Totus Tuus Posted January 21, 2007 Posted January 21, 2007 JMJ + FC The answer to the previous smoking question indicated that smoking was not a mortal sin but that it could be a venial sin (if I interpreted the question correctly). Would a smoker, who was aware of what smoking did to his body, but because of his addiction did not quit smoking, be able to obtain an indulgence? I ask this because one of the prerequisites of receiving an indulgence is having "no attachment to sin". This is just something I have been wondering for a long time God reward you. Lauren
Mr.Cat Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 (edited) They could receive a partial indulgence if they are in a State of Grace but a plenary indulgence (the remission of all temporal punishments due to already forgiven sins) I would be unsure of, although because of the strong requirements when we do not gain the whole plenary indulgence we gain as much as possible from it in form of a plenary indulgence proportional to how we sought it and in what state we are in... So smoking ought not discourage a person from seeking it but I am unsure how to answer your question in regards to plenary indulgence except that the detachment from sin is chiefly regarding sorrow for all sin and our intention not to commit sin again. Edited February 15, 2007 by Mr.CatholicCat
thessalonian Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 [quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1172378' date='Jan 21 2007, 03:38 PM'] JMJ + FC The answer to the previous smoking question indicated that smoking was not a mortal sin but that it could be a venial sin (if I interpreted the question correctly). Would a smoker, who was aware of what smoking did to his body, but because of his addiction did not quit smoking, be able to obtain an indulgence? I ask this because one of the prerequisites of receiving an indulgence is having "no attachment to sin". This is just something I have been wondering for a long time God reward you. Lauren [/quote] Parital indulgences can always be recieved as long as one is in the state of grace. I would assume you are talking about plenary indulgences which are for full remission of temporal punishment of all sin. These require confession, eucharist, prayers or the Holy Father's intentions, and detcachement from sin. If detachement from sin is not full a partial indulgence is recieved when in the state of grace. Smoking is not neccessarily a sin. It can be but is not always. If one does not know of the health effects it would not be. Also if one knows of the health effects but does not have the will power to overcome the urge to smoke there may be no sin. However in both cases it would seem that the smoker would have some attachment to what is sinful, i.e. the person could not fullfill the detachment requirement. Therefore I do not think a plenary indulgence is possible in the case you have describe. We should always perform indulgences even if we only recieve partial indulgences. Actually ownly God knows if we have recieved the full or partial effects of the indulgenece.
Aloysius Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 smoking is no more sinful than eating a McDonald's hamburger. it is in excess that either of those things becomes sinful gluttony. if one has an attachment to excessive smoking then one has attachment to sin. what is excessive? hard to pin-point or define. but just because someone is addicted does not necessarily mean they smoke to excess. knowing that it has negative health effects does not mean one sins by smoking. I know that a McDonald's hamburger has negative health effects but I also know that I am perfectly permitted to have one on occasion; even on some regular basis I would not necessarily be sinning. only if I was gluttonous in my eating of McDonald's hamburgers would I be sinning; even though every McDonald's hamburger increases my risk for heart disease. One may sin against their conscience if they believe smoking to be wrong; but no one is required to believe objectively that smoking is morally wrong; only smoking to excess. addiction to smoking, therefore, does not exclude anyone from plenary indulgence because smoking is not in itself objectively wrong.
traichuoi Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1196297' date='Feb 15 2007, 01:51 PM'] smoking is no more sinful than eating a McDonald's hamburger. it is in excess that either of those things becomes sinful gluttony. if one has an attachment to excessive smoking then one has attachment to sin. what is excessive? hard to pin-point or define. but just because someone is addicted does not necessarily mean they smoke to excess. knowing that it has negative health effects does not mean one sins by smoking. I know that a McDonald's hamburger has negative health effects but I also know that I am perfectly permitted to have one on occasion; even on some regular basis I would not necessarily be sinning. only if I was gluttonous in my eating of McDonald's hamburgers would I be sinning; even though every McDonald's hamburger increases my risk for heart disease. One may sin against their conscience if they believe smoking to be wrong; but no one is required to believe objectively that smoking is morally wrong; only smoking to excess. addiction to smoking, therefore, does not exclude anyone from plenary indulgence because smoking is not in itself objectively wrong. [/quote] Thank you for eloquently expressing what I was thinking.
Mr.Cat Posted February 15, 2007 Posted February 15, 2007 (edited) Father John Corapi has said several times in his videos that smoking is morally wrong for we know it causes health problems regardless of how it is used, while your example of a hamburger is only dangerous in excess. Therefore he proposes that not only is it wrongful but it is gravely wrong, meaning it can be mortal sin under proper conditions. I have heard many other Priests propose much of the same, but they speak that those whom are addicted already since they were not fully aware of this when they started it could still be venial. I would be very interested to see what the Church would say on this in light of modern research and if what side is correct... Edited February 15, 2007 by Mr.CatholicCat
thessalonian Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 Smoking has a more addictive nature to it than a hamburger. A hamburger can be good for you up to a point. Beyond that point if you are eating it, it is sinful. Smoking is bad for your heath to my understanding from the start and so one who knowingly engages it in, knowing the health risks may well be committing at least venial sin. This can be lessoned by the addiction which controls the will. The two, smoking and hamburgers are not exactly alike. I do suppose that Just a risk to the health however does not make something sinful or going on a rollercoaster ride, which has no health benefits and does endanger life in multiple ways, would be condemned by the church.
