Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1174266' date='Jan 23 2007, 05:52 PM']
Yours I suppose.
[/quote]

From what I can tell, what is proclaimed correct is that which is opposite to the condemnation.

It is an error to say "1. The ecclesiastical law which prescribes that books concerning the Divine Scriptures are subject to previous examination [i]does not[/i] apply to critical scholars and students of scientific exegesis of the Old and New Testament."

So it is correct to say "1. The ecclesiastical law which prescribes that books concerning the Divine Scriptures are subject to previous examination [i]does [/i]apply to critical scholars and students of scientific exegesis of the Old and New Testament."



The error:

[quote]2. The Church's interpretation of the Sacred Books is by no means to be rejected; nevertheless, it is subject to the more accurate judgment and correction of the exegetes.[/quote]

This would probably be correct as:

[quote]
2. The Church's interpretation of the Sacred Books is by no means to be rejected; moreover, it is not subject to the more accurate judgment and correction of the exegetes.[/quote]

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1174261' date='Jan 23 2007, 07:43 PM']
With most of these condemnations, it is blatenly obvious what the correct view is...
[/quote]
Then what is your point? Which of these have I violated? Which of these has the "modern Church" violated? Are you here to help us see light and rejoice in it or are you here to make statements about how much you follow the Tradition and how upset you are that others don't? There is no time to be scandalized by the actions of others; use your time to help them see the light and live it, not to condemn their darkness. God condemned the evils of Israel again and again, but only in order to prepare them for the Revelation of His Son. It is not the case that one person may condemn and another may enlighten; one must do both, and carefully and lovingly. There are many cancerous sores on the Church (not of the Church, but on her), but if you are not gentle and careful in removing them, you mistreat your patient, who is Christ. Just the same, if you are not gentle in removing the lesions of your brother or sister in Christ or careful in removing the rod from his or her eyes, it is Christ you may hurt.

I am not saying this in judgment. I also struggle with making sure that I show the positive joy of the Gospel, but you must show love. You clearly hold the faith, but you must exercise the virtue of faith by proclaiming the love of God in hope of the Resurrection. We must all shine like stars with God's love or no one will be able to navigate in all this darkness.

God bless,

Micah

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Raphael' post='1174275' date='Jan 23 2007, 05:58 PM']
Then what is your point? Which of these have I violated? Which of these has the "modern Church" violated? Are you here to help us see light and rejoice in it or are you here to make statements about how much you follow the Tradition and how upset you are that others don't? There is no time to be scandalized by the actions of others; use your time to help them see the light and live it, not to condemn their darkness. God condemned the evils of Israel again and again, but only in order to prepare them for the Revelation of His Son. It is not the case that one person may condemn and another may enlighten; one must do both, and carefully and lovingly. There are many cancerous sores on the Church (not of the Church, but on her), but if you are not gentle and careful in removing them, you mistreat your patient, who is Christ. Just the same, if you are not gentle in removing the lesions of your brother or sister in Christ or careful in removing the rod from his or her eyes, it is Christ you may hurt.

I am not saying this in judgment. I also struggle with making sure that I show the positive joy of the Gospel, but you must show love. You clearly hold the faith, but you must exercise the virtue of faith by proclaiming the love of God in hope of the Resurrection. We must all shine like stars with God's love or no one will be able to navigate in all this darkness.

God bless,

Micah
[/quote]

I am not accusing you of believing in any modernist errors, nor am I accusing the Holy Catholic Church herself of believing in any modernist errors, nor am I accusing her current Visible Head, Pope Benedict XVI of believing in any modernist errors, but I am saying that many persons claim to be Catholic are not, in fact, Catholic becuase they believe in some of the modernist errors condemned in Lamentabili.

[quote]Joking aside, a negation of one thing does not support every alternative to that negated proposition. If the Church declared tomorrow: "communism is bad,"[/quote]
By the way, the Church has already condemned communism in the Syllabus of Errors.

[quote name='The Syllabus of Errors of Bl. Pius IX']IV. SOCIALISM, COMMUNISM, SECRET SOCIETIES, BIBLICAL SOCIETIES, CLERICO-LIBERAL SOCIETIES

Pests of this kind are frequently reprobated in the severest terms in the Encyclical "Qui pluribus," Nov. 9, 1846, Allocution "Quibus quantisque," April 20, 1849, Encyclical "Noscitis et nobiscum," Dec. 8, 1849, Allocution "Singulari quadam," Dec. 9, 1854, Encyclical "Quanto conficiamur," Aug. 10, 1863. [/quote]

Edited by StThomasMore
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1174284' date='Jan 23 2007, 08:07 PM']
I am not accusing you of believing in any modernist errors, nor am I accusing the Holy Catholic Church herself of believing in any modernist errors, nor am I accusing her current Visible Head, Pope Benedict XVI of believing in any modernist errors, but I am saying that many persons claim to be Catholic are not, in fact, Catholic becuase they believe in some of the modernist errors condemned in Lamentabili.
[/quote]

Yes, many do, and many do so unknowingly, too. You seem to condemn them all. My point is this: acknowledge the evil, but strive for the good. If you strive for the good, you will still be fleeing from evil, but you will be a moving target, rather than standing still and trying to combat evil, and you will be able to lead others. One who does not move forward cannot lead.

I would say that those who unknowingly are against Church teaching are Catholic (to cease to be Catholic requires formal heresy, a mortal sin, and knowledge is required for that), but imperfectly and that they are in need of good catechesis.

[quote]By the way, the Church has already condemned communism in the Syllabus of Errors.[/quote]

Yes, I'm aware. Sorry for the confusion, I was stipulating in a hypothetical situation outside of time.

Posted

true enough, some of them are fairly obvious what the true statement is and I am not going to go through each one individually. Some condemnations of the Church are not so obvious. Some traditionalistis make mistakes like protestants have with regard to trent and works, faith, and grace. They assume the right meaning.

Posted

STM, most of the negatives which could apply to many positives are the modernist errors regarding sosciety, the state, and Church and state seperation. if something is not ideal, it does not mean it is never acceptable, for example.

you are rigght that most of the topics in principal as regards Religion itself are obvious.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...