Mateo el Feo Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 Does anyone have any advice for those who wish to begin the study of Philosophy? I've just begun to read an introductory book which takes ten fundamental issues (e.g. nature of the universe, free will, etc) and walks through how philosophers through the ages answered these questions. Some issues I'm thinking of as I'm learning: 1) The value of books on particular philosophy topics vs. particular philosophers 2) Western vs. non-Western tradition 3) Particular philosophers worth paying attention to or avoiding 4) Particular books or online resources that are helpful It's a big topic, so I appreciate any help!
qfnol31 Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 Having studied philosophy at a university for almost four years now, I would recommend beginning with the Ancient philosophers, perhaps Plato's [i]Republic[/i] or his [i]Euthyphro[/i] first. From there I would go to Aristotle's [i]Nichomachean Ethics[/i]. Those are not easy works, but they lay a good foundation. After that I have quite a few more recommendations, such as the work(s) of Parminides or the other pre-Socratics.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 Personally, I would suggest finding a brief [i]historical[/i] introduction to philosophy. I have found that if you try to grapple with things outside of their chronological context, it is more difficult to understand the concepts in question. Of course it is possible to just pick up Kant and start reading, but he'll be a heck of a lot easier if you are at least familiar with Hume and understand [i]why[/i] Kant is doing what he does. The same is true throughout. So, while I definately think that Mateo is correct and the Early Platonic Dialogues are the single best place to begin actually doing philosophy (though I would suggest perhaps the [i]Euthyphro[/i], the [i]Phaedo[/i], and the [i]Apology[/i] before you sink your teeth into the [i]Republic[/i]), I have personally found that doing philosophy is a whole lot easier when you already have a basic introduction to the history of philosophy as a whole.
Starets Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 I would have to agree with taking an historical approach to philosophy in order to give yourself a good grounding first. A good reference work I used was Copleston's A History of Philosophy
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 Ditto. I agree with the above in that having a general grasp of the history of philosophy straight away would be invaluable. And the better your grasp of the ancients (particularly Plato and Aristotle), the more you will appreciate subsequent philosophy. I would just add that taking one great philosopher as a teacher can be beneficial in studying philosophy in general. I would recommend getting deep into the philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas. I'm not saying that I think everyone should be a strict Thomist (I'm not), but in my experience this sort of thing helps in staying somewhat grounded and focused whilst exploring the terrain of philosophical history. The best way to really learn and appreciate philosophy in my opinion is to really engage each philosopher that you study, rather than simply memorizing what they said. But it also takes a lot of time and study to fully develop a comprehensive philosophical view; therefore I believe it is helpful to become a Padawan as it were. It doesn't necessarily have to be Thomas; I was actually more into St. Bonaventure. Duns Scotus is cool too, or Augustine, Jeff might suggest St. Anselm. Just a suggestion anyway.
mroger Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1168757' date='Jan 17 2007, 10:44 PM'] Does anyone have any advice for those who wish to begin the study of Philosophy? I've just begun to read an introductory book which takes ten fundamental issues (e.g. nature of the universe, free will, etc) and walks through how philosophers through the ages answered these questions. [/quote] Wow! One book does all that? I'm impressed, but how does the book fit on your shelf? I'd recommend, that if you are just beginning, then begin with the Ancients. Read Phaedo and read The Republic (twice each). And that, too, if you understand Aristotle, then you'll have an easier time understanding why people like Kant [in your modern philo books] would have a problem accepting Thomism and the other Midieval philosophies. As for non-western philosophy, the big thing right now is Hindu/Indian philosophy. In American/Continental philosophy, Hermeneutics is it. You can do it without Heidegger, because Heidegger alone will take you two years just to get a grip on it, but hey - that's the good stuff!! Good luck! [color="#FF0000"]Sie müssen leben das Erlebnis! Auch, kein Betrügen![/color] Edited January 18, 2007 by geistesswiesenschaften
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 [quote]It doesn't necessarily have to be Thomas; I was actually more into St. Bonaventure. Duns Scotus is cool too, or Augustine, Jeff might suggest St. Anselm. [/quote] hahaha, Anselm is to me what Bonaventure is to you. He certainly doesnt define my philosophical and theological approach (I'm way too aristotelian for Anselm to provide a system that is entirely convincing) but every time I need a breath of fresh air so to speak, I always find something illuminating in Anselm. Plus, the [i]Prosologion[/i] was the first bit of philosophy that made me realise just how amazingly cool philosophy could be. Maybe you could call him my first philosophical love? Ultimately he just wasn't the one I was meant to be with, but he'll always have a special place in my heart :
Thy Geekdom Come Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 If you want to study philosophy, I would make the following recommendation: 1. Get yourself a good, solid, thick, historical text, something from Plato or Aristotle, or perhaps the entire Summa in one volume, with commentary. 2. Beat your skull continually with it until you decide you would no longer like to damage your brain (thus terminating your desire to study philosophy). 3. Put the brain-damaging text down and go outside for some fresh air. Okay, well...if you still want to study philosophy, I suppose you could always do what these folks say, but I think it either makes you nuts or it's what nutty people study. : Okay, just kidding...I appreciate the good Christian philosophers we have here.
