Resurrexi Posted January 30, 2007 Posted January 30, 2007 Was the Second Council of the Vatican a pastoral or dogmatic Oecumenical Council? N.B. This isn't meant to be a debate so I didn't make this thread in the debate board, but if it turns into one, mods, feel free to move it.
thessalonian Posted January 30, 2007 Posted January 30, 2007 It did not proclaim new dogma so it could not be said to be dogmatic in that sense. Nor did it write any proclaimations that contradicted previous dogma.
Resurrexi Posted January 30, 2007 Author Posted January 30, 2007 [quote] both. [/quote] Can you show me any canons from the Second Vatican Council anathematizing errors? Can you show me where it used "We declare, define and pronounce that x is a divinely revealed Dogma"? From what I can tell, it only restated already defined Dogmata.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 30, 2007 Posted January 30, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1180664' date='Jan 30 2007, 07:03 PM'] Can you show me any canons from the Second Vatican Council anathematizing errors? Can you show me where it used "We declare, define and pronounce that x is a divinely revealed Dogma"? From what I can tell, it only restated already defined Dogmata. [/quote] `Have you read the Dogmatic Constituton?
Resurrexi Posted January 30, 2007 Author Posted January 30, 2007 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1180666' date='Jan 30 2007, 05:09 PM'] `Have you read the Dogmatic Constituton? [/quote] which?
Mr.Cat Posted January 30, 2007 Posted January 30, 2007 The Second Vatican Council was a General or Ecumenical Council of the Church, meaning its reach is over the entire Catholic Church. It is also an Infallible and Indefectible Council of the Catholic Church, meaning nothing contained in those matters concerning faith or morals contain error. Although, the Second Vatican Council was not Magisterial Council meaning that it proposed those things already understood rather than actively clarifying or crystallizing teaching along with the condemnation of errors. Thus, the Second Vatican Council must be accepted by all the Catholic faithful. Then again, there are certain decisions in the Second Vatican Council that are “pastoral” meaning they are not in the scope of infallibility, or that those decisions can change. For example, the Second Vatican Council ended all excommunications for Catholics going before a non-catholic minister to be married, even though they still called it grave matter. The Church could recant this action and restore the excommunication if they so desired. The problem is two extremes when dealing with the actual mindset of the Council Fathers, the first is taking everything as pastoral and the second is taking everything as dogmatic decree. Then we have Catholics whom take the Second Vatican Council out of context of the other documents, other Councils, or other teachings of the Church. Almost a “Sola Concillum” where we can hear much of the “Spirit of the Second Vatican Council.” Then we have Catholics who refuse to even accept the Second Vatican Council all together. All of theses people contribute to the Second Vatican Council being the most misunderstood Council in the history of the Catholic Church.
Resurrexi Posted January 30, 2007 Author Posted January 30, 2007 [quote name='Mr.CatholicCat' post='1180733' date='Jan 30 2007, 05:50 PM'] The Second Vatican Council was a General or Ecumenical Council of the Church, meaning its reach is over the entire Catholic Church. It is also an Infallible and Indefectible Council of the Catholic Church, meaning nothing contained in those matters concerning faith or morals contain error. Although, the Second Vatican Council was not Magisterial Council meaning that it proposed those things already understood rather than actively clarifying or crystallizing teaching along with the condemnation of errors. Thus, the Second Vatican Council must be accepted by all the Catholic faithful. Then again, there are certain decisions in the Second Vatican Council that are “pastoral” meaning they are not in the scope of infallibility, or that those decisions can change. For example, the Second Vatican Council ended all excommunications for Catholics going before a non-catholic minister to be married, even though they still called it grave matter. The Church could recant this action and restore the excommunication if they so desired. The problem is two extremes when dealing with the actual mindset of the Council Fathers, the first is taking everything as pastoral and the second is taking everything as dogmatic decree. Then we have Catholics whom take the Second Vatican Council out of context of the other documents, other Councils, or other teachings of the Church. Almost a “Sola Concillum” where we can hear much of the “Spirit of the Second Vatican Council.” Then we have Catholics who refuse to even accept the Second Vatican Council all together. All of theses people contribute to the Second Vatican Council being the most misunderstood Council in the history of the Catholic Church. [/quote] I don't deny the Second Council of the Vatican, I just think that it was a non-dogmatic council that only restated previously defined Dogmata, and was therefore, totally pastoral.
