Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Things That Make A Catholic Go Hmmmmmmmmm.


Recommended Posts

Guest Resonate
Posted

Last night I was watching a movie with my wife called "The Guardian". A scene goes something like this:

Two of the characters get in a bar fight defending the "name" of the United States Coast Guard. One of the characters when confronted by his superiors responded with, "Your gonna send me home because I was defending the name of the US Coast Guard?" The superior responded with, "The Coast Guard has been around for over 200 years and it doesn't need a 23 year old kid like you to defend it."

I've been active in Lay ministry for the Roman Catholic Church for over ten years. Over the last few weeks I have been struggling. As much as I love the divine side of our Church, the human side (mostly religious) who work in our dioceses are on the brinks of burning me out. Generally speaking, most do not have a clue what working in the trenches in the year 2007 is like. I am sure the 1970s was a great decade but it is time to 'let go of it'.

Just for kicks, I dropped in on a non-catholic church's worship service last week. From the moment I stepped out of my car, I could feel the Holy Spirit moving all around me. As I walked in to the church, it was evident that Christ was there among the thousands of people who were worshiping and praying.

Why should I live my life worshiping and serving in a church that does not bring me peace and hope? I truly believe in the Eucharist but isn't that same Christ in Holy Scripture (the Word of God, the Word made Flesh)? The Sacraments are great but if they have so much strength and power why do the ones who administer them struggle with mortal sin so much? While the Church holds hostage the Sacraments it does not have a monopoly on the Holy Spirit. If God's grace knows no bounds, would He not accept those who bathe in the Spirit in their worship services? Really, if they are so "separated" from Catholics then why does the Holy Spirit attend their services???

The biggest void in the Catholic Church is that space between Her altar and the people who sits in the pews across from it.
Ironically, in the non-Catholic churches the space between their altar and pews/chairs is THE EXACT PLACE where everyone ends up by the end of their services.

Look, you do not have to convince me that the Roman Catholic Church is the church that Christ founded. However, I have this urge to go sit with the Protestants until God calls all of us "Catholics" home. Really, if the Catholic Church is all that, does it really need me to help it??? I will always be Catholic, but you might have to find me at the prayer service next door.


Blessed,

Resonate

Posted (edited)

I am an ex-Catholic, notice youre newer here, I left over many reasons, finding out that scripture did not match with Catholic teachings, my rejection of the Catholic as well as Protesatnt interfaith movement, since I am an ex universalist and I believe the Catholic Church is the counterfeit curch warned of in Revelation.

One thing to realize is that ones salvation is NOT based on church membership but if you hvae been saved in Jesus Christ? This is not about partaking of a Eucharist or sacraments but repenting and turning yourself over to Jesus Christ in Faith. One does not work for salvation this is a free gift via Gods grace.

There are many good and nice people in the Catholic Church who do search for God, but I believe because of the false teachings they being cheated. I was once where you were, realizing something was missing even though I was an RE teacher and had friends within the church.

There is a void in the Catholic Church, because it is not about the body of Christ and Jesus, but a false system that has elevated a clergy class and its sacraments {so called middle man} that they teach you need to gain Gods graces.

There are many Catholics who are not being fed within the Catholic Church. I was one of them. I turned to Bible reading, and searching for Gods will via His word. Many do visit other churches. even my last indpt Baptist church had a few Catholics coming with one step in and one step out, because they knew they were not being fed.

I will pray for you, my suggestion is to get down on your knees and pray for God to show you the truth and start a daily study of His word.

[mod]We don't link to anti-Catholic websites. -Raphael[/mod]

Edited by Raphael
Birgitta Noel
Posted

Budge, do you know what a sacrament is?

Do you understand that we are bound by the sacraments, but God is not?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Resonate' post='1224674' date='Mar 31 2007, 09:36 PM']The biggest void in the Catholic Church is that space between Her altar and the people who sits in the pews across from it.
Ironically, in the non-Catholic churches the space between their altar and pews/chairs is THE EXACT PLACE where everyone ends up by the end of their services.[/quote]
I'm going to address your whole post, but this really struck me, because as a former Protestant this is EXACTLY where I feel the MOST connection in the Catholic church.

As a Catholic it is really important to remember what we have, while still acknowledging that we can continue to grow. You say you believe in the Eucharist, that this is truly Christ. There are many things that set the Catholic Church apart, but this one thing is more precious than all others. It is the Eucharist that bridges the gap between the pews and the altar. It is here that the divine meets the human, that the connection is made between heaven and earth. And it's here that we are each called to partake every week.