qfnol31 Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 [quote name='JeffCR07' post='1168927' date='Jan 18 2007, 09:33 AM'] Personally, I would suggest finding a brief [i]historical[/i] introduction to philosophy. I have found that if you try to grapple with things outside of their chronological context, it is more difficult to understand the concepts in question. Of course it is possible to just pick up Kant and start reading, but he'll be a heck of a lot easier if you are at least familiar with Hume and understand [i]why[/i] Kant is doing what he does. The same is true throughout. So, while I definately think that Mateo is correct and the Early Platonic Dialogues are the single best place to begin actually doing philosophy (though I would suggest perhaps the [i]Euthyphro[/i], the [i]Phaedo[/i], and the [i]Apology[/i] before you sink your teeth into the [i]Republic[/i]), I have personally found that doing philosophy is a whole lot easier when you already have a basic introduction to the history of philosophy as a whole. [/quote] I'm not sure if you meant to say qfnol31 in there or Mateo, but oh well. : I myself got my introduction to the history of philosophy through the course of four classes in which I never read a history of philosophy book...and not having done so I would actually question the worth of such a book. I just don't trust anyone enough to not read the philosophers themselves...I think that most people are too biased to give such an understanding, but I'm not sure. I love my professors, though I recognize in which ways they are biased (such as one is a Straussian, etc.) My .02 cents.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 hahaha yep, I meant you, not Mateo. And we're in total agreement: if you can take a couple [i]courses[/i] that together give you a preliminary knowledge the broad history of philosophy, that is far better than reading a book on the history of philosophy. In my opinion, philosophy is not best done alone. A small classroom setting, in which open discussion reigns, is ideal. I just assumed that someone asking how they should go about studying philosophy doesn't have access to philosophy classes. Oh, and I love raph's answer as well.
traichuoi Posted January 18, 2007 Posted January 18, 2007 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1168844' date='Jan 17 2007, 09:27 PM'] Having studied philosophy at a university for almost four years now, I would recommend beginning with the Ancient philosophers, perhaps Plato's [i]Republic[/i] or his [i]Euthyphro[/i] first. From there I would go to Aristotle's [i]Nichomachean Ethics[/i]. Those are not easy works, but they lay a good foundation. After that I have quite a few more recommendations, such as the work(s) of Parminides or the other pre-Socratics. [/quote] I second qfnol's suggestion about reading Plato's Republic...
MichaelFilo Posted January 22, 2007 Posted January 22, 2007 (edited) Why the answer is quite simple... start with the early Greeks (a thread about Xeno is out there) Epicurus (sp?).. then move on to some of the later stuff, such as Plato and Aristotle... then head on forward to Early Christianity, then middle ages... then the more modern stuff.. Descartes, Locke, Hume, Kant, Hobbes.. then to Camus, Kierkegaard, Buber, Nietzsche, etc. Of course, this is only if you want philosophy itself, not Catholic philosophy in particular. So, as everyone said, move through history with philosophical progression. Edited January 22, 2007 by MichaelFilo
Totus Tuus Posted January 22, 2007 Posted January 22, 2007 For some lighter Catholic philosophy on the side, you might want to read Peter Kreeft's books. I wouldn't suggest using them as a primary source, but he can help you keep your focus on [i]loving wisdom[/i]. I have to warn you though, that he is more of an Augustinian/Socratic (like me ) in his thinking, as opposed to a Thomist/Aristotilian. God bless
Mateo el Feo Posted January 29, 2007 Author Posted January 29, 2007 Just FYI, here is the book that I mentioned above. It's called [b]"Basic Teachings of the Great Philosophers[/b]" by S. E. Frost. Here's the Amazon link: [url="http://www.amazon.com/Basic-Teachings-Great-Philosophers-Frost/dp/038503007X/sr=8-1/qid=1170049813/ref=sr_1_1/102-0087848-9919312?ie=UTF8&s=books"]http://www.amazon.com/Basic-Teachings-Grea...TF8&s=books[/url]
Laudate_Dominum Posted February 3, 2007 Posted February 3, 2007 [quote name='qfnol31' post='1168844' date='Jan 18 2007, 01:27 AM'] Having studied philosophy at a university for almost four years now, I would recommend beginning with the Ancient philosophers, perhaps Plato's [i]Republic[/i] or his [i]Euthyphro[/i] first. From there I would go to Aristotle's [i]Nichomachean Ethics[/i]. Those are not easy works, but they lay a good foundation. After that I have quite a few more recommendations, such as the work(s) of Parminides or the other pre-Socratics. [/quote] I've been thinking about this and I believe I know how I would approach things if I could start all over again. I would start with an overview of ancient philosophy such as the first volume Copleston's "History of Philosophy" or perhaps something more recent such as the "Handbook of Greek Philosophy" by Nikolaos Bakalis. After this