Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi,

I have a few questions that spew from each other, so if you could bear with me, it'd be a great help.

In a discussion I was having a few days ago, it was mentioned how Adam and Eve were face to face with God in Eden and were part of the beatific vision.

Now, I've always assumed the beatific vision was Heaven and that once you enter the beatific vision and see God, one becomes perfectly happy and would want nothing more.

So, (basic questions beginning now)

Where were Adam and Eve exactly? Where they in Eden or Heaven or is Eden Heaven?


If it was Heaven, why was Lucifer there? Did he not already fall?


Did they see God while in Heaven?


If they lived face to face with God, were they not part of the beatific vision?


If they were part of the beatific vision, would that not mean they were completely happy?


Why would they then listen to the serpent and eat the apple if they already could see God face to face? What more could they want?


Any help would be appreciated.
Thank you.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Adam and Eve did not enjoy the Beatific Vision while in the Garden of Eden. That is a special grace that was not given to them at that time. Rather, they were given natural grace and had a relationship with God in an earthly paradise. When they fell, they were cast out of earthly paradise and later redeemed and brought into something even better than what they fell out of: the Beatific Vision of Heaven. If they had fallen from the Beatific Vision, they would be falling out of heaven, which would mean that it is possible for us also to fall out of heaven.

For clarification, it is not possible for a saint to fall from heaven. This is not because free will is removed, but rather that every desire is superabundantly satisfied by the Beatific Vision. It would be worse than being at a banquet and deciding to go dumpster diving for your meal. You simply wouldn't do it.

As for the fall of the angels, it does not seem completely clear whether they fell before man was created or after, but they did fall before men fell and the tradition of the Church holds that they fell because God told them about the Incarnation. God said that He would become man and Satan refused the idea because that would mean that he would have to bow to a lower being. According to some Church Fathers, there was an added hatred of the thought of hailing a human woman as "Queen," which is of course the Blessed Virgin's place as Mary, Queen of Angels (and part of what make's St. Gabriel the Archangel so cool--he did precisely what Satan refused to do).

I believe this answers all of your questions. If you have any more, I suggest this reading: CCC 325-412.

God bless,

Micah

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...