You are right to point out that the Christ of the Bible is the same Christ of the Eucharist. Ever notice how the Mass is divided into two halves, the liturgy of the Word, and the Liturgy of the Eucharist? This is no accident. In every Mass, we acknowledge Christ the Word made Flesh -- we incorporate both into every single service. The focus of each and every Protestant service is the Word alone. While there is communion, it is not the same. It is an imbalanced presentation of Christ. And we need to remember that the "made Flesh" part of the service is very important. The Incarnation is the focal point of history. The Incarnation, and Christ's subsequent sacrifice to atone for our sins, is what allows us to commune with God.

The Holy Spirit does work in Protestant churches, no big surprise there. And there are good things happening in Protestant churches. There's a lot of excitement among lay people in many Protestant churches that I have yet to find in a Catholic Church on any sort of large scale. I guess I'd say that your desire to worship with Protestants is not a bad thing -- in fact, that should be the desire of [i]every[/i] Catholic. These divisions in the body -- they're painful. We're called to be unified, and we should desire that unity.

My brother is Protestant, and he and I were recently talking about this very thing. This is how I described it to him: Every Sunday, the Church comes together for a giant holiday meal, like Thanksgiving. 500 years ago, Protestants decided that they no longer wanted to eat at the same table, so they up and left and started their own holiday celebrations. They are still family -- still grow from the same vine -- but they're separated brethren, and they no longer eat at the same table, and are not nourished by the same meal. That's not to say that those left at the table are perfect -- none of us are -- but we're still sitting at the table. And we are called to encourage our brothers to rejoin us at the table.

So I guess I'd say, if you're feeling burned out, revisit what it means to be Catholic. Meditate on the Eucharist. Go to adoration. That's not to say that prayer services are bad, but I would urge you to be think carefully about your motivation for being there. If you're not being fed spiritually by the Body of Christ, you will not find fulfillment anywhere else.

Hope I'm not being too condescending or whatever. Thanks for posting. :)

Edited by Terra Firma
Birgitta Noel
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Resonate' post='1224674' date='Mar 31 2007, 10:36 PM']Last night I was watching a movie with my wife called "The Guardian". A scene goes something like this:

Two of the characters get in a bar fight defending the "name" of the United States Coast Guard. One of the characters when confronted by his superiors responded with, "Your gonna send me home because I was defending the name of the US Coast Guard?" The superior responded with, "The Coast Guard has been around for over 200 years and it doesn't need a 23 year old kid like you to defend it."

I've been active in Lay ministry for the Roman Catholic Church for over ten years. Over the last few weeks I have been struggling. As much as I love the divine side of our Church, the human side (mostly religious) who work in our dioceses are on the brinks of burning me out. Generally speaking, most do not have a clue what working in the trenches in the year 2007 is like. I am sure the 1970s was a great decade but it is time to 'let go of it'.

Just for kicks, I dropped in on a non-catholic church's worship service last week. From the moment I stepped out of my car, I could feel the Holy Spirit moving all around me. As I walked in to the church, it was evident that Christ was there among the thousands of people who were worshiping and praying.

Why should I live my life worshiping and serving in a church that does not bring me peace and hope? I truly believe in the Eucharist but isn't that same Christ in Holy Scripture (the Word of God, the Word made Flesh)? The Sacraments are great but if they have so much strength and power why do the ones who administer them struggle with mortal sin so much? While the Church holds hostage the Sacraments it does not have a monopoly on the Holy Spirit. If God's grace knows no bounds, would He not accept those who bathe in the Spirit in their worship services? Really, if they are so "separated" from Catholics then why does the Holy Spirit attend their services???

The biggest void in the Catholic Church is that space between Her altar and the people who sits in the pews across from it.
Ironically, in the non-Catholic churches the space between their altar and pews/chairs is THE EXACT PLACE where everyone ends up by the end of their services.

Look, you do not have to convince me that the Roman Catholic Church is the church that Christ founded. However, I have this urge to go sit with the Protestants until God calls all of us "Catholics" home. Really, if the Catholic Church is all that, does it really need me to help it??? I will always be Catholic, but you might have to find me at the prayer service next door.
Blessed,

Resonate[/quote]


I can understand your frustration, but do you really think that leaving is the answer? What sort of a witness is it to say that you believe in the Eucharist, but that you are willing to leave it behind? That seems tantamount to saying to Christ, "Thanks for your gift, but I'm going over here for now." Burnout is common in Church work, but remember the grass is always greener.

