Dave Posted February 4, 2007 Posted February 4, 2007 (edited) I know that all Catholics have the right to Masses said correctly and reverently. Well, both priests at my parish say that, if the only parish(es) in the area had Masses that were improperly and irreverently done, then the Sunday obligation would be dispensed. Or maybe they were just saying that they personally would give such dispensations; I don't know. Anyway, I find it hard to believe that that could ever be a reason to have the Sunday obligation dispensed ... unless maybe the only available parish were like St. Joan of Arc in either Minneapolis or St. Paul (can't remember which city). So who's off base here -- my parish priests or me? Edited February 4, 2007 by Dave
cmotherofpirl Posted February 4, 2007 Posted February 4, 2007 [quote name='Dave' post='1184816' date='Feb 4 2007, 07:43 PM'] I know that all Catholics have the right to Masses said correctly and reverently. Well, both priests at my parish say that, if the only parish(es) in the area had Masses that were improperly and irreverently done, then the Sunday obligation would be dispensed. Or maybe they were just saying that they personally would give such dispensations; I don't know. Anyway, I find it hard to believe that that could ever be a reason to have the Sunday obligation dispensed ... unless maybe the only available parish were like St. Joan of Arc in either Minneapolis or St. Paul (can't remember which city). So who's off base here -- my parish priests or me? [/quote] It would depend on what they mean by improper. I think if the only Mass available to you would be invalid [trying to consecrate a pizza], then you could not be required to go. However if they mean the liturgy is just poorly done, that would not be an excuse to miss Mass.
thessalonian Posted February 5, 2007 Posted February 5, 2007 (edited) Of course if they were consecrating something other than the proper bread that would be invalid. If a non-ordained to the preisthood person (including women) were doing the consecration I am sure you would not be obligated to go and in fact should not. If the words of the consecration were changed to invalidate the consecration I am not sure what you obligation regarding the Mass would be. If you went, not knowing this would happen you have probably fullfilled your obligation. If you knew, you have probably not fullfilled it. At any rate, just a poorly done Mass would neither excuse your obligation to go, nor mean that it was not fullfilled if you went. I am quite sure that the Bishop would have to excommunicate those performing the Mass to remove the obligation. We cannot make such judgements ourselves to go or not to go, excluding an invalid mass. I guess I don't know that the consecrations are invalid at St. Joan. Therefore I believe those Masses fullfill the obligation, though I have no desire to go there and would drive 100 miles to avoid it. Edited February 5, 2007 by thessalonian
Knight of the Holy Rosary Posted February 5, 2007 Posted February 5, 2007 I once attended an Highschool parish retreat that was held at a camp ( ). We were scheduled to have Mass in an upstairs room. The altar was a lunch table. There was swaying, clapping, dancing, kids (some of whom were wearing PJ's) reclining on the floor, and the Liturgical music came primarily from a compilation CD. To make matters worse the Priest forgot the host [b]so he used Wonderbread[/b]. This was the Sunday Liturgy. I had no other means by which to attend another Liturgy. Was I justified in not attending?
Groo the Wanderer Posted February 5, 2007 Posted February 5, 2007 [quote name='Knight of the Holy Rosary' post='1185362' date='Feb 5 2007, 11:42 AM'] I once attended an Highschool parish retreat that was held at a camp ( ). We were scheduled to have Mass in an upstairs room. The altar was a lunch table. There was swaying, clapping, dancing, kids (some of whom were wearing PJ's) reclining on the floor, and the Liturgical music came primarily from a compilation CD. To make matters worse the Priest forgot the host [b]so he used Wonderbread[/b]. This was the Sunday Liturgy. I had no other means by which to attend another Liturgy. Was I justified in not attending? [/quote] Yes. Wonderbread, beside being yucko, is not a proper type of bread. If i recall correctly, the bread must be made from wheat and be completely unleavened. The table is fine, as are the rest (if not exactly the most reverent).
thessalonian Posted February 5, 2007 Posted February 5, 2007 I don't think the use of leavened bread would invalidate a consecration as in the East in some places it is allowed from what I understand. However other ingredients, like you would find in normal processed bread such as wonderbread do invalidate a consecration to my understanding. This question really needs to be answered in the Catholic questions part by a qualified theologian or priest. I've given some opinions but don't find them totally adequate.
