Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

We are studying it in history. We are reading a book called "Night" by Elie Wiesel, and we watched documentaries.

I just can't believe people would do something like that. People. How could God allow all thos einnocent men, women, children to be tortured like that, to die.

In the book NIGHT, the author says that a few moments were enough to shatter his faith forever. In class we had a discussion, and most people, i could tell after a while, were thinking that either God doesn't exist, or that he exists and just doesn't care.

This depresses me. I'm sorry for yet another rambling post, but I'm just struggling with the question "why?"

Posted

Vera, I'm with you all the way.

Nothing grieves me more than the inhuman acts that man is capable of committing to his own kind.

I read a book set in wartime France called "Charlotte Grey". The persecution of the Jewish people (particularly children) made me cry.

Posted

I read that book, Night it is so... scary. So sad. :mellow:

Posted

sad can't describe it. i just feel a horror. it's indiscribable.

when watching a documentary, with the pictures of auschwitz, i just felt something really really dark was suffocating me.

Posted

Such feelings (although horrifying) are surely a sign that you're a natural, caring and sensitive human being.

Feeling nothing would be infinitely more worrying. That's how the perpetrators were able to commit such abominable acts in the first place.

Posted

I threw up and teared up at the Holocaust Museum in Washington when I went last year. There is a room at the end of the tour filled with all the actual shoes that were left outside the gas chambers in Auschwitz - belonging to men, women, children, babies - I'm a man that was too much for me to handle.

The only way I find some peace was knowing that God never abandoned anyone, not in Nazi Germany, Communist Russia, Maoist China, Saadam's Iraq, etc. God was there in the midst of it all working through many courageous people, he promised to never abandon us. It's also a realization that there is a great evil in this world that hates what is good and true.

Avoir Les Enfant , literally "GoodBye Little Children" is a movingly beautiful and tragic story of how the French resistance tried to hide French Jewish children in the Catholic schools. The plans is an ultimate fumble :( I had to read it in high school and watch the movie and that particular film really openned my eyes. Go check the movie out and you'll see the good, the innocent, and the evil.

God Bless.

Posted

Hey Vera,

Try to look at it from another angle. What miracles ocurred during those times. How many Jewish people were brought closer to God because they had to put their faith in Him. Catholics helping Jews to survive. Enemies helping enemies within the Jewish community.

The question isn't why God would "do" or allow something such as this to happen.

The Holocaust only serves to prove what it is like WITHOUT God. Because it was the Nazis who totally rejected God.

The secular media and society in general likes to blame God for alot of things. But lets put blame where it is due, to Satan.

See how twisted our society is. The Holocaust didn't occur because of God, it happened due to a lack of God.

If Hitlar believed in God and followed God's commands, the Holocaust wouldn't have happened. It isn't the other way around.

People look and see how hurt the Jews were and wonder why God would allow that. But they forget to analyze WHY the Jews were being hurt. Why? Because a group of individuals denied God and rejected His Commands.

Posted

It's the poor kids that effects me the worst. In the book I read, they were loaded onto buses (separate from their parents) to go to the camps. They had to write signs round their necks with their name on, but some kids didn't know how to write their name or what their surname was. They were too young.

I read that bit, thought about my two kids and broke down. I'm choked up writing this now, but the world has to know what went on!

Posted

Vera, you should read Corrie Ten Boom's autobiography if you haven't already! Her family were Christians who hid Jewish people during the war; they were then caught by the Nazis and were sent to a concentration camp themselves; a number of her family didn't survive. Corrie talks about how it affected her belief in God and her faith - it is a very powerful account.

Posted

I threw up and teared up at the Holocaust Museum in Washington when I went last year. There is a room at the end of the tour filled with all the actual shoes that were left outside the gas chambers in Auschwitz - belonging to men, women, children, babies - I'm a man that was too much for me to handle.

I went there too, my senior year in high school. My English class had just finished reading Night and it made a powerful impact on me. If you ever get a chance in your lifetime, you MUST go to the Holocaust museum. It is very powerful.

Vera, God bless. I'm sorry I cannot write more right now.

Posted

I've read Night. It is a book beyond sad. It isn't that God allowed it to happen, but we allowed it to happen. It is a book that should compel us to speak up for what is right. It is a book that still speaks not only of the memories of the horrors of the Holocaust, but the horrors that go beyond the Holocaust. As I read that book, I saw abortion and enthuasia as the Holocaust of today. As Jake said, there were miracles. Look at St. Maximailian Kolbe! He died to save another who had a wife and children! I took that book and made it my own. My grandfather (abuelito) lost an arm and fought in WWII. Our battle is without guns/granades, but with rosaries and Mass. It is the ulitmate battle we cannot lose for our brothers and sisters who have no voice but ours who are too weak, too little, not "Healthy enough" born deformed, too old etc.

