Jaime Posted March 15, 2007 Posted March 15, 2007 I thought "The Prestige" was horrible. Once I figured out what the plot twist was, (about halfway through) I was bored. The only memorable moment from the film was when I was talking about it with Cam. I told him I thought Christian Bale's british accent was not believable. He then informed me that Bale was british. The Illusionist was quite good
N/A Gone Posted March 15, 2007 Posted March 15, 2007 His accent was a poor style, not the common. Cant make fun of batman At what point did you know the plot? My thing was I could not decide who to cheer for. I did like the Illustionist better. edward Norton and Paul Giamatti are very underated actors
Totus Tuus Posted March 17, 2007 Posted March 17, 2007 (edited) Edit post... nevermind, I thought y'all were talking about the Guardian. I never saw The Prestige. Edited March 17, 2007 by Totus Tuus
DemonSlayer Posted March 18, 2007 Posted March 18, 2007 [quote name='onathing1' post='1214008' date='Mar 15 2007, 10:49 PM']Well see, I'm a girl so you'da thought I'd appreciate the chick flickness, but I didn't really like it. Hm, odd....I also didn't like how they didn't explain how he did his trick. My mom swears they did, but I don't remember it. Although I must say that poor Rufus Sewell will never play the hero in any movie. I like him though, he's a good actor.[/quote] Rufus Sewll played the hero in the great sci-film Dark City, the first film I saw him in. I just saw The Illusionist, and I still think that The Prestige was a better film, I'm still not 100% sure how Norton's character did what he did.
onathing1 Posted March 19, 2007 Author Posted March 19, 2007 [quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1215353' date='Mar 18 2007, 04:40 AM']I'm still not 100% sure how Norton's character did what he did.[/quote] AH! Thank you! I'm still not clear on that myself...
ilovechrist Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 i found it hysterical how the prestige came out about the same time as the illusionist... and kicked the illusionist back to europe with its awesomeness. prestige wins. case closed. amazing movie.
nleyetn Posted March 19, 2007 Posted March 19, 2007 I saw The Illusionist now also, and I have to say I liked The Prestige more although both films were great. They did try and explain a 'possible' way Norton's character might have done the trick, but I don't think the explanation was good enough to justify what he did. That was really the only trick they came close to explaining. They also hinted a little bit at what was going on with his first 'big' trick, but they didn't say anything about it. Overall The Illusionist was less realistic as far as the magic goes, but The Prestige isn't really believable either.
Totus Tuus Posted March 21, 2007 Posted March 21, 2007 Okay I saw it. We watched it for the Feast of St. Patrick (any excuse to override our Lenten sacrifice of movies...) [quote name='hot stuff' post='1214113' date='Mar 15 2007, 02:31 PM']He then informed me that Bale was british. [/quote] I didn't think Christian Bale's British accent was believable, either... didn't realize he [i]is[/i] British. I didn't like the movie. It was interesting to some extent, but as far as a moral rating, although it was cleaner than many films, it was not uplifting or inspirational. It leaves one with little hope and little to meditate on. (I know I sound crazy, but I'm one of those people who think entertainment should raise your mind to something higher...) It was, however, inspirational to my little brothers and sister; they have been practicing their own magic tricks ever since they watched the movie. Lauren
uruviel Posted March 22, 2007 Posted March 22, 2007 I completely agree with you Lauren. It kept me guessing, and I suppose that was entertaining. I liked it according to the way it was written and how thought through it was. However it wasn't uplifting in the slightest, as most movies are these days. As far as understanding the film, I thought it was very easy to understand when I saw the result. There was one phrase that caught me and I, to this day, cannot understand it. When he said he doesn't know if he will be the prestige or just the man in the box, when talking about going into the machine. Celine and I had a long discussion about this and still it does not make sense to me.
