phlex Posted January 20, 2007 Posted January 20, 2007 First of all - Mark Hart aka the Bible Geek is one of the most amazing Catholics I've ever had the chance to talk with. He truly is a man of God and is definitely a man to be respected - both in his Catholic education & training as well as his sincere desire to serve the teens of the Church. Check out the article: [url="http://www.lifeteen.com/default.aspx?PageID=BGQADETAIL&__DocumentID=227337"]http://www.lifeteen.com/default.aspx?PageI...cumentID=227337[/url] My favorite part of the article: [quote]Your Catholicism is not a badge of honor that gives you the right to judge, condemn or hate. It is the call to love, regardless of denomination or belief, ALL who God put in your path. John 3:16 reminds us that “God so loved the world”, not “God so loved the Catholic”. Spend time praying and reading the Psalms and Proverbs and Matthew 5, for greater insight into how to grow in humility and meekness.[/quote]
Akalyte Posted January 20, 2007 Posted January 20, 2007 (edited) Im anti-heresy and anti-liberal. Love is not always sweet and mushy. You can love someone by telling them they are wrong and need to change. By releasing them from their ignorance. There is no sin against love or charity in admonishing people. I love the people, but yes I hate Protestantism. "Protest-antism". Edited January 20, 2007 by Akalyte
xTrishaxLynnx Posted January 20, 2007 Posted January 20, 2007 [quote name='PHLEX' post='1171515' date='Jan 20 2007, 06:27 PM'] First of all - Mark Hart aka the Bible Geek is one of the most amazing Catholics I've ever had the chance to talk with. He truly is a man of God and is definitely a man to be respected - both in his Catholic education & training as well as his sincere desire to serve the teens of the Church. [/quote] I recently bought one of his books. [i]Blessed are the Bored in Spirit: A Young Catholic's Search for Meaning.[/i] I've only read the introduction and a few bits and pieces from skimming through some of the book, but I think it's gonna be a great book and from what I've read about him so far he seems to be devoted to helping to bring young people closer to God.
Resurrexi Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 [quote name='Akalyte' post='1171523' date='Jan 20 2007, 05:37 PM'] Im anti-heresy and anti-liberal. Love is not always sweet and mushy. You can love someone by telling them they are wrong and need to change. By releasing them from their ignorance. There is no sin against love or charity in admonishing people. I love the people, but yes I hate Protestantism. "Protest-antism". [/quote] so do I.
Era Might Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 [quote]Love for the truth is the deepest dimension of any authentic quest for full communion between Christians. Without this love it would be impossible to face the objective theological, cultural, psychological and social difficulties which appear when disagreements are examined. This dimension, which is interior and personal, must be inseparably accompanied by a spirit of charity and humility. There must be charity towards one's partner in dialogue, and humility with regard to the truth which comes to light and which might require a review of assertions and attitudes. With regard to the study of areas of disagreement, the Council requires that the whole body of doctrine be clearly presented. At the same time, it asks that the manner and method of expounding the Catholic faith should not be a hindrance to dialogue with our brothers and sisters. Certainly it is possible to profess one's faith and to explain its teaching in a way that is correct, fair and understandable, and which at the same time takes into account both the way of thinking and the actual historical experiences of the other party. ... Dialogue does not extend exclusively to matters of doctrine but engages the whole person; it is also a dialogue of love. The Council has stated: "Catholics must joyfully acknowledge and esteem the truly Christian endowments from our common heritage which are to be found among our separated brothers and sisters. It is right and salutary to recognize the riches of Christ and virtuous works in the lives of others who are bearing witness to Christ, sometimes even to the shedding of their blood. For God is always wonderful in his works and worthy of admiration". --Pope John Paul II, Encyclical Letter "Ut Unum Sint"[/quote]
Nathan Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 If I loved Protestantism, I'd be a Protestant. I'd also be a heretic. We are not called to love heresy, but to be sorrowful over its very existence. The followers of heresy, however, are to be loved. Loved, perhaps, even more than others because they are in need of it the most. The greatest expression of that love we are to have for them is our evangelization -- to gently take them by the hand and walk them home. A great factor in my conversion to the Catholic faith was the sheer warmth and love that I felt -- intelligent love, responsible love, like the love a parent has for his child -- when I met with my group of Catholic friends, in RCIA.
desertwoman Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 The same thing can be said of Protestants who are anti-catholic. They don't hate you, but hate the fact that you are steeped in heresy and so forth.
Knight of the Holy Rosary Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 [quote]Im anti-heresy and anti-liberal. Love is not always sweet and mushy. You can love someone by telling them they are wrong and need to change. By releasing them from their ignorance. There is no sin against love or charity in admonishing people. I love the people, but yes I hate Protestantism. "Protest-antism".[/quote] Well put sir. I do hate Protestantism. It is a lie that came from the 'Father of all lies'.
