Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Refurbishing Defaced Hymnals


Recommended Posts

QuidquidOptamus
Posted (edited)

May it please Your Reverences, and members of the forum:

As they say on radio call in programs, "long time listener, first time caller" -- I'm a long time viewer, first time poster. My post concerns [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=62360"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=62360[/url].

The discussion going on between my friend Dave and me (yes, thats proper grammar :)) is whether it was permissible for me to refurbish defaced hymnals. To wit, the publishing company of these hymnals made several gross errors in the language, which caused the hymnals to be turned into "usnals", or "allnals" or "peoplenals" or my personal favourite, "wenals." The publishing company, in my judgment, DEFACED these beautiful hymns by removing, without permission, words from the hymns and inserting their own gender-neutral language. For example, "Joy to the world, the Lord Is come.. let [b]us our[/b] songs employ...", "The cause of joy to [b]us[/b] below, O Maria, the spring through which all graces flow...", "Hark the herald angels sing... mild He leaves His Throne on high, born that [b]we[/b] no more may die.. born to raise [b]us from[/b] the earth.." (*spits on the ground*)

Of course, as a Christian, as a respecter of tradition, and as a man, I was quite offended at the defacement of these wonderful hymns in such a way. Thus, as a pre-Mass activity, I took the liberty of restoring them by using an ink pen and marking out the gender neutralized language, and replacing it with the actual word of the hymn. (Which very much unnerved the people sitting behind me.) Dave seems to believe this improper; I am not in agreement. I am eager to learn others' opinions on this topic.

Kissing the hands which consecrate, I thank Your Reverences and all the members of this forum for reading this and for sharing your opinions.
QuidquidOptamus

Edited by QuidquidOptamus
cmotherofpirl
Posted

Two wrongs do not make a right, and you do not have the right to deface the Property of the Church, even if you disagree with it. Yes its your parish, yes you probably put money in the offeratory basket that helped pay for those books, but you
STILL have no right to deface them. :)
I used to sing in a choir and trust me, I understand the temptation. I always sing the old words, and claim I have a bad memory for the PC versions.

Why don't you engage the pastor or whatever committee who buys this stuff to buy better boooks. THere ARE better ones out there.
But you have no right to do what you are doing, so get thee to confession :)

Welcome to phatmass :D:

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1175737' date='Jan 25 2007, 10:21 AM']
Two wrongs do not make a right, and you do not have the right to deface the Property of the Church, even if you disagree with it. Yes its your parish, yes you probably put money in the offeratory basket that helped pay for those books, but you
STILL have no right to deface them. :)
I used to sing in a choir and trust me, I understand the temptation. I always sing the old words, and claim I have a bad memory for the PC versions.

Why don't you engage the pastor or whatever committee who buys this stuff to buy better boooks. THere ARE better ones out there.
But you have no right to do what you are doing, so get thee to confession :) [/quote]
Ditto all that.
[quote]
Welcome to phatmass :D:
[/quote]
and that.

Posted

Welcome to the Phorum ^_^

Might I suggest that you offer the idea of purchasing the [u]Adoremus Hymnal[/u] to your pastor? I believe it would be a good alternative. God bless you.

Posted

Um... The thing is that, although the words have been changed, the Church was very likely aware of what they were purchasing, and not blindsided by the publisher. Although it is tempting to blame the publisher, the Church consciously CHOSE to purchase those particular books.

So, I don't believe the publisher was wrong at all. They published what they were paid to publish. No matter how much gender neutral language annoys some people, non-gender neutral language annoys others too. You were definately in the wrong defacing Church property that your parish CHOSE to purchase. If you had a problem with it, you should have spoken to your priest or music coordinator.

:)

And Welcome ;)

franciscanheart
Posted

Ditto to all that has been said above. I also especially like the recommendation by Totus Tuus. Welcome.

QuidquidOptamus
Posted (edited)

Two wrongs do not make a right, that is beyond dispute. However, I am not arguing that two wrongs make a right; I am arguing that what I did was not wrong. [b]I did not deface, I refurbished.[/b] I UN-defaced them, because they were already defaced.

For example, it is like cleaning up a graffiti-filled wall. Is that defacing the wall? Clearly not, because the graffiti should not have been there in the first place. The graffiti is the defacement - cleaning it up is just that, cleaning it up. The gender neutral language should not have been there in the first place, and so I was CLEANING IT UP by removing it. No one with any sense would argue that cleaning up graffiti on walls is wrong, so what is wrong with cleaning up graffiti in wenals? Cleaning the graffiti up is not defacing, it is un-defacing, restoring the original beauty.

