Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Parents Have No Right To Object To Gay Education


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

The simplest question of all is why in the hell is a public school, run by the state, even TEACHING children about marraige? People have to remember that marraige is not some secular, hippy, butterflies-in-the-stomach love fest. It is religious, first and foremost. If you take the religion out of marraige you have nothing. You want to feel commited and happy? two rings do not magically give these things to you. This secular perversion of one of the most holy acts humans have is a disgrace. The fairy tale guise of this book is an atrocity to history, marraige, and the real world. People say that it is discimatory to prevent something like this book be taught. This book is discrimiation by its very nature! It idealizes homosexual behavior by showing that traditional, hereosexual marraige [i]isnt right[/i]. Excuse me for my bluntness, but I will not stand for people who cry discrimination and turn around and do just that!

The real threat is where this is leading. Sure it's "harmless" (HA!) fairytales now. What about when they get into sex education. The same rules will most certainly apply. How do [i]you[/i] feel about your kids learning about sodomy in school. Do you want your kids to hear that it is "ok"? The situation here is grave. Kids are straight up being taught that sex is everything [i]except[/i] the creation of children. That marraige is nothing but a happy feeling. This is rediculous and inexcusable and every parent SHOULD take thier children out of public schools.

How is it that a group of people [i]who don't have children of their own[/i], have the right to dictate what [i]everyone else's child[/i] is taught to believe? And THEN claim that when we say "NO" that [i]we[/i] are being discrimatory...that WE are the one's pushing our beliefs on others!

No one should stand for this.

It has been said before, but it needs repeating, because i know it will come up. Violence against homosexuals [i]is[/i] wrong. It is wrong because violence against ANYONE is wrong. This lesson is [i]already[/i] taught in schools. It is taught everyday and in every class.

Edited by Sirklawd
Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1198166' date='Feb 17 2007, 02:31 PM']But hate is taught, and that is what I want changed. Crimes exist and we can't do anything about it, but hate crimes are different. Being targeted soley because you're a minority is wrong and no one should be taught that it is okay.

Discrimination hasn't been outlawed. One can still be fired or denied housing because of their sexual orientation.[/quote]
So, according to you, "hate" is taught in elementary schools, and 7-year-old kids need to read stories promoting homosexuality in order to prevent them from "hating"??

The whole concept of "hate crimes" legislation should be offensive to any American.
The law should punish criminal acts, not attempt to control interior thoughts such as "hate." The ramifications of "hate crime" legislation are downright Orwellian, and lead to such things as people being fined or arrested simply for voicing the morality of their religion. Bring in the "Thought Police"!

All violent crime ought to be prosecuted equally by law, regardless of the "sexual orientation" of the perp or victim.
All crime is "hate crime" - precious few violent crimes are committed out of love!

Should a criminal receive a lighter sentence for brutally murdering an eight-year-old girl than for brutally murdering a homosexual man??

All "hate crimes" laws would do is curb legitimate free speech, and give homosexuals and "minorities" preferred status under the law.

[quote]You have to pay taxes. Deal with it. They go to teaching kids and although you might not agree with everything that is taught I'm fairly sure we all agree that teaching everyone multiplication tables, English, and science is important. I'd pay for that no matter what because I know that some kids aren't as fortunate as I was and they can't afford a private education.[/quote]
Exactly, we have to pay taxes; therefore there is no reason why our hard-earned tax dollars should go towards teaching our children homosexualist propaganda, and other proselytizing contrary to our values!
The public schools should stick to multiplication tables, English, and science, not promoting homosexuality.

And (since we are so worried about preventing crimes), if someone dares suggest we teach kids the Ten Commandments - "though shalt not kill," "thou shalt not steal," etc. - the courts will immediately shut that down because that would be using public schools to "promote our religious values."

However, the courts have absolutely no problem insisting that public schools promote a homosexualist political agenda to second grade kids against their parents' wishes!

This should be extremely disturbing to any serious Christian, indeed to any American!

