Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Harry Potter And Those That Oppose It...


Recommended Posts

Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

I'm dealing with this individual who's pretty much bashing the First Lady cause she put up Harry Potter ornaments on their Christmas tree. Then he linked me to a website that totally bashing the series. Why can't people just accept that some books are just that, books? And it's a book that makes you use your imagination?

I say that these people bashing Harry Potter are just like that one guy that claimed that the purple Tele-tubby was guy!

What do you think?!

Posted

i like them. They are just imagination books. Many do not like it but they are oK with Lord of the rings. :ph34r:

Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

The main arguments that are used are:

1. There are witches and wizards

2. They deal with the undead

3. it's occultet

I'm sorry, but two out of those three are in the Lord of the Rings series.

1. Gandalf

2. ORcs

Why can't people just leave people alone?

Posted

Dont forget the talking trees. :lol:

Kilroy the Ninja
Posted (edited)

Ok, I'm trying to stay out of this one because it's been argued to death here at Phatmass (and I, for one, was kinda hoping the whole topic would die and go away), but the big difference is that Lord of the Rings is pure fantasy meaning it takes place in a world where the only similiarities are that there are men and trees and dirt and mountains just like our world. (BTW, Orcs are not "undead", they are monsters. The undead warriors in ROTK were undead.)

Harry Potter's world, while fantasical at times, is meant to be very much the world we live in today. The occult references made in Harry Potter are REAL ones. There are pentacles in use in Harry Potter that are in use in REAL LIFE. There are many, many references to actual occult things in Harry Potter. The danger is that some children, many children, cannot truly separate the fiction from reality. These are the same children who will tell you they know it's just a story. And they truly know it's just a story but the real danger is being exposed to those occult things in a positive way. What I mean by this is these children - while knowing it was just a story from their childhood - may very well grow up believing the occult things to be benign or innocent - because, after all, Harry Potter used them to do good...

Are there "good" witches? The answer to that is there are good people who are mis-informed and are playing with forces they cannot understand.

To underestimate the power of these forces is to be a fool.

Personally I find the Harry Potter books offensive on a purely literate level. They are poorly written in an off-hand, lacsidaisical style that is a trashy comment on modern literature. Younger children (the kind that these books are aimed at) should not be reading them purely from the point of view that they are poor examples of literature. I found the movies to be much less offensive.

Edited by Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

I appreciate Harry Potter as literature. And I love the fact that the author had a chance to go from rags to riches. I'm glad it didn't get written by an already rich person. I would however shy away from letting my children read it until they are at least 12 and clearly know the difference between fantasy and reality, and they understand the underlying sin in the Harry Potter series.

I know it is possible the series could strike up an interest in the occult in a young one, as innocent as it might be, but we are much better off not dabbling in the evil ones territory.

Mary's Knight, La
Posted (edited)

the wizards in LotR weren't actually human though you'd really have to read the silmarillion to know that they would be something akin to angels one of the "lower" choirs

Edited by Mary's Knight, La
Posted

Catholics who have a problem with Harry Potter are the same Catholics who have a problem with drinking, and cussing, and talking about scrunching or folding . . . in other words, those who have been strongly influenced by a Protestant culture that suggests the devil is creeping around every corner and we must resist any thing that isn't straight from the gospels . . .

Oh, and also those who are confused.

Posted

Catholics who have a problem with Harry Potter are the same Catholics who have a problem with drinking, and cussing, and talking about scrunching or folding . . . in other words, those who have been strongly influenced by a Protestant culture that suggests the devil is creeping around every corner and we must resist any thing that isn't straight from the gospels . . .

Oh, and also those who are confused.

i don't agree. i don't have a problem with talking about scrunching/folding, i like cussing, i like to drink and gamble occasionally. i just think parents should be a little leery of letting their younger children read Harry Potter. Older children, i don't know if i'd be so concerned.

