Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Ok, So I Got Four Questions...


Recommended Posts

Phoenix Reborn
Posted

The first two are kinda strange, but here it goes...

1) What's wrong with Pokemon? We used to do it, but our parents made us stop all of a sudden.

2) What's the difference between the magic in Harry Potter and the magic in Lord of the Rings? How come the magic in LOTR is ok?

3) Is it ok to leave mass right after taking communion? (I'm not planning to do it, but I've seen other people do it...)

4) What are the Seven Deadly Sins? My dad can get up to #6...


I'd be thankful if anyone can answer #1, cause I've been wondering for a long time.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

1.no clue whats wrong with pokemon, other than the characters seem a bit unpleasant as role models

2.I see no difference between the magic other than degree. When you read fiction part of the fun is the "what if" of the presented worldview. We know its not real, but I would still like an owl bringing me my mail. :)

3.No I don't think its ok to leave Mass after Communion, its rude.

4.Seven deadly sins: Lust, gluttony, greed, sloth, wrath, envy, pride

Phoenix Reborn
Posted (edited)

Ok, thanks...didn't expect to get answers that quick...well, with the Harry Potter\Lord of the Rings thing...I'll just cut it short, how come Harry Potter's bad? (Unless I'll come up with the same answer...)

Edited by Phoenix Reborn
Phoenix Reborn
Posted

Well actually, I could always ask my parents about #2...never mind about that one.

Posted

Harry Potter, is using an evil magic in order to "do good". It gives the idea to youth that magic is something desirable and good. It basically is glorifying something intrinsically evil.

LOTR is destroying evil magic. It never once suggests that magic is something positive to be possessed by mankind.

I have a very good friend that discusses this exact topic. It is very interesting.

As for the communion, you are not completing Mass if you do not stay for the final blessing.

Sins have been listed.

Pokemon, I don't know much about. Probably the idea of using something intrinsically evil again (magic) with the illusion that it can "do good",but in a role playing sort of way?? Not sure TBH because I have never played Pokemon.

Posted

Harry Potter is based in the real world, and can sometimes give kids the idea that magic can be studied and used for good. LOTR is based in a fantasy world, using magic as merely a literary device: a setting for the battle between good and evil. same with the magic in Narnia, it's fantasy world (and the real world study is intentionally put in a bad light)

of course, one can enjoy Harry Potter without sin... it's not necessarily bad. there is a reasoning, however, as to why more caution should be taken with Harry Potter than with LOTR or Narnia. it's imitatable magic study (one could get into the occult, where they would attempt to study magic much the same way Harry Potter does at his school).

but Harry Potter can be enjoyed as fiction for the sake of the overall themes of good vs. evil and all. but one must remember that in the real world such magic study would be evil; it can only be enjoyed as a literary device which gives a setting for battles between good and evil.

and the only thing I could think of that would be problematic about pokemon is a troubling theme in many children's stories nowadays: kids running about with little or no reference to their parents... as if kids can/should just go around on their own. but that's not too problematic, and so as fiction (though I was never into it and can't say anything for sure because I never watched it.) it's not evil or anything

Posted

One resource I found: Fantasy and Your Family: A Closer Look at The Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter and Magick in the Modern World (Christian Publications, Inc.), by Richard Abanes.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='prose' post='1178246' date='Jan 27 2007, 11:27 PM']
Pokemon, I don't know much about. Probably the idea of using something intrinsically evil again (magic) with the illusion that it can "do good",but in a role playing sort of way?? Not sure TBH because I have never played Pokemon.
[/quote]

Oddly enough, Pokemon doesn't involve magic... It's about little creatures that people use to "fight" in competitions with and train... Don't ask me how I know :disguise:

I think some parents dislike them because they either dislike the :starwars: battling :bash: part or see the creatures as :devil:s

:breakdance:

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

As far as the Harry Potter books are concerned, I personally enjoy them, but tend to argue against both the idea that they're perfectly fine and that they're completely evil.

Some arguments against it from this (dated but really good) article at [url="http://www.weeklylowdown.com/pottertaran.shtml"]http://www.weeklylowdown.com/pottertaran.shtml[/url]
An adult theme is lacking
Class issues are handled inconsistently
There is little poignancy in Rowling’s books
The mythology is flawed, muddled, and weak in its attempt to embrace every half-legend in existence
Slytherin makes no bloody sense
Harry suffers few consequences for his mistakes
Save for a simple good vs. evil arrangement, magic has no real drawbacks
Evil in Rowling's books has few gray areas
Rowling is unnecessarily verbose

Other:
Rowling doesn't portray wholesome family dynamics. The Weasley family is described as being a kind of ideal family, the thing Harry wishes for. However, when you actually see it, it's not that great. Maybe Rowling's trying to be realistic, but she seems unable to show people dealing well with the normal conflicts that arise. Just in general, there are no real role models. Characters may be portrayed as such, but when you see them in action, they don't live up to it.

