Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Children Sent To War In Iraq...


Recommended Posts

Posted

Children deployed to fight in Iraq
Press Association
Sunday February 4, 2007 4:43 AM


Fifteen children have been deployed to fight in Iraq since June 2003, it has been disclosed.

The figure, given by defence minister Adam Ingram, was described as "shocking" by the Liberal Democrats.

Mr Ingram said the "vast majority" were deployed within a week of their 18th birthdays or were removed from theatre less than a week after arriving.

All were 17 years old, while as many as four were girls.

He said: "Provisional estimates collated from manual records show that no 16-year-old and 15 17-year-old personnel have been deployed to Iraq since the 'Optional Protocol to the Convention on the rights of the child on the involvement of children in armed conflict' was ratified on 24 June 2003. None have been deployed since July 2005."

In a written answer to the House of Commons, Mr Ingram said that new procedures had been introduced to ensure that under-18s were not deployed to war zones.

He added: "Unfortunately, these processes are not infallible and the pressures on units prior to deployment have meant that there have been a small number of instances where soldiers have been inadvertently deployed to Iraq before their 18th birthday."

But Liberal Democrat education spokeswoman Sarah Teather, who requested the information, called on Prime Minister Tony Blair to apologise.

She said: "This is an inexcusable blunder by the Government that reveals a shocking level of incompetence. We have rules about sending those under 18 into conflict for a reason.

"There is no way people so young are mentally or emotionally prepared to face bloodshed on the scale seen in Iraq."

Posted

So the Bush & Blair governments put children in harm's way. And people still support this stupid thing?

Mary's servant
Posted

AMDG+JMJ
So at 17 they are not mentally or emotionally prepared to handle it, but one week later, when they are 18, they are? The Liberal Democrats really need to find an intelligent argument to support their causes. Just one, that's all I'm asksing. I'm only asking that because that will take the investigative teams of the entire party busy until I'm dead, and I'm only 19.

Posted

If you ask me, even 18 is too young for all of that. 18 year-olds today are not the 18 year-olds of the 1930s and 40s; the law in the United States, Canada, and Britain has not recognized this shift, which is the result of immense social and cultural changes in the West since the days of WWII. Quite legally, we really are sending babes over there. This may very well be a major factor to the disastrous situations in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Posted

[quote name='Nathan' post='1184851' date='Feb 4 2007, 08:47 PM']
If you ask me, even 18 is too young for all of that. 18 year-olds today are not the 18 year-olds of the 1930s and 40s; the law in the United States, Canada, and Britain has not recognized this shift, which is the result of immense social and cultural changes in the West since the days of WWII. Quite legally, we really are sending babes over there. This may very well be a major factor to the disastrous situations in Iraq and Afghanistan.
[/quote]

In the US, they may be "babes" when they go to boot camp, but they are not babies by the time they deploy. They are trained military men capable of doing their jobs and ready to do what they [b]voluntarily[/b] signed up for.

Posted

[quote name='Mary's servant' post='1184796' date='Feb 4 2007, 05:54 PM']
AMDG+JMJ
So at 17 they are not mentally or emotionally prepared to handle it, but one week later, when they are 18, they are? The Liberal Democrats really need to find an intelligent argument to support their causes. Just one, that's all I'm asksing. I'm only asking that because that will take the investigative teams of the entire party busy until I'm dead, and I'm only 19.
[/quote]

So you support illegal deployment?

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

I wonder what the the soldiers in question have to say. I doubt their wineing like "children."

The only purpose a soldier has is to risk his/her life to kill and break things. If this is such a problem with the Brits why do they have 17yr old soldiers in the first place? If their too young for the job, why let them have it in the first place?

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1184765' date='Feb 4 2007, 04:54 PM']
So the Bush & Blair governments put children in harm's way. And people still support this stupid thing?
[/quote]
why are you bringing Bush into this?

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1185135' date='Feb 5 2007, 12:23 AM']
why are you bringing Bush into this?
[/quote]

Because Mr. Blair didn't lead the charge for this War.

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1184765' date='Feb 4 2007, 04:54 PM']
So the Bush & Blair governments put children in harm's way. And people still support this stupid thing?
[/quote]
I really would appreciate you giving a link proving that Bush did this with our soldiers, or edit your post

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1185088' date='Feb 4 2007, 11:32 PM']
The only purpose a soldier has is to risk his/her life to kill and break things.
[/quote]

Everyone jumps over me when I call our troops boys and girls, but he can say carp like this?

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1185177' date='Feb 5 2007, 01:28 AM']
Because Mr. Blair didn't lead the charge for this War.
[/quote]

This is getting absurd. This war would have been fought no matter what administration. They were all talking about WMDs. Clinton himself said that Saddam had them and that he'll use them. Hilary had said there is no other way to deal with this than regime change. Pellosi the same. Blair, Rumsfeld. They all agreed. And America stood by them because it was the right thing to do. They all led the charge, some just feel all the pressure should go to the leader of them all, which is Bush. I'm still behind my president in this war, because we still live on the same planet that we did on September 12, 2001, when the entire country was behind him.

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1185246' date='Feb 5 2007, 08:24 AM']
This is getting absurd. This war would have been fought no matter what administration. They were all talking about WMDs. Clinton himself said that Saddam had them and that he'll use them. Hilary had said there is no other way to deal with this than regime change. Pellosi the same. Blair, Rumsfeld. They all agreed. And America stood by them because it was the right thing to do. They all led the charge, some just feel all the pressure should go to the leader of them all, which is Bush. I'm still behind my president in this war, because we still live on the same planet that we did on September 12, 2001, when the entire country was behind him.
[/quote]

You're getting off topic. The issue is that the UK, led by Mr. Blair, illagally sent children to fight in a war.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' post='1185273' date='Feb 5 2007, 09:29 AM']
You're getting off topic. The issue is that the UK, led by Mr. Blair, illagally sent children to fight in a war.
[/quote]
You brought Bush into this.