I would linger for a good while on Pre-Socratic Philosophy. I would read a couple short overviews such as "Beginning with the Pre-Socratics" whilst simultaneously familiarizing myself with the fragments and testimonia via one of the collections out there. Now I would read (or reread) at least Homer and Hesiod (possibly the Elegiac poetry and other such things). At the same time I would read a couple books on early Greek history. Once I felt somewhat comfortable with the early historical and cultural setting I would revisit the fragments and testimonia whilst reading the first two volumes of W.K.C. Guthrie's "History of Greek Philosophy" followed by Kirk, Raven and Schofield's "The Pre-Socratic Philosophers". Next I would probably read some more specialized books on particular Pre-Socratic figures that may have particularly interested me or who I still need to chew on for a while, for example I might feel the need to scoop up some scholarly studies specifically about Heraclitus or the Pythagoreans. I would continue this general sort of approach through the Sophists, Socrates, Plato, etc.. except in the case where there are extant writings rather than mere fragments I would of course study those writings more closely instead of relying more or less on analysis. But I would still strive to have a grip on the state of scholarship and interpretation. The study would not be limited to the philosophers, I would also (although more selectively) chronologically read the major poets, historians, etc. It would also be invaluable to read material pertaining specifically to the history of science as well as the history of mathematics (for example Heath's "History of Greek Mathematics"), and when the time came I would read Euclid, Archimedes, etc. No doubt the best way to prepare for this kind of study would be to attain some familiarity with ancient Greek language. Many will vehemently disagree, but in my opinion the best place to start is with Biblical Koine Greek. I think this way partly because I am Catholic and reading the Bible in Greek is ultimately more important to me than reading Plato, but also because it is easier to learn since classical Greek is more involved. I would of course get some good lexicons and guides to earlier forms of Greek (basically just be sure to have resources specific to Homeric, Attic, etc available for when you need them). Another reason I don't think starting with Koine is a bad idea is because as a beginner the goal won't be to read the writings in their original, but simply to be able to decipher short quotations, study words, etc. Taking this kind of approach I believe that in two years or less one would have a pretty good grasp of ancient Greek Philosophy and the perfect foundation for studying the rest of Western Philosophy in this historical manner. And if after the historical sweep of Western Philosophy one wanted to specialize in ancient phil. you would then go back and read things in the original languages and get hip to the scholarship on a more comprehensive level (dip into the journals, etc). To quote George Burns: "I wish I was eighteen again". Oh, and if this seems like overkill I must say that I disagree. If one adopted this kind of systematic, holistic approach the rewards would be immense. By the time you got around to reading, say Augustine, the fruits would speak for themselves.
Mateo el Feo Posted February 3, 2007 Author Posted February 3, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1183686' date='Feb 3 2007, 08:04 AM']To quote George Burns: "I wish I was eighteen again".[/quote]Amen. [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1183686' date='Feb 3 2007, 08:04 AM']Oh, and if this seems like overkill I must say that I disagree. If one adopted this kind of systematic, holistic approach the rewards would be immense. By the time you got around to reading, say Augustine, the fruits would speak for themselves.[/quote]It's funny that you mention Augustine. Almost immediately after beginning the basic philosophy book mentioned above, I realized that significant parts of St. Augustine's "Confessions" don't make much sense without the framework of Greek Philosophy. For example, when he's writing on the subjects of time, matter, form, Creation, etc. My thought was, maybe St. Augustine's writings won't hurt my brain as much if I learned a little philosophy...
Era Might Posted February 3, 2007 Posted February 3, 2007 Richard Geraghty has a good book called "The Right Way To Live: Plato's Republic for Catholic Students" ([url="http://www.amazon.com/Right-Way-Live-Republic-Catholic/dp/1891280066/sr=8-1/qid=1170545212/ref=sr_1_1/002-2752740-8694427?ie=UTF8&s=books"]LINK[/url]).
Laudate_Dominum Posted February 3, 2007 Posted February 3, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1184207' date='Feb 3 2007, 07:28 PM'] Richard Geraghty has a good book called "The Right Way To Live: Plato's Republic for Catholic Students" ([url="http://www.amazon.com/Right-Way-Live-Republic-Catholic/dp/1891280066/sr=8-1/qid=1170545212/ref=sr_1_1/002-2752740-8694427?ie=UTF8&s=books"]LINK[/url]). [/quote] Hey, that's pretty cool. Philosophy books by real Catholic scholars are the best.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now