Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Hiddenness Of God


Recommended Posts

Justified Saint
Posted

In one of my classes we are currently studying this topic and I am interested in what people here think about it.

For those who might not be familiar with what is meant by the "hiddenness of God," it could mean one of two things:

a. just what it says, that God is hidden from us and not easily discerned

What is the proof for this claim? Two things, God is a spirit, so he can't be "observed". Perhaps one of the consequences of this is that not everyone believes in God, and so have some diffculty accepting the existence of this Being.

b. That God is so hidden and not easily known is considered by some a great evil.

One of the consequences of this claim is that God could not exist since no God worthy of praise and worship would allow such an evil.

Thus, for the Christian it appears you could take one of two positions regarding the "hiddenness of God." You could either simply deny that God is hidden and is quite knowable even to the most ardent doubter; or that God is in fact hidden but this is a necessary relation that creation has to the creator.

Where do you stand?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1240812' date='Apr 13 2007, 01:58 PM']In one of my classes we are currently studying this topic and I am interested in what people here think about it.

For those who might not be familiar with what is meant by the "hiddenness of God," it could mean one of two things:

a. just what it says, that God is hidden from us and not easily discerned

What is the proof for this claim? Two things, God is a spirit, so he can't be "observed". Perhaps one of the consequences of this is that not everyone believes in God, and so have some diffculty accepting the existence of this Being.

b. That God is so hidden and not easily known is considered by some a great evil.

One of the consequences of this claim is that God could not exist since no God worthy of praise and worship would allow such an evil.

Thus, for the Christian it appears you could take one of two positions regarding the "hiddenness of God." You could either simply deny that God is hidden and is quite knowable even to the most ardent doubter; or that God is in fact hidden but this is a necessary relation that creation has to the creator.

Where do you stand?[/quote]

A few ideas on both:

[b]a.[/b] - It is true God cannot be directly perceived, that is, His Nature cannot be perceived. Because this cannot happen unless one is blessed, in possession of the Beatific Vision (a direct vision and comprehension, even if limited due a creature being finite, of the Essence of God). Now if this were true in the world there would 1. be no question about God's existence 2. no perversity in our wills (which would not opt for a false and only apparant good, in being in complete possession of the Sovereign Good, in comprehending it exactly what the True Good is).

- However God is not hidden in the sense that one cannot grasp and accept his existence. Deductively it can be shown that God certainly does exist through the principle of cause and effect, etc. In fact, knowledge of God's existence is innate in us insofar as these principles are innate in us and can necessarily reason the existence of God [sentence paraphrased from what I remember reading in FUNDAMENTALS OF CATHOLIC DOGMA, by Dr Ludwig Ott]. God is by no means hidden to those who seek Him and the truth with sincerity.

[b]b.[/b] The Problem of Evil does not prove that God does not exist at all. For no believer will suggest that God [i]causes[/i] evil. Only, God does [i]allow or permit[/i] evil to occur for purposes we cannot fully grasp, in being not a even a drop in the infinite wisdom of God. However we can know that : 1) God allows evil so a greater good may come from it, 2) On the question of moral evil only (from our free choices), it is only through our free will that we can opt for God; how can love be shown without a choice to love?

Edited by Hirsap
Justified Saint
Posted

Good points Hirsap, but there are some other things to keep in mind.

First and foremost, is it not the case that there are those individuals who seek God with "sincerity", yet still do not end up in believing in God? Perhaps we might think of an individual who had no religious background and has had no "religious experience" of any recognizable sort. Consequently, this person would probably have to consider the claim of God's existence on exculsively intellectual and evidential grounds. If this person was not compelled by any of this "evidence", would you consider him insincere?

Also, how the problem of evil relates to the hiddenness of God is twofold. First, it is the assertion that it is some kind of evil that God is hidden, that is that not everyone knows and believes in God. Secondly, if the above case is true, then this would seem to be a great evil because this is the person's eternal salvation at stake. What is more, for all those people who don't believe, some of them at least seem to be "sincere" seekers who still come up disbelieving.

Posted

In Byzantine theology God is hidden because His essence, which is common only to the three divine [i]hypostaseis[/i], is utterly transcendent and unknowable. Nevertheless, the hiddenness of God, which is founded upon the fact that He is [i]heteroousios[/i] in relation to the world, does not lead to agnosticism, because God is simultaneously revealed through His uncreated energies (e.g., His life, glory, love, truth, etc.), which manifest His presence in the world as a deifying gift of grace and power (cf. St. Basil's "Letter 234").

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1241381' date='Apr 14 2007, 01:54 AM']Good points Hirsap, but there are some other things to keep in mind.

First and foremost, is it not the case that there are those individuals who seek God with "sincerity", yet still do not end up in believing in God? Perhaps we might think of an individual who had no religious background and has had no "religious experience" of any recognizable sort. Consequently, this person would probably have to consider the claim of God's existence on exculsively intellectual and evidential grounds. If this person was not compelled by any of this "evidence", would you consider him insincere?

