Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have a question about Catholicism and how it relates the everything secular.

As Catholics, is it "wrong" to partake in secular activities or indulge in secular items?
Stuff like reading secular books, listening to secular music, or watching secular movies and TV shows.

Just curious how people feel about these things. Thanks.

Posted (edited)

There is a whole lot more freedom in those areas than before Vatican 2.

The answer is basically that you are allowed to do anything except sin.

If you read a bunch of examinations of conscience, you will think most everything on tv is not permitted. Especially the sexual stuff. Funny stuff comes in 2nd, seems to me.

P.S. Edit - I really did not want to sound that cynical. But my view is very close to how I said it.

Edited by Paddington
Posted

According to the Church, while some of what the secular world has to offer is sinful and/or will likely lead one to sin (pornography, Atheism, and unjust political movements, for instance), not everything secular is bad. There is nothing wrong, in general, with partaking in and even enjoying secular books, music, TV, etc. In fact, the lay faithful is called to engage the secular world in a real way -- to be a part of it -- so that we might be witnesses for the faith in it. How can we reach out to the secular world if we don't know what is going on in it, what its thinking is -- good and bad -- on the issues and problems of the world, etcetera? (Note: In Catholicism, being a "witness" in the world does not mean knocking on doors and preaching on street corners, but very often the simple act of living ones life as a true Christian in the world: letting our Spirit-given light and our deeds speak for us. Treating people as Christ did, behaving as Christ did.)

The thing is to not get lost in the secular world, and not forget who you are. To be [i]in[/i] it, but not [i]of[/i] it.

Posted

not sure what you mean to say about the pre-Vatican II Church; a time when Catholics clearly enjoyed many secular things without guilt.

There is nothing wrong with enjoying secular things. It just depends on what those secular things are. Immoral things cannot be enjoyed.

But secular things, ie things which do not necessarily pertain to God, are perfectly acceptable. The Church is not, nor has she ever been, puritan. Alcohol is good to enjoy to the point of hilarity; wholesome entertainment is okay to enjoy; if you can handle it without temptation peices of entertainment which may include some adult situations (as long as they are reasonably situational for the sake of the storyline) are okay.

There are sacred things, there are secular things, and then there are profane things. The first two categories are acceptable, the last is not.

I have never seen an examination of conscience that made me feel guilty for laughing at comedies or watching television... except this one that was written by a puritanical scrupulous kid I knew (but it didn't make me feel guilty, just sorry for him)

Puritanism does nothing but repress the good inclinations along with the bad until you explode and release both your good and bad desires. Repress your bad desires, focusing on letting them be converted in Christ; and enjoy (without letting them control you) your good desires.

Posted

[quote]There is a whole lot more freedom in those areas than before Vatican 2.[/quote]

It's exactly the same as it was before the Second Council of the Vatican.

[quote]Funny stuff comes in 2nd, seems to me.[/quote]
'funny stuff' is only a sin when it blapshemes or disrespects God, His Mother, the Saints, the Magisterium, the Sacraments etc.

[quote]I have never seen an examination of conscience that made me feel guilty for laughing at comedies or watching television... except this one that was written by a puritanical scrupulous kid I knew (but it didn't make me feel guilty, just sorry for him)[/quote]

I'm jw.... why would a non-ordianed person write an examination of concience? Oh also, what examination of concience do you usually use?

Posted

well intentioned adolescents often express their immature faith in many ways, some of which are innappropriate to their state in life. this particular boy felt he had a calling to the priesthood... listed under sins he put stuff like watching tv, smoking, drinking pop, drinking alcohol, et cetera... in addition to that he had a lot more rediculous ones that I cannot think of off hand.


I usually use different ones from my Latin Mass missals.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='SearchingForSomething' post='1184927' date='Feb 4 2007, 10:42 PM']
I have a question about Catholicism and how it relates the everything secular.

As Catholics, is it "wrong" to partake in secular activities or indulge in secular items?
Stuff like reading secular books, listening to secular music, or watching secular movies and TV shows.

Just curious how people feel about these things. Thanks.
[/quote]

St. Paul took part in philosophical debates with the Greeks, showing them how Christ was the fulfillment of their religion. Clearly, great faith and humility before God is needed to head into a battle like that, but I know in my experience that the secular world ultimately shows me why I need Christ and His Church, sometimes precisely because secular environments cause me to trip up and sin. Of course, that's no excuse to sin. Besides, it's not like any of us has to worry about becoming sinful people so we can be redeemed. :)

There something you'll find in an examination of conscience about "occasions of sin." If you know from experience that in certain situations you find that temptation is nearly overpowering, you need to avoid those situations in the future.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1185334' date='Feb 5 2007, 02:18 PM']
It's exactly the same as it was before the Second Council of the Vatican.
[/quote]

Index of Forbidden Books = gone.

I was thinking something about movies too. But I realized I didn't know what I was talking about. I'm sorry. If somebody could pipe in with insight about forbidden movies, that would be great. Maybe that is all just a rumor. Don't bother saying "porn isn't allowed." We all know that.

As far as what I actually remember reading in exams of conscience.
"Reading non-Catholic literature" 'non' not 'anti'.
I'm sure that it wasn't supposed to say that. Also some exams say "UNNECESSARILY reading anti-Catholic stuff." There are diction issues out there. That is why I need to learn more so I can't get deceived about it.
I've read other things that freaked me out. They were probably right tho, so I'm going to have to deal.
I've always liked religious humor, but I like to think that I only like it when it is respectful. Something like "I mean well, so it's okay." But I've read an exam of conscience that made it sound like nothing is permitted in this area. *shrug*

Edited by Paddington

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...