Guest CollegeCatholic Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 I was asked what church teachings were optional to believe and how they were chosen to be optional. I know some, but I'm not sure how the church came to those decisions. Help?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted February 4, 2007 Posted February 4, 2007 The Church's faith is what is called the deposit of faith. Matters of that deposit are fixed and certain. There are different degrees to which those doctrines have been defined, depending on need. You have doctrines and you have dogmas. Neither is more true than the other; both are certain. However, a doctrine might develop into a dogma as it is further defined. For instance, Christ's divinity was taken for granted until some early heretics began to teach against it. At that point, what had been a relatively undefined doctrine became the subject of a council and was defined for the faithful, that is, the Church said exactly what Christ's divinity means. That, however, doesn't mean that it was any less true before it was defined dogmatically. There are also teachings which the Church proposes, but which are not doctrine, such as limbo. Limbo is really just a sort of theological speculation which, for a long time, was considered pretty highly by the Church, but which has since come out of popularity. It was not itself a doctrine, but really only a concept proposed to explain a doctrine. The Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15) helps us to see how this process is Scriptural. Some people (Judaizers) were saying that Christians had to be circumcized and refrain from unclean meats. Others were saying this was not true. The apostles got together and held a council in Jerusalem. They defined dogmatically what had already been held, that is, that the Old Covenant was fulfilled, so we see there a distinction between doctrine and dogma. They also set rules for the faithful not to eat unclean meats, not because they were evil, but so as not to scandalize the converts from Judaism (this was a discipline, not a doctrine, and it is no longer in force). In short, nothing from the deposit of faith (basically, anything you read in the Catechism) is optional. What is optional for believe are matters of discipline (you can be for overturning priestly celibacy, for instance, which is only a discipline, but you have to submit to it in the here and now, out of obedience to the bishops) and theological speculation which attempt to explain doctrines (such as limbo). Some things which are often considered optional but are not optional are the Church's teaching against contraception, abortion, women's ordination, homosexual activity, euthanasia, cloning, embryonic stem cell research, fornication, etc. For further reading, try Ludwig Ott's "Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma," which runs through the teachings of the Church and their classifications. God bless, Micah
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now