Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

hoosieranna
Posted

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1229457' date='Apr 4 2007, 09:26 AM']Sir, Christopher Tolkien is not writing the Chidlren of Hurin. He has simply compiled the dozens of manuscripts and edited the work so that it had a logical structure and is typographically fit for publication. The Silmarillion was also published posthumously in this manner. The work is entirely Tolkien's, his son acts only as editor. In the 12 volume History of Middle Earth collection, Christopher provided a running commentary and explanation text, but these books are not intended to be read as novels, but as a scholarly compilation with notes so that the largely incomplete and unpublishable works of Tolkien could be read by the average Joe. The Children of Hurin (though in a more mythological strain with an antiquated style) will like the Silmarrilion will not achieve the prose worship that the Lord of the Rings has. However, it will likely be just as good if not better than the Silmarillion, not to mention considerably darker in mood and content. I am very much excited about this book and already have it preordered in the special edition.

Edit: The reason that it is so significant a publication is because IT IS the newest complete story, finished but not revised by Tolkien. The other complete stories were the Silmarillion, Roverandom, and a couple of minor essays, works, lectures, and children stories, plus letters &c.

Edit Two: I should have mentioned that I am a disciple of the Professor. I have a fixation on his scholarly work and his accomplished style, which mirrors almost perfectly the early mythological Lays. His mythopoeic pricniples and his views of Myth and religion are particularly fascinating. I have read the Lord of the Rings once to twice a year since I first read it in fourth grade, the Hobbit nearly twice as much as that, and the Silmarillion half a dozen times. I have eight 1" notebooks with careful notes, commentary, and what not. In 2004 I purchased the 2005 50th Anniversary Edition and it is actually displayed on a book display stand on my 'Tolkien Shelf.' As you said, my dear sir, I know more about Middle Earth than I should care to admit.[/quote]

Miss, actually. Thanks for the explanation. Like I said, it's been a significant interval since I've read any of the histories. For what it may be worth, I've read the Silmarillion, The Lost Road, at least one of the books of Lost Tales, and the Lays of Beleriand. I like reading them to see what might be gleaned about Tolkien's views of ecology. I also enjoy the allusions to the Kalevala and ancient epic writings. I'm not totally clueless, I just can't remember every minute detail. Again, thanks.

Mitchell_b55
Posted (edited)

My apologies, Miss. I did not wish to offend you. I hope I did not come accross as thinking you 'clueless.' Not every fan of Tolkien enjoys an intimate knowledge of how the books came to be. I can't tell where, why, and how Twain wrote a Conneticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court, though I can tell you the entire plotline. For me, Tolkien is different, I make it a secondary purpose in life to study his works on many different levels, including Biographical analysis which includes the circumstances under which the books were written. Again, my apologies. Not the least of which is for my gender confusion. By the way, your avatar is one of my favourtie pieces of Japanese art and I attempted to duplicate it (not with any particular skill or success) with a linoleum print and gauche. It was semi-successful, though not nearly as intricate, fine, and crisp. I enjoy Eastern art and culture, mostly as an oddity. I am a thoroughly western individual, with western sentiments, western tastes, and a love of the Graeco-Roman-Christian Tradition in every aspect of its manifestation, even unto aesthetics. But I digress, did you say that you are interested in the Professor's slant on ecology? I would interested to hear what you have to say on the matter, please PM me if you care to.

Edited by petrus_scholasticus
hoosieranna
Posted

[quote name='petrus_scholasticus' post='1229839' date='Apr 4 2007, 01:47 PM']I would interested to hear what you have to say on the matter, please PM me if you care to.[/quote]

Happily, later. Currently, schoolwork calls.

Anna

Posted

Haha, I wonder if my Professor knows about this (he teaches the Tolkien class I'm taking).

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

I'm still waiting for a copy to come back to any of the Maine libraries... I should have put a hold down sooner.

