goldbug16 Posted February 9, 2007 Posted February 9, 2007 [quote name='littleflower+JMJ' post='1186418' date='Feb 6 2007, 03:49 PM'] This stuff IS awful, unsafe and will do NO good. It is NOT preventing anything and young girls should not be treated in such a way. Its ridiculous and wrong. I don't like it at all. [/quote] It is also basically saying that girls at that young age are bound to be sexually active.
exquisitebones Posted February 9, 2007 Posted February 9, 2007 first off, any parent can opt out of ANY vaccine they do not want their child to have. My son has had very few vaccines.. SECOND, as a person who HAS hpv, and the possiblity of cancer. I am monitored every few months to make sure it does not get worse. I think the vaccine is a good idea. And i know they are saying the vaccine against cervical cancer... but guess what. HPV is the ONLY way to get cervical cancer. so in a sense, YES it is a vaccine against the cancer. I wish i would have had the knowledge to not be a troubled teen who did terrible things, but i cant change that, even if I could, I wish i could have got that vaccine years ago. It would have saved me all the trouble i have now. [quote name='goldbug16' post='1188935' date='Feb 8 2007, 06:08 PM'] It is also basically saying that girls at that young age are bound to be sexually active. [/quote] HOw many people dont grow up to be sexually active? you are? are you not? this is to ensure that when they are OLDER and hopefully MARRIED, they have no risk of contracting it. you dont always get to marry virgins, while it would be AWESOME if we all could.. that is not always the case.
jmjtina Posted February 9, 2007 Posted February 9, 2007 (edited) First off, I am sorry to hear you have HPV. Know you are in my prayers. However, not all young girls should be mandated with this vaccine when there is not sufficient research on the long term effects of getting it so young. This vaccine should be voluntary. Instead of opting out, it should be availabe to opt in. from CatholicMom: "If a kid with measles is sitting in a classroom, he or she is going to infect many other classmates. A kid with HPV infects no one other than one she might have sex with," "We're not protecting the public health in the same way that we protect public health when we require measles vaccine." The point is, the state should not mandate this. This is not 100% effective either of cervical cancer. We should not treat this as a cure all for the cancer. It no more a sure proof vaccine against cancer any more than a condom is a sure way to prevent a pregnancy. Also note, HPV is not the only way to get cervical cancer. There is a greater possibility of you getting cervical cancer if you have HPV. Other causes are the birth control pill, smoking, poor diet, and others. Remember, these are factors, however small, that give you a greater possibility of getting cervical cancer. Some people have HPV and don't get cervical cancer. Some people do. This is a prevention of an STD and the bonus will decrease your chances of getting cervical cancer. Of course, widespread behavior modification, aka chastity, would do the same thing, but that's much harder for the state to do. Again, this is something the state should not mandate and parents should be educated on the risks of being vaccinated so young and the benefits of having the vaccine to decrease thier chance of the incidence of cervical cancer. It should never be mandated. Edited February 9, 2007 by jmjtina
exquisitebones Posted February 9, 2007 Posted February 9, 2007 (edited) i dont think any vaccine should be mandated. and yet.. most are. I think every person should have a right to chose vaccination.... that being said, I also think that behavior modification, would be GREAT and i am all for chastity until marriage.. Unfortunatly, at this point of time, in our world, its not gonna happen for everyone. that also being said, the statistics for HPV are INSANE... higher than ANY other STD.. HPV infects 75% of sexually active men and women in their lifetimes; that means that 3 out of 4 of your friends who are having sex will get it or already have it! There are currently 20 million people in the United States who have HPV and 5.5 million more get it every year -- - my best friend, my sister in law, my cousin, my aunt, ALL have it. I just think more PARENTS, should OPT to THINK about the benefits of the vaccine. I know I would LOVE to hope adn think my son, will grow up and marry and stay chaste... but who knows, I can not FORCE him to follow in that hope. I can not FORCE him not to have sex. I would like to hope that he will not contract a disease like this. EDITED TO ADD: sorry about saying it was the only way to get cervical cancer.. here is a accurate statistic: The human papillomavirus (HPV) is the cause of 93% of all cervical cancer cases. There are about 30 sexually transmitted strains of HPV. 13 of the 30 sexually transmitted strains of HPV are thought to cause cervical cancer. Edited February 9, 2007 by exquisitebones