Proud2BCatholic139
Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1197243' date='Feb 16 2007, 07:48 PM']Or home-school! :)[/quote]

I definately want to home school until at least 6th grade because I am getting an elementary education degree, that is, if the homeschool system in 7 years is poopy.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1198507' date='Feb 17 2007, 06:09 PM']So, according to you, "hate" is taught in elementary schools, and 7-year-old kids need to read stories promoting homosexuality in order to prevent them from "hating"??

The whole concept of "hate crimes" legislation should be offensive to any American.
The law should punish criminal acts, not attempt to control interior thoughts such as "hate." The ramifications of "hate crime" legislation are downright Orwellian, and lead to such things as people being fined or arrested simply for voicing the morality of their religion. Bring in the "Thought Police"!

All violent crime ought to be prosecuted equally by law, regardless of the "sexual orientation" of the perp or victim.
All crime is "hate crime" - precious few violent crimes are committed out of love!

Should a criminal receive a lighter sentence for brutally murdering an eight-year-old girl than for brutally murdering a homosexual man??

All "hate crimes" laws would do is curb legitimate free speech, and give homosexuals and "minorities" preferred status under the law.[/quote]
I'm only addressing this portion of your post, nothing about the schools aspect of the discussion.

Since I'm in the middle of prepping for my criminal law midterm, I feel at least a little qualified to speak to your assertions that "the law should punish only criminal acts, not attempt to control interior thoughts such as 'hate'" and a couple of other statements which I'll reference later.

First, there are few crimes that do not by definition include both a thought/intent as well as an act. In criminal law this is called mens rea (guilty thought) and actus reus (guilty act). We recognize that there are varying degrees of these two things in almost every crime.

Now, I'm not aware of any crime that is solely a thought-based crime. You can hate your neighbor because he's black all you want while sitting in your living room eating popcorn, and the law can't touch you.

But, as soon as you act on your evil thoughts, the law CAN touch you. And, suddenly your guilty thoughts DO have criminal liability.

Say I am chopping wood, and I lose control of the ax, and it hits my neighbor in the head and he dies. In that instance, I might get off scott free because it was a tragic accident. But, if I show up and wait outside my neighbor's door with an ax and chop his head off, that's murder. Why is it murder? Same result as before -- the guy is dead -- but here I have intent to kill him.

There are varying levels of intent that are recognized in the varying degrees of charges that can be filed. If I intend to chop off my neighbor's hand, and instead chop off his head on accident, I might be guilty of reckless manslaughter instead of murder -- and that can be the difference between 20 years in prison and death row. So, we DO punish for interior thoughts. Hate crimes are merely an extension of this same logic to curbing what we as a society have deemed are especially unwelcome thoughts. It's not punished as a separate crime -- again, you can't be punished simply for hating your neighbor -- but it is an enhancement of the penalty for acting on that hatred in certain circumstances.

Posted

public schools keep going down hill. Unfortunatly some Catholic schools are following them. However, I still believe in Catholic Education ( I am a product of it) and When I God willing have kids, I will send them to Catholic school

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1198166' date='Feb 17 2007, 02:31 PM']But hate is taught, and that is what I want changed. Crimes exist and we can't do anything about it, but hate crimes are different. Being targeted soley because you're a minority is wrong and no one should be taught that it is okay.

Discrimination hasn't been outlawed. One can still be fired or denied housing because of their sexual orientation.

You have to pay taxes. Deal with it. They go to teaching kids and although you might not agree with everything that is taught I'm fairly sure we all agree that teaching everyone multiplication tables, English, and science is important. I'd pay for that no matter what because I know that some kids aren't as fortunate as I was and they can't afford a private education.[/quote]

People ARE taught that hatred is wrong.
But there is a big difference between teaching against hate and promoting a deviant lifestyle.

Posted

Soc and HSM

No one is telling anyone to be gay. This isn't the point of the court. They aren't promoting jack, just not condeming it. If you're all about loving your neighbor and forgiving and whatever you'd also realize it isn't really your job to marganilize people because of who they sleep with. Just treat everyone like their worth something and then we wouldn't have to deal with hate crimes or courts telling people they have to teach their kids to be nice.

Posted

I'm probably going to send my kids to Catholic school, or homeschool them if possible, but I will never send my kids to public school.

Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1198166' date='Feb 17 2007, 02:31 PM']You have to pay taxes. Deal with it. They go to teaching kids and although you might not agree with everything that is taught I'm fairly sure we all agree that teaching everyone multiplication tables, English, and science is important. I'd pay for that no matter what because I know that some kids aren't as fortunate as I was and they can't afford a private education.[/quote]
Then I should not have to keep quiet about what my kids are taught in school. If I'm the one paying for it then I should have some say in what gets taught.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1198639' date='Feb 17 2007, 10:37 PM']Soc and HSM

No one is telling anyone to be gay. This isn't the point of the court. They aren't promoting jack, just not condeming it. If you're all about loving your neighbor and forgiving and whatever you'd also realize it isn't really your job to marganilize people because of who they sleep with. Just treat everyone like their worth something and then we wouldn't have to deal with hate crimes or courts telling people they have to teach their kids to be nice.[/quote]
No they are saying we must embrace homosexuality whether we like it or not.
I will not teach my kids that that same sex unions are ok, or that it is equivalent to heterosexual marriage because its not. I have taught my children to respect other peoples choices, but they certainly do not have to embrace them or accept them as normal because they are not.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1198530' date='Feb 17 2007, 08:57 PM']I'm only addressing this portion of your post, nothing about the schools aspect of the discussion.

Since I'm in the middle of prepping for my criminal law midterm, I feel at least a little qualified to speak to your assertions that "the law should punish only criminal acts, not attempt to control interior thoughts such as 'hate'" and a couple of other statements which I'll reference later.

First, there are few crimes that do not by definition include both a thought/intent as well as an act. In criminal law this is called mens rea (guilty thought) and actus reus (guilty act). We recognize that there are varying degrees of these two things in almost every crime.

Now, I'm not aware of any crime that is solely a thought-based crime. You can hate your neighbor because he's black all you want while sitting in your living room eating popcorn, and the law can't touch you.

But, as soon as you act on your evil thoughts, the law CAN touch you. And, suddenly your guilty thoughts DO have criminal liability.

Say I am chopping wood, and I lose control of the ax, and it hits my neighbor in the head and he dies. In that instance, I might get off scott free because it was a tragic accident. But, if I show up and wait outside my neighbor's door with an ax and chop his head off, that's murder. Why is it murder? Same result as before -- the guy is dead -- but here I have intent to kill him.

There are varying levels of intent that are recognized in the varying degrees of charges that can be filed. If I intend to chop off my neighbor's hand, and instead chop off his head on accident, I might be guilty of reckless manslaughter instead of murder -- and that can be the difference between 20 years in prison and death row. So, we DO punish for interior thoughts. Hate crimes are merely an extension of this same logic to curbing what we as a society have deemed are especially unwelcome thoughts. It's not punished as a separate crime -- again, you can't be punished simply for hating your neighbor -- but it is an enhancement of the penalty for acting on that hatred in certain circumstances.[/quote]
While I do not claim to be any sort of legal expert, I am quite aware that the law takes intention into account when judging actions - which can mean the difference between first degree murder, second degree murder, and manslaughter.

However, there is actually a leap between judging whether or not one had the intention to act, and so-called "hate-crime" legislation.

Obviously, one should not be charged the same for what one did as an accident, or in self-defense, the same as for a premeditated crime.
"Hate-crime" legislation, on the other hand, would penalize people additionally for crimes comitted with the same level of intention for being associated with a certain ideology.

Are you arguing in support of "hate crime" laws?
I still see no reason a perp should be charged more for a premeditated crime supposedly motivated by hate for homosexuals, than someone else should be charged for the exact same crime, with the exact same level of premeditation, committed simply out of personal vendetta or spite, or simply randomly for no rational reason at all.

Why should a brutal murder or beating against a homosexual be treated any different under the law than an identical and equally brutal murder or beating commited against a straight person?
Should brutally murdering an eight-year-old girl for no logical reason be considered any less serious a crime than brutally murdering a 21-year-old homosexual man because one "hates fags"?

