Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Response To A Question On Papal Infallibility


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello friends,

I will apologize in advance if this is posted in the wrong forum.

I was hoping to get some advice in my response to a colleague of mine who has fallen away from the Church due to his blind acceptance of much of the anti-Catholic propaganda that exists nowadays. I was attempting to explain to him the concept of the infallibility of the Pope on the matters of Church doctrine only. He brought up the concept of tithing, and stated that tithing was enforced in medieval times based on papal decree that tithing was absolutely necessary for salvation. His reasoning was that, since tithing is no longer required, then the Pope cannot be infallible on the topic of faith. I asked him to provide me with the name of the Pope and the decree with the full weight and authority of the Catholic Church (and not some Wikipedia article) as his form of proof. However, I would also like to provide him with some information, preferably written, on the history of tithing. Would any of the many knowledgeable folks here be able to help me with this? Thank you.

CBH

Posted

The Church’s infallibility is not confined to matters of morality and doctrines per say but this are where they “namely” reside. The issue of tithing is still real since it is a precept of the Church and it is still bounding by the Code of Canon Law, but I believe the Church has become more lenient in what is actually required in light of the Gospel message. So if we refuse to give something to the Church we would be breaking Church Precept which is grave matter and therefore could be mortal sin.

This although has very little to do with doctrine but more to do with discipline. Discipline does and often times does change over time with the advent of devotions and the spiritual (or even physical) needs and limitations of the people. Even though theses disciplines are founded in scripture, tradition, or doctrine it does not make it an infallible statement. Those writings of the Pope, Council, or otherwise which is Infallible or elevates a doctrine to Dogmatic Law is [b]clearly evident in the writing it self[/b]. This does not happen in every doctrine proposed by the Pope thus a bull or letter would not fall under this classification.

On the history aspect of this, I am sad to say I dont know too much (without research) and feel free to correct me...

Tithing is from the Old Testament where they were commanded to give ten percent of what they gained in wages or profit. At the advent of the New Covenant this was seemingly perfected in the woman who gave the least in money but gave the most in spirit showing that what we give for the glory of God must not only be physically abounding but spiritually abounding. Also that God is pleased with smaller sacrifices of our resources in the physical upkeep of the Church but at the same time the Church knowing she needs physical resources requires the faithful to give such when able.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Mr.CatholicCat' post='1223089' date='Mar 30 2007, 02:25 PM']The Church’s infallibility is not confined to matters of morality and doctrines per say but this are where they “namely” reside. The issue of tithing is still real since it is a precept of the Church and it is still bounding by the Code of Canon Law, but I believe the Church has become more lenient in what is actually required in light of the Gospel message. So if we refuse to give something to the Church we would be breaking Church Precept which is grave matter and therefore could be mortal sin.[/quote]

Mr. CC I have to say I disagree with your contention that infallibility goes beyond maters of morality and doctrine (faith). Vatican I specifically says that it applies to faith and morals. Now perhaps your statement is trying to capture the fact that Church discipline goes beyond Faith and morals. I.e. not eating meat is a sin because the Pope has the authority to require us to not eat meat. Therefore if we go against that authority we are sinning against his authority. Or perhaps you are trying to make the point that because what the Pope says on a given incidence is not infallibe, we don't have to listen to it. It is a false assumption to assume because a statement is not infallibly stated that it is in error.

Edited by thessalonian
thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='CameBackHome' post='1223062' date='Mar 30 2007, 01:52 PM']Hello friends,

I will apologize in advance if this is posted in the wrong forum.

I was hoping to get some advice in my response to a colleague of mine who has fallen away from the Church due to his blind acceptance of much of the anti-Catholic propaganda that exists nowadays. I was attempting to explain to him the concept of the infallibility of the Pope on the matters of Church doctrine only. He brought up the concept of tithing, and stated that tithing was enforced in medieval times based on papal decree that tithing was absolutely necessary for salvation. His reasoning was that, since tithing is no longer required, then the Pope cannot be infallible on the topic of faith. I asked him to provide me with the name of the Pope and the decree with the full weight and authority of the Catholic Church (and not some Wikipedia article) as his form of proof. However, I would also like to provide him with some information, preferably written, on the history of tithing. Would any of the many knowledgeable folks here be able to help me with this? Thank you.