jmjtina Posted February 9, 2007 Posted February 9, 2007 (edited) This prevents an STD. That is the primary. Although it decreases the chances of you getting cervical cancer, it is a secondary. There is not enough of a public health risk to mandate all young girls to recieve this vaccine. The chances of a chaste girl getting HPV is significantly lower than a girl who is sexually active. Routine pap smears will usually detect pre-cancerous or early cancerous changes so that treatment can be initiated in these early stages and full recovery is expected. HPV vaccine does not remove the need for continued pap smears. Bottom line, this is a decision that shouldn't be mandated by the state. A 9 year old is only a fourth grader or end of the year third grader. 9 years old. That is absolutely ridiculous. As far as stats go: 2. Even without the vaccine, the number of cervical cancer cases is trending downward and has been for years. (This is only true in the U.S.; worldwide it is one of the top cancer killers of women because women in many other countries have limited access to Pap tests and other health services.) The Gardasil commercials refer to "thousands of women" being diagnosed with cervical cancer in the U.S. each year, which is true, but they don't put that number into context. “Cervical cancer has gone from being one of the top killers of American women to not even being on the top 10 list. This year cervical cancer will represent just 1 percent of the 679,510 new cancer cases and 1 percent of the 273,560 anticipated cancer deaths among American women. By contrast, some 40,970 women will die of breast cancer and 72,130 will die of lung cancer. According to the American Cancer Society, "'Between 1955 and 1992, the number of cervical cancer deaths in the United States dropped by 74 percent.' Think about it: 74 percent.”[2] [2] link: [url="http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?sec=health&res=9E06E7DF163FF93BA25754C0A9609C8B63"]http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html...754C0A9609C8B63[/url] Edited February 9, 2007 by jmjtina
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted February 9, 2007 Posted February 9, 2007 By the govonor mandating this law, it gives the impression on young girls, "Oh, I have this vaccination, I can have sex all I want because I have this medicine; I won't have an STI/STD." NO!!!
Lil Red Posted February 9, 2007 Author Posted February 9, 2007 [quote name='jmjtina' post='1188876' date='Feb 8 2007, 05:21 PM']I know you posted the doc. jess, but that was way too good for even the lazy clickers.[/quote]lol, i know, but it's a long document [quote name='jmjtina' post='1188876' date='Feb 8 2007, 05:21 PM'][color="#FF0000"][b]What we instead DO know is that current practices of annual pap smears and screening for ALL bad strains of HPV continue to reduce rates of cervical cancer among the US population annually.[/b][/color] If all US women received a pap smear every year and were then promptly treated for any abnormal growths encountered, both the cervical cancer contraction and mortality rates would plummet even further to the point where HPV-associated cervical cancer would kill no more than a handful of US women a year. Yes, that is a guess as well, but it's a far better guess than assuming that conferring protection against four of the myriad of current and future strains of harmful HPV will somehow do the trick.[/quote] what i would like to know is why aren't 'they' promoting annual Pap smears and screening for women more heavily if that's how it is caught early and treated early?
XIX Posted February 10, 2007 Posted February 10, 2007 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1186496' date='Feb 6 2007, 05:09 PM'] my concern is truly on the science and politics behind this - really not on the religious aspect. if you look at the document i provided, it goes into greater detail. [/quote] Okay. Fair enough. But I think what really set me off is the comparision between the vaccination and birth control. Saying they are no different. I have dedicated my life to contributing to the end of birth control (among other things) can not understand how the two are identical. I think it's kinda annoying that this is being touted as something we need to have, but I don't understand this huge uproar.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted February 10, 2007 Posted February 10, 2007 This vaccine will cost about 350,000 families 350 dollars for the three shots. I'm sorry though...that is ridiculous. I guess it just comes to the moral issue of age and also it can harm their health. It violates private family life it should be the option of the parents, not a requirement. It's also the parents responsibility to teach their child many things...
