Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Saints Were Just High--didn't Have Real Visions


Recommended Posts

Posted

Help! I am so :maddest: my 9th grader came home today and said her religion teacher (a real kum-by-ya type) taught that saints' visions (like St Francis' Stigmata) were due to them being high on mind-altering drugs! This is so infuriating!! Any suggestions as to what to do? I have already spoken with him about last sememster's 'purgatory is probably not true, just made up and isn't required for our faith' --then I confronted him directly---he was all smiles and gloss and smoothed it over ('your dtr must have heard wrong')....

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1173276' date='Jan 22 2007, 05:41 PM']
Help! I am so :maddest: my 9th grader came home today and said her religion teacher (a real kum-by-ya type) taught that saints' visions (like St Francis' Stigmata) were due to them being high on mind-altering drugs! This is so infuriating!! Any suggestions as to what to do? I have already spoken with him about last sememster's 'purgatory is probably not true, just made up and isn't required for our faith' --then I confronted him directly---he was all smiles and gloss and smoothed it over ('your dtr must have heard wrong')....
[/quote]
Go from him to the principal to the priests.

Posted

the principal is a nun, but there are no priests, only visiting priests. I am just really mad right now, should I cool off ??? I don't want to be uncharitable, but I just cannot stand it anymore! I may start with the religion chair, she is faithful and comes to Rosary every month.

Posted

ditto

because not only is your daughter being made to hear such carp, but all the other students as well whose parents may not know, and some I would guess would be very happy to know what their child is wrongly being "taught"

him - prinicpal - priests

Posted

Thanks, and please pray for me in this. Sheesh, you send your kid to Catholic school, and don't expect perfection, but for crying out loud, at least THIS sort of thing shouldn't be an issue. Public school is safer in my book than 'Catholic' school---a wolf in sheep's clothing!

MissScripture
Posted

Pray. A lot. And then pray some more.
I went to a highschool like that. At one point the teacher told the class that Mary turned away from Jesus at his crucifixion, and she wasnt' really at the foot of the cross, because it's only mentioned in John's gospel. And the reason she wasn't there was because she turned away from Christ.
That teacher is now the "Faith Formation Coordinator."
My sister is a ninth grader and before she went in, my mom talked to everyone she could think of at that school to try and change garbage like that. They all pretend that it's new news or like the students are twisting what they're saying and misunderstanding (at which point, I would argue that they should fix the misunderstanding, then!!). But nothing is ever done. And the curriculum is trash. My mom gave me some of the syllubi and I the one I read made me sick (it's gotten worse since I was there). Apparently, miracles are helping your neighbor and feeding the hungry. (may I just say it's a SAD, sad world when helping your neighbor is a miracle!)
Make sure to discuss the class with her and teach her what is right. In some ways, it's almost a blessing that my highschool was as it was, because it required me to put more effort into learning my faith. I don't think I would be quite so attached to it, had it been spoon fed to me. I had to fight for it, and I had to rely on it. So, while it's terrible that things like that are being taught at so-called Catholic Highschools, try to make the best of it.
Prayers for you and your daughter and that school!

Posted

well i would address this specific matter to him again

and right after go to the religion chair as well and not let it slide this time - it seems as though they should be able to figure something out w/ this matter

and if the religion chair doesn't do something then off to the nun but hopefully the religion chair will help and be concerned and inform the principal anyways

cooloff - pray a rosary - but act asap because too late after the fact is often too late

cmotherofpirl
Posted

You can start sending a tape recorder to class to prevent any more "misunderstandings".
You can offer to sit in the class for the rest of the semester.

Posted

Please do something. There was an idiot (can I say that?)who taught in the RCIA I attended who said we really didn't have to believe in the physical resurrection of Jesus. The Pastor was very interested to hear about that. The "mistake" was corrected but it caused harm to some of the catechumens.

Posted

oooh, I like the tape recorder thing, maybe she can do that with her cell phone? (I am techno-delayed)

Where DO they get these people?

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1173347' date='Jan 22 2007, 05:17 PM']
Where DO they get these people?
[/quote]
Happy places?

Posted

Maybe your bishop would appreciate being informed about this.

Posted

[quote name='MRSannie' post='1173347' date='Jan 22 2007, 07:17 PM']
oooh, I like the tape recorder thing, maybe she can do that with her cell phone? (I am techno-delayed)

Where DO they get these people?
[/quote]

My experience is that they get them from several places.

1. If you're lucky they will be dedicated Catholics whose spouse has a decent paying job and they feel called to teach in the Catholic School system. They might not be the best biology or anything else to complicated of teachers but they are faithful.

2. People who have a college degree but no job, might be interestedin teaching or might not. They don't have teaching degrees, but don't really don't differ much from a public school teacher who may or may not have jaded views of Catholicism. Sometimes they like teaching and stick around. However the chances of them being faithful catholics is not very high.

Posted

Just curious- where would St. Francis have gotten his drugs?

Catholictothecore
Posted

prayers for you

Guest Rick777
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1173381' date='Jan 22 2007, 07:03 PM']
Just curious- where would St. Francis have gotten his drugs?
[/quote]

:annoyed:

Posted

I'm sorry that's just the biggest hole in the high saints arguement.

Catholictothecore
Posted

a very good point.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Catholictothecore' post='1173394' date='Jan 22 2007, 08:13 PM']
a very good point.
[/quote]
not really. any number of natural items out there are hallucinogenic.
I vote for the Holy Spirit :)

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1173292' date='Jan 22 2007, 04:57 PM']
You can start sending a tape recorder to class to prevent any more "misunderstandings".
You can offer to sit in the class for the rest of the semester.
[/quote]
Why on earth did we not think of that? (actually, I think in the "health class" they wouldn't let the parents sit in...yeah, the one where they told us to save sex until "we're ready.")

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...