Oh, and the writing style is dreadful. <_<

Posted

Sorry BLAZEr, but I believe you're wrong. I'm not against drinking or gambling (as long as it's within reason), and I don't mind cussing (even though it isn't the best thing).

Burn Harry Potter.

Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

Catholics who have a problem with Harry Potter are the same Catholics who have a problem with drinking, and cussing, and talking about scrunching or folding . . . in other words, those who have been strongly influenced by a Protestant culture that suggests the devil is creeping around every corner and we must resist any thing that isn't straight from the gospels . . .

Oh, and also those who are confused.

Blazer I take personal offense to your post.

I tend to cuss like a sailor when I'm mad and I'll drink most people under the table when I have no responsibilities to attend to (like when the child is under the care of someone else).

The scrunching/folding thing was disgusting on a whole new level but if you want to talk about your excrement habits - go right ahead.

I don't believe that everything needs to be straight from the gospels - in fact I question that too much for my own good.

EVIL IS LURKING AROUND EVERY CORNER AND IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE THAT THEN YOU ARE A FOOL.

And I seriously doubt I could be confused about any of this considering my past, but thanks for implying so.

Posted

EVIL IS LURKING AROUND EVERY CORNER AND IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE THAT THEN YOU ARE A FOOL.

Word.

A Catholic Apologist, Patrick Madrid even warned us of the danger of Harry Potter. In fact, most of society has become desensitized to evil itself.

My fave Kilroy posting:

My new favorite Simpson's quote:

Ned Flanders, reading a Harry Potter book to his kids: "And Harry Potter and all his friends died and went to Hell for practicing witchcraft. The end!"

Kids in unison: "YAAAAAAYYYY!!!"

Ned tosses the Harry Potter book in the fire. As it should be.

Posted

Word.

A Catholic Apologist, Patrick Madrid even warned us of the danger of Harry Potter. In fact, most of society has become desensitized to evil itself.

My fave Kilroy posting:

i love your post! ^_^

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

Catholics who have a problem with Harry Potter are the same Catholics who have a problem with drinking, and cussing, and talking about scrunching or folding . . . in other words, those who have been strongly influenced by a Protestant culture that suggests the devil is creeping around every corner and we must resist any thing that isn't straight from the gospels . . .

Oh, and also those who are confused.

hmm...thats not how i see it.

I see it as catholics who knows and recognizes the potential and danger of something when it is taken lightly or underestimated, and acknowledges them

and i learned about harry potter from a catholic apologist, who is nothing at all protestant but who has studied in depth the situation and has shared his concern as a defender of the faith and catholic father of eleven ;)

God bless,

+JMJ

Posted

I've sat with these people as well, discussed this book as well. In fact I sat and listened to three philosophers debate these Anti-Potter catholics for well nigh an hour. (In a bar, quite frankly with cussing now and then)

I still contend that the fear of Harry Potter is a particularly Protestant phenomena. The people who are opposed to harry can usually be found in two quarters: the Latin Mass People and the Charismatics/Marian Apparition crowds . . . I am not saying that "Protestants" oppose Harry Potter and these Catholics are like Protestants in their theology. I am saying that we are a product of our culture and the dominant religious culture in our Country has been Protestantism, and quite frankly most Catholics act more like Protestants than they do like Catholics. In fact, the 99% of Apologetics I've read is not "Catholic" in any sense of the word.

Face it, we act in the Church like Protestants. We view the Church like Protestants. We are protestant Catholics. Has there been a great hulla-baloo in Italy over Harry Potter? Gabriel Amorth is the only Italian I've heard condemn it and quite frankly he condemns everything as Satanic, including Protestant versions of the Bible.

For every Harry Potter is evil article you can bring up, we can bring one that demonstrates Harry isn't a problem. Quite frankly, the whole thing is best left to Parent's discernment. In fact, that would be the real Catholic position . . . to allow a family to decide what its children will and will not read.

Posted

Blazer I take personal offense to your post.

I tend to cuss like a sailor when I'm mad and I'll drink most people under the table when I have no responsibilities to attend to (like when the child is under the care of someone else).