I've been waiting for this since last summer. :guitar:

Posted

I need to get to Barnes and Noble and pick it up. Hopefully in hardcover.... :D:

theculturewarrior
Posted

I finished reading it friday. It is amazing. But yes, it is dark and tragic, and if Tolkien were still alive, it would wrench tears from anybody.

Tindomiel
Posted

Gah! It's still not in!

I've re-read the story, piecing together sections from the Silmarillion and the Book of Lost Tales, but I want to read it all put together.

  • 1 month later...
kenrockthefirst
Posted

OK, I finished this yesterday. Not sure how I feel. It was readable, but unremittingly negative. I understand that the story is a tragedy, and that Turin was cursed. But he was also a jerk. I'm disappointed in the fact that Turin didn't really have any redeeming qualities. I found it hard to care about him, to connect with him, and because of that I ultimately found the story a let-down.

Lounge Daddy
Posted

My wife read it and enjoyed it... except for the tragedy in the story from start to finish

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1298903' date='Jun 20 2007, 11:19 AM']OK, I finished this yesterday. Not sure how I feel. It was readable, but unremittingly negative. I understand that the story is a tragedy, and that [b]Turin was cursed. But he was also a jerk.[/b] I'm disappointed in the fact that Turin didn't really have any redeeming qualities. I found it hard to care about him, to connect with him, and because of that I ultimately found the story a let-down.[/quote]
perhaps a moral?

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1299050' date='Jun 20 2007, 03:45 PM']perhaps a moral?[/quote]

What, that being cursed gives you an excuse to be a jerk?

Posted

yeah I doubt it. I sat down to read this at a bookstore yesterday and I just couldnt get into it. I sure its good, but I guess I'm not a diehard Tolkein fan. . .

Posted

Aha! I finally read it and loved it. :D:

Posted

does it take a while to get into? Maybe I should give it a second chance

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1299549' date='Jun 21 2007, 02:38 PM']does it take a while to get into? Maybe I should give it a second chance[/quote]

I found myself picking up the book when I had a chance -- it's definitely readable, although stylistically old-fashioned (deliberately so, I'm sure), almost ponderous. My only gripe is that Tolkien should have given us something to hold on to vis-a-vis some redeeming quality in the main character, Turin.

My two cents.

Posted

the release of this book has resparked my interest in Tolkein. Yesterday I learned two interesting things:

He wrote an epic poem about Beren and Luthien. Its called "The Lay of Leithian." It is made up 4200 verses split into cantos. Tolkein never finished it. I read some lines and its absolutely GORGEOUS! Here is the link to wikipedia
[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lay_of_Leithian"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lay_of_Leithian[/url]

Also Here is what is engraved on Tolkein and his wife's grave:

EDITH MARY TOLKIEN

LUTHIEN
1889 – 1971

JOHN RONALD
REUEL TOLKIEN
BEREN

1892 – 1973

Talk about Romantic. . .

Posted

I enjoyed it. It was tragic, but beautiful. I think Tolkien was drawing heavily on the Hamlet myth when he wrote the story.

  • 1 month later...
hoosieranna
Posted

I finally finished it two days ago. I called Turin many names that I can't repeat here. Nienor is the only one I have any sympathy for. Turin was pretty useless and endlessly arrogant. Sorry, but that's how I feel after enduring the story.

Posted (edited)

Turin did have plenty of redeeming qualities at the beginning. The whole plot of the story revolved around his unwillingness to try to conquer his faults and his resulting destruction of himself and those around.... that's how the curse was fulfilled: through Turin's own free choices rather then through any inexorable events. Even if Morgoth would have killed him anyway, the tragedy of the curse wouldn't have been so complete if, for example, Turin had died but died as a hero.

I found the book very interesting precisely because Turin's pride and antagonism fulfilled the curse. The book had the tone of a Norse epic, but does not share such an epic's fatalistic view of life.

Edited by Tindomiel

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...