Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Why are sedevacantists silenced on PM?


Recommended Posts

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Rod' post='1188530' date='Feb 8 2007, 03:24 PM']
Come on .... don't hold back ... let it out..
[/quote]
Sorry, I can't. The obsession with silencing my thoughts, no doubt fueled by the sadly misunderstood post like the one following yours, has kept me quiet in all the fun topics the last few months. It's okay though, if my faith gets special treatment from all the rest then it gives me strength, shows me it has something no other faith has. Mine is the only faith on here that is not allowed to discuss our faith. No idea why, but I've kept quiet thus far, no need to start being a jerk and breaking the rules now :). I've almost decided that I don't think I would even want to debate my faith here anyways. There are so very few people that would know enough to even engage in discussion, again as evidenced by the post following yours.

Edited by goldenchild17
goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1188955' date='Feb 8 2007, 09:17 PM']
As was spoken in the letter of titus:

Titus, chapter 1


11: they must be silenced, since they are upsetting whole families by teaching for base gain what they have no right to teach.
Seems we have accomplished that quite well with one who is in schism on this board. Praise God! He's seems to be playing the persecuted martyr card now.
[/quote]


[quote name='Socrates' post='1189030' date='Feb 8 2007, 09:57 PM']
The whiny crybaby card is more like it. :ohno:
[/quote]

you guys are fun :). It's resorted to names now hmm? Honestly I used to think you were above all that. But if you're going to do it, at least come up with some fun names. These are boring :D:. It's all good :). All I was pointing out is that there is apparently something different about my faith than all the others because mine is the only one not allowed here. The protestants are, the athiests are, anyone but mine. Apparently my faith is the only one that can upset the "whole family". Either that means my faith is the only one that has a strong argument. Or else all the other non-Catholic faiths are actually a part of your church and thus are in the truth and do not have to be silenced as a result. I would argue that both are true, but I suspect you would only want to pick one. As it stands I'm gonna keep playin' by the rules. But I would suspect that you guys would want to re-examine your stance that consequently puts my faith on a pedestal above all the others.

Essentially if this is what it's going to come down to I don't think I would be all that interested in discussing my points here. Aside from a select few whom I still respect greatly for their charity and scholarship, I'm starting to see these qualities dropping significantly and discussing with people under these circumstances can only lead to bad results.

One more thing right quick :). Why would I play the "martyr card"? Why wouldn't I just leave and concentrate my efforts elsewhere? I'm not on any other "catholic" boards at this point. Just this one. And it's only because of those few people whom I still have enough respect for to want to come and get their insights on things and care enough for to have such people engage in some discussions that could essentially bring me back home to your church. But apparently evangelism to schismatics is not something you guys care about. Maybe we're not worthy of being saved. Maybe schism is the unpardonable sin Scripture refers to from which no one can come away from.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

What is your faith anyways? I just came back to phatmass just several months ago, so I dont know exactly what all the 'do not rep' members believe. (Urib and truthseeker however are obvious).

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

Yeah, those too make themselves pretty clear don't they :D:. To your question, I'm Catholic ;) (which incidently is the controversy in a nutshell). But this thread isn't about me. Time to get back on subject. Continue ya'll :).

Edited by goldenchild17
littleflower+JMJ
Posted

he says it in his last paragraph, schism. He's separated brethan.

[i]From the "Everything about the Phorum" Thread:[/i]
Separated Brethren- Those claiming Catholicism who have show an unwillingness to submit to the full authority of the Church. Will be tagged with a "I do not rep the Church" icon.


edited since this post is split now....

Posted

I regret that we have to resort to personal attacks when in these discussions. It lowers the tone and the spirit of the discussions and would - in MHO be better to have a resopectable discussion without lowering the level to that of insults and cheap jibes. This is not to say I support 'their' interpretation of the 'Church' it is a matter of allowing the discussion to proceed without it becoming personal.

