Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Opinions On Article, Please.


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.speroforum.com/site/article.asp?idCategory=34&idsub=127&id=2435"]http://www.speroforum.com/site/article.asp...127&id=2435[/url]

Reactions, por favor. :)

cmotherofpirl
Posted

There is no such thing as a "daughter" church, unless they are under the Pope.
Anglican ordinations are not valid, because when the Anglicans rewrote the ordination rites, they deliberately broke valid succession. Hence when a clergy converts they are reordained a Catholic priest.

So yes Anglicans call themsleves "catholic" but they are not Catholic. They carry on tradition as they so choose, trying to be a big umbrella to high, low and middle members, with an increasingly diverse theology. How long can the Bishops of Nigeria and Bishop Spong claim to be in the same Church?
They are falling apart because precisely because no organization survives being run by committees.

Posted

Thanks cmother :)

I wish I knew the difference between Anglican and Anglican-Catholic. There is an Anglican Catholic Church about 5 miles from my mom's house.

Can I get a reaction to this specific quote from somebody?

"Also, the Fathers of the 5th Ecumenical Council struck Pope Vigilius off the diptychs and refused him communion till he would do what they (and the whole Catholic Church, eventually) considered the right thing about the Three Chapters: i.e., condemn them and the doctrines contained therein. To say that an Ecumenical Council did its job successfully but, by the way, was composed pretty much entirely of formal schismatics (and heretics for denying in practice the absolute necessity of being in communion with and complete subjection to Rome?) is a bit too ridiculous for words. Therefore, broken communion with Rome, even when it is broken deliberately from the non-Roman side, is not and never has been sufficient proof of schism."

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I am trying to find someone to answer you.

Posted

I do not have time to read the entire article, but as an ex-anglocatholic and son of an ECUSA priest, I will give you my limited comments.

-The Orthodox don't think Anglicans have valid orders either. (I called and asked)

-

"I wish I knew the difference between Anglican and Anglican-Catholic."

The difference is worship style. Both are part of ECUSA or other Anglican group. Your normal ECUSA (Episcopal church) is going to look a bit like the Norvus Ordo Mass. Your Anglo-Catholics can be anywhere from NO to TLM. Women in veils, rosary, confessionals, Greek, Latin, Highmass, acolites, 7 sacraments, icons, etc.

Morally, they can be anywhere from Catholic morals to 'anything goes' gay marriage.

Take the time to wiki Anglo Catholic.

Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1179120' date='Jan 28 2007, 10:43 PM']
Thanks cmother :)

"Also, the Fathers of the 5th Ecumenical Council struck Pope Vigilius off the diptychs and refused him communion till he would do what they (and the whole Catholic Church, eventually) considered the right thing about the Three Chapters: i.e., condemn them and the doctrines contained therein. To say that an Ecumenical Council did its job successfully but, by the way, was composed pretty much entirely of formal schismatics (and heretics for denying in practice the absolute necessity of being in communion with and complete subjection to Rome?) is a bit too ridiculous for words. Therefore, broken communion with Rome, even when it is broken deliberately from the non-Roman side, is not and never has been sufficient proof of schism."
[/quote]

I am not familure with this issue in history, however it is not a relevant as the writter might hope. The author is basically finding one extreme and novel example to justify the entire Anglo schism by establishing ceaseropapism of Henry VIII. The big picture is being ignored. It reminds me of the SSPX who cry, 'we are not in schism,' or 'our excommunication is not valid.' Bottom line, if the bishop of Rome says you are not in full communion, you are not in full communion.

For an analogy, imagine a man claims he is an employee of Microsoft. Bill Gates then says the man is not an employee because he was fired almost 500 years ago. Would it make sense if the man then replied he is an employee anyway because he was not properly fired or cites how another employee didn't get fired in a simular situation.

The only people who believe the Anglican Orders are valid is the Anglicans.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...