Nathan Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 (edited) [quote name='desertwoman' post='1171669' date='Jan 20 2007, 09:41 PM'] The same thing can be said of Protestants who are anti-catholic. They don't hate you, but hate the fact that you are steeped in heresy and so forth. [/quote] Thankfully, the truth is on the side of the Catholic faith. Not to mention demonstratable evidence, to any Protestant with open ears. Edited January 21, 2007 by Nathan
cathoholic_anonymous Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 (edited) I don't think it's possible to distinguish a belief from a person. What I believe is what I am. Attack my Catholicism, and you attack me. For this reason it is extremely difficult to hector Protestants over heresy, because even if their beliefs are not correct, they do cherish those beliefs. I can remember feeling very wounded when a close friend (Protestant) challenged me over Catholic devotion to Mary. When he said matter-of-factly, "She was no more special than anybody else" I even felt slightly nauseous. This is my mother. You're talking about my mother. It hurt. It would have hurt [i]him[/i] just as much if I had started trying to dismantle his beliefs. In the past I have been guilty of doing just that, dismissing Protestant ideas with amused contempt and even poking exaggerated fun at its more implausibile cousins (i.e. Jack Chick). I will confess all this when I next go to Reconciliation, because it's just plain wrong. The prayers for Christian unity that we have been saying this week have made me realise that. Do I believe Protestantism to be false? Yes, of course. But you can't demolish someone's home - the best home he's ever had - without showing him that there's a better place waiting for him. Precious few Protestants will turn to Catholicism if their surroundings have been reduced to rubble by over-eager Catholic 'preachers' who are more eager to score points and be proven right than they are to love their neighbour. Because don't we all feel that urge? Scott Hahn describes it so well at the end of [i]Hail Holy Queen[/i]. It can feel really exhilarating when you walk away from a debate with a Protestant or an atheist or a Muslim or goodness only knows who else in the knowledge that you came off best. I know the feeling. I like the feeling. But it's not a feeling I'm going to indulge in any more. P.S. And this isn't a manifestation of 'mushy' love. I think it will take discipline to be a Church representative who hasn't got a trumpet to blow. It might mean I will even have to act like Jesus once in a while instead of just talking about how marvellous my faith is and wondering why everyone around me seems to need their ears syringing. Edited January 21, 2007 by Cathoholic Anonymous
Catholictothecore Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 [quote name='Akalyte' post='1171523' date='Jan 20 2007, 06:37 PM'] Im anti-heresy and anti-liberal. Love is not always sweet and mushy. You can love someone by telling them they are wrong and need to change. By releasing them from their ignorance. There is no sin against love or charity in admonishing people. I love the people, but yes I hate Protestantism. "Protest-antism". [/quote] Absolutely. But at the same time, we can't afford to go on "witch-hunts." These seriously went out of fashion centuries ago. However, there are a few kooks out there. No need to name names. We know who they are. :
Seven77 Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 2 cents: Protestants are imperfectly united to us via Baptism. God brings good out of all things.
Guest catholi-stant Posted January 24, 2007 Posted January 24, 2007 I became a Catholic because I wanted to worship in the same religion as my husband and to raise any future children in the same faith. I am proud to be a Roman Catholic, but I also cherish my old Protestant beliefs as well. I met riotous Catholics and Protestants. To hear you all speaking as if those who choose to practice Protestantism are “less than ” or “not good enough” as though we Catholics are better than Protestants is extremely offensive to me. We are all “less than”. We are all not good enough. That is why Christ had to make His sacrifice for us. I was so distressed by some people's attitude on this forum until I realized something very important. These people will not be judging weather or not I will be admitted into heaven, so their opinion are just that an opinion. Thank God our admittance into heaven isn't contingent on what others think of us. Don't we all know of someone who we wouldn't admit into heaven? Don't we all know at least one person who wouldn't want us in heaven with them? The only person who is fit to judge is our Heavenly Father and for that I am truly thankful.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 24, 2007 Posted January 24, 2007 [quote name='catholi-stant' post='1174574' date='Jan 24 2007, 12:58 AM'] I became a Catholic because I wanted to worship in the same religion as my husband and to raise any future children in the same faith. I am proud to be a Roman Catholic, but I also cherish my old Protestant beliefs as well. I met riotous Catholics and Protestants. To hear you all speaking as if those who choose to practice Protestantism are “less than ” or “not good enough” as though we Catholics are better than Protestants is extremely offensive to me. We are all “less than”. We are all not good enough. That is why Christ had to make His sacrifice for us. I was so distressed by some people's attitude on this forum until I realized something very important. These people will not be judging weather or not I will be admitted into heaven, so their opinion are just that an opinion. Thank God our admittance into heaven isn't contingent on what others think of us. Don't we all know of someone who we wouldn't admit into heaven? Don't we all know at least one person who wouldn't want us in heaven with them? The only person who is fit to judge is our Heavenly Father and for that I am truly thankful. [/quote] We are not better than non-catholics by any means, we simply have access to the Fullness of Truth and they do not. Therefore the standard for Catholic behavior should be higher.
