Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

My Comment On Peta: Was It Rude?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Today I met someone who is a member of PETA and refuses to eat meat as she picked through food at a fundraiser.

I made a remark that instead of being concerned with the welfare of animals and eating animals, we should be concerned with the rights of human beings. The right to life, the right to food and shelter, the right to be happy. We must work for the oppressed. In the end when our lives end God isn't going to say, "What did you do to save the whales" He wil be asking, "When did you clothe the naked, feed the stranger, and visit the prisoner. When did you help the poor. For whatever you did for the least of my people you did for me. And whatever you didn't do for the my people you didn't do for me."

What do you think? Is it rude?

Let me know.

Thanks,

Edward

Posted

I didn't see anything rude about it. What you said was the truth!

Mary's servant
Posted

AMDG+JMJ
Nope, you were completely justified.
Remember Peter's vision in Acts 10 as well. " A voice said to him, "Get up, Peter. Slaughter and eat.""
Many of these PETA people who throw paint of people's clothes and have sex on street corners are the same people working to keep it legal to slaughter preborn children in their mothers' womb.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='the_rev' post='1192000' date='Feb 11 2007, 11:17 PM']
Today I met someone who is a member of PETA and refuses to eat meat as she picked through food at a fundraiser.

I made a remark that instead of being concerned with the welfare of animals and eating animals, we should be concerned with the rights of human beings. The right to life, the right to food and shelter, the right to be happy. We must work for the oppressed. In the end when our lives end God isn't going to say, "What did you do to save the whales" He wil be asking, "When did you clothe the naked, feed the stranger, and visit the prisoner. When did you help the poor. For whatever you did for the least of my people you did for me. And whatever you didn't do for the my people you didn't do for me."

What do you think? Is it rude?

Let me know.

Thanks,

Edward
[/quote]
Keep preaching the truth Rev :)

Posted

[quote name='the_rev' post='1192000' date='Feb 11 2007, 10:17 PM']
Today I met someone who is a member of PETA and refuses to eat meat as she picked through food at a fundraiser.

I made a remark that instead of being concerned with the welfare of animals and eating animals, we should be concerned with the rights of human beings. The right to life, the right to food and shelter, the right to be happy. We must work for the oppressed. In the end when our lives end God isn't going to say, "What did you do to save the whales" He wil be asking, "When did you clothe the naked, feed the stranger, and visit the prisoner. When did you help the poor. For whatever you did for the least of my people you did for me. And whatever you didn't do for the my people you didn't do for me."

What do you think? Is it rude?

Let me know.

Thanks,

Edward
[/quote]

+

Good stuff Rev. In a nearby town, there's a Planned Parenthood nextdoor to a "Humane Society". The irony drives me nuts!

Posted

The way in which those animals are killed is very very cruel compared to how others do it. They will hack and hack away at the animal while it is still alive. My grandmother and father would make sure the animal died a quick death instead of letting the poor thing suffer.

It's cool to worry about the welfare of animals for God did tell us to have dominion over them. If we rule over them, then we should rule justly and fairly, not crudely. She can help God's creatures great and small, from man kind, to our furry little friend.

Posted

[quote name='desertwoman' post='1192047' date='Feb 12 2007, 12:20 AM']
The way in which those animals are killed is very very cruel compared to how others do it. They will hack and hack away at the animal while it is still alive. My grandmother and father would make sure the animal died a quick death instead of letting the poor thing suffer.

It's cool to worry about the welfare of animals for God did tell us to have dominion over them. If we rule over them, then we should rule justly and fairly, not crudely. She can help God's creatures great and small, from man kind, to our furry little friend.
[/quote]

We are stewards of this Earth as well.

Posted

[quote name='the_rev' post='1192000' date='Feb 11 2007, 10:17 PM']
Today I met someone who is a member of PETA and refuses to eat meat as she picked through food at a fundraiser.

I made a remark that instead of being concerned with the welfare of animals and eating animals, we should be concerned with the rights of human beings. The right to life, the right to food and shelter, the right to be happy. We must work for the oppressed. In the end when our lives end God isn't going to say, "What did you do to save the whales" He wil be asking, "When did you clothe the naked, feed the stranger, and visit the prisoner. When did you help the poor. For whatever you did for the least of my people you did for me. And whatever you didn't do for the my people you didn't do for me."

What do you think? Is it rude?

Let me know.

Thanks,

Edward
[/quote]

How tactfully did you say this?

goldenchild17
Posted

We need to remember Francis of Assisi and know that we must care for the animals as well. But what you said is important.

Posted

It's important to not make it sound like a dichotomy.
Treating animals kindly is always good.
Of course it is completely lopsided to compare the importance of animals to humans.
I would still try to compliment PETA-types on their kindness to animals and never make any assumption about how they treat humans.
I would see what I could learn from them.
If they come out and say that they are into baby-killing and do not care about the poor and sick, etc.. THEN a mini-sermon would be in order.

Posted

[quote]Of course it is completely lopsided to compare the importance of animals to humans.
I would still try to compliment PETA-types on their kindness to animals and never make any assumption about how they treat humans.
I would see what I could learn from them.
If they come out and say that they are into baby-killing and do not care about the poor and sick, etc.. THEN a mini-sermon would be in order.[/quote]

I agree

Posted

[quote name='CatholicCid' post='1192049' date='Feb 12 2007, 02:22 AM']
We are stewards of this Earth as well.
[/quote]


Of course. Be fair and just rulers for all, not just one for God entrusted us to do so... yet we fail miserably.

Posted

That is true. Very true but does this person already support human rights from sperm to worm?

Posted

I certainly agree that we need to do our part as stewards of the earth to protect animals from unnecessary cruelty. But when the branch of PETA in Maine starts protesting lobster bakes, one becomes to view them less than favorably.




PETA = People Eating Tasty Animals......... :hehe:

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Nope, not rude. However, it's better pastorally to start off by commending the good another person does. Maybe you could have commended her care and concern for animals and then said that she takes it a little too far in some areas and then add that it's more important to take care of human causes.

It is rarely the case that someone is completely wrong.

...but no, not rude.

Posted

if you spoke with true charity---then no, not rude.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...