My humble suggestion would be to take some time (and time off from your work if you can) to reconnect with Christ. Go to adoration, sit in contemplation and in awe of His love. Get back to basics.

As for the humanity of Christ's priests remember Christ knew there would be priests who would sin. After all, He chose Judas as well as Peter. We are all human. I know a man whose wife said to him, "You think you're so great, you go to mass every day and yet you continue to sin by drinking, being verbally abusive, etc." He turned to her and said quietly, "Yes, and I cannot imagine how I would be without mass."

Don't give up. The Church (indeed every church) is run by humans. And remember that our separated brothers and sisters are separated from us, but they have some of the truth, they just lack the full truth. So, yes, the Holy Spirit et al may be present, but that's no justification for abandoning Catholicism. You'd be giving up the whole for only part.

May God bless you in your struggles and :welcome: to PM. I hope we'll see more of you around these here parts!

Edited by The Little Way
Posted

[quote name='Resonate' post='1224674' date='Mar 31 2007, 11:36 PM']Last night I was watching a movie with my wife called "The Guardian". A scene goes something like this:

Two of the characters get in a bar fight defending the "name" of the United States Coast Guard. One of the characters when confronted by his superiors responded with, "Your gonna send me home because I was defending the name of the US Coast Guard?" The superior responded with, "The Coast Guard has been around for over 200 years and it doesn't need a 23 year old kid like you to defend it."

I've been active in Lay ministry for the Roman Catholic Church for over ten years. Over the last few weeks I have been struggling. As much as I love the divine side of our Church, the human side (mostly religious) who work in our dioceses are on the brinks of burning me out. Generally speaking, most do not have a clue what working in the trenches in the year 2007 is like. I am sure the 1970s was a great decade but it is time to 'let go of it'.

Just for kicks, I dropped in on a non-catholic church's worship service last week. From the moment I stepped out of my car, I could feel the Holy Spirit moving all around me. As I walked in to the church, it was evident that Christ was there among the thousands of people who were worshiping and praying.

Why should I live my life worshiping and serving in a church that does not bring me peace and hope? I truly believe in the Eucharist but isn't that same Christ in Holy Scripture (the Word of God, the Word made Flesh)? The Sacraments are great but if they have so much strength and power why do the ones who administer them struggle with mortal sin so much? While the Church holds hostage the Sacraments it does not have a monopoly on the Holy Spirit. If God's grace knows no bounds, would He not accept those who bathe in the Spirit in their worship services? Really, if they are so "separated" from Catholics then why does the Holy Spirit attend their services???

The biggest void in the Catholic Church is that space between Her altar and the people who sits in the pews across from it.
Ironically, in the non-Catholic churches the space between their altar and pews/chairs is THE EXACT PLACE where everyone ends up by the end of their services.

Look, you do not have to convince me that the Roman Catholic Church is the church that Christ founded. However, I have this urge to go sit with the Protestants until God calls all of us "Catholics" home. Really, if the Catholic Church is all that, does it really need me to help it??? I will always be Catholic, but you might have to find me at the prayer service next door.
Blessed,

Resonate[/quote]

I understand your frustration and I will be praying for you. But keep in mind that God does not give us carte blanche to run away from the Church even if she is in the pits. The Reformation, the Lefebvrist movement and other various impulses were reactions to extremely negative situations within the Church, but the bad things do not justify throwing up our hands and saying, "I give up on this."

There is the famous story about St. Bernard, which you may already be familiar with. St. Bernard was sent to a parish to try to help the parish priest, who was really, really rotten. He mistreated the laity, he embezzled from the collection plate, he had a concubine and was a drunkard. St. Bernard tried to reason with the priest, talk to him, exhort him, scream at him, all in vain. He gave up and decided to leave. St. Bernard made one last visit to the parish's tabernacle, and said, "I’m sorry, Lord. I failed, and now I’m leaving."

Then he heard a voice from the tabernacle:

"Well, I’m staying."

The Eucharist and the other sacraments are not just great. Christ is present in the Word, it is true, but His presence par excellence is in the Blessed Sacrament. Again I'll be praying for you. God bless you! :sign:

Guest Resonate
Posted

I really appreciate the responses. Thank you for taking the time to reply.

Take care,

Resonate

Archaeology cat
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1224786' date='Apr 1 2007, 05:26 AM']I'm going to address your whole post, but this really struck me, because as a former Protestant this is EXACTLY where I feel the MOST connection in the Catholic church.[/quote]

I second this one. I never felt that connection when I was Protestant, but coming to the altar to partake of the Eucharist, at every Mass, not just once a quarter, I feel so intimately connected to God, and to everyone else in the Catholic Church.

