Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Vatican Official Acknowledges Liturgical Crisis


Recommended Posts

Posted

It took the Vatican 40 years to realize we have a liturgical problem? They should have saw that when our masses and archictecture started looking non-catholic. When priests started turning around to face the darkness of the west rather than the light of Christ in the east.



[url="http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=49461"]http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=49461[/url]

Vatican official acknowledges liturgical crisis

Feb. 23, 2007 (CWNews.com) - In an unusually candid conversation with the monthly Inside the Vatican, the secretary of the Vatican’s Congregation for Divine Worship concedes that liturgical reform after Vatican II “has not been able to achieve the expected goals,” and indicates that Pope Benedict XVI (bio - news) is determined to address the crisis in Catholic liturgy.

In a lengthy interview, Archbishop Albert Malcom Ranjith Patabendige Don told the Inside the Vatican that a revival of the Catholic liturgy is essential to counteract the decline in practice among the faithful, particularly in the Western world.

[The full text of the interview is available on the CWN site, courtesy of Inside the Vatican]

“Undoubtedly there have been positive results” from the post-concilar liturgical renewal, the Sri Lankan prelate told interview Anthony Valle. But he quickly added that “the negative effects seem to have been greater, causing much disorientation in our ranks.”

Pope Benedict fully recognizes the crisis in the liturgy, the archbishop says, and the time has now come “with the help of the Lord to make the necessary corrections.”

Questioned about the prospects for a motu proprio in which Pope Benedict XVI would allow wider use of the pre-conciliar Latin liturgy, Archbishop Ranjith indicated that the document should be expected, although he would not predict when it would appear or exactly what it would say. “With regard to the timing and nature of the motu proprio,” he said, “nothing yet is known. It is the Holy Father who will decide.’

The challenge that the Pontiff faces, Archbishop Ranjith said, is “not so much a matter of the Tridentine Mass or of the Novus Ordo. It is just a question of pastoral responsibility and sensitivity.” He added that “if the Holy Father so desires, both could co-exist.” Wide use of the old Mass, he said, would not require abandoning the post-conciliar liturgy. “But in the interaction of the two Roman traditions, it is possible that the one may influence the other eventually.”

The fundamental challenge, the archbishop said, is stop what he called “freewheeling” liturgical innovation, and to recover the sense of the sacred. Steps in that direction, he said, would bring Catholics back into more active practice of the faith.

Archbishop Ranjith was unsparing in his analysis of the crisis facing Catholicism today. Noting the decline in active Mass attendance, he said: “We have to ask ourselves what happened in these churches and then take corrective steps as may be necessary.”

The archbishop refused to accept some common explanations for the decline in Catholic practice. “I do not think that this situation is attributable to secularization only,” he said. “A deep crisis of faith coupled with a drive for meaningless liturgical experimentation and novelty have had their own impact in this matter.”

Posted

[quote name='Akalyte' post='1203860' date='Feb 24 2007, 09:19 AM']It took the Vatican 40 years to realize we have a liturgical problem? They should have saw that when our masses and archictecture started looking non-catholic. When priests started turning around to face the darkness of the west rather than the light of Christ in the east.[/quote]

Amen! When I first say the video on Google Vidoes called "What we have lost", I realized the large amount of things we have lost!

Posted

[quote]The fundamental challenge, the archbishop said, is stop what he called “freewheeling” liturgical innovation, and to recover the sense of the sacred. Steps in that direction, he said, would bring Catholics back into more active practice of the faith.[/quote]

best line in the report

could u link me to the video?

Knight of the Holy Rosary
Posted

Thank God!

Posted

[quote]It took the Vatican 40 years to realize we have a liturgical problem? They should have saw that when our masses and archictecture started looking non-catholic.[/quote]

To be fair, I think it was recognized by many people inside the Vatican (Cardinal Ratzinger for instance) that the liturgy as it is commonly celebrated isn't what it should be. I understand the general frustration, because I often feel the same way myself <_< Things move sloooowly in the Vatican, and in some ways that's good and in some ways that's bad.

