Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Blessed Are The Pure In Heart.


Recommended Posts

Posted

Matthew 5 tells us "Blessed are the pure in heart, for they shall see God. " .
So I wonder what some of these who believe Once Saved always saved would say if you asked them "are you pure in heart"?
Also worth some thinking regarding purgatory.

Catch my drift?

Thoughts.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

"My heart is made pure through Christ's Blood, when he said on the cross, 'It is finished,' which means I shouldn't suffer for my sins. After all, my suffering would be to no avail because only Christ is the worthy sacrifice."

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

They might. That is the sort of answer that I somewhat expected but tthis verse seem to indicate real purity of heart rather than snow covered dung purity of heart:

1 Tim 1
5: whereas the aim of our charge is love that issues from a pure heart and a good conscience and sincere faith. Most undoudtedly he goes through both physical an spiritual suffering.

As for suffering for sins one cannot tell me the alcoholic who has lost all he has and destroyed his family and his health does not suffere for his sins, though he may be born again or in a state of grace.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

The other question I have with regard to your answer is, does the negation of the one beatitude, mean that the other 8 are not neccessary explicityly either? That we don't have to take care of the widow and the orphan explicitly? God hides our lack of charity toward others and our impure hearts rather than makes them really pure?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1188736' date='Feb 8 2007, 05:49 PM']
As for suffering for sins one cannot tell me the alcoholic who has lost all he has and destroyed his family and his health does not suffere for his sins, though he may be born again or in a state of grace.
[/quote]

True, but an evangelical would make a distinction between suffering from the consequences of our sins and suffering for the sake of our eternal redemption.

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1188832' date='Feb 8 2007, 07:37 PM']
The other question I have with regard to your answer is, does the negation of the one beatitude, mean that the other 8 are not neccessary explicityly either? That we don't have to take care of the widow and the orphan explicitly? God hides our lack of charity toward others and our impure hearts rather than makes them really pure?
[/quote]

Well, my answer didn't negate the beattitude about having a pure heart. I think they would acknowledge that with time Christ changes our hearts and makes them more pure. Honestly, do we as Catholics have pure hearts? If we do, why do we need Confession? Perhaps what is intended by that verse is having an innocent or sincere heart that yearns for God.

Coming from that side of Christianity myself, I know it takes a whole change in perspective to become Catholic. In a lot of ways, Catholics speak a different language. Protestants don't understand how the physicial and spiritual world can be so intimately connected that bread and wine can become the true Body and Blood of Christ or that Baptism and Confession actually forgives sins. So there are a lot of hurdles. You know, I think most of your average Protestants are simply looking for beauty and love. Theology isn't all that important. I feel that too many Catholic apologists prioritize theology over the beauty and love in our faith. I've been trying to seek what is beautiful about Catholicism and the sacraments and that's what I'd really like to share.

Posted (edited)

[quote]Honestly, do we as Catholics have pure hearts?[/quote]

Did I say we did? That is a part of the point. We grow in sanctifying grace. If that is not complete by the end of life then purgatory is a logical conclusion.

[quote]Theology isn't all that important.[/quote]

This is indifferentism which was condemned by JP II in Dominus Iesus.
How can you say theology is not important. The Eucharist is important! Confirmation is important! The priesthood is important! The papacy is in fact important. Devotion to our lady is important. They reject these things. The truth is what sets us free. It is all important and it is quite beautiful.

[quote] I feel that too many Catholic apologists prioritize theology over the beauty and love in our faith. [/quote]

This seems to be what you are accusing me of because I am trying to look at a point of apologetics from a different angle again. If you don't like apologetics stay off this board because that is what it is for.
Apologetic discussions do not neccessitate that we forget love. WE MUST NOT. There is a danger in this with apolgetics. But that does not mean that we cannot develope apologetic arguements. Share the beauty of the faith. I applaud that. But your sweeping the differences under the rug is not beneficial to protestants.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

I guess that blessedness and forgiveness can be separated in theology.

The whole "snow on a dunghill" thing in Protestant soteriology is more about conversion than post-conversion life. Not that I'm an expert on it.

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1188721' date='Feb 8 2007, 04:37 PM']
"My heart is made pure through Christ's Blood, when he said on the cross, 'It is finished,' which means I shouldn't suffer for my sins. After all, my suffering would be to no avail because only Christ is the worthy sacrifice."
[/quote]

But that's inconsistent w/ Jesus repeatedly saying "Take up your cross and follow me."

Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1189318' date='Feb 9 2007, 01:00 AM']
I guess that blessedness and forgiveness can be separated in theology.

The whole "snow on a dunghill" thing in Protestant soteriology is more about conversion than post-conversion life. Not that I'm an expert on it.
[/quote]

The problem with separating the two as they do is that the other part, the sanctification does have to happen. Therein lies the inconsistency. Of course we are "saved" when we become born again. But if you are not truly pure at heart. If you are not truly righteous then you cannot enter heaven. There is a severe disconect here is my point. I understand that they separate justification and sanctification. That's fine. But the sanctification part is kinda swept under the rug if it is not completed by the end of life.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1189009' date='Feb 8 2007, 09:41 PM']
Did I say we did? That is a part of the point. We grow in sanctifying grace. If that is not complete by the end of life then purgatory is a logical conclusion.[/quote]

And a Protestant will agree with you, except for the Purgatory part. I think they effectively do believe in Purgatory because they believe we are purified of all sin at or after death, before entering Heaven. But they won't acknowledge Purgatory because they are convinced it is a punishment and a way of paying for sins, hence making the cross insufficient.

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1189009' date='Feb 8 2007, 09:41 PM']
This is indifferentism which was condemned by JP II in Dominus Iesus.
How can you say theology is not important. The Eucharist is important! Confirmation is important! The priesthood is important! The papacy is in fact important. Devotion to our lady is important. They reject these things. The truth is what sets us free. It is all important and it is quite beautiful.
This seems to be what you are accusing me of because I am trying to look at a point of apologetics from a different angle again. If you don't like apologetics stay off this board because that is what it is for.
Apologetic discussions do not neccessitate that we forget love. WE MUST NOT. There is a danger in this with apolgetics. But that does not mean that we cannot develope apologetic arguements. Share the beauty of the faith. I applaud that. But your sweeping the differences under the rug is not beneficial to protestants.
[/quote]

I agree that theology is important, but it's not important to most Protestant laypeople, even those who are sincere about their faith. There's a tendency that as long as you believe in Jesus, that he is God, died and was raised (and the other basics of Christianity), the other stuff about sacraments, priesthood, the papacy, and Mary are not worth bickering over. Basically, they'll say, "I'm glad you have a sincere faith and found your church home, but the Catholic Church isn't for me."

That's why I think new, creative approaches to apologetics are needed, so I'm glad your searching for that. I'm just sharing from my own experience, the responses I've heard when sharing my Catholic faith and the things I've noticed about how my non-Catholic friends approach their relationship with God. But don't let me say for sure what will or will not work... that all just depends on the individual and how God tugs on their heart at the time.

I think you could quote Scripture and the Church Fathers all day, but it won't resonate with most people. I once had my roommate read part of St. Ignatius' letter about desiring to have his flesh chewed by the lions to become the wheat of God and he thought it was all symbolic (that is, no reference to the Eucharist at all). And Protestants approach the Bible almost like it's a catechism because they look for things to be spelled out. If it's not spelled out, you don't have to believe it. Of course, Scripture doesn't work like that because it's more like a love letter from God to us (or a series of letters written over thousands of years).

So I don't intend to sweep differences under the rug, but we need to begin from that perspective because our audience does sweep theological differences under the rug. This is why there are so many non-denominational and independent churches and why mainline Protestantism is half the size it was three decades ago. Like Paul preaching to the Greeks about their unnamed god, we have to start with where they are at and lead them to discover what's missing. I know you aren't tossing the love and beauty of Catholicism aside. The challenge is that most Protestants don't see beauty and love in the traditional approach to Catholic apologetics (that is, referencing the Scripture and early Church for every doctrine). They just see rules, laws, and a lot of religion that restricts a living relationship with God.

Just as an aside, let me say that I haven't yet found a Protestant who could give an answer to miracles that specifically testify to Catholic teaching. Introduce them to Our Lady of Guadalupe, Lourdes, Eucharistic miracles, accounts of physical healing resulting from Anointing or Reconciliation, and stuff like that and you'll probably get 'em thinking.

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1189662' date='Feb 9 2007, 05:20 PM']
Just as an aside, let me say that I haven't yet found a Protestant who could give an answer to miracles that specifically testify to Catholic teaching. Introduce them to Our Lady of Guadalupe, Lourdes, Eucharistic miracles, accounts of physical healing resulting from Anointing or Reconciliation, and stuff like that and you'll probably get 'em thinking.
[/quote]

Fatima has kept my interest in Catholicism numerous times when I have thought "what's the point of even studying it anymore?"

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...