Also, how the problem of evil relates to the hiddenness of God is twofold. First, it is the assertion that it is some kind of evil that God is hidden, that is that not everyone knows and believes in God. Secondly, if the above case is true, then this would seem to be a great evil because this is the person's eternal salvation at stake. What is more, for all those people who don't believe, some of them at least seem to be "sincere" seekers who still come up disbelieving.[/quote]

I suppose it comes down eventually to the question of grace. That is, God gives all people sufficient grace for them to secure their eternal salvation. It certainly can appear as a dilemma, that how certain people who on face value appear to be sincere, yet this sincerity does not lead to its conclusion grace guarantees. So we have 2 options in a sense; 1) God's grace is not universal for all people, 2) Or it actually is (which is the truth), and those who appear sincere are in fact deep down not co-operating with grace, e.g.: through adopting an ''I don't care since this topic is so 'big' for my mind; I just want to get on with life without thinking about this'' attitude. This is not to say that sincerety effects an immediate conviction of the truth; rather a persistant sincerety will.

I agree that not many convert to theism on simply intellectual arguments. They don't work automatically, but coupled with a special openness; for instance, prayer (praying as if He did exist, for He could well exist; therefore, there is only something to gain by praying therefore).

Edited by Hirsap
Justified Saint
Posted

[quote name='Hirsap' post='1242621' date='Apr 14 2007, 12:03 AM']I suppose it comes down eventually to the question of grace. That is, God gives all people sufficient grace for them to secure their eternal salvation. It certainly can appear as a dilemma, that how certain people who on face value appear to be sincere, yet this sincerity does not lead to its conclusion grace guarantees. So we have 2 options in a sense; 1) God's grace is not universal for all people, 2) Or it actually is (which is the truth), and those who appear sincere are in fact deep down not co-operating with grace, e.g.: through adopting an ''I don't care since this topic is so 'big' for my mind; I just want to get on with life without thinking about this'' attitude. This is not to say that sincerety effects an immediate conviction of the truth; rather a persistant sincerety will.

I agree that not many convert to theism on simply intellectual arguments. They don't work automatically, but coupled with a special openness; for instance, prayer (praying as if He did exist, for He could well exist; therefore, there is only something to gain by praying therefore).[/quote]

These are interesting distinctions to make. Apparent sincerity vs true sincerity, and we might also say apparent belief vs true belief. What counts as true belief? I guess this brings it back to the topic of salvation. Who knows who truly believes and is saved but God?

Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1242956' date='Apr 15 2007, 05:33 AM']These are interesting distinctions to make. Apparent sincerity vs true sincerity, and we might also say apparent belief vs true belief. What counts as true belief? I guess this brings it back to the topic of salvation. Who knows who truly believes and is saved but God?[/quote]

True belief and apparent belief can be categorised I think in two interelated ways. Firstly, belief that does not spring into action is not really a deep and sincere belief. Faith works. eg: people who profess belief in the Creed at an Easter Day Mass and don't think of God and religion for much else of the year. Secondly, natural vs supernatural belief. If in the state of grace, our 'faith' takes on a supernatural level (a level beyond human nature, and therefore, a gift from God). This supernatural faith is what secures ones salvation. Natural faith, is a sort of 'belief' had in God and the things of God when not in a state of grace. For instance, if one commits a mortal sin, he does not completely 'lose faith'. Only on the supernatural level he does, but on the natural level it remains. Needless to say, a natural faith does not secure salvation. Correct me anybody if I'm wrong.

We cannot know the hearts of others. In fact, we cannot, with certainty, even know our own! That is, nobody can be utterly certain that he is in the state of grace; except through a special Revelation. Therefore we ought to take pains to 'look into this'; and never take on an overly presumptious attitude. We can reasonably assume we are in the state of grace, but we can not know with infallible certainty.

Posted

reminds me of St. Bontaventure "journey to the mind of God"

Justified Saint
Posted

Hirsap,

Is this a fair summation of what you have said?

Appearances can be deceiving and confusing, but ultimately everyone is responsible for true belief, and I suspect failure to do so would have certain consequences (namely damnation). Therefore, God is unhidden in the sense that concerns us most, that he can be known by us as our source for salvation. In fact, God's existence is relatively obvious, and failure to recognize this clarity must be due either to willful ignorance or sloth (given the weakened nature of our nature and wills).

Justified Saint
Posted

bump

Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1249560' date='Apr 20 2007, 09:07 AM']Hirsap,

Is this a fair summation of what you have said?

Appearances can be deceiving and confusing, but ultimately everyone is responsible for true belief, and I suspect failure to do so would have certain consequences (namely damnation). Therefore, God is unhidden in the sense that concerns us most, that he can be known by us as our source for salvation. In fact, God's existence is relatively obvious, and failure to recognize this clarity must be due either to willful ignorance or sloth (given the weakened nature of our nature and wills).[/quote]

Everybody is responsible for having belief in God, of course.

It's a fair summation yes.

Posted

Just as a clarification. I did mention above that once one loses the theological virtue of faith (when dying in mortal sin), that faith then does still remain, but only on a 'natural' level. This may not be entirely the case; as even sinners remain members of the Church, and only sins against faith or church unity can seperate oneself from the Church. Point being there may be a type of supernatural level in this type of faith, even if not constituting the theological virtue of faith (had only when in the state of grace). Really :idontknow: I'm not quite sure.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...