As for the other parts, I think Terra Firma, The Little Way, and Maggie said it a bit better.

I'll pray, Resonate. :bigpray:

Edited by Archaeology cat
Posted

The false teaching of the Eucharist keeps many in the Catholic Church, even people who KNOW as a church it is failing them spiritually.

The idea that only the Catholic clergy can "confect" the only valid "god" wafer, keeps many in and I believe it is one of the main sources of bondage.

Its a perfect teaching for cementing the power of the clergy class.

Without US, you cannot receive "GOD"

Without US, giving you permission, you cannot receive "GOD"

Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1225600' date='Apr 1 2007, 06:37 AM']I second this one. I never felt that connection when I was Protestant, but coming to the altar to partake of the Eucharist, at every Mass, not just once a quarter, I feel so intimately connected to God, and to everyone else in the Catholic Church.[/quote]
:yes:
It's a connection of a different type than what I enjoyed as a Protestant ... it's deeper and more meaningful than chit-chat over coffee and donuts in the gallery, or even than a three-hour-long prayer service.

[quote name='Budge' post='1225639' date='Apr 1 2007, 08:36 AM']The false teaching of the Eucharist keeps many in the Catholic Church, even people who KNOW as a church it is failing them spiritually.

The idea that only the Catholic clergy can "confect" the only valid "god" wafer, keeps many in and I believe it is one of the main sources of bondage.

Its a perfect teaching for cementing the power of the clergy class.

Without US, you cannot receive "GOD"

Without US, giving you permission, you cannot receive "GOD"[/quote]
Actually, it was the Eucharist that brought me INTO the Catholic Church, after I became convicted that Jesus flesh is real food, and his blood is real drink. No Protestant church (except the Anglican/Episcopalians) purports to give the real Body and Blood of Christ in Communion. And now I know it's the real thing, and I appreciate the strictures put on reception by the Church, because it teaches me proper reverence.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1225643' date='Apr 1 2007, 04:01 PM']Actually, it was the Eucharist that brought me INTO the Catholic Church, after I became convicted that Jesus flesh is real food, and his blood is real drink. No Protestant church (except the Anglican/Episcopalians) purports to give the real Body and Blood of Christ in Communion. And now I know it's the real thing, and I appreciate the strictures put on reception by the Church, because it teaches me proper reverence.[/quote]

Again, I second that. When I studied the Scriptures on the Real Presence, and looked at all the Eucharistic miracles, I had no doubts about it at all. Yes, I can connect with God in other ways as well, but that way is so powerful.

Posted

First off welcome to the board Resonate! I hope you stick around!! I certainly hope you come back and check the responses to your thread.

Weird thing is I watched the Guardian last night. And while it was slightly more entertaining then the Da Vinci Code, I don't think it was good enough to drive anyone from the Church.

I worked for the Church as a lay minister for 10 years so I can, well, *ahem* resonate with what you're feeling. You are in a very unique situation within the Church. People who work in Church ministry are the absolute last to be ministered to, if at all. I also understand the draw and the charisma of some protestant services and pastors. There was an amazing pastor at my uncle's funeral on Friday. The crowd of over a thousand hung on his every word. (As did I) He had the rare gift of being able to help heal through his words. My father, who is not an overly emotional man, hugged him like he had just pulled him out the raging seas (Guardian reference). He was so good, it made me miss the few priests that I've known who could do the same.

I also can empathize with having to work with ineffective out of touch ministers within the diocese and your parish. I was at my first parish for four years. I built up the strongest program in the diocese. But if I had a nickel for every time the parish administrator threatened to fire me, I'd be retired. (For the record, the 70s was actually a pretty good decade) The reality is that most who get into ministry don't really minister. They create programs. Less than 10% actually have any experience being in the trenches and doing real ministry. And they are an additional burden to those of us who did go into the trenches.

Those in my life who know my history over the past 20 years, know that I have more than ample reasons to leave the Church. And several have asked "Why would you possibly want to stick around?" While I have several excellent reasons to leave (none of which will be shared in a public forum) I have one resounding reason to stay.

I am in love with Holy Mother Church.

Because of that fact, I will stay committed to her. When members of her hierarchy have done me wrong, I will stay with Her. When there are times that I feel distanced and disenfranchised (and there are), I will stay with Her. And while the warmth, peace and hopefulness of another church may be a strong draw, I know in my heart that it can never reach the depth of love that I have for the Catholic Church.

