In Anglican use parishes is communion received at the altar rail? Also are extraordinary ministers of communion used?
Maybe I should move to Texas.

Posted (edited)

[quote]When you are baptised in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit you become a member of the Body of Christ.[/quote]

You are in error. The Catechism teaches:

[quote name='The Catechism of St. Pius X']Those Outside the Communion of Saints

10 Q. Who are they who do not belong to the Communion of Saints?
A. Those who are damned do not belong to the Communion of Saints in the other life; and in this life those who belong neither to the body nor to the soul of the Church, that is, those who are in mortal sin, and who are outside the true Church.

11 Q. Who are they who are outside the true Church?
A. Outside the true Church are: Infidels, Jews, heretics, apostates, schismatics, and the excommunicated.

12 Q. Who are infidels?
A. Infidels are those who have not been baptised and do not believe in Jesus Christ, because they either believe in and worship false gods as idolaters do, or though admitting one true God, they do not believe in the Messiah, neither as already come in the Person of Jesus Christ, nor as to come; for instance, Mohammedans and the like.

13 Q. Who are the Jews?
A. The Jews are those who profess the Law of Moses; have not received baptism; and do not believe in Jesus Christ.

14 Q. Who are heretics?
A. Heretics are those of the baptised who obstinately refuse to believe some truth revealed by God and taught as an article of faith by the Catholic Church; for example, the Arians, the Nestorians and the various sects of Protestants.

15 Q. Who are apostates?
A. Apostates are those who abjure, or by some external act, deny the Catholic faith which they previously professed.

16 Q. Who are schismatics?
A. Schismatics are those Christians who, while not explicitly denying any dogma, yet voluntarily separate themselves from the Church of Jesus Christ, that is, from their lawful pastors.

17 Q. Who are the excommunicated?
A. The excommunicated are those who, because of grievous transgressions, are struck with excommunication by the Pope or their Bishop, and consequently are cut off as unworthy from the body of the Church, which, however, hopes for and desires their conversion.

18 Q. Should excommunication be dreaded?
A. Excommunication should be greatly dreaded, because it is the severest and most terrible punishment the Church can inflict upon her rebellious and obstinate children.

19 Q. Of what goods are the excommunicated deprived?
A. The excommunicated are deprived of public prayers, of the Sacraments, of indulgences and of Christian burial.

20 Q. Can we in any way help the excommunicated?
A. We can in some way help the excommunicated and all others who are outside the true Church, by salutary advice, by prayers and good works, begging God in His mercy to grant them the grace of being converted to the faith and of entering into the Communion of Saints.[/quote]

Edited by StThomasMore
Posted

Yes- rail. No- EM's.

[quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1169133' date='Jan 18 2007, 01:09 PM']
I have a quick question. In Anglican use parishes is communion received at the altar rail? Also are extraordinary ministers of communion used?
Maybe I should move to Texas.
[/quote]

Posted (edited)

She,

I am an ex-ECUSA as of Nov '05. My dad is an episcopal priest. PM me if you wish.

here he is.
[url="http://www.allsaintsweatherford.org/rector.shtml"]http://www.allsaintsweatherford.org/rector.shtml[/url]


John

[quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1169133' date='Jan 18 2007, 01:09 PM']
I have a quick question. In Anglican use parishes is communion received at the altar rail? Also are extraordinary ministers of communion used?
Maybe I should move to Texas.
[/quote]

I miss the rail and Book of Common prayer also, however the more I have learned about the Eucharist, the less it matters. Besides you might get the rail back at a Latin Mass if one of the 3 parishes in your town has one.

John

Edited by jswranch
Posted

I think it is the neatest thing that there are entire congregations converting to the Catholic Church. I attended the parish in Arlington, Texas while I was there, and now I'm in San Antone, there is another close by.

Several of my friends who are Episcopalian have asked me, when I am back in DFW, to attend Church with me. I am truly hoping they will ask God into their hearts and continue searching for Him, so that we can all be together in Paradise and on Earth!

I think it is definitely time that we finally come together, all of us, Greek, Anglican and Catholic, all under one Church, preaching the One Faith like Paul used to write about. The world would be so great then!!

Posted

[quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1169133' date='Jan 18 2007, 03:09 PM']
I have a quick question. In Anglican use parishes is communion received at the altar rail? Also are extraordinary ministers of communion used?
Maybe I should move to Texas.
[/quote]And maybe you should find a Catholic Church where the Tridentine Latin Mass is celebrated. No altar girls. No EM's. Communion is received kneeling. Holy silence before and after Mass. Gregorian chant. A choir sings Latin High Mass from the balcony. Socializing is done only outside the sacred space. Dress requirements are posted on the door (they relate to modesty, not money). It's glorious.

Jay

----------------------------------
Blessed Father Damien, pray for us!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...