Posted

No goldenchild, you are a trad. A member of an excommunicated schismatic sect and that is important for people to know. Out of love for those who may unwittingly be influenced by your devient religion, that poses as faithful Catholic I MUST notify those who are unaware of your leanings that you are not orthodox. I say what I say to you in chairty for those who are unaware. You should be silenced. for you had the grace of the Eucharist and still turned your back on the fullness of the truth. I am not going to make exuses for that for you. Further for your benefit I must give you no quarter. If that is personal then so be it. Paul said what he said for people like you. You should be silenced. Not only should but must for you have no business claiming to be Catholic and saying what you say. We can understand protestants. They don't claim to be Catholic (which you did above). sad.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

mmm, so being noncatholic and admitting to it makes it all better. Got it. It is quite apparent that I'm not orthodox according to your means based on my title. There should be nothing more to it and efforts concentrated to evangelization. But I now see that evangelization is not your interest here. Which is fine, I mean if you don't want us back in your church then I can't imagine that it is much of a church to wish to belong to.

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1189222' date='Feb 9 2007, 12:27 AM']
So if you use a compass are you a mason? :lol:
[/quote]
:D:

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1189533' date='Feb 9 2007, 11:50 AM']Paul said what he said for people like you.
[/quote]

Oh okay, and I suppose he didn't have in mind any other non-catholic faith of any kind right? I don't think so. Fact is, you guys entertain discussion from all other faiths, simply not mine. And I know there is a reason for it. What is that reason? Do you fear the strength of the argument? I doubt you would admit to this so it must be something else? What separates us from the other noncatholic faiths that make us ineligible for conversion?

But seriouslyt now ya'll, probably you should get back to talking about the Masons. That's what the threads about.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1189541' date='Feb 9 2007, 06:31 PM']
mmm, so being noncatholic and admitting to it makes it all better. Got it. It is quite apparent that I'm not orthodox according to your means based on my title. There should be nothing more to it and efforts concentrated to evangelization. But I now see that evangelization is not your interest here. Which is fine, I mean if you don't want us back in your church then I can't imagine that it is much of a church to wish to belong to.
:D:
Oh okay, and I suppose he didn't have in mind any other non-catholic faith of any kind right? I don't think so. Fact is, you guys entertain discussion from all other faiths, simply not mine. And I know there is a reason for it. What is that reason? Do you fear the strength of the argument? I doubt you would admit to this so it must be something else? What separates us from the other noncatholic faiths that make us ineligible for conversion?

But seriouslyt now ya'll, probably you should get back to talking about the Masons. That's what the threads about.
[/quote]

It has nothing to do with not wanting to evangelize those in schism, but of avoiding confusion for all others, Catholic or not. You are just as eligible for conversion as anyone else. Neither does it have anything to do with strength of arguement. You flatter yourself.

You ask what separates you from the other noncatholic faiths? I think you know. Other noncatholic faiths make no claim to be the one, true, Catholic Church. It is the same reason why impostors of any other sort can cause so much damage. If I pretended to be a doctor, dressed up as a doctor, even knew some medical terminology and went to a hospital and told them I was working there temporarily - they would be much more adamant about making me leave than other visitors at the hospital, wouldn't they?

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='morostheos' post='1189630' date='Feb 9 2007, 02:32 PM']
It has nothing to do with not wanting to evangelize those in schism, but of avoiding confusion for all others, Catholic or not. You are just as eligible for conversion as anyone else. Neither does it have anything to do with strength of arguement. You flatter yourself. [/quote]

No see it's not quite this way. If you (referring to the board in general) really wanted to evangelize us then you would allow such discussion instead of banning it under the guise of "catholic vs. catholic" debate, which isn't allowed. Interestingly I fall under the category of "catholic vs. catholic" debate, and yet, I am not a Catholic according to your standards. So it ends up as a double standard. I can understand the policy for those who argue voraciously for things such as the indult or whatever and cause trouble this way. That is confusing for your church body. But if I am not, in actuality, a catholic then my case should be allowed open for discussion. I think the overgeneralization of the term "trads" referring to all people who prefer the Latin Mass etc. throws us into this boat, when actually we are a different church and thus have no bearing on the "catholic vs. catholic" debate prohibition.