You mentioned that you're married. I would imagine that there are times that are harder than others. There are moments in your marriage when you do not feel peace or hopeful. (If not, I would imagine that you will sometime) But I would imagine that you are deeply in love with your wife. And its in that love that you find the commitment and strength to carry on through those times.

It is my hope and prayer that your love for the Church can do the same for you through this time of hardship.

Posted

great post, hot stuff. :)

Posted

I see that Maggie, The Little Way, and Terra Firma have already given you some good replies. "forgive me, Lord, for I am frustrated and burned out" is a legitimate prayer, as far as I am concerned :)

maybe you need a stress break? Like say a weekend silent retreat? Any retreat centers in your town/city? Any monasteries within a day trip?

Guest Resonate
Posted (edited)

My wife and I are devout Catholics... Like in Romans 3:16 we feel our faith should be all or nothing. We do not smoke, drink, use profanity, and we pray a great deal. Unfortunately, this lifestyle is not attractive to others our age. People assume that because we are "holy rollers" that being friends with us would be more work than anything else. This leaves us feeling isolated. As you know, we are sinners as much as anyone else.

My position in the church gives me a perspective on church politics more than most which can be very frustrating and disappointing. I know it seems like I am whining and with the liturgical season of Lent, it is a bit ironic. However, I feel like my faith/spirituality has been run over by a freight train. It is very difficult for me to not whine when I feel like I am holding my guts in my hands. Sorry for the imagery.

A quick comment towards the Catholic Bashers who have visited the thread. I appreciate your thoughts and words but for me it is "more of the same of what I already have". By the nature of this forum I am able to see your other posts, the quantity of your posts, and the content of them. It stands to reason that if you spend most of your time condemning another person's faith than you too must be a bit unsettled in your own faith.

What attracts me to non-Catholic church services are the way they pray and the way they worship. I wish we had that within our Holy Mass. Many Catholic Church leaders and laity would say that there is not any room for that sort of thing in the Holy Mass.

We might have 1200 people show up to Mass but 1100 of them are text messaging, doing their nails, giving their kids crayons and cheerios, reading the bulletin, and talking about the family in the other pew. In the name of "saving", "unifying", "protecting" the liturgy, I feel we are sacrificing a lot more. All of this is a huge can of worms that can be debated until the end of time. Which while that debate is going on, I still want to quietly excuse myself from the heated arguments attend the 20-minute daily morning Mass and go over to the Bible Church for fellowship, additional prayer, and worship.

This isn't something that I can fix alone or change or even feel like I have the energy to be a part of such a movement. The issues of the Catholic Church are way bigger than I and I would rather spend my life in an environment of peace, hope, and love. Not to mention that as a Father, I have a responsibility to providing nourishment to my children's faith life as well. It seems to me that my kids would be able to find Christ more in the Protestant Church's Youth Softball league than at any Religious Education class that I've seen. Just my humble opinion.


Thank you for your support and prayers.

In Christ,

Resonate

Edited by Resonate
Posted

[quote name='Resonate' post='1225678' date='Apr 2 2007, 12:35 AM']My wife and I are devout Catholics... Like in Romans 3:16 we feel our faith should be all or nothing. We do not smoke, drink, use profanity, and we pray a great deal. Unfortunately, this lifestyle is not attractive to others our age. People assume that because we are "holy rollers" that being friends with us would be more work than anything else. This leaves us feeling isolated. As you know, we are sinners as much as anyone else.

My position in the church gives me a perspective on church politics more than most which can be very frustrating and disappointing. I know it seems like I am whining and with the liturgical season of Lent, it is a bit ironic. However, I feel like my faith/spirituality has been run over by a freight train. It is very difficult for me to not whine when I feel like I am holding my guts in my hands. Sorry for the imagery.

...
What attracts me to non-Catholic church services are the way they pray and the way they worship. I wish we had that within our Holy Mass. Many Catholic Church leaders and laity would say that there is not any room for that sort of thing in the Holy Mass.

We might have 1200 people show up to Mass but 1100 of them are text messaging, doing their nails, giving their kids crayons and cheerios, reading the bulletin, and talking about the family in the other pew. In the name of "saving", "unifying", "protecting" the liturgy, I feel we are sacrificing a lot more. All of this is a huge can of worms that can be debated until the end of time. Which while that debate is going on, I still want to quietly excuse myself from the heated arguments attend the 20-minute daily morning Mass and go over to the Bible Church for fellowship, additional prayer, and worship.

