Justin (Wiccan) Posted April 15, 2007 Posted April 15, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1243552' date='Apr 15 2007, 12:33 AM']I made a great post here..dang phatmass ate it.[/quote] So that was where that burp came from......
mortify Posted April 15, 2007 Author Posted April 15, 2007 (edited) [quote]Actually, there is a common-sense way for the valves specifically to form. The first animals with circulatory systems were quite a bit smaller than we are, and do not have the problems of gravity-induced blood pooling issues that we do. For those animals who had circulatory systems, it is possible that valves developed. The species where valves developed in the arteries died of course. The species where valves did not develop were not able to go above a certain size before recirculation issues became a limit. Only those species that developed valves in the veins were able to exceed that limit.[/quote]The above sounds more like scientific myth-making than something based off facts. There are many gaps in the above scenerio. I personally don't know what animal you have in mind but the existence of valves in an animal that doesn't need them would only hinder it's blood flow (even if they developed in the veins) and therefore would be detrimental. The valveless species lacking any hindrance to blood flow would outcompete its valved counterpart (assuming an animal could survive with such a detriment.) How do you imagine such a detrimental mutation being retained until the small animal species finally evolved to require them? This is what I was talking about before. The nature of these systems (like the circulatory system) is that all factors be present. These factors are dependent on one another to make the system function as a whole. Keep in mind with valves we are talking about one small aspect of the circulatory system. Valves themselves are incredibly complex, designed in such a way to keep the blood from flowing backwards even under the tension of muscular movement (imagine if they prevented blood flow?) A species that gradually evolved the innumerable factors of the circulatory system would not survive. We aren't even factoring in the fact that function of the circulatory system depends on others systems (i.e. pulmonary). When you try to comprehend all that is required to live and function the idea of gradual blind evolution sounds absolutely untenable. [quote]In all reality, the use of the term "sheer accident" is a mis-statement of evolutionary theory. There is no known naturalistic cause for why certain things happen--we can, as human beings, posit a theological explanation, but such explanations fall outside of the purview of science. Science cannot even [i]consider[/i] theological explanations--it is not competent to do so.[/quote] To take a process that has "no known naturalistic cause" (i.e. mutation) and describe it as "random" or "spontaneous" carries an underlying belief/philosophy. If you don't believe me, consider the significance of substituting the antonym for those words. Edited April 15, 2007 by mortify
Justin (Wiccan) Posted April 15, 2007 Posted April 15, 2007 [quote name='mortify' post='1243631' date='Apr 15 2007, 12:51 AM']The above sounds more like scientific myth-making than something based off facts. There are many gaps in the above scenerio.[/quote] Of course there are--I am not a biologist. I don't even play one on TV. This is simply a common-sense depiction of how it [i]could[/i] have happened. Did it happen that way? While I have no real idea, that is something that can only be determined evidentially. My scenario might make a half-way decent hypothesis (probably not even that), but if it was a good hypothesis, it would be testable in the lab. But let's say for a moment that some scientific textbook came out with my explanation above without laboratory tests--then, but only then, would you be able to accurately complain that it was myth-making. [quote]To take a process that has "no known naturalistic cause" (i.e. mutation) and describe it as "random" or "spontaneous" carries an underlying belief/philosophy. If you don't believe me, consider the significance of substituting the antonym for those words.[/quote] Substituting the antonyms is irrelevant: we describe it as random because it appears, to science, to be random. Remember, science is not competent to evaluate non-naturalistic phenomena: if God acts to produce a specific mutation, and a second mutation occurred spontaneously, science cannot differentiate between the two.
