Lounge Daddy Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 [img]http://drudgereport.com/siren.gif[/img] BREAKING NEWS
Lounge Daddy Posted April 18, 2007 Author Posted April 18, 2007 [quote][b][u]AP[/u] - The Supreme Court upheld the nationwide ban on a controversial abortion procedure Wednesday, handing abortion opponents the long- awaited victory they expected from a more conservative bench. The 5-4 ruling said the Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act that Congress passed and President Bush signed into law in 2003 does not violate a woman's constitutional right to an abortion.[/b][/quote]
Phoenix Reborn Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 [url="http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=D8OJ2HV82&show_article=1"]Link[/url]
thessalonian Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 Just saw this. FANTASTIC. A victory in the abortion battle at last! Charge!
Sojourner Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 For anyone interested, [url="http://www.scotusblog.com/movabletype/archives/05-380_All.pdf"]here is a link[/url] to the actual opinion. Beware that the procedure is described in some detail.
kenrockthefirst Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 A step in the right direction, however... [i]"Abortion opponents say the law will not reduce the number of abortions performed because an alternate method -- dismembering the fetus in the uterus -- is available and, indeed, much more common. <snip> But Kennedy said, 'The law need not give abortion doctors unfettered choice in the course of their medical practice.' He said the more common abortion method, involving dismemberment, is beyond the reach of the federal ban."[/i] We're only just beginning.
thessalonian Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 (edited) But Kennedy said, 'The law need not give abortion doctors unfettered choice in the course of their medical practice.' He said the more common abortion method, involving dismemberment, is beyond the reach of the federal ban." [b] YOU GOTTA BE KIDDING ME. PULLING A BABY APART PIECE BY PIECE IN IT"S MOTHER'S WOMB IS SOMETHING THE LAW CAN'T REGULATE?!!!!!! [/b] The dumbest thing I've heard in my life by a mile or 100 miles. Edited April 18, 2007 by thessalonian
Sojourner Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 [quote name='thessalonian' post='1247982' date='Apr 18 2007, 10:31 AM']But Kennedy said, 'The law need not give abortion doctors unfettered choice in the course of their medical practice.' He said the more common abortion method, involving dismemberment, is beyond the reach of the federal ban." [b] YOU GOTTA BE KIDDING ME. PULLING A BABY APART PIECE BY PIECE IN IT"S MOTHER'S WOMB IS SOMETHING THE LAW CAN'T REGULATE?!!!!!! [/b] The dumbest thing I've heard in my life by a mile or 100 miles.[/quote] No, he's saying that the ban Congress passed doesn't regulate it. Not that the law in general can't regulate it.
Totus Tuus Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 Praise God!! I think this should be pinned.....
Sojourner Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 One of my professors was really involved in this case (for the good guys) and she's talking about it now ... I'll share what she's telling us when she's done.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 Alleluia! I'm pinning this... Anyway, I heard this this morning. Great news!
xTrishaxLynnx Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1247974' date='Apr 18 2007, 11:19 AM']A step in the right direction, however... [i]"Abortion opponents say the law will not reduce the number of abortions performed because an alternate method -- dismembering the fetus in the uterus -- is available and, indeed, much more common. <snip> But Kennedy said, 'The law need not give abortion doctors unfettered choice in the course of their medical practice.' He said the more common abortion method, involving dismemberment, is beyond the reach of the federal ban."[/i] We're only just beginning.[/quote] Yes, this is a small triumph over a horrific and widespread evil. At the very least it should tell us that there is, most certainly, hope.