This isn't something that I can fix alone or change or even feel like I have the energy to be a part of such a movement. The issues of the Catholic Church are way bigger than I and I would rather spend my life in an environment of peace, hope, and love. Not to mention that as a Father, I have a responsibility to providing nourishment to my children's faith life as well. It seems to me that my kids would be able to find Christ more in the Protestant Church's Youth Softball league than at any Religious Education class that I've seen. Just my humble opinion.
Thank you for your support and prayers.

In Christ,

Resonate[/quote]

I personally don't know anything about being a lay minister so I can't advise you on that side of things. I know there are different kinds of parishes and each one has its own charism, just as each religious order does. Some have charismatic prayer groups, which might give you more of the feeling of the Holy Spirit that you are looking for. And some are very kid-friendly and have great youth groups. One that I went to in Northern California had the teenagers going out for prayers over pizza! It sounds as if your parish has turned you against the Church. There are great Protestant churches and poor ones as well, just as there are Catholic parishes that suit different people.

I can tell you that God has an interesting sense of humor when it comes to his friends (and I am assuming that you are one of His friends too)... just look at St Teresa of Avila.

I am entering a cloistered Carmelite convent in July (at age 55) and I greatly admire St Teresa of Avila. She was a woman who had to deal with the politics of the Church and the stresses of trying to reform her own order... plus she had to face the Inquisition!

...and through it all, she also had to face day to day living...

[url="http://www.goodgroundpress.com/index.asp?PageAction=Custom&ID=71"]Teresa of Avila[/url]
[i]On her journeys through Spain where she established many Carmelite convents, she constantly called upon God. Even those who know little about St. Teresa of Avila may have heard her famous quip to God. In 1582 while on her way to make her last Carmelite foundation, where in fact she died, she and her companions encountered life-threatening flood conditions. Standing in a river torrent, she complained: [b]“Lord, amid so many ills this comes on top of all the rest.” A Voice answered her, “Teresa, that is how I treat my friends.” She retorted, “Ah, my God! That is why you have so few of them!” [/b] [/i]

but always she put her faith in God...

[i]“Let nothing disturb you,
let nothing cause you fear
All things pass.
God is unchanging.
Patience obtains all:
Whoever has God
needs nothing else.
God alone suffices.” [/i]

This poem, found as a bookmark in St. Teresa's prayer book, tells of her complete trust in God. GOD ALONE SUFFICES!

I am sorry that you have not had the human love and support that you have needed while doing your service for God. But don't give up on Him. There is only one holy Catholic and apostolic Church, and instead of running away from it, we need to help it. Sure it's hard, but Jesus faced much more for us, so is it too much for Him to ask us to help his Church? If you can see the faults, then you can help with the solutions. St. Teresa could have just declared the Carmelite order a waste of time, but instead she spent her life trying to reform it. Instead of running off to the Protestants, help fix the Church and bring them back home again. And if the battle is too hard, then give it to Him to fight - through prayer. Anyway, just my humble opinion, as someone who knows the Church is flawed, but who wants to dedicate her life anyway, for His sake. I will pray that you find the strength to stay true to your faith through your love of God.

Yours in His love,
Annie

Posted (edited)

[quote]y wife and I are devout Catholics... Like in Romans 3:16 we feel our faith should be all or nothing. We do not smoke, drink, use profanity, and we pray a great deal. Unfortunately, this lifestyle is not attractive to others our age. People assume that because we are "holy rollers" that being friends with us would be more work than anything else. This leaves us feeling isolated. As you know, we are sinners as much as anyone else.[/quote]Im glad you have this devotion and that you are follow scripture and Gods comamndments. I believe the same to be honest with you, I feel the Catholic Church as well as most mainline protestant denominations have seperated themselves from any true Christian commitment and conviction.
[quote]
My position in the church gives me a perspective on church politics more than most which can be very frustrating and disappointing. I know it seems like I am whining and with the liturgical season of Lent, it is a bit ironic. However, I feel like my faith/spirituality has been run over by a freight train. It is very difficult for me to not whine when I feel like I am holding my guts in my hands. Sorry for the imagery.[/quote]

Hey you have seen the inner workings behind the scenese. Even I when I volunteered as a RE teacher in the last Catholic church I was in, saw some of the politics, including the weird rule the priest had to follow from the bishop about how he was not supposed to make any "personal friends" with anyone in the church, the RE director gave a lunch invite to the priest at her home with her family and was turned down, and other weird stuff like that. Totally different from my next Christian church where we visited each others homes and shared many meals together including with the pastor and his wife.

