Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Catholic Moral Theology


Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm taking a class on bioethics at the moment and at one point it was mentioned that the Church defers determination of the fact of death to scientists, which, at first glance, makes some sense. My question is whether (1) this is the extent of the Church's position and if so (2) whether this may be unwise given the scientific community's more recent attempts to re-define when life begins and ends. Any ideas?

Posted (edited)

The Catholic Church has little understanding concerning when the soul departs from the body, the reason why even after someone is medically declared dead Priests will sometimes still administer Sacraments “conditionally.” Moreover, if those graces and blessings can be given to them it would be wrongful to not take advantage of such, when it could be benefit in the salvation of the soul.

If I remember correctly pious tradition holds that when the Pope is thought to be dead one of the first things the cardinals do is call forth his baptismal name, rather than his professional name as the Pope or when becoming a Priest. Maybe that helps...

Edited by Mr.CatholicCat
Birgitta Noel
Posted (edited)

Let me try to shed some light on this. I am doing a PhD in health care ethics with an emphasis on Catholic moral theology (with a nationally renowned expert on transplantation and Catholic health care) and I am working in an orthodox Catholic health care facility with a very active transplant service so I've read a lot on this.

I'm going to try to break this down in a very straightforward manner so forgive me for not getting overly technical.

1) yes, the Church does defer to science for the determination of death. There are some pretty strict criteria for brain death, I believe there are seven in all, but in a nutshell, brain death is when your respiration/cardiac function is being maintained by a ventilator etc, but your brain is "dead" that is to say that there is no measurable functioning in the brain. If one were to remove the machines you would "die", that is, your respiration and heart would stop.

The other kind of death, cardiopulmonary/cardiac death is pretty straight forward (your heart is stopped and there is no blood circulation and within about 15 seconds you will have no measurable brain activity).

Neither of these determinations of death have anything to do with when the soul departs the body. There is an understanding that when the body is no longer able to function as an integrated whole that death has occurred, this is part of why the Church accepts brain death as death.

You will find some within the Church who do not accept brain death, but the Church accepts it. I'm not sure if it would be theologically correct to say that it's an "official" teaching, but if it's not, it's close. Thus the Church supports organ donation from brain dead donors. If there were scientific evidence to suggest that brain death is not really death then the Church would revisit the issue but would still rely on science for its facts.

2) As for the difficulties in determining when life begins that is a controversy that rages on, but with the determination of brain death the standards that are followed are very clinical, not definitional. Certain processes/abilities are measured, it's very calculated.

Does that make sense?

Here's a counter example that may help. The determination of whether the morning after pill is an abortifacient hinges on the definition of pregnancy one uses. If I say pregnancy begins at implantation and the meds prevent implantation then there's no abortion. If I say pregnancy begins at conception and the meds prevent implantation, the drug IS an abortifacient.

So, similarly, if I say that one who is in a persistent vegetative state (PVS) is dead then I've redefined death because one who is in a PVS would not meet the criteria for brain death. (for example, some in PVS can breathe on their own, that alone means they are not brain dead.) If I say that someone whose respiration/circulation is being maintained by machines is dead I have to meet a number of very strict criteria. I can't just redefine what I think death to be. Ask your proff about the criteria for brain death, there are strict guidelines that organ donation groups use.

I hope that sheds some light on the issue. Let me know if you need more info.

Edited by The Little Way
Posted

Thanks, that is helpful. I guess my hang up is this: how do we know that the soul actually has separated from the body in cases where there are basic biological functions still occuring yet some argue that the person is no longer conscious?
I was reading about anencephalic infants & those who wish to transplant the organs from the babies who have no consciousness but still are breathing.

Posted

The exact point at which death occurs (the soul leaves the body) is still much debated, and there is no official teaching on this.