Phoenix Reborn Posted April 15, 2007 Posted April 15, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Justin (Wiccan)' post='1243565' date='Apr 14 2007, 08:36 PM']So that was where that burp came from......[/quote] Are you sure it wasn't your M&M friend? I personally don't care about the 'evolution' topic. People shouldn't try and figure out how we were created, because we were created as images of God and that's all that matters. Edited April 15, 2007 by Phoenix Reborn
mortify Posted April 15, 2007 Author Posted April 15, 2007 [quote]Did it happen that way? While I have no real idea, that is something that can only be determined evidentially. My scenario might make a half-way decent hypothesis (probably not even that), but if it was a good hypothesis, it would be testable in the lab. But let's say for a moment that some scientific textbook came out with my explanation above without laboratory tests--then, but only then, would you be able to accurately complain that it was myth-making.[/quote]How could you make a test to confirm or reject your hypothesis? Can we ever really know how something like the circulatory system came about? Ultimately the scientist will posit an imaginative scenario that tries to explain the unknown, and that is what makes her a myth maker. [quote]Substituting the antonyms is irrelevant: we describe it as random because it appears, to science, to be random. Remember, science is not competent to evaluate non-naturalistic phenomena: if God acts to produce a specific mutation, and a second mutation occurred spontaneously, science cannot differentiate between the two.[/quote] It's relevant because it reflects a materialist world view, even though world views should have no place in science. The neutral position would be to leave it as you had stated earlier. To fill in the blank with words like "random" or "spontaneous" is on par to me substituting them with words like "planned" and "meaningful." The materialist and theist will look at these processes differently. Right now a materialist world view underlies science.
mortify Posted April 15, 2007 Author Posted April 15, 2007 (edited) I'm sorry, I forgot to add that describing something as "spontaneous" delves into the "why" of the process, which is as Justin said beyond science. Edited April 15, 2007 by mortify
Justin (Wiccan) Posted April 15, 2007 Posted April 15, 2007 [quote name='Phoenix Reborn' post='1244191' date='Apr 15 2007, 10:44 AM']Are you sure it wasn't your M&M friend?[/quote] That's my picture. [quote]I personally don't care about the 'evolution' topic. People shouldn't try and figure out how we were created, because we were created as images of God and that's all that matters.[/quote] I don't know about "people shouldn't"--nothing wrong with science, as long as people remember that science can neither prove nor disprove God. That's what faith is for.
MissyP89 Posted April 15, 2007 Posted April 15, 2007 [quote name='Phoenix Reborn' post='1244191' date='Apr 15 2007, 09:44 AM']Are you sure it wasn't your M&M friend?[/quote] Man, Justin, you have [i]no life[/i]. I didn't realize that was your display pic...*giggles* [quote]I personally don't care about the 'evolution' topic. People shouldn't try and figure out how we were created, because we were created as images of God and that's all that matters.[/quote] My theory works like this: "Creation? Evolution? Who cares? *points at feet* You are here. Deal with it." I mostly agree with you, Phoenix.
Justin (Wiccan) Posted April 15, 2007 Posted April 15, 2007 [quote name='mortify' post='1244370' date='Apr 15 2007, 01:42 PM']How could you make a test to confirm or reject your hypothesis?[/quote] Aw, heck, that's where the analogy falls apart. Knowing as little biology as I do (just the basic Freshman year biology from college ... more years ago than I care to admit ), I would have no idea. [quote]Can we ever really know how something like the circulatory system came about? [/quote]Why not? It is theoretically possible. I do not have the knowledge in biology to tell you how it could be achieved, but other structures can (and have) been traced. [quote]Ultimately the scientist will posit an imaginative scenario that tries to explain the unknown, and that is what makes her a myth maker.[/quote] Mortify, I have rarely seen such a fundamental misunderstanding of the scientific method. Is this your analysis, or one that you have learned from someone else? [quote]It's relevant because it reflects a materialist world view, even though world views should have no place in science. The neutral position would be to leave it as you had stated earlier. To fill in the blank with words like "random" or "spontaneous" is on par to me substituting them with words like "planned" and "meaningful." The materialist and theist will look at these processes differently. Right now a materialist world view underlies science. [/quote]A materialistic methodology? Yes. A materialistic worldview? No. There are many scientists--including evolutionary biologists--who are Christian, even specifically Catholic Christian. While you may disagree with evolution (which is, of course, your right), it would be better not to do so based on false claims of what science is, or what underlies science. [quote]I'm sorry, I forgot to add that describing something as "spontaneous" delves into the "why" of the process, which is as Justin said beyond science.[/quote] Again, Mortify, that is such an extreme misunderstanding of the word "spontaneous" that I wonder if you came up with this particular argument, or if you heard it from another source. The word "spontaneous," like many English words, can have different meanings in different contexts, but in this context the meaning is "happening without any apparent cause." Again, you must remember that we are speaking of science: science is not competent to evaluate non-materialistic issues. If event A occurs randomly, and event B occurs because of divine will, science is not capable of differentiating between the two.