[quote]
A quick comment towards the Catholic Bashers who have visited the thread. I appreciate your thoughts and words but for me it is "more of the same of what I already have". By the nature of this forum I am able to see your other posts, the quantity of your posts, and the content of them. It stands to reason that if you spend most of your time condemning another person's faith than you too must be a bit unsettled in your own faith.[/quote]Hey Im trying to help you. Why wouldnt I condemn Catholicism if I believe it is a false religon? I am an EX-Catholic by the way as I told you.
[quote]

We might have 1200 people show up to Mass but 1100 of them are text messaging, doing their nails, giving their kids crayons and cheerios, reading the bulletin, and talking about the family in the other pew. In the name of "saving", "unifying", "protecting" the liturgy, I feel we are sacrificing a lot more. All of this is a huge can of worms that can be debated until the end of time. Which while that debate is going on, I still want to quietly excuse myself from the heated arguments attend the 20-minute daily morning Mass and go over to the Bible Church for fellowship, additional prayer, and worship.[/quote]

When I left the Catholic Church I entered a wonderful church, I was in for many years, sadly I had to move away. It was an indpt Bpatist church, and there we were fed Gods Word, had wonderful worship, and I learned what real Christian fellowship was like. THere is no way in the Catholic church I would have had 8 church members showing up to help because I got sick on moving day. They even gave me a dinner to say goodbye. I miss all of them horribly and plan to go back to visit as soon as I can. You know I want you to make sure your relationship with Christ comes first, but the difference I found between my last church and the Catholic Church couldnt even compare. After I was saved, I was strengthened and edified in Gods Word, I realize how fortunate I was that I was in a church that adhered to Gods Word, and led by the Holy Spirit especially considering the churches even in evangelism that are rapidly falling away.

As a father, you do have to think of your kids and what they will learn and where your family can become closer to Jesus Christ and be fed His Word.

Edited by Budge
cmotherofpirl
Posted

THis thread is not a debate so its being moved.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Welcome to Phatmass, Resonate. :) I saw this last night, but didn't reply because it was late.

I'm about to graduate with a degree in Catechetics. Like hot stuff, I'm very familiar with the work of lay ministry in the Church today (and the politics, too). I must say that sometimes it can be tiring. It's especially hard for me to be at the campus I attend, because most of the people have really lively faith. They're at Mass singing vibrantly, the priests really bring life into their homilies, there's a 24 hour perpetual adoration chapel, etc. However, I'm a more laid back kinda guy and I don't get as emotionally excited as they generally do. At first glance, someone might think that I'm not really into it, but I love our Catholic faith and I think it's beautiful...I'm just not an energetic person. Then come the actual statistics...at a school where most of the people go to Mass every day of the week, 70% of the men are addicted to pornography. Liveliness, for all it's worth, apparently isn't a sign of sanctity. Then I look at myself and my own flaws...and it hurts. We really are a hospital for sinners. It's like Jesus said...there will be weeds sown in among the wheat...we can't look for a field of pure wheat, because we have a guarantee that that is not the true Church. Our Lord, while present in the Scriptures, is substantially present in the Eucharist. I guess my point is that if we want to see the life of the Church, we need to look toward Christ, not toward each other and not toward ourselves...and if we look toward Him, He will help us to remove whatever obstructs our vision and He will give us peace.

The Holy Spirit is the soul of the Church. He's here among us. The problem is that we're just not always open to Him. Even when we are open to Him, we still screw up. I guess that's why He's the Advocate and Consoler, because we need one.

Work to bring the Holy Spirit to your parish. Ask the Holy Spirit to be poured out into your heart and into your parish and try to enliven it. Know that your task is to renew the Catholic Church, always in need of renewal, not to leave her for community lacking all the gifts she has by nature. Non-Catholic communities can have the Holy Spirit working in them, but He is trying to bring them to the Catholic Church. Alive with the Spirit, the Body of Christ, the Church, is fully alive and beautiful. Without the Spirit, she remains the Body of Christ, but she has less soul to her. That Holy Spirit works among non-Catholics who are imperfectly bound to the Body of Christ not to authenticate their teaching, but to lead them toward the Catholic Church, because He knows that we need those people who are open to the Spirit, to be leaven for us. I beg you to take your love of the Holy Spirit, to grow in it, and to be leaven in your Church so that the Body of Christ may be made fully alive with the Holy Spirit, who now is restricted by closed-hearts to work more among those who lack the fullness of the Body, but are willing to accept the Soul.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

[quote name='Resonate' post='1225678' date='Apr 1 2007, 12:35 PM']My wife and I are devout Catholics... Like in Romans 3:16 we feel our faith should be all or nothing. We do not smoke, drink, use profanity, and we pray a great deal. Unfortunately, this lifestyle is not attractive to others our age. People assume that because we are "holy rollers" that being friends with us would be more work than anything else. This leaves us feeling isolated. As you know, we are sinners as much as anyone else.

