Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Human Relations Class Is Having A Birth Control Debate


Recommended Posts

Posted

Sanvean,

What I'm getting out of your comments is that.......you are telling people that it is intellectually inconsistent to be okay with condoms but against abortion.
I have not put near the work into that issue that you have, but I disagree.
I would not tell anybody that it is intellectually inconsistent, without thinking that I am insulting their intelligence.
So, I'm sorry, but I have to stand by my comment.

Paddington

Posted

I just want to add that I have deep suspicions about "logical entailment" in everyday use.

Posted (edited)

Paddington,

I certainly wasn't asking you to retract your comment; what's said is said.

I am also curious as to what concerns you have about logical entailment in everyday use. Everyday used as opposed to... what, precisely?

For my own part, yes, I do strive to maintain a logically consistent belief system; and, for me, that requires a consideration of the implications of each, and all, of my beliefs. I expect that most people do the same, albeit with varying levels of formality.

Still, you are misreading me, and that's probably at least partially my fault. I would not say that a person's reasoning is "intellectually inconsistent" in any context that I can think of. However, I most certainly do think that it is [i]logically[/i] inconsistent to accept condoms, and condemn abortion.

Nevertheless, I would certainly appreciate it if you stopped claiming to know anything of my intentions in saying such a thing, and concern yourself more closely with what I am actually saying. You disagree with me? Wonderful! Can you explain to me why?

Errors in logic happen all the time, and I highly doubt that there is a single human being out there who does not make an error in their reasoning at some point or another; humans are, in general, rather fallible. Making such an error is hardly indicative of a lack of intelligence. Rather, it may be caused by any number of things. Most commonly, I suspect that we often simply fail to think through all of the consequences of our beliefs.

Heaven knows I certainly often fail in this way: such a thing takes a fair bit of effort, and even then we are often prone to missing things.

None of us has a God's eye view of the world.

In the end, if I disagree with an argument it is because it is either inconsistent with reality as I perceive it, or because it is somehow inconsistent with itself. Rooting out the latter can often take a great deal of work, and does not reflect anything of my beliefs concerning a person's intelligence. Rather, it only concerns the quality of their argument.

I generally expect the same of anyone who disagrees with one of [i]my[/i] arguments, as well.

Edited by Sanvean
Posted (edited)

Nevermind actually...I gotta get back to work and then I won't have internet for 5 days.
All I will throw out there is that condoms don't kill human beings and that is enough for my logic.
Everything else is too much right now. Thanks for giving me things to think about. If you reply, I will probably read it next week.

Edited by Paddington
cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote]What I'm getting out of your comments is that.......you are telling people that it is intellectually inconsistent to be okay with condoms but against abortion.[/quote]

I think I understand what Sanvean is saying. I had a similar discussion with a Catholic friend who disagrees with the church's position on birth control a few nights ago. She kept saying that using a condom would not suddenly make her see abortion as morally acceptable, as she believes that life begins at conception. Then she said, "A council of men should not be allowed to make fertility decisions for a group of women. It's my body, so it should be my choice."

That last sentence is the exact same line of argument that people use in support of abortion. I believe that my friend is telling the truth when she says that she will always believe abortion to be morally wrong. But what her children will grow up to believe is another matter, as the widespread use of contraception generates a certain kind of moral climate that isn't helpful. Prior to the 1967 Abortion Act, during the so-called 'sexual revolution', the British population by and large was very much against abortion - although the widespread use of contraception had just taken off. The next decade saw a steep rise in the number of abortions carried out. I don't think for one moment that this upsurge occurred just because abortions were now easier to obtain. They went up because of society's new what-I-want-I-get approach to sexuality. This laissez-faire attitude begins with contraception and it ends in the abortion clinic. Sex with contraception is sex without personal responsibility. This is not a good mentality to choose.

The Church teaches that married couples are called to bring children into the world responsibly, yes. This means using a responsible and spiritual method - not a selfish one that is focused exclusively on your own physical pleasure. For Catholics, this is NFP. According to the Family Planning Association, NFP is 98% effective - which makes it just as 'effective' as condoms. It is based on very simple principles (Mother Teresa taught it to women who live in the gutters of Calcutta) but it is not 'easy'. Couples have to abstain from sex for about ten days each month. A lot of non-Catholics find this idea disturbing, perhaps because sex is often presented as a 'right', something that you should be able to have whenever you want.

For Catholics it is a gift, not a right, and this monthly period of abstinence is very helpful in allowing couples to discover the nature of that gift. It teaches patience and encourages them to focus on other aspects of the relationship. In short, it keeps the marriage in balance. Orthodox Jews also practice a monthly period of abstinence, albeit for different reasons, but with identical benefits. It is a religious tradition that is thousands of years old.

Women who use NFP have to take their temperature daily in order to monitor their fertility. In doing this, they are gaining a much more intimate knowledge of their own bodies than they would if they were just shoving a pill down their throats every morning. It's good to have that level self-awareness. It is actually a form of prayer. NFP also involves a woman's husband in a way that artifical contraception does not - couples taking a Catholic marriage preparation course are encouraged to share this responsibility together. When artificial birth control 'fails', it is frequently treated as a woman's problem. This is never ever the case for Catholics.

Finally, artifical contraception frustrates human fertility in a way that NFP doesn't. If you use artifical contraception, your body is saying to your partner, "I love every part of you...except for your fertility." Catholic sex, however, simply says, "I love every part of you." This is the way it should be. We embrace all the possibilities and live in total trust. As sex is a sacrament and the creation of new life a fundamental part of marriage's holiness, a Catholic couple can't live in any other way.

Posted

In a sense, yes, that's the sort of thing I am referring to.

The assumptions underlying the various arguments in favour of contraception tend to have disturbing parallels to the assumptions underlying various arguments in favour of abortion. The same is true in reverse. As well, the form and structure of the arguments for each tend to be more or less identical.

This means that, if the fundamental assumptions are wrong in the case of abortion, then they will still be wrong in the case of contraception.

Similarly, if the arguments in favour of abortion are flawed, then they will still be just as flawed when used in favour of contraception.

The same works in reverse; if the assumptions are correct, and the arguments valid, in favour of contraception...then it follows that they must be correct and valid in the case of abortion.

It's not at all the case, obviously, that a condom is an abortificant. Still, there is a strange sort of causal link between the two beliefs, and, while it's not always direct, it's also not terribly subtle. I'm really not sure why more people don't notice it.

Posted

one of the big arguments the class had involved NFP and claimed that it did not promote Life, and is the same as artificial birth control in the way that it is not promoting and being open to human life.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...