Paddington Posted February 7, 2007 Posted February 7, 2007 What's the difference in your opinion? How do you strive for repentance? Is repentance ever not good enough for the salvation of non-Catholics? So...please share. Thanks
Nathan Posted February 7, 2007 Posted February 7, 2007 (1) In my way basic understanding -- this will likely be redundant -- repentance takes place in the confessional; penance takes place afterward. Repentance is the act of confessing our sins; penance, prescribed by the priest, is as an act of restitution, a way of showing our sorrow for having sinned and also a way to help us in our spiritual journey to not sin again. (2) I strive for repentance by making examinations of conscience and receiving the Sacrament of Reconciliation (Confession) very frequently. (3) I suppose you mean saying the "Jesus prayer" alone on ones bed, for instance, and whether or not one is truly forgiven through such an act. I would have to say that they are [i]not[/i] forgiven, or what is the Sacrament of Reconciliation as insituted by Christ's Church for? This is a tough reality, but let us never forget that Protestantism is fundamentally a heresy: a rejection of the true Christian faith, Christ's Church, and through them, the Lord Jesus Christ Himself. As for ultimate Salvation, only God knows.
goldenchild17 Posted February 7, 2007 Posted February 7, 2007 Repentance is being truly sorry for your sins and truly seeking forgiveness. Penance is what you do to show that your repentance is genuine.
Paddington Posted February 8, 2007 Author Posted February 8, 2007 [quote name='Nathan' post='1187317' date='Feb 7 2007, 10:54 AM'] (3) I suppose you mean saying the "Jesus prayer" alone on ones bed, for instance, and whether or not one is truly forgiven through such an act. I would have to say that they are [i]not[/i] forgiven, or what is the Sacrament of Reconciliation as insituted by Christ's Church for? [/quote] Thanks for being blunt. I'm still not convinced that is the Catholic answer.
LouisvilleFan Posted February 8, 2007 Posted February 8, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Paddington' post='1187290' date='Feb 7 2007, 04:39 AM'] What's the difference in your opinion? How do you strive for repentance? Is repentance ever not good enough for the salvation of non-Catholics? So...please share. Thanks [/quote] [quote name='Nathan' post='1187317' date='Feb 7 2007, 08:24 AM'] (3) I suppose you mean saying the "Jesus prayer" alone on ones bed, for instance, and whether or not one is truly forgiven through such an act. I would have to say that they are [i]not[/i] forgiven, or what is the Sacrament of Reconciliation as insituted by Christ's Church for? This is a tough reality, but let us never forget that Protestantism is fundamentally a heresy: a rejection of the true Christian faith, Christ's Church, and through them, the Lord Jesus Christ Himself. As for ultimate Salvation, only God knows. [/quote] [quote name='Paddington' post='1188171' date='Feb 8 2007, 01:39 AM'] Thanks for being blunt. I'm still not convinced that is the Catholic answer. [/quote] I think Nathan did provide the "Catholic" answer since the Church does teach that the sacrament of Reconciliation is the normal way in which we are reconciled to God and the Church. However, the Church also teaches that God isn't a slave to the seven sacraments. Therefore, I believe that any act of confession, whether in a private prayer to God or to another person yields some measure of grace since it is an act of humility. Why would Christ give us the sacrament of Confession? For one, it's far more beneficial than any other act of repentance, but is also provides us with final closure and redemption from specific sins, allows us to hear Jesus' words through a priest, and because in a sacrament we can't withhold sins or lie without lying directly to God (the major weakness of Protestant "accountability groups" is that it's so easy to withhold the truth because, while it's a sin to do so, it's not a direct affront to God). I'm not really sure how to describe Penance... it's definitely not an act of punishment as many non-Catholics misunderstand it, but more like a corrective action or a loving response to God's grace. hmm... I like that And I don't know what is or isn't good enough for the salvation of non-Catholics... I guess for most, since they are following what they've been taught, any sincere act of repentance is good enough to receive the grace of forgiveness. But I don't like to speculate into who will or will not be saved. After all, I hope all are saved because I know my worthiness comes from Christ and Christ alone. Edited February 8, 2007 by LouisvilleFan
LouisvilleFan Posted February 14, 2007 Posted February 14, 2007 I had an after-thought to this... I've was thinking about penance a little more, trying to fit the "loving response to God's grace" definition with the fact that it's a mandatory thing and absolution depends upon performing the penance. But then I remembered the virtue of even the simplest acts of obedience. See, last year I heard an awesome talk by an exorcist about the powers of angels and demons and how they relate to our world, how people come under their influence, etc. He talked about different ways people can become possessed and one of them is direct, purposeful disobedience to the Church. For example, if he were to attempt an exorcism anywhere outside of his bishop's diocese without the permission of the bishop of that respective diocese, he could actually become possessed. After all, he's openly disobeying the Church, which is also disobedience to Christ, and how can someone consciously disobey Christ while calling upon His name to expel a demon? That's an extreme example, but it shows the power of obedience to the Church to fight evil. When a priest gives you a penance, even one of those easy "pray three Hail Mary's," he gives that penance under his bishop's authority, and the bishop presides under the Church's authority, and the Church exists under Christ's authority. Therefore, performing your penance is a simple act of obedience to none other than Christ and it is through that act of obedience that we successfully fight Satan and all demonic powers and temptations.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now