You know, I remember reading someplace how pastors (not just Catholic pastors but in general) are noticing that the pews are filled with fewer and fewer MEN; could it be that one of the reasons for this is that they feel pushed out, partly due to the PC "everything that mentions men is evil and should be erased" attitude?

Edited by QuidquidOptamus
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='QuidquidOptamus' post='1175661' date='Jan 25 2007, 03:47 AM']
May it please Your Reverences, and members of the forum:

As they say on radio call in programs, "long time listener, first time caller" -- I'm a long time viewer, first time poster. My post concerns [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=62360"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=62360[/url].

The discussion going on between my friend Dave and me (yes, thats proper grammar :)) is whether it was permissible for me to refurbish defaced hymnals. To wit, the publishing company of these hymnals made several gross errors in the language, which caused the hymnals to be turned into "usnals", or "allnals" or "peoplenals" or my personal favourite, "wenals." The publishing company, in my judgment, DEFACED these beautiful hymns by removing, without permission, words from the hymns and inserting their own gender-neutral language. For example, "Joy to the world, the Lord Is come.. let [b]us our[/b] songs employ...", "The cause of joy to [b]us[/b] below, O Maria, the spring through which all graces flow...", "Hark the herald angels sing... mild He leaves His Throne on high, born that [b]we[/b] no more may die.. born to raise [b]us from[/b] the earth.." (*spits on the ground*)

Of course, as a Christian, as a respecter of tradition, and as a man, I was quite offended at the defacement of these wonderful hymns in such a way. Thus, as a pre-Mass activity, I took the liberty of restoring them by using an ink pen and marking out the gender neutralized language, and replacing it with the actual word of the hymn. (Which very much unnerved the people sitting behind me.) Dave seems to believe this improper; I am not in agreement. I am eager to learn others' opinions on this topic.

Kissing the hands which consecrate, I thank Your Reverences and all the members of this forum for reading this and for sharing your opinions.
QuidquidOptamus
[/quote]

Your parish's property is your parish's property, not yours. You can't go defacing it. The ends don't justify the means.

If you don't like the text, complain the people responsible. Don't destroy private property.

[quote name='QuidquidOptamus' post='1175970' date='Jan 25 2007, 03:50 PM']
Two wrongs do not make a right, that is beyond dispute. However, I am not arguing that two wrongs make a right; I am arguing that what I did was not wrong. [b]I did not deface, I refurbished.[/b] I UN-defaced them, because they were already defaced.
[/quote]
You can try to hide behind language as much as you want, but your parish bought the hymnals in that form, meaning that you took a sheet in its original format and altered it. That's defacing it.

With your graffiti example, let's say that there is a bathroom stall that comes with writing on the inside walls...it comes like that, on purpose...perhaps it has jokes written there, I don't know. Then you go and correct the grammer. The person who bought those stalls bought them for the purpose of having those words and you have defaced them.

What you are describing IS defacing property, not refurbishing.

Welcome to Phatmass.

God bless,

Micah

QuidquidOptamus
Posted

All things belong to God. God Is not a respecter of political correctness. He did not send His only begotten Daughter, a married lesbian abortion doctor, to die on the Cross. Some denominations like to think He did - for example I recently read about the Presbyterian Church (the liberal half) saying that it is ok to say 'In the Name of the Mother, the Child, and the Womb' (*spits on the ground*)

However, the Catholic Church teaches that God Is not a respecter of political correctness. Thus, in God's Sight, would it not be that I was taking something bad (politically correct) and making it better (non-politically correct)? To increase the value of something is a good thing.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='QuidquidOptamus' post='1175998' date='Jan 25 2007, 04:08 PM']
All things belong to God. God Is not a respecter of political correctness. He did not send His only begotten Daughter, a married lesbian abortion doctor, to die on the Cross. Some denominations like to think He did - for example I recently read about the Presbyterian Church (the liberal half) saying that it is ok to say 'In the Name of the Mother, the Child, and the Womb' (*spits on the ground*)

However, the Catholic Church teaches that God Is not a respecter of political correctness. Thus, in God's Sight, would it not be that I was taking something bad (politically correct) and making it better (non-politically correct)? To increase the value of something is a good thing.
[/quote]
All things belong to God, but God respects the rights of mankind to hold private property (which is also upheld by the Church). You have no right to destroy another person's private property.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Or the parish's communal property, for that matter.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Its wrong.
Go sit in the corner, no crayons or markers allowed :ninja:

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

It's wrong for the same reason you can't go blowing up abortion clinics. You can't do something intrinsically wrong (destroying someone else's property) even if that property is used for something evil.

