The Joey-O Posted January 31, 2007 Posted January 31, 2007 Ok. Maybe the last place I posted this wasn't the right place. So, I'm posting it again: I am mostly looking for the nuances in Catholic soteriology. Please link to sources (y'all are usually good about this, but things are better left said than unsaid). I'm trying to understand the state of the soul 1) before the Fall 2) in original sin, after the Fall, 2) at the moment of redemption in Baptism, 3) when the Redeemed sin and 4) and when the Redeemed are absolved in Reconciliation. My understanding is just a little rough. I already have a basic understanding of all these areas. Some specific things I would like to know is: a) I have heard Protestants teach that before the Fall, though we were untainted by original sin, we were not able to or in the process of moving into the Trinity. Is this a correct teaching? Please elaborate if possible. b) I have heard people use the analogies of our souls being "dirty", "totally depraved", "shattered/broken", etc. to describe our souls' state after the Fall. Obviously the church teaches that we are "stained" with original sin. It seems to me saying things like "dirty" or even "stained" doesn't do justice to the level of depravity Fallen Man has nor does it do justice to the Transformative nature of Baptism. So, do our souls essentially remain unchanged, simply cleansed in the waters of Baptism or are they transformed? (I'm not questioning the doctrine of original sin; I'm just interested in a fuller explanation.) c) Is there a qualitative difference in the manner that the Redeemed Man sins? Or, is there a qualitative difference in the state of the soul of a Redeemed Man that enables Reconciliation to be the proper means of grace rather than Baptism? Or, Is there a qualitative difference between original sin and other sins that demands original sin be removed through Baptism and all other sins simply require Reconciliation? d) (This is closely related to b & c.) How would you describe the difference between the state of the soul of the Fallen Man and the state of the soul of a Redeemed Man who has sinned? Also, any good Catholic atonement models would be helpful in furthering my understanding. JoeyO.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now