XIX Posted February 10, 2007 Posted February 10, 2007 I agree that the mandate itself is a little over the top. Especially since they are forcing you to pay for the whole thing.
jmjtina Posted February 10, 2007 Posted February 10, 2007 (edited) [quote name='XIX' post='1190376' date='Feb 9 2007, 09:55 PM'] Okay. Fair enough. But I think what really set me off is the comparision between the vaccination and birth control. Saying they are no different. I have dedicated my life to contributing to the end of birth control (among other things) can not understand how the two are identical. I think it's kinda annoying that this is being touted as something we need to have, but I don't understand this huge uproar. [/quote] If you've dedicated your life to end birth control, the similarities between this shot (which is a primary for a sexually transmitted disease NOT the cancer) should be clear. The huge uproar is this: girls as young as 9 years old will be mandated by the state to have this. The fact that this is a shot for those sexually active, to stop an STD, and the media etc have touted it as if it is for cancer. We do not know the long term effects this may have on 9 year olds. This is a FAMILY decision!!! Birth control: Will stop you from being pregnant. (hidden lie: will cause an early abortion i.e. is an abortificient meaning that women ARE becoming pregnant but are losing the baby before they even know it. Also, not a guareentee that you will NOT be pregnant) "Cervical Cancer Shot" : will stop you from getting this cancer. ( hidden lie: will only decrease your chances of getting this cancer which are horribly greater for those who are sexually active but the primary for this shot is to stop an STD. Secondary: is for the "chances" of getting this cancer. You may get it. [b]To effectively catch this cancer in time, a PAP smear is required. [/b] Also, no long term study has been done to see the long term effects of this shot on girls who have not reached puberty yet. Similarties: both are lies. Both have to do with being sexually active. Both are being pushed on us as "good" things and both are now (or will be) readily available. Bottom line: The state has no buisness mandating this. This should be a choice between the family where they opt in, instead of opting out. Edited February 10, 2007 by jmjtina
Akalyte Posted February 10, 2007 Posted February 10, 2007 From what I understand a person can get HPV just by touching...This is very serious.
jmjtina Posted February 10, 2007 Posted February 10, 2007 (edited) There are many different types of HPV. Many women contract HPV and their healthy immune system clears it without any consequences. The HPV vaccine addresses only the 4 subtypes that are associated with cervical cancer--6,11,16, and 18 with types 16 and 18 accounting for 70% of the associated cervical cancer. The vaccine targets these subtypes of HPV that are linked to cancer. Non-cancer causing HPV is linked to venereal warts and the vaccine does nothing to prevent those. If you get the vaccine you still have to get pap smears. The vaccine increases your odds that your pap smears will always be normal. The touching you are referring to is probably linked to the non-cancerous type. Also, you need to touch an infected area which requires you to take your clothes off or touching visible warts on the skin. Edited February 10, 2007 by jmjtina
Lil Red Posted February 12, 2007 Author Posted February 12, 2007 More information courtesy of Julie at Happy Catholic: [b]In medical cost vs. benefit modeling[/b] (which strongly informs national medical public policy making and far too strongly informs the medical policies of HMOs), [b]the most critical component is a value called "cost per life year gained."[/b] [color="#FF0000"]If the cost per life year gained is [size=5]under $50,000[/size], that is generally considered a decent investment by US medical policy makers.[/color][b] If "cost per life year" gained is over $100,000, that is generally considered a wasteful medical policy[/b] because that money could surely be put to much better use elsewhere. Yes, this is cruel and heartless to some degree, but wide scale medical cost allocations do need to be made and, more relevantly, are continually made using these cost plus risk vs. benefit analyses. Think HMOs. [color="#FF0000"]Now consider why pap smears, blood tests and urine tests aren't recommended every month for everyone.[/color] Testing monthly could definitely save more than a few lives, and there is no measurable associated medical risk. But the cost would be astronomical versus the benefit over the entire US population when comparing these monthly tests to other therapies, procedures and medicines. Now on to GARDASIL. By the time you pay doctors a small fee to inventory and deliver GARDASIL in three doses, you are talking about paying about $500 for this vaccine. [b]And because even in the best case scenario GARDASIL can confer protection against only 70% of cervical cancer cases, GARDASIL cannot ever obsolete the HPV screening test that today is a major component of most US women's annually recommended pap smears.