Theologian in Training Posted March 23, 2007 Posted March 23, 2007 [quote name='uruviel' post='1217376' date='Mar 22 2007, 03:57 PM']I completely agree with you Lauren. It kept me guessing, and I suppose that was entertaining. I liked it according to the way it was written and how thought through it was. However it wasn't uplifting in the slightest, as most movies are these days. As far as understanding the film, I thought it was very easy to understand when I saw the result. There was one phrase that caught me and I, to this day, cannot understand it. When he said he doesn't know if he will be the prestige or just the man in the box, when talking about going into the machine. Celine and I had a long discussion about this and still it does not make sense to me.[/quote] The phrase is based on what drives any magician, or any performer for that matter, to be the center of attention, to be the one getting the credit for being the entertainer. The prestige is the one who accomplishes this, the man in the box, is the guy downstairs listening to the crowd go crazy all the while wishing the crowd was really cheering for him. The only thing about that movie is that it truly does capture the essence of what a magician truly feels, which is why they were able to give away some very good effects that really should have remained a secret
goldbug16 Posted March 24, 2007 Posted March 24, 2007 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1214113' date='Mar 15 2007, 01:31 PM']I told him I thought Christian Bale's british accent was not believable.[/quote] Yeah, he is British all right. I can t wait to see it. I have had it on hold for a long time and still havent gotten it.
Sojourner Posted March 24, 2007 Posted March 24, 2007 I am not as smart as hot stuff and so didn't figure out the twist in Prestige until the end, so it was more enjoyable for me. But still not as good as Illusionist, yes. There are times it pays to turn off your brain :
uruviel Posted March 25, 2007 Posted March 25, 2007 [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1217930' date='Mar 23 2007, 07:24 PM']The phrase is based on what drives any magician, or any performer for that matter, to be the center of attention, to be the one getting the credit for being the entertainer. The prestige is the one who accomplishes this, the man in the box, is the guy downstairs listening to the crowd go crazy all the while wishing the crowd was really cheering for him. The only thing about that movie is that it truly does capture the essence of what a magician truly feels, which is why they were able to give away some very good effects that really should have remained a secret [/quote] No I got that part. My question was, when he goes into the machine, he makes a clone of himself. This clone has all the memories and the characteristics of him. However, when he is cloned, he is dropped down below the stage to drown. How can he not know if he will drown or be the prestige? In some views, he is both, however the presitge does NOT remember being drowned because he was cloned before the real man drowned. So really, the very first man died the first time he did the trick, and so his clones have been continueing this trick. How can he not know if he will drown or be the prestige!??! It doesn't make sense to me.
nleyetn Posted March 25, 2007 Posted March 25, 2007 (edited) [b]SPOILERS:[/b] Because he does not know how the machine works. The machine can do 1 of 2 things. It can clone somebody and somehow send that clone to another place which it sounds like is they way you believe. Or it can clone somebody sending the original to a different place leaving the clone standing where the original was. Since the clone is an exact copy down to every memory he has until the moment he is cloned, both copies will think they are the original but they have no way of knowing which is which. Edited March 25, 2007 by nLEyETn
nleyetn Posted March 25, 2007 Posted March 25, 2007 (edited) [b]SPOILERS:[/b] I'll also say that I think it is more likely the first case which you believe also. Even if it seems that the first theory is the more likely one to Angier, he would probably be reluctant to accept it because if the second theory is true, then the original will always survive meaning only the clones are dying. To think that the original will survive instead of the clone would probably be more comforting to him even if it might be more far fetched. But he still will never be able to tell for sure which one he is. Edited March 25, 2007 by nLEyETn
Totus Tuus Posted March 26, 2007 Posted March 26, 2007 Off the subject... has the Church made a statement on clones having souls? Thanks for the info, nleyetn.
nleyetn Posted March 26, 2007 Posted March 26, 2007 [quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1219582' date='Mar 25 2007, 08:14 PM']Off the subject... has the Church made a statement on clones having souls? Thanks for the info, nleyetn. [/quote] No problem. That's an interesting question there about the souls though. Hypothetically if someone was cloned where they are cloned in whole and do not follow the life cycle of a human through conception, birth and growth, it would seem they would be a soulless person. I've only seen this type of cloning in sci-fi movies though and don't know if it is to feasible no matter how much progress we make in technology. The more traditional type of reproductive cloning that follows the pattern of life would seem to have a soul, and that would be the only thing that separates it from the original, it's own unique soul. It's an interesting thing to think about.
uruviel Posted March 30, 2007 Posted March 30, 2007 It is interesting to think about. When you clone a human, does God put a soul in it?? Someone should ask God when they get to Heaven.
Lounge Daddy Posted April 2, 2007 Posted April 2, 2007 hmmm... think about watching both movies. it reminds me of the time The Professional and Eraser hit theaters at the same time Professional was waaaay better.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now