Read the "magic has no real drawbacks" part of the article. In both the Prydain Chronicles and TLOTR, magic isn't something for most of the characters we follow; in fact it's not something for our main character. In Harry Potter, it's a little like Batman's belt in the old comedic TV series. She can pull anything she wants out of it.
For some reason I feel that what Chesterton wrote seems to fit here:
The old fairy tale makes the hero a normal human boy; it is his adventures that are startling; they startle him because he is normal. But in the modern psychological novel the hero is abnormal; the centre is not central. Hence the fiercest adventures fail to affect him adequately, and the book is monotonous. You can make a story out of a hero among dragons; but not out of a dragon among dragons. The fairy tale discusses what a sane man will do in a mad world. The sober realistic novel of to-day discusses what an essential lunatic will do in a dull world.
The first HP book has the feel of 'the old fairy tale', but that becomes less and less so as the series progresses.
Perhaps what I’m feeling here (and not articulating very well) is the point the article makes when it says that there is little poignancy in the books. Weird and fantastic things happen, but there is less feeling than any old fairy tale. It’s just supposed to be amusing in some way.

Posted

[quote name='Phoenix Reborn' post='1178073' date='Jan 27 2007, 08:23 PM']
The first two are kinda strange, but here it goes...

1) What's wrong with Pokemon? We used to do it, but our parents made us stop all of a sudden.

[color="#FF0000"]Pokemon is about Magic. Anything to do with magic shouldn't be entertained.[/color]

2) What's the difference between the magic in Harry Potter and the magic in Lord of the Rings? How come the magic in LOTR is ok?

[color="#FF0000"]In my books, both are evil and you shouldn't be involved with them. But I'm just a fundy.

Abstain from all appearance of evil. 1 Thessalonians 5:22.[/color]

3) Is it ok to leave mass right after taking communion? (I'm not planning to do it, but I've seen other people do it...)

[color="#FF0000"]I would never leave a service of any religion I was involved in. Not only is it rude to other people, and to cause division within the believers is wrong, but it insults YHWH as well. If you want to honour him, you will be more than happy to personally involved in each service up to the end.[/color]

4) What are the Seven Deadly Sins? My dad can get up to #6...
I'd be thankful if anyone can answer #1, cause I've been wondering for a long time.

That question has already been answered.
[/quote]

LuchaporElRey21
Posted

[quote name='Phoenix Reborn' post='1178073' date='Jan 27 2007, 07:23 PM']
The first two are kinda strange, but here it goes...

1) What's wrong with Pokemon? We used to do it, but our parents made us stop all of a sudden.

2) What's the difference between the magic in Harry Potter and the magic in Lord of the Rings? How come the magic in LOTR is ok?

3) Is it ok to leave mass right after taking communion? (I'm not planning to do it, but I've seen other people do it...)

4) What are the Seven Deadly Sins? My dad can get up to #6...
I'd be thankful if anyone can answer #1, cause I've been wondering for a long time.
[/quote]


1) Basically, if you play the song backwards, you get a satanic message. No seriously, I am not full of carp. I saw it on tv. ;)

2) Because J.R.R Tolkien was Catholic. A better answer than that would be because I said so.

3) No. We call this the Judas Shuffle. Unless you have immediate work you need to head off to, or someone in the family is dying, people should stick around the dinner table until the father excuses everyone.

4) Lust, wraith, gluttony, sloth, blank, blank..lol

Posted

If you want to learn more about why some people think Harry Potter is bad, you could always go to Michael O'Brien's website....he gives pretty much all the reasons. idk which i agree with, i kinda just stay away from harry potter because i really dont know, and i'd rather not have anything to do with it if it is bad....

one argument about the difference between harry potter and lord of the rings is that in harry potter it is humans using the magic to have power over nature and other things. and harry potter uses loads of occultic symbols and beliefs as well. in lord of the rings, a human never uses magic, and the creatures who DO use magic are serving a higher power, a God. They are not using magic to have power over things, and their magic is not unlimited. idk how well i explained that....michael o'brien explains it pretty well. i'm not sure i buy all the stuff he says, but it's worth reading anyway. he's a catholic fiction writer. a pretty good writer too. I read Father Elijah....it was really good.

Phoenix Reborn
Posted (edited)

Well, thanks guys.

I also heard from my brother, that one of the things about Harry Potter is that Harry Potter goes to make magic. Magic you're born with is ok, but magic you just go out and try and do is like saying you don't like what God has already given you...

You see, what started this thing between my brother is, I have a bunch of fantasy stories, where random people are born with 'elemental' powers, but usually they have to be taught to know how to use them. If their elemental powers grow too strong, it actually overpowers them and they can get messed up. Usually with the elemental powers, they can empower weapons or shoot it out of their hands...it's usually the goodguys using it against evil. I do have some strange stories...