Noel's angel Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 (edited) [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1180668' date='Jan 31 2007, 12:12 AM'] which? [/quote] The Dogmatic Constitution on the Church, The Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation What's your point anyway?? Edited January 31, 2007 by Noel's angel
scardella Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1180652' date='Jan 30 2007, 05:52 PM'] both. [/quote] You said exactly what I was gonna say.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1180737' date='Jan 30 2007, 07:54 PM'] I don't deny the Second Council of the Vatican, I just think that it was a non-dogmatic council that only restated previously defined Dogmata, and was therefore, totally pastoral. [/quote] It further defined and expanded upon previous conciliar definitions, such as EENS. That means it's a doctrinal council. The Church even stated that there is was a need for a new Catechism (the CCC) after the council (Laetimur Magnopere), which means that there were expansions and specifications in the definitions of doctrine.
Resurrexi Posted January 31, 2007 Author Posted January 31, 2007 [quote name='Raphael' post='1180947' date='Jan 30 2007, 08:36 PM'] It further defined and expanded upon previous conciliar definitions, such as EENS. That means it's a doctrinal council. The Church even stated that there is was a need for a new Catechism (the CCC) after the council (Laetimur Magnopere), which means that there were expansions and specifications in the definitions of doctrine. [/quote] Now on VII expanding previous definitions, I would disagree, but I guess yours is a valid interpretation. The CCC is directed at Bishops. The CCT is directed at priests. The CSPX is directed at lay adults. When the new Catechism was published all adults had a catechism for them. You see? The need was not for a new Catechism but was for a Catechism for Bishops.
Akalyte Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 the council was fine. Nothing wrong with the council. Except the fact that when liberals took hold of it worldwide they decided to add their own spirit and interpretation. That's not good. Yes it was hijacked.
Resurrexi Posted January 31, 2007 Author Posted January 31, 2007 [quote name='Akalyte' post='1180972' date='Jan 30 2007, 09:02 PM'] the council was fine. Nothing wrong with the council. Except the fact that when liberals took hold of it worldwide they decided to add their own spirit and interpretation. That's not good. Yes it was hijacked. [/quote] Where do we find he authentic interpretation?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1180960' date='Jan 30 2007, 10:47 PM'] Now on VII expanding previous definitions, I would disagree, but I guess yours is a valid interpretation. The CCC is directed at Bishops. The CCT is directed at priests. The CSPX is directed at lay adults. When the new Catechism was published all adults had a catechism for them. You see? The need was not for a new Catechism but was for a Catechism for Bishops. [/quote] The CCC was published for the entire faithful, but especially for catechists: "This work is intended primarily for those responsible for catechesis: first of all the bishops, as teachers of the faith and pastors of the Church. It is offered to them as an instrument in fulfilling their responsibility of teaching the People of God. Through the bishops, it is addressed to redactors of catechisms, to priests, and to catechists. It will also be useful reading for all other Christian faithful." -CCC 12
goldenchild17 Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1180658' date='Jan 30 2007, 06:54 PM'] Nor did it write any proclaimations that contradicted previous dogma. [/quote] hmm... I don't recall him asking anything about this. Looking for trouble are we?
thessalonian Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 (edited) [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1181072' date='Jan 30 2007, 11:02 PM'] hmm... I don't recall him asking anything about this. Looking for trouble are we? [/quote] I say this with all charity I can muster. Schismatics bring trouble on themselves. I stand by what I said. Edited January 31, 2007 by thessalonian
Resurrexi Posted January 31, 2007 Author Posted January 31, 2007 [quote]It did not proclaim new dogma so it could not be said to be dogmatic in that sense. Nor did it write any proclaimations that contradicted previous dogma.[/quote] I would agree with that.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1181532' date='Jan 31 2007, 06:02 PM'] I would agree with that. [/quote] But since it further defined dogma it was dogmatic in nature.
Recommended Posts