Is All That God Left Us Was A Book?

[dairygirl4u2c]

i bet he tens to fail to realize you have to choose to be catholic given the evience,and the CC doesnt choose that or shouldn't choose that for you. he's not immune from making a choice. given the choice you have to look at the evidence and are accountable for your choice.

that thes was clearly taling about prots should take history etc into consideration more isn't clear from the foundation of the thread. the first posts mention nothing about it, and the title is even "is all god left us a book". if he ackowledges that moost prots take traditoin into consideration some, then that title isn't very good is it. maybe better would be "shouldn't prots take tradition into consideration more" to that effect. that he thinks it's clear this thread, just goes to show how he bases his reasoning that being catholic is the obvious and only rational choice given the evidence. he takes gut reaction to the poitn of clarity to him, probably even to the point he doesn't even realize it. i can see why anomaly equated thes with akalyte, they are just zeolots who say unfounded things. "clearly this" etc, or don't at least aknowledge the weight of conter evidence.

[thessalonian]

God bless you dairy.

[Katholikos]

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1246574' date='Apr 16 2007, 09:50 PM']It is horrific to me that dairy, or any person who may not be Baptised, believe that they should not or cannot not be Baptised unless they fully believe and agree with everything they 'think' the Roman Catholic Church teaches.[/quote]

My understanding was that Dairygirl said she might become a Catholic only for the Eucharist, since she doesn't believe in the other teachings of the Church.

Thessalonian responded that she would not (should not) be allowed.

I posted the Profession of Faith that every adult convert is required to make as confirmation of what Thessalonian said.

One cannot be baptized a [b][i]Catholic[/i][/b] unless one fully believes and agrees with everything the Catholic Church teaches. One certainly may be baptized as a Two-Seed-in-the-Spirit Predestinarian Baptist, or in the Apostolic Overcoming Holy Church of God, Inc., or in the Triumph the Church and Kingdom of God International, or in any of the many thousands of other Protestant denominations one may choose. One MAY be saved outside the Catholic Church, but it's risky to take that chance since Christ, the only Redeemer, founded only one Church for the salvation of the world. If one is saved, he is saved through Christ and His Church, though he may not be aware of it prior to his death.

Likos

[thessalonian]

Was he saying I said she couldn't be baptized? (I have him on ignore) Man this guy has a reading comprehension problem. I never said she couldn't be baptized. As you said, the issue was the Eucharist.

[Anomaly]

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1247191' date='Apr 17 2007, 04:05 PM']Was he saying I said she couldn't be baptized? (I have him on ignore) Man this guy has a reading comprehension problem. I never said she couldn't be baptized. As you said, the issue was the Eucharist.[/quote]Dude,
Unbunch your panties, you weren't mentioned or even thought of.

[thessalonian]

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1247196' date='Apr 17 2007, 03:10 PM']Dude,
Unbunch your panties, you weren't mentioned or even thought of.[/quote]


Then why did you bring it up. Nobody else said anything close to what you claim to be some Catholics position.

Why do you need to come on here and be a complete jake ars to Catholics? I could care less but sadly it makes me wonder if your playing with a full deck. Nothing christian about you dude. Say what you want about me. Your demonor discredits you. Back to ignore for good. Edited April 17, 2007 by thessalonian