So I asked him about the elemental powers in my story, if it was like magic, and he said it WAS like magic, but he also said it was fine cause, they were actually born with it. Do you think the elemental powers are ok?

Edited by Phoenix Reborn
cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Phoenix Reborn' post='1178466' date='Jan 28 2007, 09:27 AM']
Well, thanks guys.

I also heard from my brother, that one of the things about Harry Potter is that Harry Potter goes to make magic. Magic you're born with is ok, but magic you just go out and try and do is like saying you don't like what God has already given you...

You see, what started this thing between my brother is, I have a bunch of fantasy stories, where random people are born with 'elemental' powers, but usually they have to be taught to know how to use them. If their elemental powers grow too strong, it actually overpowers them and they can get messed up. Usually with the elemental powers, they can empower weapons or shoot it out of their hands...it's usually the goodguys using it against evil. I do have some strange stories...

So I asked him about the elemental powers in my story, if it was like magic, and he said it WAS like magic, but he also said it was fine cause, they were actually born with it. Do you think the elemental powers are ok?
[/quote]
Harry potter was born with magic, he simply didn't know how to control it. :)

Posted

[quote name='LuchaporElRey21' post='1178317' date='Jan 28 2007, 12:54 AM']
1) Basically, if you play the song backwards, you get a satanic message. No seriously, I am not full of carp. I saw it on tv. ;)
[/quote]

yeah, its on that one backmasking website too. The song sounds like, "I love satan I love satan."

its kinda funny...

Posted

Here's [url="http://www.refracted-light.net/michaelobrien.html"]a critique[/url] of Michael O'Brien's position on fantasy in general which is well worth reading and summarizes my opinions.

With his articles on Harry Potter, if anyone really wants me to, I can demonstrate how they contain provable falsehoods about the actual content of the series.

Basically, I think the main difference between Harry Potter and LotR is that LotR is a classic of the fantasy genre whereas Harry Potter books are just good entertainment--something I have no problem with. Is the series morally flawless? No, but there has never been created by fallen man such a thing as a perfect work of art. Harry Potter has its problems.

But I don't think those problems are crippling, or that they make it bad reading. For example: Harry isn't punished every single time he committs an infraction. That would just be unrealistic and make for bad storytelling. However, on the whole, some of Harry's worst misfortunes come about because he failed to trust Dumbledore or because he acted on his own with mistaken or incomplete information. The most dramatic example of this is in Book 5--all the misfortune at the end comes about as a direct result of Harry taking matters into his own hands.

Magic is a power Harry is born with--he simply has to develop it via study, just like I have to develop my inborn talents at college. Magic isn't even a supernatural force in the world of Harry Potter--they don't pray to a higher being, good or evil. It's more like a natural force like electricity that can be harnessed.

I think a priest I know said it best (and I'm paraphrasing, but this is the general gist: If your child becomes a Satanist after reading Harry Potter, its your fault, not J. K. Rowling's. If your child is poorly formed enough that something like Harry Potter is going to draw them into the occult, you have failed as a parent.

Posted

I think people have pretty much covered it. Akalyte, liked the explanation for Harry Potter.

Anyway, I don't know much about Pokemon, except that I had to confiscate any Pokemon cards I saw from my students (3rd grade). The reasoning is because some of the students at my school were using them to gamble. Other than that, I have no clue about them.

Phoenix Reborn
Posted (edited)

I thank everyone for the explaination for Harry Potter. But I didn't understand everything clearly. So I asked about it in middle of a conversation about my priest not caring about Harry Potter. (Yes, he's a Liberal...). I came up with:
Harry Potter: Magic and witchcraft is the highest thing you'll get.
Lord of the Rings: They know there's a higher being (God) then them and they give up all their power in the end to go to Him. (That's my Aunt's explaination.)

So now I hope I don't get an O.D. on so much information...

Edited by Phoenix Reborn
Posted

I hope you don't mind if I add something... I think I'm clarifying my own thoughts.
In HP, there are what should be amazing and wonderful things all over the place, but she still manages to make it feel somewhat humdrum. Even her horrible stuff lacks the terror it should have. Everything is a little too flat. I think it lacks a certain sense of mystery. In the HP books, sure there's stuff we're not familiar with, but that's just 'cause we're muggles. It's ordinary to the wizarding community.
And yet, while everything is presented a little too matter-of-factly, there's no coherent vision of why things are the way they are. It really tries to ignore the whole philosophy stuff, which perhaps gives a hint as to what Rowling's view of philosophy might be (ie, that it doesn't matter, it's irrelevant). There is a kind of built in philosophy or cohesiveness to the other books -- the why are we here, etc.: it's what the main character explores as he matures. In HP, the furthest it goes is that HP is here to destroy Voldemort or to be destroyed by him. HP is amusing, but all it is is candy.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...