Resurrexi Posted February 5, 2007 Posted February 5, 2007 (edited) [quote name='The Catechism of the Council of Trent']THE MATTER It is particularly incumbent on pastors to know the matter of this Sacrament, in order that they themselves may rightly consecrate it, and also that they may be able to instruct the faithful as to its significance, inflaming them with an earnest desire of that which it signifies. THE FIRST ELEMENT OF THE EUCHARIST IS BREAD The matter of this Sacrament is twofold. The first element is wheaten bread, of which we shall now speak. Of the second we shall treat hereafter. As the Evangelists, Matthew, Mark and Luke testify, Christ the Lord took bread into His hands, blessed, and broke, saying: This is my body;13 and, according to John, the same Savior called Himself bread in these words: I am the living bread, that came down from heaven.14 THE SACRAMENTAL BREAD MUST BE WHEATEN There are, however, various sorts of bread, either because they consist of different materials, - such as wheat, barley, pulse and other products of the earth; or because they possess different qualities, - some being leavened, others altogether without leaven. It is to be observed that, with regard to the former kinds, the words of the Savior show that the bread should be wheaten; for, according to common usage, when we simply say bread, we are sufficiently understood to mean wheaten bread. This is also declared by a figure in the Old Testament, because the Lord commanded that the loaves of proposition, which signified this Sacrament, should be made of fine flour.15 * THE SACRAMENTAL BREAD SHOULD BE UNLEAVENED But as wheaten bread alone is to be considered the proper matter for this Sacrament - a doctrine which has been handed down by Apostolic tradition and confirmed by the authority of the Catholic Church - so it may be easily inferred from the doings of Christ the Lord that this bread should be unleavened. It was consecrated and instituted by Him on the first day of unleavened bread, on which it was not lawful for the Jews to have anything leavened in their houses.16 Should the authority of John the Evangelist,17 who says that all this was done before the feast of the Passover, be objected to, the argument is one of easy solution. For by the day before the pasch John understands the same day which the other Evangelists designate as the first day of unleavened bread. He wished particularly to mark the natural day, which commences at sunrise; whereas they wanted to point out that our Lord celebrated the Pasch on Thursday evening just when the days of the unleavened bread were beginning. Hence St. Chrysostom18 also understands the first day of unleavened bread to be the day on the evening of which unleavened bread was to be eaten.* The peculiar suitableness of the consecration of unleavened bread to express that integrity and purity of mind which the faithful should bring to this Sacrament we learn from these words of the Apostle: Purge out the old leaven, that you may be a new paste, as you are unleavened. For Christ our Passover is sacrificed. Therefore, let us feast, not with the old leaven, nor with the leaven of malice and wickedness, but with the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth.19 UNLEAVENED BREAD NOT ESSENTIAL This quality of the bread, however, is not to be deemed so essential that, if it be wanting, the Sacrament cannot exist; for both kinds are called by the one name and have the true and proper nature of bread. No one, however, is at liberty on his own private authority, or rather presumption, to transgress the laudable rite of his Church. And such departure is the less warrantable in priests of the Latin Church, expressly obliged as they are by the supreme Pontiffs, to consecrate the sacred mysteries with unleavened bread only. QUANTITY OF THE BREAD With regard to the first matter of this Sacrament, let this exposition suffice. It is, however, to be observed that the quantity of the matter to be consecrated is not defined, since we cannot define the exact number of those who can or ought to receive the sacred mysteries.*[/quote] [quote] This was the Sunday Liturgy. I had no other means by which to attend another Liturgy. Was I justified in not attending? [/quote] Yes, it would have been wrong for you to attend. The consecration of the bread was invalid (though the consecration of the wine may have been valid if what was being consecrated was true wine made from grapes*). Even if it were valid, though, it wouldn't have fufilled your obligation since it would have been said on a portable altar. [quote name='The 1917 Catholic Encyclopedia article 'Sunday'']When the parochial system was introduced, the laity were taught that they must hear Mass and the preaching of the Word of God on Sundays in their parish church. However, toward the end of the thirteenth century, the friars began to teach that the precept of hearing Mass might be fulfilled by hearing it in their churches, and after long and severe struggles this was expressly allowed by the Holy See. [b]Nowadays, the precept may be fulfilled by hearing Mass in any place except a strictly private oratory, and provided Mass is not celebrated on a portable altar by a privilege which is merely personal.