[quote name='morostheos' post='1189630' date='Feb 9 2007, 02:32 PM']You ask what separates you from the other noncatholic faiths? I think you know. Other noncatholic faiths make no claim to be the one, true, Catholic Church. It is the same reason why impostors of any other sort can cause so much damage. If I pretended to be a doctor, dressed up as a doctor, even knew some medical terminology and went to a hospital and told them I was working there temporarily - they would be much more adamant about making me leave than other visitors at the hospital, wouldn't they
[/quote]

I don't really see the point though. What if that fake doctor was given a big sign that he had to carry around with him saying something to the effect of "I am not a real doctor" or better yet, "I do not rep this hospital." That would at the very least put some question into the mind of his "patients" as to his true identity. And such a thing has been done with me. I have been identified as someone who is not a true representative of your church. And I am glad for that. Just because we use the same name for our church does not mean that we are referring to the same church. This "sign" is needed. And it was given. So then, from there we can then move on and help me see my error, instead of ignoring and prohibiting the airing of my problem. How is that "doctor" ever going to come to realize that he is no doctor? Likely only through some sort of outside convincing, but in keeping with the accuracy of the example, the hospital in which he poses as a doctor simply ignores him and lets him continue in his error. They care nothing for his sickness but only deal with all the rest. How is that different than what is happening here?

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

Goldenchild, sedevacantism is a damnable heresy and you will lead souls to hell by seperating them from submissioin to the Roman Pontiff; as you yourself are already leading your own soul into hell with sedevacantism. I would not say such things about Lefebvre or the SSPX, but I will say such things about sedevacantism.

A forum is like a publishing company. The owner of it spends large amounts of money in order to publish things he hopes will affect the world positively as per his agenda. No one has the right to tell the publisher that he must publish their agenda. This phorum chooses to publish debates between Catholics and non-Catholics hoping to further the agenda of converting protestants et cetera. It is of no use to merely post good Catholic arguments; protestants can only be converted if they see the best of the best of their arguments also published in intellectual honesty.

We have no desire to deal with the damnable heresy of sedevacantism, however. Even the SSPX expells sedevacantists; and PhatMass silences them. It is a good thing to bash formal heretics in this manner; and make no mistake about it: a sedevacantist is a formal heretic (unless, perhaps, he was raised by one) because he is at the height of study into Catholic dogma and still refuses to submit to the Chair of Peter.

What is proper for a Catholic society to do to formal heretics when they threaten the faith? It is proper to execute such heretics as any modern state would execute a traitor.

This is an online Catholic society, and the best we can do to be faithful to the Tradition of the Church is to ostricize formal heretics and silence them on our medium of publication.

I would be less likely to silence you (though some mods would) if you were merely supported traditionalism. But you commit Treason and Formal Heresy against the Chair of St. Peter and as such do not deserve to have your opinions published on this medium.

Posted

[quote]sedevacantism[/quote]

OK, now after a quick side trip to Wiki I understand the arguement going on here. Thank you.

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1189718' date='Feb 9 2007, 09:17 PM']
How is that "doctor" ever going to come to realize that he is no doctor? Likely only through some sort of outside convincing, but in keeping with the accuracy of the example, the hospital in which he poses as a doctor simply ignores him and lets him continue in his error. They care nothing for his sickness but only deal with all the rest. How is that different than what is happening here?
[/quote]

Here's the thing - efforts are much more effective when they are focused - especially evangelization efforts. If your focus becomes too diffuse, nothing every gets done. Especially because apologetic dialogue with sedevacantists is very particular to them and has very little overlap your run-of-the-mill protestant/agnostic/etc. dialogue, those in charge of this phorum have chosen it as a forbidden topic. I was here when it wasn't forbidden, and I can tell you it also was very harmful to the charity of all involved.

Posted

Thread closed. There will be a thread in the debate phorum where Goldenchild and I will discuss sedevacantism.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...