Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Do All Dogs Go To Heaven?


Do all dogs go to heaven?  

32 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Cure of Ars
Posted

Anyone have any dead pets they want to talk about?

Brother Adam
Posted

Only if they are baptized of course! :o

Dogs don't have souls, only humans do. All animals came from the dust and to the dust they shall return. <_<

hyperdulia again
Posted

Cure your avatar scares me!

there can be as much theological debate as people wanna have, but Brownie was people. He's waitin' on me.

Posted

Isn't it possible that all living things have souls but their souls die when they die?

Winchester
Posted

My pet lawyer, Warren Snicket. He used to sleep on a heat rock in my room and sue people.

Cure of Ars
Posted

Only if they are baptized of course! :o

Dogs don't have souls, only humans do. All animals came from the dust and to the dust they shall return. <_<

I personally don't know the answer to this so I want to dive into this a little deeper.

If we are going to have a body and a spirit in heaven, why can't God resurrect pets even if they do not have a soul?

Winchester
Posted

No one said He couldn't.

Cure of Ars
Posted

No one said He couldn't.

So is will fluffy go to heaven or not?

Posted

To me, heaven is a place where there are no cats.

Cure of Ars
Posted

Cure your avatar scares me!

there can be as much theological debate as people wanna have, but Brownie was people.  He's waitin' on me.

It is a little scary. Do you think I should change it?

Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

I believe I once read an arguement that went along the lines of every living creature has a soul, because that is the spark that indicates life, but that only human souls went to heaven or hell primarily because they had knowledge of good and evil.

<_<

:ph34r:

Cure of Ars
Posted

To me, heaven is a place where there are no cats.

Amen, I hate cats.

My grandma used to say that they would jump right on a baby and smell of elderberries the life out. <_<

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Isn't it possible that all living things have souls but their souls die when they die?

Vegetative souls vs. Rational Souls. Only people have Rational souls (and thats why only people go to heaven). All other living things--animals, plants, etc., have vegetative souls.

I don't think I can go into this much more without doing some research, though, because I'm dredging up freshman year Theology. I'd need to go back and refresh my memory to really discuss the concept I just tossed out.... maybe next time I'll keep my trap shut...

hyperdulia again
Posted

My Kitty is my Child, my first-born. My Heart. I don't like people that are racist again' cats. :ph34r: ;)

Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

Yeah Hyper, I've got three cats. And Don John is a dog person. Just remember that bit of poetic justice the next time he ticks you off!

:ph34r:

Cure of Ars
Posted

My Kitty is my Child, my first-born.  My Heart.  I don't like people that are racist again' cats. :ph34r:  ;)

Please tolerate my intolerance.

:rolleyes:

Posted

My Kitty is my Child, my first-born.  My Heart.  I don't like people that are racist again' cats. :ph34r:  ;)

It wouldn't be racist. It would be specist.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

My Kitty is my Child, my first-born. My Heart.  I don't like people that are racist again' cats. :ph34r:  ;)

I confess, I'm racist against cats... I'm allergic to them, so I have a lame excuse. I am a dog person. My husband likes cats, but since he can't have one b/c of my allergies, he wants pet ducks or geese. I told him the day he gets birds I'm going out and getting my dog. And I do mean he wants them as PETS, like, he'd train them to follow him around and stuff. He's done it before.

hyperdulia again
Posted

Yeah Hyper, I've got three cats.  And Don John is a dog person.  Just remember that bit of poetic justice the next time he ticks you off!

:ph34r:

haha

Posted

My mom used to love cats, when she was 5 or 6 she chased this big cat around and it scratches her in the face. She had to go to the hospital. She doesn't like them as much now (but doesn't hate them)(at least I don't think).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...