Sojourner Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1248015' date='Apr 18 2007, 11:18 AM']One of my professors was really involved in this case (for the good guys) and she's talking about it now ... I'll share what she's telling us when she's done.[/quote] OK here is the legal significance of the case, in addition to the moral victory () My professor represented a number of corollary organizations on this case, and has actually been involved in other related cases, such as a predecessor to this case, [i]Stenberg v. Carhart[/i] (2000). In that case, the Nebraska legislature passed a partial birth abortion ban, and Dr. Carhart challenged the state regulation, and won. There were several points from the Stenberg case that are important in understanding this more recent case. But to understand that case, it is important to understand some of the findings of Roe v. Wade. In Roe, individual states are given a graduated right to regulate abortion. In the first trimester, when 85 percent of abortions are performed, the Roe court found states have no right to regulate abortion. In the second trimester, states have the right to regulate only for the safety of the woman, and not because of an interest in the unborn child. In the last trimester, states have great latitude in their ability to regulate abortions, up to an outright ban on late-term abortions. Read the following only when not eating lunch: [spoiler]The testimony given by Dr. Carhart in the Stenberg case did a couple of things. First, he testified that he never performed partial-birth abortions in the last trimester (when the state has the most regulatory power) but only in the middle one, when states may regulate only to protect the life/health of the mother. Second, he testified that he never turned the fetus so that it presented breach. The early medical literature at the time indicated that the highest risk to the woman in a partial birth abortion was the turning of the fetus to cause it to present breach. In addition, this particular form of abortion is considered safer for women because the primary medical risk to women after an abortion is infection, which untreated can be life-threatening. The most common cause of infection from a dilation and extraction (when the baby is dismembered) is from retained fetal parts -- the doctor doesn't get it all cleaned out. Another common risk is from perforation of the uterus due to multiple passes to remove all trace of the baby from the uterus. This can lead to bleeding and infection. In a partial-birth abortion, these risks are lower because a) the child is removed intact, so no parts are left behind, and b) there are no sharp objects introduced into the uterus. Studies indicate (and it sickens me that there are studies comparing these procedures) but studies indicate that a PBA is actually safer for the mother. This is the prevailing medical opinion.[/spoiler] In stating her views on this, Ruth Ginsburg basically said, if you're going to end up with a dead baby no matter what, why not go with the process that is safer for the woman? This was basically the view adopted by the majority here. The same study that found that PBA is safer for women did find one other result that is important. Because the cervix must be dilated more to do a PBA, it greatly increases the risk of premature delivery in future pregnancies. So the big finding from Stenberg is that when there is a disputed medical question (i.e., which abortion procedure is preferable in terms of safety for the woman) you must leave the resolution of it to the medical profession to determine whether a procedure is medically legitimate or not. If there is substantial medical authority that supports the procedure as a legitimate medical procedure, then the medical profession has to have the professional autonomy to perform the procedure. Unlike legislature in Neb., if congress takes on disputed medical question, then Congress has the authority to ban the procedure. Huge change from the autonomy of the medical profession to the ability of the legislature to regulate procedures. Now, to further explore the jurisprudential terrain coming into today's decision, you have to understand other decisions outside the realm of abortion that have been happening. In the area of physician-assisted suicide and of regulation of medical marijuana, there have been several cases that have been hashing out who has teh power to regulate medically-related decisions. Issues of substantive due process (is there actually a Constitutional provision for this stemming from the 5th and 14th Amendments?) and federalism (what is the balance of power between state and federal governments?) have been at the center of these disputes. So, subsequent to Stenberg, the court finds that states have no power to weigh in on medical practices. If the feds find that there is no medicinal purpose to a particular drug (marijuana) they have the power to ban it. And, when it comes to the nature of the practice of medicine (Oregon and physician-assisted suicide) states have to be free to define what the practice of medicine is. The question in today's case is, does the federal legislature have the power to ban disputed medical procedures? Or are they, like states, prohibited from making laws regulating this? The court finds that Congress is free to regulate disputed medical procedures, which brings the question of this back into the public forum and out of the hands of the medical community. A further important and more broadly-reaching part of the decision is a restriction on the federal court's ability to enjoin laws before they have gone into effect based on a hypothetical problem with the law. Laws regulating abortion and free speech have been subject to pre-enforcement facial challenges, because of the concerns about chilling a constitutional right. This court finds that abortion laws cannot be challenged until there is actually a case or controversy arising under the law, and that pre-enforcement challenges are limited to the free speech arena.
Groo the Wanderer Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 PRAISE BE TO THE ALMIGHTY GOD ABOVE!!!!!! A small step, but one in the right direction. Only takes one small hole to bring down the dam!
Ash Wednesday Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 LOL.. it's the Drudge Report "ooogaoogaholypoop" light... (only James Lileks doesn't say mushy mud pie, he says the fish word.) This is good news.
Sojourner Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1248085' date='Apr 18 2007, 01:09 PM']This is good news.[/quote]
Phoenix Reborn Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 (edited) It's good news for the pro-lifers, not the pro-choisers. Mwahaha! Edited April 18, 2007 by Phoenix Reborn
Didymus Posted April 18, 2007 Posted April 18, 2007 (edited) [url="http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070418/ap_on_go_su_co/scotus_abortion"]http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070418/ap_on_...scotus_abortion[/url] it's rediculous how so many people can actually see these news reports and read about the 'dismemberment of the fetus' and "crushing the skull" and whatever other terms they use and yet feel NO compassion for the child going through this death-row torture. I am happy for the Supreme Courts decision, as it does take us another step in the right direction, but reading these reports from the disgusting media scum and knowing how they influence the ignorant makes me sick. The godless America is a concentration camp to the most helpless and innocent in the womb. Anyways, praise be to God for this victory. Edited April 18, 2007 by Didymus
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now