And how accurately can it be determined in court whether or not a particular crime was committed out of "hate"?

The law should treat equal crimes, commited with equal amount of deliberation, the same. The law should say that it is unaccepable to murder people, not that it is unacceptable to murder people, but exceptionally unnacceptable to murder people because they are homosexual.

Anything else gives homosexuals and "minorities" additional protection under the law not rewarded to "straight" people or white people, and punishes particular ideologies deemed politically-incorrect.

Why is hating homosexuals any worse than any number of other unsavory thoughts a murderer or other criminal might have?
I think very few violent crimes are committed out of "nice" good motivations and thoughts.

And if someone committed a crime against you because he hated you personally, would that be considered the same as committing a crime against someone because he was gay?

[quote]It's not punished as a separate crime -- again, you can't be punished simply for hating your neighbor -- but it is an enhancement of the penalty for acting on that hatred in certain circumstances.[/quote]
The "enhancement" of the penalty is for harboring certain ideologies seperate from whether or not one deliberately chose to commit the crime.

And the only logical extension of "hate-crime" law is to prohibit voicing of views deemed by the government to be "hateful." You can deny that this would happen, but people have been heavily fined for speaking out against homosexuality in Canada and some other countries.
"Hate crime" legislation is a best a very slippery slope, at worst downright totalitarian.

Edited by Socrates
Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1198639' date='Feb 17 2007, 10:37 PM']Soc and HSM

No one is telling anyone to be gay. This isn't the point of the court. They aren't promoting jack, just not condeming it. If you're all about loving your neighbor and forgiving and whatever you'd also realize it isn't really your job to marganilize people because of who they sleep with. Just treat everyone like their worth something and then we wouldn't have to deal with hate crimes or courts telling people they have to teach their kids to be nice.[/quote]
What's the point of reading this homo "fairy tale' ([i]fairy[/i] tale?) to 7-year-old kids then?

Like there's no agenda behind that. Rrrrriggghhht.

We were taught to love our neighbor and all that just fine as kids, without being forced to read "cute" stories about homosexuality.

And should the parents have no say in what political agendas are being imposed upon their own children, using their own tax money, even if it goes against their morality??

This is absolutely disgusting in so many ways.

Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1198166' date='Feb 17 2007, 02:31 PM']But hate is taught, and that is what I want changed. Crimes exist and we can't do anything about it, but hate crimes are different. Being targeted soley because you're a minority is wrong and no one should be taught that it is okay.[/quote]


None of this is taught in public school. At all. No public school teaches hate.

To use this sort of reasoning as an excuse to promote homosexual tendancies in a school is absured. How can you (and everyone defending the states decision in the article) come to the conclusion that because a school does not promote homosexual behavior that it MUST be convincing 8 year olds to commit violent acts against homosexuals. This doesnt make sense. School's continuously teach children not to hit or even touch other people, and to respect them, their space, and their things. and specifically not to descriminate.

Let me say that again, schools [i]do this[/i].

I'm really sick of this attitude that if you disagree with the homosexual issue that you are against civil rights, liberty, and are violent, hate-filled discrimatory bigots. Im not singling you out Track, this is just in general. People [i]can[/i] disagree and not be violent or hateful. Many people seem to have forgotten that the vast majority of people against homosexual unions are [i]not[/i] violent and do not hate. For instance I think this whole issue is wrong, absuredly wrong, and that it is spiriling completely out of control, but when see a gay man or a lesbian I do not, for example, punch them in the face. I know many homosexuals, and am very close to some. But this is where I stand.

Finally, Parents have an ABSOLUTE right to teach and raise their children how they want, and to have the state dictate social matters such as these is rediculous and fascist. All sorts of parallels can be made. How bout a situation where polygomy was being taught. A book where a king was not happy until he had 8 queens, promoting more than one partner as beeing "ok" and "just as good and normal as heterosexual monogomy". Or how bout a book where a king was not happy with a queen, but instead wanted the 10 year old prince of the neighboring country as his partner to live happily ever after.

This sort of stuff is propaganda, plain and simple.

And this stuff is gentle compared to what will be taught in sex ed... (as I stated above)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...