[/b] These tests screen for 36 nasty strains of HPV, while GARDASIL confers protection against just four strains of HPV. Now let's consider GARDASIL's best case scenario at the moment -- about $500 per vaccine, 100% lifetime protection against all four HPV strains (we currently have no evidence for any protection over five years), and no risk of any medical complications for any subset of the population (Merck's GARADSIL studies were too small and short to make this determination for adults, these studies used potentially dangerous alum injections as their "placebo control" and GARDASIL was hardly even tested on little kids). Now, using these best case scenario assumptions for GARDASIL, let's compare the projected situation of a woman who gets a yearly HPV screening test starting at age 18 to a woman who gets a yearly HPV screening test starting at age 18 plus the three GARDASIL injections at age 11 to 12. Even if you include all of the potential medical cost savings from the projected reduction in genital wart and HPV dysplasia removal procedures and expensive cervical cancer procedures, medicines and therapies plus all of the indirect medical costs associated with all these ailments and net all of these savings against GARDASIL's costs, [color="#FF0000"]the best case numbers for these analyses come out to [size=5]well over $200,000[/size] per life year gained -- no matter how far the hopeful pro-GARDASIL assumptions that underpin these projections are tweaked in GARDASIL's favor.[/color] Several studies have been done, and they have been published in several prestigious medical journals: [color="#000099"]http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/jama.290.6.781 [url="http://tinyurl.com/2ovy95"]http://tinyurl.com/2ovy95[/url] [url="http://tinyurl.com/2tbuma"]http://tinyurl.com/2tbuma[/url][/color] None of these studies even so much as consider a strategy of GARDASIL plus a regimen of annual HPV screenings starting at age 18 to be worth mentioning (except to note how ridiculously expensive this would be compared to other currently recommended life extending procedures, medicines and therapies) because the cost per life year gained is simply far too high. What these studies instead show is that a regimen of GARDASIL plus delayed (to age 21, 22, 23, 25 or 27) biennial or triennial HPV screening tests may -- depending on what hopeful assumptions about GARDASIL's long term efficacy and risks are used -- hopefully result in a modest cost per life year savings compared to annual HPV screening tests starting at age 18. If you don't believe me about this, just ask any responsible OB-GYN or medical model expert. Now, why do I think all of this is problematic? [b]1) Nobody is coming clean[/b] (except to the small segment of the US population that understands medical modeling) [b]that the push for widespread mandatory HPV vaccination is based on assuming[/b] that we can use the partial protection against cervical cancer that these vaccines hopefully confer for hopefully a long, long time period to back off from recommending annual HPV screening tests starting at age 18 -- in order to save money, not lives. [b]2) Even in the best case scenario, the net effect is to give billions in tax dollars to Merck so HMOs and PPOs can save billions on HPV screening tests in the future.[/b] [b]3) These studies don't consider any potential costs associated with any potential GARDASIL risks. [/b]Even the slightest direct or indirect medical costs associated with any potential GARDASIL risks increase the cost per life year gained TREMENDOUSLY and can even easily change the entire analysis to cost per life year lost. Remember that unlike most medicines and therapies, vaccines are administered to a huge number of otherwise healthy people -- and, at least in this case, 99.99% of whom would never contract cervical cancer even without its protection. [b]4) These studies don't take in account the fact that better and more regular HPV screening tests have reduced the US cervical cancer rate by about 25% a decade over the last three decades[/b] and that there is no reason to believe that this trend would not continue in the future, especially if we used a small portion of the money we are planning on spending on GARDASIL to promote free annual HPV screening tests for all low income uninsured US women. [b]5) The studies assume that any constant cervical cancer death rate[/b] (rather than the downward trending cervical cancer death rate we have today)[b] that results in a reduced cost per life year gained equates to sound medical public policy.[/b] As I said before, if any of you don't believe me about this, please simply ask your OB-GYN how the $500 cost of GARDASIL can be justified on a cost per life year gained basis if we don't delay the onset of HPV screening tests and back off from annual HPV screening tests to biennial or triennial HPV screening tests. The recommendations are already in:[color="#000099"] [url="http://tinyurl.com/33p9q6"]http://tinyurl.com/33p9q6[/url][/color] [i]The USPSTF strongly recommends ... beginning screening within 3 years of onset of sexual activity or age 21 (whichever comes first) and screening at least every 3 years ...[/i]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now