QuidquidOptamus
Posted (edited)

The Church has no "private property." The Church is merely a temporal steward of God's property, since Christ Is the Head of the Church.

If I went into someone else's home and started marking up their books, that might be one thing. But this is entirely different; the wenals do not belong to any person, they belong to the Church. Ultimately, that means that they are the "property" of His Holiness the Pope, who holds them vicariously as steward for Christ. (In the eyes of the civil law, I suppose they belong to The Bishop of Arlington, Incorporated - but I'm not really talking about the realm of man's law here... oops I mean people's law).

[quote]It's wrong for the same reason you can't go blowing up abortion clinics. You can't do something intrinsically wrong (destroying someone else's property) even if that property is used for something evil.[/quote]

Of course. I agree, you agree, everyone agrees. But that's not the issue - the issue is whether I did something wrong. If I did something wrong, then of course you cannot do it even if good would come of it. But my contention is not that "I did something wrong, but good came of it" - my argument is "I did not do anything wrong."

Edited by QuidquidOptamus
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='QuidquidOptamus' post='1176010' date='Jan 25 2007, 04:20 PM']
The Church has no "private property." The Church is merely a temporal steward of God's property, since Christ Is the Head of the Church.

If I went into someone else's home and started marking up their books, that might be one thing. But this is entirely different; the wenals do not belong to any person, they belong to the Church. Ultimately, that means that they are the "property" of His Holiness the Pope, who holds them vicariously as steward for Christ. (In the eyes of the civil law, I suppose they belong to The Bishop of Arlington, Incorporated - but I'm not really talking about the realm of man's law here... oops I mean people's law).
[/quote]
The Church has property which does not belong to the general public, but to the Church. That makes it private property of the Church. Also, individual parishes and offices within the Church have legal private property. Anyone who has worked in a parish or chancery office can tell you that.

Furthermore, since you bring up the stewardship of the Church, you should know that the stewards of the property of the Church are the clergy, not the laity. As such, it would be their place, not yours, to deal in such a way with Church property, and then only according to the amount an individual has stewardship over. Since it is not your place to hold stewardship over these articles, then it is not your job, right, or privilege to alter them, for good or bad. A bishop, for instance, is the steward over his priests; he can have them ordained from diaconate. You cannot. Your stewardship within the Church is on a different level. If you are a father or a mother, then you have stewardship over a family. If you are a child, then you have stewardship over what God has given you to have stewardship over. It is disrespectful to authority to step outside your bounds in order to assume the stewardship of another.

God bless,

Micah

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Yes you did something wrong. Don't do it again. Get thee to confession.

Posted

[quote name='QuidquidOptamus' post='1176010' date='Jan 25 2007, 04:20 PM']
the issue is whether I did something wrong. If I did something wrong, then of course you cannot do it even if good would come of it. But my contention is not that "I did something wrong, but good came of it" - my argument is "I did not do anything wrong."
[/quote]

You did something wrong.

QuidquidOptamus
Posted

Those are very conclusory statements. I'm not asking for a vote, but for opinions and discussion.

Posted

if one uses or intends to use their private property for something intrinsically evil, they forfeit their right to it. if one uses their private property for murder, for instance, anyone has the right to deface or take that property away. why? because they do not have the right to hold property for the sake of evil. if someone was pointing a gun at a child, you wouldl be well within your rights to destroy their gun by any means necessary. if one was intending to use a gun they owned to kill someone, you would be within your rights to take that gun away from them, even by destroying it. if someone intended to use an abortion clinic to kill many babies, then they no longer have the right to privately own that property and it may be taken away without any sin against the 7th commandment.

I'm not condoning abortion clinic bombings necessarily. What makes those not acceptable is the fact that they do not, in the end, actually stop abortions and actually have a negative impact on the campaign to make it illegal. abortion clinic destruction is only wrong insofar as it backfires and does not actually do any good to stop abortions. if it did not thusly backfire there would be no sin against the 7th commandment: their property rights do not extend to owning property that they use for intrinsic evils.

as regards the altering of the hymnals, I'm inclined to say you are restoring peices of art to their proper form. if they had purchased peices of fine art with mustaches and devils' horns painted overtop of them, you would be perfectly within your rights to restore those paintings even if the private owners of them wished them to remain like that. property rights do not permit the destruction or defacing of sacred art, which is what is being done by these hymnals: the defacing of sacred music.

if someone came into ownership of the pieta, and wished to paint it with rainbow colors, it would be perfectly fine to try to stop them and, if given the oppurtunity, take away all of their rainbow colored paint.

just IMHO

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...