I had a philosophy prof who rather adamentally argued that actual decay of the flesh was the only way to tell whether death had actually occured, citing cases where those who appeared dead have later revived, or turned out to have been buried alive.
(though he holds eccentric positions on a number of issues)

However, lack of conciousness in itself is not reason to declare one dead. With regards said infants and the severely brain-damaged, this presents a slippery slope.
Living human beings must not be considered "dead" or "non-persons" because they lack full brain function.

Posted

I saw a TV program on near death experiences some time ago. One of the stories raises some questions about the definition of death.

A woman in my city (Phoenix) had a brain aneurism. A team of doctors headed by neurosurgeon extraordinare Robert Spitzer, M.D., of the Barrows Neurological Institute, packed her in ice, lowered her temperature to just above freezing, stopped her heart, drained her of blood, and operated on her brain. Her heart was not beating, she was not breathing, and she was "brain dead." Following surgery, her blood was pumped back into her body, her heart was restarted, and she was revived. She described how she left her body and observed the surgery, describing in detail what the doctors said and did, followed by a journey through a tunnel and other events common to those who describe near death experiences. But she was intentionally flatlined -- no heartbeat, no brain activity, for the duration of this lengthy surgery. By definition, she was dead. Yet she remembered all these events and experiences that occurred while she was "dead." Dr. Spitzer said we'd better reevaluate our definition of death.

How can a person with no brain function recall her surgery? Memory appears not to be the exclusive function of the brain.

Wish I had a copy of that program!

Jay

---------------------------
Blessed Father Damien, pray for us!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Bishop Chaput I believe, wrote an excellent article in opposition to "brain death".

Catholic medical authority raps 'brain death' criteria
ROME, February 7, 2005 (CWNews.com/LifeSiteNews.com) - At a meeting of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences, dedicated to the discussion of organ transplants, a former president of the Catholic Medical Association has demanded a more accurate definition of when death occurs.

Current criteria used by doctors to determine "brain death"-- the point at which vital organs may be removed from a donor-- are not adequate, argued Dr. Paul Byrne. He pointed out that at the time the organs are removed, the donor's heart is beating, his body is warm, and other vital organs are still functioning, even if there is medical assistance.

"Brain death is not death," Dr. Byrne said.

In an article published in Catholic World Report in October 2001-- with Bishops Fabian Bruskewitz and Robert Vasa among several co-authors-- Byrne argued that it is the removal of the vital organs that causes the death of the donor. Therefore, the article concluded, the donation of vital organs is never morally licit.

Although he has given his support in principle to organ donation, Pope John Paul II (bio - news) has urged doctors to define clear criteria for the death of an organ donor. Bishop Marcelo Sanchez Sorondo, the chancellor of the Pontifical Academy for Sciences, said that last week's meeting in Rome had been devoted to that purpose.

See previous LifeSiteNews.com Stories on this issue
Denver Coroner Rules "Homicide" in Organ-Donor Case
[url="http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2004/oct/04101208.html"]http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2004/oct/04101208.html[/url]

Russian Surgeons Removing Organs Saying Patients Almost Dead Anyway
[url="http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2003/sep/03090906.html"]http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2003/sep/03090906.html[/url]



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Birgitta Noel
Posted

Those two articles highlight why it is very important to protect human life. I was at a national conference of bioethicists this fall when a man stood up and suggested that we do away with the dead donor rule which would mean that we could harvest organs from those in PVS, anencephalic babies, etc. This is of course unacceptable as these people are not dead. It is imperative that Catholic hospitals strictly follow organ donation guidelines so as to avoid instances where the person is "almost" dead and their organs are taken. The hospital controls the procurement of organs. The transplant team cannot take any organs without the consent of the hospital (after consent from the family has been obtained).

Dr. Byrne's article suggests that the removal of organs causes the death of the person, but this is not so, the person who is brain dead is already dead. Their brain and their brain stem have no activity, none. With no brain or brain stem activity the organs cannot function separate from the machine. The body is not functioning as a whole. We have moral certainty that these people are dead.