Justin (Wiccan) Posted April 15, 2007 Posted April 15, 2007 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1244515' date='Apr 15 2007, 03:47 PM']Man, Justin, you have [i]no life[/i]. I didn't realize that was your display pic...*giggles*[/quote] This coming from the young lady who showed me the website to make the picture? And precisely [i]who[/i] has no life?
mortify Posted April 15, 2007 Author Posted April 15, 2007 [quote]Mortify, I have rarely seen such a fundamental misunderstanding of the scientific method. Is this your analysis, or one that you have learned from someone else?[/quote]Were you employing the scientific method with your scenario? I think you were just presenting an imaginative possibility. Likewise the scientist who tries to explain how the eye formed is using more imagination than fact. In this way it's like myth-making. [quote]Again, Mortify, that is such an extreme misunderstanding of the word "spontaneous" that I wonder if you came up with this particular argument, or if you heard it from another source. The word "spontaneous," like many English words, can have different meanings in different contexts, but in this context the meaning is "happening without any apparent cause." Again, you must remember that we are speaking of science: science is not competent to evaluate non-materialistic issues. If event A occurs randomly, and event B occurs because of divine will, science is not capable of differentiating between the two.[/quote] Justin, the problem is science may inadverently describe event B as "spontaneous" since it can't differentiate. If it doesn't have the ability to distinguish, why even speculate? Saying the principle means of change in evolution is without a cause denies Divine creation outright. Creation implies deliberate and planned design orchestrated by the Divine Will. Whether this design took a day or millions of years is not the problem. If the complexity of the human body compels us to question the notion that all of this is the product of innumeralble improbable mutations, why is considering deliberate and planned mutations so problematic? Doesn't the science in some way lead you towards believing God created us? Just as an aside, you seem to be a spiritual person. Wouldn't you agree you can somehow differentiate coincidence from purpose/destiny? I've found that I can, but I can't really explain it. Perhaps I'm alone with this?
Justin (Wiccan) Posted April 15, 2007 Posted April 15, 2007 [quote name='mortify' post='1244624' date='Apr 15 2007, 06:11 PM']Were you employing the scientific method with your scenario? I think you were just presenting an imaginative possibility. Likewise the scientist who tries to explain how the eye formed is using more imagination than fact. In this way it's like myth-making.[/quote] Again, Mortify, that is such a grotesque mischaracterization of the scientific process as to place serious question in my mind as to whether the person who originated the analysis did so maliciously or not. This is why I asked where you got your analysis--I cannot dream of you being deliberately dishonest, so I shall assume that you have heard someone else's disingenuous analysis and repeat it in good faith. However, let me assure you that your good faith has been badly abused. The [i]only[/i] place that "imagination," or anything remotely resembling imagination, has in the scientific process is the initial formulation of the statement of the idea. The initial statement is formulated as a testable question--called a hypothesis. In turn the hypothesis is tested by the scientist who developed it--but (and this is a very important caveat), the tests that are performed are tests that are designed to prove the hypothesis false. [i]If[/i] that particular scientist cannot disprove his own hypothesis, he publishes, and other scientists reproduce the experiments to see if they can prove the hypothesis false. If, after years of testing, the hypothesis is not disproven, [i]and[/i] it is useful for furthering our understanding of related concepts, then--and only then--is that hypothesis called a "theory." A theory is "a mathematical description, a logical explanation, a verified hypothesis, or a proven model of the manner of interaction of a set of natural phenomena." But even then, there is no "theory" that is immune from further testing, and possible disproval. The "Theory of Evolution" is actually a complex set of rigorously tested theories, hypotheses still being tested, and obvious facts ("obvious facts" including such things as "different fossils appear in different geological layers"). The individual theories that make up the over-arching Theory of Evolution have been rigorously tested, in some cases for over a century. Yet there is no part of that theory that is free from continued testing, doubt, or even downright rejection by an individual scientist. Mortify, I want to ask you a question: suppose a scientist developed a hypothesis that disproved a major component of the Theory of Evolution. In your personal opinion, would he most likely suppress that knowledge, or would he test it, then publish? [quote]Justin, the problem is science may inadverently describe event B as "spontaneous" since it can't differentiate.[/quote]Mortify, that is one of the limitations of science: science [b]only[/b] deals with natural phenomena. Science is incapable of measuring God, just as it is incapable of measuring the soul. [quote]If it doesn't have the ability to distinguish, why even speculate?