Posted

Search this forum for the video... I saw a thread on it a few months back... This is a good article... I think it says it all... if not, it says most of what needs to be said.

Posted

[quote name='St. Benedict' post='1204402' date='Feb 25 2007, 02:00 PM']Amen! When I first say the video on Google Vidoes called "What we have lost", I realized the large amount of things we have lost![/quote]

I agree that we need to restore many of the traditional aspects of the church, however I do not agree with the conclusions and assertations of this video. In fact, I believe it to be very misleading and may even cause a crisis of faith in the younger members of phatmass.

The will have you believe that the sacrifce of the Novus Ordo mass is not valid, that Vatican II changes in the sacraments makes those sacraments validity questionable, that the Catholic Church after Vatican II is a "new church" not unlike the protestant churches, and that the true church established by Jesus is no longer found with the Catholic Church but with the SSPX and independent chapels.

I would say that if you do google this video you need to take it with a grain of salt, it does present things that should be restored in the church, but it also gives one point of view and many of their arguments have couterarguments from tradition that I have seen from phatmassers, such as Cam42, and others on Flyfree.

Posted

Ditto what peach_cube wrote. The video is interesting; but its pessimism--and its exagerated claims--make it pretty clear that we're watching something produced by "rad-trads."

Posted

I found the Barney Mass video that was available a few weeks back more informative, because it is an example of what is wrong with the Roman liturgy. Sadly, for the past 40 years Western Catholics have labored under the false idea that they must "create" liturgy, and that liturgy must be spontaneous and entertaining to be relevant.

Hopefully, a liturgical restoration in the Roman Church will occur at some point in the future, but -- to be blunt -- I do not foresee that happening in my lifetime.

God bless,
Todd

P.S. - Happy "Feast of the Triumph of Orthodoxy" to all the Eastern Christians at the phorum.

Posted

is this then focused on the abuses, or the things that are just misinterpreted and done wrong due to lack of knowledge as to why we do it? For example, is this going to focus on the abuses like when a priest comes in dressed like a clown and allows people to dance around the altar, or is it going down to which direction the priest stands and the translation of the mass parts?

Posted

[quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1204619' date='Feb 25 2007, 08:08 PM']Ditto what peach_cube wrote. The video is interesting; but its pessimism--and its exagerated claims--make it pretty clear that we're watching something produced by "rad-trads."[/quote]

I agree that some claims in the video are quite biased and untrue. But it does do a good job of showing changes that followed Vatican II. As I said, use caution when watching the video. But I do suggest watching it.

Posted

I Googled the video and watched it between Masses this afternoon. The "rad-trad" label seems appropriate. The sort of liturgy that that seem to think occurs in all celebrations of the Pauline missal simply doesn't occur with the frequency they imply. The limbo-ing presider is not by any means normative in the United States (I've never seen one at Mass - only at the bar after a couple whiskey sours...). The video seemed also to take a lot of its material for generalization from the 1970's and 1980's, when there was a spirit of experimentation, however well-intentions or misguided.

I agree that the reforms of Vatican II should be scrutinized, but truth lies somewhere in the middle of radical liberalism and radical traditionalism. For example, solid Eucharistic theology needs to be reasserted, but the swing away from belief in the Real Presence can be seen as somewhat expected when there is a period of rapid change, both inside and outside the Church. We must remember that we exist in a relatively brief instant of the Church's history, both past and future. Simply bludgeoning people with Pius V's missal when they are accustomed to the Pauline missal won't increase attendance, vocations or fervor. It will simply confuse a majority of the faithful yet again.