CBH[/quote]

I do not know that a tithe has ever been a requirement of the Church. It may have been. It is a precept of the Church even today that we support the Church. That would include time, talent, and treasure I would assume. As Mr. Catholic Cat pointed out precepts of the Church are matters of salvation because we are violating the authority of the Church. Christ told Peter "WHATEVER you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven". Therefore it is a serious sin to violate a command of the Pope. This is under Papal primacy and papal supremacy rather than infallibility. Disciplines can and do change. However I would question your friend to produce the papal statement first. I've never seen such a statement and I've read alot of the papal decress.

Posted

The point is that it is wrongful to limit the infallible attribute of the Church since I know of no direct writing that limits it exclusively to matters of faith and morals but to show a reason for writing this, when you say “faith and morality” this can cover almost anything you can think of four our faith and morals extend over all things. So it is easier to say that there are no limitations but that namely they reside within direct matters of faith and morals. The reason why people enjoy hearing “faith and morals” restrictively because they see theses as mere men but when the Church speaks infallibility it is not the men but the Almighty Lord God speaking through them, thus to limit the Church’s infallible attribute is to limit God. This is something I try to avoid doing. (Generally speaking) :sweat:

We are bound by the "authentic magisterium" to respectfully heed those things proposed by the Church and avoid those things contrary to them even if they are simply theological opinion of the Pope regardless if they are true or false. This can be found in the Code of Canon Law.[quote][b]Code of Canon Law for the Latin Rite[/b]
[b]Can. 752[/b] Although not an assent of faith, a religious submission of the intellect and will must be given to a doctrine which the Supreme Pontiff or the college of bishops declares concerning faith or morals when they exercise the authentic magisterium, even if they do not intend to proclaim it by definitive act; therefore, the Christian faithful are to take care to avoid those things which do not agree with it.
[url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM[/url][/quote][quote][b]Code of Canon Law for the Latin Rite[/b]
[b]Can. 753[/b] Although the bishops who are in communion with the head and members of the college, whether individually or joined together in conferences of bishops or in particular councils, do not possess infallibility in teaching, they are authentic teachers and instructors of the faith for the Christian faithful entrusted to their care; the Christian faithful are bound to adhere with religious submission of mind to the authentic magisterium of their bishops.
[url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM"]http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/__P2H.HTM[/url][/quote]

thessalonian
Posted

This might be of some use.

50 Proofs of the Papacy

[url="http://www.deoomnisgloria.com/archives/2003/12/dave_armstrong.html"]http://www.deoomnisgloria.com/archives/200..._armstrong.html[/url]