If sometimes our poor people have had to die of starvation, it is not because God didn't care for them, but because you and I didn't give, were not instruments of love in the hands of God, to give them that bread, to give them that clothing; because we did not recognize him, when once more Christ came in distressing disguise- in the hungry man, in the lonely man, in the homeless child, and seeking for shelter. God has identifed himself with the hungry, the sick, the naked, the homeless; hunger, not only for bread, but for love, for care, to be somebody to someone; nakedness, not of clothing only, but nakedness of that compassion that very few people give to the unknown; homellessness, not only just for a shelter made of stone, but that homelessness that comes from having no one to call your own. ~ Blessed Mother Teresa

Posted

a whole chunk of Our Lord's suffering and Passion must have been suffered for the sins committed during that time in those camps

Posted

It's something that I find tremendously painful. I think partly because it's very close to home as so many of my family were killed in extermination camps, but also because it forces me to confront the horrors to which humanity can sink. I went to Yad Vashem (the Holocaust memorial in Jerusalem) a couple of years ago and stuggled not to completely break down in tears. The most powerful part I found was the children's memorial. They have a single candle in the centre that is reflected throughout the room by mirrors, whilst a tape plays the names and ages of children who were killed by the Nazis.

I think though that rather than turning me away from God, it brings home to me how much I need to place my trust in Him.

Posted

I went to the Holocaust museum. That one of the saddest things I've ever had to go through, but it was like I knew I had to do it, that I couldn't escape it, and it wouldn't go away just because I wanted it to.

Jake makes some good points. Remember, we have a free will. Completely free. God can try, but in the end, we choose. In that instance, the world, for the most part, chose to turn away. As has been said, there was good that existed in and came out of the Holocaust (NOTE: I am NOT trying to justify what happened by the good that came out of it). In addition, when we view the Holocaust, we see that part of us that we want to hide. The part that hates. We see what hatred, bigotry, and apathy cause. And we learn. We learn that we cannot turn away, and we cannot say "someone else will take care of it."

Posted (edited)

Night is a really depressing book, but an important one. Definitely also read Corrie ten Boom's book The Hiding Place. It may help you. And I echo all of you who said to go to the Holocaust Museum if you are ever anywhere near Washington, D.C. It's indescribable.

I have found it's a good thing to read and talk with people about personal experiences of suffering, ours and theirs. A guy who has been through a lot of carp recently told me, "You can’t go through something like this and not be changed – and it’s not easy for it to change you for the better.” So true.

Going through suffering -- whether it's vicariously through witnessing the suffering of others or through your own experience -- will change you. It has changed me, in some ways for the better and in some ways not.

The thing I kept coming back to is that God is sovereign, and I have to trust that he will do as he has promised, and make all that is now ugliness new and beautiful again. Someday this will all make sense. I used to think that was a cop-out answer, but I don't really know any other.

One book I keep coming back to when I get stuck on the question "why" (which happens from time to time) is the book of Job. Job asks God "Why" about his own suffering, and God takes him on a whirlwind tour of creation, asking him questions like, "Is it by your discernment that the hawk soars, that he spreads his wings toward the south?" or "Would you refuse to acknowledge my right? Would you condemn me that you may be justified?"

Finally, Job comes to the place where he says, "I have dealt with great things that I do not undersand; things too wonderful for me, which I cannot know. I had heard of you by wordo f mouth, but now my eye has seen you. Therefore, I disown what I have said, and repent in dust and ashes."

I read this periodically to remind myself of who God is and who I am. It helps.

I'll be praying for you.

Sojourner

Verses quoted from The New American Bible.

Edited by Sojourner
Posted

thanks.

The thing that made me post was also that in the discussion we had after class, our teacher made some points, like :

If you know the Bible, you probably know the story of Sodom and Gomorra. Id God punished them just because they were sinning, what about all those millions of lives lost in the greatest sins of all. "God" was silent.

at the beginning he made a whole speech about he didn't want to "pressure" us to talk about our "religious beliefes", but sincethe theme of god, the question of "why", and lost faith are important themes in the book, we'll discuss it.

I find it hard to stand up for my faith in my class. My reasons get all mixed up and it sounds so lame coming out of my mouth.

Posted

thanks.

The thing that made me post was also that in the discussion we had after class, our teacher made some points, like :

If you know the Bible, you probably know the story of Sodom and Gomorra. Id God punished them just because they were sinning, what about all those millions of lives lost in the greatest sins of all. "God" was silent.

at the beginning he made a whole speech about he didn't want to "pressure" us to talk about our "religious beliefes", but sincethe theme of god, the question of "why", and lost faith are important themes in the book, we'll discuss it.

I find it hard to stand up for my faith in my class. My reasons get all mixed up and it sounds so lame coming out of my mouth.

i understand what you mean Vera. I went through Catholic schools all my life and i'm in a public community college now, and sometimes it's seems hard for me to stand up for my faith too, for much of the same reasons you said. I remember my junior year we learned all about the Holocaust (and then some! I swear my teacher was so into you'd swear she was jewish herself! :sweat: ) and had to write an essay on it (Mangela is just horrible!)and had a survivor come in to speak to us. She read to us parts of "Night" and i think i remember her saying Weisel eventually did come back to his faith. We watched Schindler's List too, very sad movie. but if there's anything of comfort i can give you, remember this "he who saves one life, saves the world entire". It's from the Talmud, and it was written on a ring the survivor gave schindler.

Posted (edited)

hey vera! This might be of intrest for you.

http://holocaust.hklaw.com/

someone from my school wrote an essay for this in 2001, and won.

Edited by hopeful1
Posted

Vera,

You don't have to say anything. Your teacher and classmates already know your stance, so your presence does the talking.

Just pray for them. I will too.

You are so special.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...