[/quote] Because without that speculation, we would lack not only the theory of evolution, but also the very computers that you and I are speaking of. The same methods and rationale of scientific method and scientific investigation was used to discover and utilize electricity. One of the first step along that path was actually taken by our own Benjamin Franklin, yet his work also met strong resistance from religious authorities, because lightning was thought to be the power of God demonstrated on earth, and that interfering with lightning was presumption. Franklin's reply to such sentiments was as follows: [quote][Nollet]speaks as if he thought it Presumption in Man to propose guarding himself against Thunders of Heaven! Surely the Thunder of Heaven is no more supernatural than the Rain, Hail, or Sunshine of Heaven, against the Inconvenience of which we guard by Roofs and Shades without Scruple.[/quote] Mortify, where do we draw the line between what is acceptable to investigate and what is not? At what point does our investigation become "why even speculate" in your mind? [quote]Saying the principle means of change in evolution is without a cause denies Divine creation outright.[/quote]This is also grossly incorrect. You seem to have fallen into the same error as Richard Dawkins, that scientific examination of natural phenomena somehow "invalidates" faith. Nothing could be further from the truth. [quote]Just as an aside, you seem to be a spiritual person. Wouldn't you agree you can somehow differentiate coincidence from purpose/destiny? I've found that I can, but I can't really explain it. Perhaps I'm alone with this?[/quote] I can, but such a differentiation is subjective, prone to error (because we are human, and are subject to error), and not particularly useful in a scientific context. Mortify, God has given us the wonderful gifts of Creation, an inquisitive mind, and a boundless curiosity. Science is not the only method of inquiry and investigation that we have of discovering more about the world that God has given us. And lest it preturb your heart, there is NOTHING that God has gifted us with that can come between us and He--the only thing that can do so is our refusal to draw nigh to Him.
mortify Posted April 16, 2007 Author Posted April 16, 2007 [quote]Again, Mortify, that is such a grotesque mischaracterization of the scientific process as to place serious question in my mind as to whether the person who originated the analysis did so maliciously or not. This is why I asked where you got your analysis--I cannot dream of you being deliberately dishonest, so I shall assume that you have heard someone else's disingenuous analysis and repeat it in good faith. However, let me assure you that your good faith has been badly abused.[/quote]I was not saying all of science is myth making. I was referring to your scenario of valve formation and of other scenarios like it (i.e. the evolution of the eye). The natural question is how do these things evolve since they are so complex. We weren't present to observe the evolution of these processes and we have no facts to guide us in this regard. We can only hope to imagine a possible scenario. Again, I'm not saying science itself or all theories are myths. [quote]Mortify, I want to ask you a question: suppose a scientist developed a hypothesis that disproved a major component of the Theory of Evolution. In your personal opinion, would he most likely suppress that knowledge, or would he test it, then publish?[/quote] I honestly don't know. Eventually I'm confident his information would be made public. [quote]Because without that speculation, we would lack not only the theory of evolution, but also the very computers that you and I are speaking of. The same methods and rationale of scientific method and scientific investigation was used to discover and utilize electricity. One of the first step along that path was actually taken by our own Benjamin Franklin, yet his work also met strong resistance from religious authorities, because lightning was thought to be the power of God demonstrated on earth, and that interfering with lightning was presumption.[/quote]I'm not disagreeing with you. Speculating into how things operate is fine and noble but you admitted science can't speculate into the "why." When you brand a process as spontaneous you've already closed further speculation. You also already delved into the "why" since if it is spontaneous, there can be no room for a Creator to act because then it would be deliberate (and not spontaneous). [quote]Mortify, where do we draw the line between what is acceptable to investigate and what is not? At what point does our investigation become "why even speculate" in your mind?[/quote] What is within the confines of the field is acceptable. For science it's addressing how things operate. [quote]This is also grossly incorrect. You seem to have fallen into the same error as Richard Dawkins, that scientific examination of natural phenomena somehow "invalidates" faith. Nothing could be further from the truth.[/quote] I should have been more clear, I wasn't talking about science as a whole but that particular understanding of evolution which describes it as a purely blind process. If evolution is a blind process, and we are the product of innumerable spontaneous mutations, there can still be a God but not a Creator. Creation would rule out spontaneity and infuse purpose, meaning, and design into the world.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now