Aloysius Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 it's pretty clear that a McDonald's hamburger has basically no health benefits beyond, perhaps, basic sustinence. you've just made everyone who ever ate a McDonald's hamburger a sinner for it because no one has ever eaten a McDonald's hamburger only up to the point it remained healthy for them. every smoke increases the risk of cancer in the same way every McDonald's hamburger increrases your risk of heart disease. of course, I would always suggest moderate non-inhaling pipe smoking over cigarettes any day; all the research which singles out that type of pipe tobacco smoking indicates that it does not increase mortality rates (in fact, moderate non-inhaling pipe smokers tend to live on average 2 years longer than non-smokers)... but I refuse to accept the idea that we can never engage in behavior which may risk extreme longevity of our life. as a moral principal, it is just far too much of a slipperry slope that would, as you say, reach all the way to roller coasters. addiction lessens culpability for sin, but properly speaking "sin" or "evil" is still committed, you are just not blameworthy for the sin/evil; but when talking about indulgences this is irrelevant. one could have absolutely no culpability for sin, but if they are addicted to a sinful act then they are attached to sin. you cannot receive a plenary indulgence with an addiction to sin even if you are not culpable for your sin... any more than you could be released from purgatory whilest still being addicted to a sin. in any event, I reject the idea that smoking is objectively wrong in and of itself. it can be a sin against one's conscience; and it is a sin when done to excess; but in and of itself the action of puffing smoke from the burning of a tobacco product is not a sin even if it puts you at risk for less longevity of life.
Paddington Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 I don't see how smoking can be an addiction without being done to excess. I know from my own experience smoking. [quote name='Mr.CatholicCat' post='1196355' date='Feb 15 2007, 09:08 PM'] but they speak that those whom are addicted already since they were not fully aware of this when they started it could still be venial. [/quote] Why would the venial/grave status of something be dependent on knowledge held prior to one's first cigarette? (or each cigarette smoked before the exact second that addiction set in ) I don't see why it would matter if the addiction started 50 years ago or 50 days ago. I thought something was venial or grave depending on a person's PRESENT state of being.
Mr.Cat Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 [quote][b]Luke 12:46-48[/b] "The lord of that servant will come in the day that he hopeth not, and at the hour that he knoweth not, and shall separate him, and shall appoint him his portion with unbelievers. And that servant who knew the will of his lord, and prepared not himself, and did not according to his will, shall be beaten with many stripes. But he that knew not, and did things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with few stripes. And unto whomsoever much is given, of him much shall be required: and to whom they have committed much, of him they will demand the more." [url="http://www.drbo.org/chapter/49012.htm"]http://www.drbo.org/chapter/49012.htm[/url][/quote]If one commits a sin but is not aware of the gravity of that sin they will not be judged the same as someone who was aware of its gravity. When one becomes addicted/habit to a sin it decreases one’s culpability to that sin on some degree (does not mean it is automatically venial) but it increases one’s responsibility to correct the addiction/habit. To what I know if a person was addicted to smoking before they knew how dangerous and harmful to the body it was they were not fully culpable then they are not as culpable because it is now an addiction. But they have every obligation to correct the addiction or habit to do the exact opposite of it. For this is what traditional Catholicism proposes to combat sin, to do the exact opposite of that temptation. The objective gravity of the sin does not change but the subjective gravity of the sin person to person does change because we cannot presume they always meet all requirements for a mortal, venial, or material sin. For example, it is objectively evil to steal but how much did the person steal, what did they steal, did they know they were stealing, what purpose were they stealing for, did they intend on returning it, did they do it out of hatred of God, and all of theses questions that we cannot objectively answer.
Paddington Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 Mr. Catholic Cat, What can make smoking grave matter? Are you sure that it can be? Peace, Paddington
Mr.Cat Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 Echoing the words of Father John Corapi on a talk that he briefly talked about smoking... if it is what the Church universally teaches I am unsure but I do know other Priests propose something of the same because it is so harmful.