[/b][/quote] *[quote name='The Catechism of the Council of Trent']THE SECOND ELEMENT OF THE EUCHARIST IS WINE It remains for us to treat of the other matter and element of this Sacrament, which is wine pressed from the fruit of the vine, with which is mingled a little water. That in the institution of this Sacrament our Lord and Savior made use of wine has been at all times the doctrine of the Catholic Church, for He Himself said: I will not drink from henceforth of this fruit of the vine until that day.20 On this passage Chrysostom21 observes: He says, "Of the fruit of the vine," which certainly produced wine not water; as if he had it in view, even at so early a period, to uproot the heresy which asserted that in these mysteries water alone is to be used. WATER SHOULD BE MIXED WITH THE WINE With the wine, however, the Church of God has always mingled water. First, because Christ the Lord did so, as is proved by the authority of Councils and the testimony of St. Cyprian;22 next, because by this mixture is renewed the recollection of the blood and water that issued from His side. Waters, also, as we read in the Apocalypse23 signify the people; and hence, water mixed with the wine signifies the union of the faithful with Christ their Head. This rite, derived as it is from Apostolic tradition, the Catholic Church has always observed. But although there are reasons so grave for mingling water with the wine that it cannot be omitted without incurring the guilt of mortal sin, yet its omission does not render the Sacrament null. Again as in the sacred mysteries priests must be mindful to mingle water with wine, so, also, must they take care to mingle it in small quantity, for, in the opinion and judgment of ecclesiastical writers, that water is changed into wine. Hence these words of Pope Honorius24 on the subject: A pernicious abuse has prevailed in your district of using in the sacrifice a greater quantity of water than of wine; whereas, according to the rational practice of the universal Church, the wine should be used in much greater quantity than the water.* NO OTHER ELEMENTS PERTAIN TO THIS SACRAMENT These, then, are the only two elements of this Sacrament; and with reason has it been enacted by many decrees that, although there have been those who were not afraid to do so, it is unlawful to offer anything but bread and wine. PECULIAR FITNESS OF BREAD AND WINE We have now to consider the aptitude of these two symbols of bread and wine to represent those things of which we believe and confess they are the sensible signs. In the first place, then, they signify to us Christ, as the true life of men; for our Lord Himself says: My flesh is meat indeed, and my blood is drink indeed.25 As, then, the body of Christ the Lord furnishes nourishment unto eternal life to those who receive this Sacrament with purity and holiness, rightly is the matter composed chiefly of those elements by which our present life is sustained, in order that the faithful may easily understand that the mind and soul are satiated by the Communion of the precious body and blood of Christ. These very elements serve also somewhat to suggest to men the truth of the Real Presence of the body and blood of the Lord in the Sacrament. Observing, as we do, that bread and wine are every day changed by the power of nature into human flesh and blood, we are led the more easily by this analogy to believe that the substance of the bread and wine is changed, by the heavenly benediction, into the real flesh and real blood of Christ. This admirable change of the elements also helps to shadow forth what takes place in the soul. Although no change of the bread and wine appears externally, yet their substance is truly changed into the flesh and blood of Christ; so, in like manner, although in us nothing appears changed, yet we are renewed inwardly unto life, when we receive in the Sacrament of the Eucharist the true life. Moreover, the body of the Church, which is one, consists of many members, and of this union nothing is more strikingly illustrative than the elements of bread and wine; for bread is made from many grains and wine is pressed from many clusters of grapes. Thus they signify that we, though many, are most closely bound together by the bond of this divine mystery and made, as it were, one body.*[/quote] Edited February 5, 2007 by StThomasMore
homeschoolmom Posted February 5, 2007 Posted February 5, 2007 [quote name='Dave' post='1184816' date='Feb 4 2007, 06:43 PM']... unless maybe the only available parish were like St. Joan of Arc in either Minneapolis or St. Paul (can't remember which city). So who's off base here -- my parish priests or me? [/quote] Thanks for remembering us.. and by that I mean those of us here... (We don't attend St. Joan's)... and it's in Minneapolis.
thessalonian Posted February 5, 2007 Posted February 5, 2007 While the Council of Trent is completely doctrinally valid, some of the matters that are of a practice or disciplinary nature are not always still in force. Therefore one should be cautious in quoting the Council of Trent as authoritative. I think it speaks well on this matter however.
cmotherofpirl Posted February 6, 2007 Posted February 6, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1185493' date='Feb 5 2007, 02:47 PM'] Yes, it would have been wrong for you to attend. The consecration of the bread was invalid (though the consecration of the wine may have been valid if what was being consecrated was true wine made from grapes*). Even if it were valid, though, it wouldn't have fufilled your obligation since it would have been said on a portable altar. * [/quote] A portable altar does NOT invalidate the Mass.
Resurrexi Posted February 6, 2007 Posted February 6, 2007 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1185724' date='Feb 5 2007, 06:25 PM'] A portable altar does NOT invalidate the Mass. [/quote] Yes, I realize that. But to satisfy one's Sunday Obligation, one must hear a Mass not 'said on a portible altar by a privilage which is merely personal'.
Dave Posted February 6, 2007 Author Posted February 6, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1185744' date='Feb 5 2007, 08:47 PM'] Yes, I realize that. But to satisfy one's Sunday Obligation, one must hear a Mass not 'said on a portible altar by a privilage which is merely personal'. [/quote] Where'd you get that idea, that a Mass on a portable altar can't fulfill one's Sunday obligation?
cmotherofpirl Posted February 6, 2007 Posted February 6, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1185776' date='Feb 5 2007, 09:12 PM'] Read post number seven. [/quote] Would it ever occur to you that we are a bit past the Council of Trent? just a bit?
Theoketos Posted February 6, 2007 Posted February 6, 2007 Let me put it simply. An Invalid mass would not fulfill the obligation, an illicit mass would. Let us remember how St. Francis De Sales said that he would recieve the eucharist from a priest with hookers on the altar.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now