Guest catholi-stant Posted January 24, 2007 Posted January 24, 2007 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1174766' date='Jan 24 2007, 01:25 PM'] We are not better than non-catholics by any means, we simply have access to the Fullness of Truth and they do not. Therefore the standard for Catholic behavior should be higher. [/quote] You know I could introduce you to some people who would feel the same exact way about us. How would you feel as a proud Roman Catholic if some had the nerve to tell you that the way you have worship Our Lord for years is wrong? When I was a Protestant and just beginning to date my husband I was ostracized for dating a nice Catholic boy who'd earned the Bishops Cross when he graduated high school. Because of this experience I have little tolerance for people who feel they are the sole holders of the Truth. Imagine my surprise when I encountered the same prejudices when I started going to mass with my husband. I think it's a waste of time to assume only we as Catholics have the Truth when we could pay attention to much more important things like world hunger. Heck I had a great grandfather who was a very holy man. Unfortunately he also believed only those who are part of the congregation Church of God were going to heaven. I have seen too many holy people who worship Our Lord with all their soul, might and strength to believe that was true and I believe the same thing about the Catholic Church. By the way you say we Catholics have the Truth, you lead me to believe that you really do believe Roman Catholics are better than Protestants. From the attitudes we have about one other, it's no wonder so many Catholics and Protestants do not trust each other. I I suppose I am offended because even though I am a Roman Catholic, I have relatives who choose to worship in a Protestant church. I don't think that they are heretics, or ignorant of truth I just think that this is the way they are the most comfortable worshiping Him. Why are we debating this anyway? I thought that Roman Catholics have tried to be more tolerant of our brother and sister Protestants since Vatican II took effect.
Lil Red Posted January 24, 2007 Posted January 24, 2007 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1174766' date='Jan 24 2007, 10:25 AM']We are not better than non-catholics by any means, we simply have access to the Fullness of Truth and they do not. Therefore the standard for Catholic behavior should be higher.[/quote]read what was said one more time. she said that Catholics have the Fullness of Truth. other religions do have some Truth, just not the fullness of the Truth. btw, welcome to the boards! : i hope you'll stick around
cmotherofpirl Posted January 25, 2007 Posted January 25, 2007 'catholi-stant' said: You know I could introduce you to some people who would feel the same exact way about us. How would you feel as a proud Roman Catholic if some had the nerve to tell you that the way you have worship Our Lord for years is wrong? [color="#3366FF"]"We are not better than non-catholics by any means, we simply have access to the Fullness of Truth and they do not. Therefore the standard for Catholic behavior should be higher" Pride has nothing to do with the facts. The fact is the Catholic Church was founded by Jesus Christ in AD33. No other group exist for 1500 years after that. We are not better than any othe group, but we are the original group. I never said anything about any other groups activities, I simply pointed out the basis for the Church. If I thought the Church didn't contain the Fullness of Truth I wouldn't be Catholic. This does not mean other groups don't contain truth, they simply don't have all of it.[/color] When I was a Protestant and just beginning to date my husband I was ostracized for dating a nice Catholic boy who'd earned the Bishops Cross when he graduated high school. Because of this experience I have little tolerance for people who feel they are the sole holders of the Truth. Imagine my surprise when I encountered the same prejudices when I started going to mass with my husband. I think it's a waste of time to assume only we as Catholics have the Truth when we could pay attention to much more important things like world hunger. [color="#3333FF"]I'm sorry you felt ostrasized for dating a Catholic. People should never be treated rudely for their beliefs. I was told at every family gathering whn I was little by my Baptist relations I was going to hell, so I do understand. But its not a prejudice, it is a teaching of the Church. Christ left the Truth in the Church he founded. World hunger is an issue many groups can work on together, doctrinal difference do not affect a starving child. But to miniminze our beliefs by saying all religious groups are equal is a disservice to all. [/color] Heck I had a great grandfather who was a very holy man. Unfortunately he also believed only those who are part of the congregation Church of God were going to heaven. I have seen too many holy people who worship Our Lord with all their soul, might and strength to believe that was true and I believe the same thing about the Catholic Church. [color="#3333FF"]THere are many holy and God-fearing people in the world, they are not all Catholic by any means [/color] By the way you say we Catholics have the Truth, you lead me to believe that you really do believe Roman Catholics are better than Protestants. From the attitudes we have about one other, it's no wonder so many Catholics and Protestants do not trust each other. [color="#3333FF"] As I pointed out it is Catholic teaching that the Church contains the Fullness of Truth. but I don't think it makes us better, in fact if we do not live as holy catholic people, it makes us worse.[/color] I suppose I am offended because even though I am a Roman Catholic, I have relatives who choose to worship in a Protestant church. I don't think that they are heretics, or ignorant of truth I just think that this is the way they are the most comfortable worshiping Him. [color="#3333FF"]I have many relatives who worship in other groups. They are ignorant of catholic teaching and in fact have been taught we are all going to hell. I would not refer to them a heretics, merely mistaken. [/color] Why are we debating this anyway? I thought that Roman Catholics have tried to be more tolerant of our brother and sister Protestants since Vatican II took effect. [color="#3333FF"]Protestants aer our seperated brothers and sisters, and we pray they may come home to the Church. It doesn't make me better than them, merely grateful to God for finding my way home.[/color]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted January 25, 2007 Posted January 25, 2007 [quote name='Akalyte' post='1171523' date='Jan 20 2007, 07:37 PM'] There is no sin against love or charity in admonishing people. [/quote] There can be.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now