I was talking with the judicial vicar of my diocese today and he suggested every diocese having a Pauline Mass in Latin - celebrated well! His idea is that most people (some people on these forums excluded) don't disagree with the theology of the Pauline missal so much as they miss the humility that hearing Mass in Latin forces one into. His idea of compromise would be to offer the normative Mass in Latin to provide liturgy to those wanting Latin while still connecting them to the normative Eucharistic liturgy of the Church. I happen to agree...

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1204625' date='Feb 25 2007, 09:43 PM']I found the Barney Mass video that was available a few weeks back more informative, because it is an example of what is wrong with the Roman liturgy. Sadly, for the past 40 years Western Catholics have labored under the false idea that they must "create" liturgy, and that liturgy must be spontaneous and entertaining to be relevant.

Hopefully, a liturgical restoration in the Roman Church will occur at some point in the future, but -- to be blunt -- I do not foresee that happening in my lifetime.

God bless,
Todd

P.S. - Happy "Feast of the Triumph of Orthodoxy" to all the Eastern Christians at the phorum.[/quote]
THank you.
Anytime you have time to post Eastern Church stuff PLEASE POST LINKS! The more we learn the better Catholics we will be.

Posted

[quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1204673' date='Feb 25 2007, 09:43 PM']I Googled the video and watched it between Masses this afternoon. The "rad-trad" label seems appropriate. The sort of liturgy that that seem to think occurs in all celebrations of the Pauline missal simply doesn't occur with the frequency they imply. The limbo-ing presider is not by any means normative in the United States (I've never seen one at Mass - only at the bar after a couple whiskey sours...). The video seemed also to take a lot of its material for generalization from the 1970's and 1980's, when there was a spirit of experimentation, however well-intentions or misguided.

I agree that the reforms of Vatican II should be scrutinized, but truth lies somewhere in the middle of radical liberalism and radical traditionalism. For example, solid Eucharistic theology needs to be reasserted, but the swing away from belief in the Real Presence can be seen as somewhat expected when there is a period of rapid change, both inside and outside the Church. We must remember that we exist in a relatively brief instant of the Church's history, both past and future. Simply bludgeoning people with Pius V's missal when they are accustomed to the Pauline missal won't increase attendance, vocations or fervor. It will simply confuse a majority of the faithful yet again.

I was talking with the judicial vicar of my diocese today and he suggested every diocese having a Pauline Mass in Latin - celebrated well! His idea is that most people (some people on these forums excluded) don't disagree witoh the theology of the Pauline missal so much as they miss the humility that hearing Mass in Latin forces one into. His idea of compromise would be to offer the normative Mass in Latin to provide liturgy to those wanting Latin while still connecting them to the normative Eucharistic liturgy of the Church. I happen to agree...[/quote]

I prefer the theology of the Tridentine Missal. It is more sacrificial and more transubstantiational.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1204715' date='Feb 25 2007, 09:40 PM']THank you.
Anytime you have time to post Eastern Church stuff PLEASE POST LINKS! The more we learn the better Catholics we will be.[/quote]
Here is a link to the ritual for the [url="http://web.ukonline.co.uk/ephrem/crowning.htm"][u]Mystery of Crowning[/u][/url]

Posted

[quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1204673' date='Feb 25 2007, 08:43 PM'][. . .]

His idea of compromise would be to offer the normative Mass in Latin to provide liturgy to those wanting Latin while still connecting them to the normative Eucharistic liturgy of the Church. I happen to agree...[/quote]
The Pauline Missal is normative only for the [b]Latin[/b] Church.

Posted

Here is a link to the [url="http://web.ukonline.co.uk/ephrem/therite.htm"][u]Mystery of the Consecration of a Church[/u][/url] (from the same site I listed above in connection with the ritual for the Mystery of Crowning).

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1204728' date='Feb 26 2007, 01:00 AM']The Pauline Missal is normative only for the [b]Latin[/b] Church.[/quote]

My impression was that we were discussing this in the context of the Latin Church, so I didn't bother to make that distinction. Thank you for the clarification.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...