Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Not Even The Holiest Night Of The Year Is Spared!


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naH8r3b7zAg"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naH8r3b7zAg[/url]

Brought to you by the Franciscan University of Steubenville.

Posted

some people have far too much time on their hands

Posted (edited)

umm... no one died.

I dont mean to sound cold, but most of the people on here know how Steubenville does the liturgy.

I'll bet most of the people in the vid dont know that its not the right way to do things. No one was trying to be sacriligious. I'm not defending the way they do things, but this shouldnt be something to throw up over...

Edited by Didymus
Knight of the Holy Rosary
Posted (edited)

Let's not bring the Church into the world! Let's bring the world into the Church! :rolleyes:

Edited by Knight of the Holy Rosary
Posted

There more important things to worry about then something that happened over 8 months ago.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I don't care for the liturgical style at FUS, but the student who shot this was punished, and for good reason: attending and recording a Mass for the sole purpose of spreading news about how bad the liturgy may be is itself an abuse of the Mass (using the Mass solely as a means to an end, rather than an end in itself). This video should not even exist. Where Jesus chooses to bless with His presence, we have no right to say that He should not.

Posted

I'd like to hear from some F.U.S. students on this.

Would that be considered standard practice in terms of liturgical celebrations? (Holy Week is obviously not standard) but I mean in terms of charismatic liturgy.

I've heard that there's some variety with respect to the celebration of the mass, both traditional and contemporary are available.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1169576' date='Jan 18 2007, 08:31 PM']
I don't care for the liturgical style at FUS, but the student who shot this was punished, and for good reason: attending and recording a Mass for the sole purpose of spreading news about how bad the liturgy may be is itself an abuse of the Mass (using the Mass solely as a means to an end, rather than an end in itself). This video should not even exist. Where Jesus chooses to bless with His presence, we have no right to say that He should not.
[/quote]

exactly.

and I just thought it was quite annoying that the filmer made sure all the viewers knew who composed each of the songs used in the liturgy. thats just rediculous

son_of_angels
Posted

No, I think most of you are quite wrong on many counts. Perhaps the filmer should not have shot the film, but don't "shoot" the messenger, if you will. This is bad liturgy, period. Bad liturgy is bad liturgy when judged by standards of beauty and sacredness and is not excused by what is "permitted" and what is not. This notion has been consistently expressed by such theologians as Pope Benedict, and others.

We need to fix bad liturgy; but fix it by means of the church and not by outlandish and radical steps that make our own selves sinful.

Posted

I was at Steubenville for a conference in 2004 and 2006, so I've seen it personally. Just as all the students here have.

The former vocations director for my diocese called Steubenville the "commonly recognized benchmark of Catholic Orthodoxy." If that's true, when it comes to theology and liturgy then the Church is in big trouble!

Could Christ the King not hold all these people? Is that why it was the field house?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1169597' date='Jan 18 2007, 10:03 PM']
I was at Steubenville for a conference in 2004 and 2006, so I've seen it personally. Just as all the students here have.

The former vocations director for my diocese called Steubenville the "commonly recognized benchmark of Catholic Orthodoxy." If that's true, when it comes to theology and liturgy then the Church is in big trouble!

Could Christ the King not hold all these people? Is that why it was the field house?
[/quote]
Any word or action which has at least the appearance of evil, and which is the occasion of sin to another. It is a [b]grave[/b] sin in grave matter because it is opposed to the law of charity. Christ speaks of scandal: "Woe to the world because of scandals. For it must needs be that scandals come: but nevertheless woe to that man by whom the scandal, cometh." (Matthew 18)

GRAVE sin means it better be on the list for confession. Trying to damage the reputation of a school is scandal.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='SJP' post='1169582' date='Jan 18 2007, 09:37 PM']
I'd like to hear from some F.U.S. students on this.

Would that be considered standard practice in terms of liturgical celebrations? (Holy Week is obviously not standard) but I mean in terms of charismatic liturgy.

I've heard that there's some variety with respect to the celebration of the mass, both traditional and contemporary are available.
[/quote]
No, the Masses are not typically that...charismatic. They usually are somewhat charismatic, though, but no more than a LifeTeen Mass.

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1169597' date='Jan 18 2007, 10:03 PM']
I was at Steubenville for a conference in 2004 and 2006, so I've seen it personally. Just as all the students here have.

The former vocations director for my diocese called Steubenville the "commonly recognized benchmark of Catholic Orthodoxy." If that's true, when it comes to theology and liturgy then the Church is in big trouble!