Posted

Can we just forget him then? The Government of Britain illegally sent children over to fight.

Posted

Please the focus is on the Blair (lets get cash for Honours) Government and the sending of under age 'children' to war.

I agree with the post regarding 'children' entering boot camp and coming out as adults. Perhaps we could say that they are trained fighting machines. There are also, unfortunately thousands of examples of those under 18 committing attrocious crimes against others. However it is the principle of the matter. The law states that no one under 18 goes to war, yet the Government 'bent' the rules. Does 1 week make a difference? Probably not in reality, but it is the spirit of the law that has been broken. Why therefore are they accepted into the military UNDER the age of 18?

We shout and scream at Third World dictators because they send children 10 years old sometimes, to fight with an AK47 in one hand and a Machette in the other, yet it is 'OK' for the Civilized West to break the same rules??

homeschoolmom
Posted

Well, no, it's not right. But how did this happen? Were they inlistees who were just called up too early?

Posted

It is terrible that 17 year olds are being sent to war. But I do agree with the argument that they probably arent much more prepared for war now that they're 18 (i assume its pretty soon since it said they're a couple weeks from their birthdays.)

We can say all we want about this being terrible, but war isnt really a pretty site for any age. It's not appropriate for anyone to see, and yet it happens and is sometimes necessary. I'm not however making excuses for PM Blair, though, because I do think this could have been avoided.

Posted (edited)

UK not the only one .... Interestingly though both Ethiopia and the UK are NOT mentioned on the list and there have been many first hand reports of Ethiopia taking kids as young at 12 from the streets just a month ago....

[quote]Child soldiers being actively recruited as frontline fodder in at least 13 countries

date published: 02/02/2007

Ten years after international guidelines were established to stamp out the recruitment and use of child soldiers, under-age fighters are still actively being recruited in at least 13 countries.

Fighting forces are recruiting and using child soldiers within Afghanistan, Burundi, Chad, Colombia, Democratic Republic of Congo, Ivory Coast, Myanmar, Nepal, Phillipines, Sri Lanka, Somalia, Sudan and Uganda. Government forces are also implicated in countries such as Southern Sudan, where the SPLA is re-recruiting children who have already been released from their own ranks.

In Uganda 1,500 children are still held by the Lords Resistance Army. Another 10,000 children associated with the LRA are still unaccounted for.
In Sri Lanka, at least 5,000 children have been recruited since 2001. Despite the ceasefire signed in 2002, the threat of re-recruitment is once again so strong that parents are afraid to let children leave the house.
An estimated 11,000 children are currently involved with militias in DRC.
Children as young as eight are being recruited by the government army of Southern Sudan.
Around 75% of former girl soldiers in Liberia reported having suffered sexual abuse or exploitation.

In 2005 over 8,000 children were still fighting in West Africa, with another 20,000 in the process of or waiting to be released.


Despite the fact that the Cape Town Principles, guidelines to eradicate the use of child soldiers and protect those released, were established by the international community in 1997, the situation is still dire. Hundreds of thousands of children are still living in misery due to association with armed groups and forces.

Child soldiers are subjected to brutal intimidation, often forced to commit atrocities as military ‘training’, and then used on the frontline. Whether violently abducted, coerced into signing up or ‘volunteering’ because they have no safe alternative, they get no access to school or healthcare and are exposed to abuse and exploitation. Girls taken to become army 'wives' are often subjected to physical, sexual and emotional abuse. When released, ex-child soldiers are frequently rejected by society, refused access to school, and find it impossible to re-enter 'normal' life after so long immersed in violence. Girls as young as 12 have to deal with rape, and care for babies in isolation without any support from the community.

Bisimwa, 14, Democratic Republic Congo
“When I went to war it wasn’t a good life because I carried guns. I don’t know how many people I killed. Some of my friends died. I left the armed group because I was about to die of cold. Here we suffer too much.”

On 5 February, the international community has a crucial chance to improve the lives of all children associated with armed groups when they meet in Paris to establish new guidelines – the Paris Principles - to help eradicate the use of child soldiers.

Johanna MacVeigh, Protection Advisor, Save the Children
“Being recruited by armed forces has a devastating effect on children’s lives. They are immersed in violence, are subject to terrible abuse and are forced to forfeit love, play, education and hope. It is inconceivable that ten years after international guidelines were set up to protect children from recruitment, so many are still being horrifically exploited. Children can’t wait. Governments and the UN must show their support for the Paris Principles and commit to stamping out the use of child soldiers and looking after those who have been released.”

Save the Children is calling on:
All governments and armed groups immediately to release all children associated with fighting forces, and to put a stop to all on-going recruitment and re-recruitment. This must not be dependent on a ceasefire or permanent peace agreement.
All governments to ensure they have signed and ratified all relevant international law to protect children from unlawful recruitment and use, and to adhere to The Paris Principles.
The UN and the Human Rights Council to adopt the Paris Principles by way of resolution, recognising these bodies as the leading international instrument on the obligations of states and others in this area.
Donors adequately to fund programmes to ensure released and demobilised children can return to normal life. Current reintegration programmes are not protecting them sufficiently. Funding for such activities should be set at a minimum of five years.
The international community to ensure special provisions are made for former girl soldiers and their children, to lessen the risks of forced early marriage, isolation, re-recruitment or health implications of sexual violence. [/quote]

Edited by Rod

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...