Catholicism understands death in a theological light but recognizes the medical understanding which echoes the theological one. In the words of Pope John Paul II death occurs "when the spiritual principle which ensures the unity of the individual can no longer exercise its functions in and upon the organism, whose elements left to themselves, disintegrate." Our soul is not contained in our organs. It depends on the integrated capacity of our brains and our bodies. When our brains stop functioning there is a separation.

As for the person Katholikos mentioned who was put into an intentionally induced brain dead state that is different. One would not suggest that it would be ethical to harvest organs in that case. If we did then we would have to argue that it is ok to kill people, via brain death, in order to harvest their organs. It is NEVER ok to kill someone for their organs.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I will have to stick with Dr Byre and the Bishops. I read the entire article [I can't find it now] , and beleive brain death is a fiction to harvest human beings.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1172395' date='Jan 21 2007, 04:10 PM']
The exact point at which death occurs (the soul leaves the body) is still much debated, and there is no official teaching on this.

I had a philosophy prof who rather adamentally argued that actual decay of the flesh was the only way to tell whether death had actually occured, citing cases where those who appeared dead have later revived, or turned out to have been buried alive.
(though he holds eccentric positions on a number of issues)

However, lack of conciousness in itself is not reason to declare one dead. With regards said infants and the severely brain-damaged, this presents a slippery slope.
Living human beings must not be considered "dead" or "non-persons" because they lack full brain function.
[/quote]
But if the decaying was the only way to know that death had occured, wouldn't that mean that the incorrupted Saints aren't really dead?

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1173246' date='Jan 22 2007, 03:50 PM']
I will have to stick with Dr Byre and the Bishops. I read the entire article [I can't find it now] , and beleive brain death is a fiction to harvest human beings.
[/quote]
Well, kind of. The only thing the definition of "brain death" will get you too that "cardiopulminary death" won't is allowing you to donate organs (because of the science/tech. requirements). The problem is with the classification of "non-heart beating donors" (NHBD)...there's an article from the Archdiocese of St. Louis [url="http://www.stlouisreview.com/article.php?id=4179"]here[/url].

Birgitta Noel
Posted (edited)

[quote name='magnificat' post='1176195' date='Jan 25 2007, 08:58 PM']
Well, kind of. The only thing the definition of "brain death" will get you too that "cardiopulminary death" won't is allowing you to donate organs (because of the science/tech. requirements). The problem is with the classification of "non-heart beating donors" (NHBD)...there's an article from the Archdiocese of St. Louis [url="http://www.stlouisreview.com/article.php?id=4179"]here[/url].
[/quote]


Ahhh, I was wondering if/when you'd bring up NHBD. I have a good bit of info on this. Right now I'm exhausted and tomorrow I'm leaving for a few days, but later next week I'll join in ...If I remember correctly that article left much to be desired.

By the way, the other thing brain death will "get" you is that many use it as a justification to remove "life" support.

Edited by The Little Way
Posted

The philosophy classes I've taken so far here at FUS have been taught be Prof. Henderson (I forget if he's Dr. or not.. if not, he's going to be very soon), who is heavy into bioethics (and served various directly related positions such as hospital bioethics boards, etc).
Anywho, even with "brain death" there are still new instruments being invented that can better measure brain activity, and those new instruments show that those considered "brain dead" are really not "brain dead" (for example, Terry Schiavo). As such, I think (IAW Henderson) that brain death should not be used as the benchmark for death (and for vital organ donation). Additionally, I think Henderson mentioned that somewhere they had successfully harvested vital organs from freshly dead patients (i.e. not brain dead, but fully dead). However, the stipulation with this is that they have to harvest the organs very soon after the death. Since death isn't always completely predictable, it makes this method hard. However, (non-embryonic) stem cell research is showing to be very promising in this area!!!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Follow the money. Organ donation and transplants are BIG money.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...