Could Christ the King not hold all these people? Is that why it was the field house?
[/quote]
Theology at FUS is very orthodox.

And no, Christ the King Chapel can hardly hold each of three daily Masses (I'd say about 80% of the student body goes to Mass every day), let alone one Mass for the whole school.

Posted

Cmom,

Steubenville has its own reputation. I've nothing other than to post a video of the Sacred Liturgy being abused.

So if I accuse Steubenville on those grounds, so do the papal instructions and documents of the Catholic Church.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='son_of_angels' post='1169590' date='Jan 18 2007, 09:55 PM']
No, I think most of you are quite wrong on many counts. Perhaps the filmer should not have shot the film, but don't "shoot" the messenger, if you will. This is bad liturgy, period. Bad liturgy is bad liturgy when judged by standards of beauty and sacredness and is not excused by what is "permitted" and what is not. This notion has been consistently expressed by such theologians as Pope Benedict, and others.

We need to fix bad liturgy; but fix it by means of the church and not by outlandish and radical steps that make our own selves sinful.
[/quote]
Bad liturgy still can have Christ present. Therefore, it is still an abuse and, as Cmom pointed out, a scandal to videotape a liturgy solely for the purpose of "exposing" liturgical faux pas. Jesus Christ was there. If I were faced with no alternative for an obligatory Mass, I would be there, too.

As it is, I was at St. Peter's downtown for Mass that Sunday.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1169636' date='Jan 18 2007, 10:28 PM']
Cmom,

Steubenville has its own reputation. I've nothing other than to post a video of the Sacred Liturgy being abused.

So if I accuse Steubenville on those grounds, so do the papal instructions and documents of the Catholic Church.
[/quote]
See I watched video. I thank God so many college kids are at Mass. I didn't like the girl skipping, and I really don't like clapping, but that did NOT invalidate the MASS IN ANY WAY.
I them all being at Holy Mass with Jesus Christ than I like you here trying to committ scandal, and trying to get us to commit scandal with you.
Try dealing with the plank in your eye, instead of what you are attempting now.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1169636' date='Jan 18 2007, 10:28 PM']
Cmom,

Steubenville has its own reputation. I've nothing other than to post a video of the Sacred Liturgy being abused.

So if I accuse Steubenville on those grounds, so do the papal instructions and documents of the Catholic Church.
[/quote]
In the words of Fr. Bob Levis, "there were just as many abuses in the Tridentine Rite; it's just that nobody knew about them because it was in Latin."

Posted

Ok there is just WAY to many people running around like idiots during that mass...

I can not stand liturgical dance, I think it brings an extreme amount of cheesiness :coagulated milk: to the sacred liturgy. I mean what is the point of a girl dancing with a bowl of holy water, or dancing with a candle it seems almost a pagan thing to do. You see that in Hindu ceremonies.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1169597' date='Jan 18 2007, 10:03 PM']
I was at Steubenville for a conference in 2004 and 2006, so I've seen it personally. Just as all the students here have.

The former vocations director for my diocese called Steubenville the "commonly recognized benchmark of Catholic Orthodoxy." If that's true, when it comes to theology and liturgy then the Church is in big trouble!

Could Christ the King not hold all these people? Is that why it was the field house?
[/quote]

If you have been to Steubenville then you know that the chapel really isn't THAT big. You would also know that their liturgy leans to the charismatic side (which I had always understood to be common kowledge anyway). That does not, however, lessen the degree of faithfulness or solidity in their theology/catechetics department as far as teaching goes. I know for fact that many of the professors go to Mass at one of the best parishes in town.

I am no big fan of the charismatic movement (frankly it just doesn't jive with me, but I'm not about to condemn it as a whole since its got Church approval), but its really beginning to bug me seeing threads keep popping up with videos of this nature. Deliberately seeking out videos of abuses doesn't seem to me to be all that healthy a spiritual exercise. We know abuses exist, we should be praying to put an end to it and working on putting an end to abuses within our own parishes. I don't think watching videos of abuses in other parishes, especially places where we can't make a difference helps any of us. (Granted some people here could try, and do try, to make a difference at FUS, but I'm not just talking about this video in this thread, I mean all of them.)

So there is my 0.02 on the subject.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='brendan1104' post='1169451' date='Jan 18 2007, 08:01 PM']
[url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naH8r3b7zAg"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naH8r3b7zAg[/url]

Brought to you by the Franciscan University of Steubenville.
[/quote]
:lol: Memories...

That video just scratches the surface. You should see the Masses at the charismatic conference. I made the mistake of checking it out one summer out of curiosity.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...