thessalonian Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Paddington' post='1196743' date='Feb 15 2007, 11:48 PM'] I don't see how smoking can be an addiction without being done to excess. I know from my own experience smoking. Why would the venial/grave status of something be dependent on knowledge held prior to one's first cigarette? (or each cigarette smoked before the exact second that addiction set in ) I don't see why it would matter if the addiction started 50 years ago or 50 days ago. I thought something was venial or grave depending on a person's PRESENT state of being. [/quote] Actually the gravity of the matter does not depend on knowledge or will. A matter is grave based solely on the merrits of the offense. Sex outside of marriage is always a grave matter. The effects of the sin on society are equal regardless of knowledge and will. Culpability for that matter is reduced by the will and knowledge. These may mean the effects on the soul venial rather than mortal. Edited February 16, 2007 by thessalonian
thessalonian Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 (edited) Thinking this over I would probably have to respectfully disagree with Fr. Corapi on whether smoking can be a mortal sin if he said that. Something I don't do lightly as I have the greatest respect for him. I don’t see smoking a single cigarette for anyone as a grave matter and noone smokes a cigarette to try and kill themselves. “Stop, don’t come one step closer or I’ll smoke another cigarette.”. It’s not a grave matter. I suppose perhaps if one was chain smoking a pack a time with no concern for there life the gravity might increase enough to be a grave matter, but then is that person in control of their will? But the general 2 pack a day smoker I don’t think is in mortal sin. A thousand venial sins don’t equal a mortal sin and the Church does not say that smoking is a mortal sin. The concern of course is that one so degrades the will for life and opens oneself up to mortal sin. The cigarette enslaves and takes away the desire to live, causing dispare. Venial sins can lead to mortal sins and I think that is where the gray area comes in on this. I suppose it is kind of in the same area as drinking. If one is drinking to get drunk, knowing it is wrong and willing it, and does then it would be a mortal sin. If one chain smokes knowing it will kill them and then dies from cigarrettes, it may be mortal. But normally I don't think smoking any one cigarette is a mortal sin and again a thousand venial sins do not equal a mortal sin. Edited February 16, 2007 by thessalonian
Aloysius Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 I've never been addicted to smoking, so I wouldn't know... but I imagine if one smokes one cigarette a day they might be addicted, but that wouldn't be smoking to excess. I disagree with smoking being objectively even a venial sin. it becomes venial sin when done to excess (and thus, if one is addicted to it in excessive amounts, one is incapable of receiving plenary indulgence). it only becomes a mortal sin when one reaches the point of directly, immediately, and knowingly risking their life (smoking through a hole in your neck is probably mortally sinful)
Totus Tuus Posted February 18, 2007 Author Posted February 18, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1196297' date='Feb 15 2007, 04:51 PM']smoking is no more sinful than eating a McDonald's hamburger. it is in excess that either of those things becomes sinful gluttony. if one has an attachment to excessive smoking then one has attachment to sin. what is excessive? hard to pin-point or define. but just because someone is addicted does not necessarily mean they smoke to excess. knowing that it has negative health effects does not mean one sins by smoking. I know that a McDonald's hamburger has negative health effects but I also know that I am perfectly permitted to have one on occasion; even on some regular basis I would not necessarily be sinning. only if I was gluttonous in my eating of McDonald's hamburgers would I be sinning; even though every McDonald's hamburger increases my risk for heart disease. One may sin against their conscience if they believe smoking to be wrong; but no one is required to believe objectively that smoking is morally wrong; only smoking to excess. addiction to smoking, therefore, does not exclude anyone from plenary indulgence because smoking is not in itself objectively wrong.[/quote] But eating a hamburger and being addicted to hamburgers and therefore constantly eating them are two different things. I am talking about addiction to tobacco. An unhealthy addiction, to me, is an attachment to sin; someone help me understand this if I'm seeing this wrong.
toledo_jesus Posted February 19, 2007 Posted February 19, 2007 [quote name='Mr.CatholicCat' post='1196355' date='Feb 15 2007, 08:38 PM']Father John Corapi has said several times in his videos that smoking is morally wrong for we know it causes health problems regardless of how it is used, while your example of a hamburger is only dangerous in excess. Therefore he proposes that not only is it wrongful but it is gravely wrong, meaning it can be mortal sin under proper conditions. I have heard many other Priests propose much of the same, but they speak that those whom are addicted already since they were not fully aware of this when they started it could still be venial. I would be very interested to see what the Church would say on this in light of modern research and if what side is correct...[/quote] Father John Corapi is neither the pope nor God. The analogy to a hamburger is apt. Barring an allergic reaction, I know of no person who has died from a single cigarette. Don't try to get between a smoker and his tobacco...you'll lose a finger.
toledo_jesus Posted February 19, 2007 Posted February 19, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1196930' date='Feb 16 2007, 02:49 PM']I've never been addicted to smoking, so I wouldn't know... but I imagine if one smokes one cigarette a day they might be addicted, but that wouldn't be smoking to excess. I disagree with smoking being objectively even a venial sin. it becomes venial sin when done to excess (and thus, if one is addicted to it in excessive amounts, one is incapable of receiving plenary indulgence). it only becomes a mortal sin when one reaches the point of directly, immediately, and knowingly risking their life (smoking through a hole in your neck is probably mortally sinful)[/quote] one could make the point that working in a coal mine is sinful, for the reason that it gives you black lung...and it would be just as spurious a point as the anti-smoking crowd's message.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now