My position in the church gives me a perspective on church politics more than most which can be very frustrating and disappointing. I know it seems like I am whining and with the liturgical season of Lent, it is a bit ironic. However, I feel like my faith/spirituality has been run over by a freight train. It is very difficult for me to not whine when I feel like I am holding my guts in my hands. Sorry for the imagery.

A quick comment towards the Catholic Bashers who have visited the thread. I appreciate your thoughts and words but for me it is "more of the same of what I already have". By the nature of this forum I am able to see your other posts, the quantity of your posts, and the content of them. It stands to reason that if you spend most of your time condemning another person's faith than you too must be a bit unsettled in your own faith.

What attracts me to non-Catholic church services are the way they pray and the way they worship. I wish we had that within our Holy Mass. Many Catholic Church leaders and laity would say that there is not any room for that sort of thing in the Holy Mass.

We might have 1200 people show up to Mass but 1100 of them are text messaging, doing their nails, giving their kids crayons and cheerios, reading the bulletin, and talking about the family in the other pew. In the name of "saving", "unifying", "protecting" the liturgy, I feel we are sacrificing a lot more. All of this is a huge can of worms that can be debated until the end of time. Which while that debate is going on, I still want to quietly excuse myself from the heated arguments attend the 20-minute daily morning Mass and go over to the Bible Church for fellowship, additional prayer, and worship.

This isn't something that I can fix alone or change or even feel like I have the energy to be a part of such a movement. The issues of the Catholic Church are way bigger than I and I would rather spend my life in an environment of peace, hope, and love. Not to mention that as a Father, I have a responsibility to providing nourishment to my children's faith life as well. It seems to me that my kids would be able to find Christ more in the Protestant Church's Youth Softball league than at any Religious Education class that I've seen. Just my humble opinion.
Thank you for your support and prayers.

In Christ,

Resonate[/quote]

If I am inferring properly (I might not be, and if that's the case, I apologize :sweat:) you are saying that you would prefer a more charismatic liturgy and feel drawn to Protestant forms of worship because the Mass isn't in the style you would like. I have heard similar difficulties from Traditionalist friends who are quite attracted to Orthodox Divine Liturgy and the SSPX Masses because of their solemnity, which they don't find enough of in ordinary Catholic masses.

Obviously many people struggle with such issues. That is perfectly normal, and it's perfectly all right to have a preferred style of worship too! :) The problems come in when folks get frustrated by the fact that [i]their[/i] way isn't the [i]universal [/i]way and start letting it chip away at their membership in the body of Christ. This is what causes some Traditionalists to gradually migrate toward Orthodox or SSPX churches, and some people in the Catholic Charismatic movement to move over toward Protestant churches. Both styles of worship have a place within the Church, but both movements have a dark side, which has a basis in the prideful demand that everything be done "their" way.

I have struggles with this myself :saint: Personally I am much more of a traditionalist; the services that you describe as Spirit-filled and lively would leave me very, very cold. "Protecting the liturgy" is very important to me. I would love my parish to have Masses that were almost all in Latin and that featured only Gregorian chant as music. Happily, I am not in charge. Many Catholics have other prayer styles, love the vernacular, have other preferences in music etc. etc. So I do not get 100 percent of my way all the time. And that is okay.

There is a base minimum standard of universality which requires that Mass be conducted with solemnity and reverence - I think the Church feels that the ideal is that several of the Mass prayers be read in Latin and that most be in vernacular, for instance. But that doesn't mean that there can't be variations on the theme, so to speak. On major holidays I go to the Tridentine Mass, which is graciously permitted by my bishop. My parish has a Charismatic prayer group and has Life in the Spirit seminars quite frequently. Is there something like that near you?

You do have a responsibility to nourish your children - and what better nourishment is there than the Eucharist? All of the wonderful fellowship and other good features inspired by the Holy Spirit in any Protestant community can not equal or exceed the grace a Christian gets from receiving God in the Eucharist.

Also, if your point wasn't about worship style at all, sorry for basically writing a book on the wrong subject, I hope some of it was useful anyway :rolleyes:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...