thessalonian
Posted

I agree we must have an attitude of submission, even for those things that are not strictly infallibly declared or faith and morals. I think your understanding of Can 753 is off a bit. Don't see the point here in debating it however. As I said, infallibility ONLY applies to F & M. You are quite incorrect there and are confusing papal supremacy with infallibility. Read the decrees of Vatican II. Infallibility is only F & M. And no, F & M is not everything. What A I have said is in no way a violation of the first canon you site. Doctrine is to be followed even if it has not been infallibly declared.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1223178' date='Mar 30 2007, 04:23 PM']I agree we must have an attitude of submission, even for those things that are not strictly infallibly declared or faith and morals. [1] I think your understanding of Can 753 is off a bit [2]. Don't see the point here in debating it however. [3] As I said, infallibility ONLY applies to F & M. [4] You are quite incorrect there and are confusing papal supremacy with infallibility. [5] Read the decrees of Vatican II. [6] Infallibility is only F & M. [7] And no, F & M is not everything. [8] What A I have said is in no way a violation of the first canon you site. [9] Doctrine is to be followed even if it has not been infallibly declared. [10][/quote][[b]1[/b]] That is not what the Canon Law writes or what the Church teaches, but it is not as important to belief as a Dogmatic Law. ([i]Such as the Assumption, Immaculate Conception, No Female Priests, ect[/i])
[[b]2[/b]] I mentioned it because it is relevant, I did not quote it because I was referencing it. So I am unsure you understand my view of this provision of canon law?
[[b]3[/b]] Respectfully abstain from comment.
[[b]4[/b]] I would willingly believe this if such a document can be fetched that it restrictively names directive matters of faith and morals.
[[b]5[/b]] I never mentioned in either of my posts Papal supremacy or even primacy. The point I make is that infallible statements are not on the authority of the Pope or Bishops but rather the authority of Almighty God... and the words they speak are of God thus cannot be limited. I am confused to what your comment means?
[[b]6[/b]] I have and I enjoyed them...
[[b]7[/b]] Same as responce number four.
[[b]8[/b]] Are not all things relevant to God?
[[b]9[/b]] I am not your judge but it certainly puts a question mark over my head...
[[b]10[/b]] Correct![quote][b]The First Vatican Council[/b]
"We teach and define that it is a dogma Divinely revealed that the Roman pontiff when he speaks ex cathedra, that is when in discharge of the office of pastor and doctor of all Christians, by virtue of his supreme Apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine regarding faith or morals to be held by the universal Church, by the Divine assistance promised to him in Blessed Peter, is [u]possessed of that infallibility with [b]which the Divine Redeemer willed that his Church[/b] should be endowed in defining doctrine regarding faith or morals[/u], and that therefore such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves and not from the consent of the Church irreformable. So then, should anyone, which God forbid, have the temerity to reject this definition of ours: [b][color="#FF0000"]let him be anathema[/color][/b]."[/quote]I had to go look up this quote again... But what I write does not contradict anything here... [b]But since I see how it could be confusing [u]I will avoid writing this in the future[/u] untill I can remember where I saw this theology (posted above) was written[/b]... But then I think of what the Second Vatican Council wrote...[quote][b]The Second Vatican Council[/b]
"This Sacred Council, following closely in the footsteps of the First Vatican Council, with that Council teaches and declares that Jesus Christ, the eternal Shepherd, established His holy Church, having sent forth the apostles as He Himself had been sent by the Father; and He willed that their successors, namely the bishops, should be shepherds in His Church even to the consummation of the world. And in order that the episcopate itself might be one and undivided, He placed Blessed Peter over the other apostles, and instituted in him a permanent and visible source and foundation of unity of faith and communion. And all this teaching about the institution, the perpetuity, the meaning and reason for the sacred primacy of the Roman Pontiff and of his infallible magisterium, this Sacred Council again proposes to be firmly believed by all the faithful."[/quote]No mention of "faith or morals."

[b]Although... we may want to take this into private because this isnt exactly on topic... But I think it is important to point out there is very little difference in what you or I have said and this is just arguing semantics. Something I would rather not engage in...[/b]

Edited by Mr.CatholicCat
thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote][9]I am not your judge but it certainly puts a question mark over my head...[/quote]

:blink: And you likewise. I'll not bother with this any further. It's not just sematntics. I've never heard ANYONE preist or Bishop or Pope or noted apologist define things the way that you are.

Edited by thessalonian
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Okay, in simple terms, what's this debate over?

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1223233' date='Mar 30 2007, 05:25 PM']Okay, in simple terms, what's this debate over?[/quote]


It's just over.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1223236' date='Mar 30 2007, 04:29 PM']It's just over.[/quote]
Okay then.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1223236' date='Mar 30 2007, 04:29 PM']It's just over.[/quote]
Okay then.

Posted

[quote]6. For canonization another miracle is needed, attributed to the intercession of the Blessed and having occurred after his beatification. The methods for ascertainment of the affirmed miracle are the same as those followed for beatification. Canonization is understood as the concession of public worship in the Universal Church. [b][u]Pontifical infallibility is involved[/u][/b]. With canonization, the Blessed acquires the title of Saint."
[url="http://www.catholic-forum.com/saints/sjs00003.htm"]http://www.catholic-forum.com/saints/sjs00003.htm[/url][/quote]I have been really thinking about this subject and reflecting; according to what I read the canonization of a Saint by the Pope is an infallible statement (if it is concerning their practice of Heroic Christian Virtue or if they reside in Heaven I understand is debated). Would this be an extension of “faith” if infallible statements are restricted to only faith and morals?

I cannot seem to find the writing I read about infallibility just not being limited to faith in morals, even though it does make sense to me, but in light of what I am finding I will retract my statements prior.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Mr.CatholicCat' post='1223321' date='Mar 30 2007, 08:28 PM']I have been really thinking about this subject and reflecting; according to what I read the canonization of a Saint by the Pope is an infallible statement (if it is concerning their practice of Heroic Christian Virtue or if they reside in Heaven I understand is debated). Would this be an extension of “faith” if infallible statements are restricted to only faith and morals?

I cannot seem to find the writing I read about infallibility just not being limited to faith in morals, even though it does make sense to me, but in light of what I am finding I will retract my statements prior.[/quote]
But this is related to the faith.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...