The scrunching/folding thing was disgusting on a whole new level but if you want to talk about your excrement habits - go right ahead.

I don't believe that everything needs to be straight from the gospels - in fact I question that too much for my own good.

EVIL IS LURKING AROUND EVERY CORNER AND IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE THAT THEN YOU ARE A FOOL.

And I seriously doubt I could be confused about any of this considering my past, but thanks for implying so.

No personal offense was intended.

Evil isn't lurking around every corner, it's right there in your own heart. You don't have to be afraid of the devil behind Harry Potter, you've got bigger fish to fry with the devil manifesting himself in your own life. When I was a kid I read LOTR and that in turn introduced me to a world of wizards and magic (admit it, if you're a boy, Gandalf is the coolest character). Very soon I was reading books about magic and spells and very wicked things. My mother found the books and had a talk with me. Case closed. Was LOTR evil?? Of course not. Could Harry prodcue the same effect? Sure. Is it evil because of it? Nope.

I've also heard the arguments about Harry encouraging lying and rule breaking if its to your benefit . . . anyone who has ever read a childrens books sees the same patterns in everything from Hank the Cowdog to Amelia Badelia and Harriet the Spy.

Harry Potter may not explicitly lead children to believe in God. However, certainly one could argue that it leads them to distinguish between Good and Evil, and that, IMHO is a very good start.

I wasn't implying that if you are against Harry Potter then you are necessarily a prude who won't drink or cuss. However, I was suggesting that the loathing of Harry Potter finds its roots in the same mentality, in my opinion.

Don John of Austria
Posted

Blazer now you must understand when I say this I am extremely well aquianted with this Topic and I have no fear of fantasy, I love the Lord of the Rings and many other Fantasies and I Play D&D every Saturday night. On the other hand I have also witnessed the Occult destroy families and live including those of my own relatives, I have come face to whatever( it didn't have a dicernable face) ( and yes I know exactly what I am saying) with the Physical manifistation of a demon. I am fully aware that of the proper role of Fantasy and alagory both in the Culture and even of the Faith, but Harry Potter is not Fantasy it is neo pagan pro--witch propoganda, It uses REAL occult referances and denegrates those who do not have magical powers or believe in Witchcraft. Harry Potter is evil because it is both insidious and directly supporting occult practices, which occur in the real world. The Heros are participatory in these Occult Pratices and they live notin a Fantastical world but right here among us muggels( sp.).

Posted

don John, I too have familiarity with the occult and with Pagan witch practices. One of my very dear friends is a nun and a former High priestess in Wicca. She and Fr. Mitch Pacwa (another expert on the occult) and I had a long talk on this topic. I used to be weary of Harry Potter because of some of what I had read. They both convinced me of two things: A.) the magic used in Harry Potter is entirely fictional and not based in real black magic or wicca and B.) the fantasy of Harry Potter is firmly rooted in the Christian tradition.

Mainly through their influence and naturally my own thought I came to have an opinion of Harry Potter that was good. I liked the books when I first read them, and in myself didn't quite feel like that hubub was coherent with my experience. Sr. Teresa Angela and Fr. Mitch helped to reassure me of this fact.

Don John of Austria
Posted

They both convinced me of two things: A.) the magic used in Harry Potter is entirely fictional and not based in real black magic or wicca and B.) the fantasy of Harry Potter is firmly rooted in the Christian tradition.

Don't take this the wrong way but on both counts they are WRONG. The magic in Harry Potter does certianly have it's roots in real wicca, and it has nothing to do with the Christian Tradition. Agian I have a great deal of experiance in this matter and so I just am going to tell you out right that what they are telling you is not true. End of story.

Posted

Honestly Don, here is where you and I have to agree to not agree Their opinions, partly because they are born out of personal relationship, are more valuable to me. I'm sure you can understand that. I don't think they are trying to deceive me, and I don't think they are being deceived. Other than that, I'm not sure what to say.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...