johnnydigit Posted April 19, 2007 Posted April 19, 2007 (edited) in the New American Bible, the footnotes for the scene of the golden calf states, "[b]The calf ... a feast of the Lord: from this it is clear that the golden calf was intended as an image, not of a false god, but of the Lord himself, his strength being symbolized by the strength of a young bull. The Israelites, however, had been forbidden to represent the Lord under any visible form.[/b]" now i thought the golden calf was wrong because they worshipped the actual calf *as* God, but here it says it was an image of his strength, a representation. it wasn't a false god, they were still worshipping the Lord. don't we do that too? our images and statues are a representation of God, we don't worship the images themselves, but they merely represent or remind us of God. i have seen Catholic pictures of God the Father as an older man with a white beard, too. how is that different from the footnotes? on a side note i just watched a video on Hinduism, and they claim that they don't worship the statues as gods either, they are merely representations of their gods. they wash, clean, and oil them very reverently, offer food and sacrifices that are "spiritually" consumed by the god, but they don't consider it idolatry. i asked my professor about this, and he said that often to prove idolatry, we have to look into the mind of the person. if the person knows full well that they are not worshipping the statue itself but the god in question, then it isn't idolatry. examples of idolatry would be some primitive tribes in which they felt the object actually had powers. now i also understand idolatry to be placing something above God, say like the pursuit of money or a favorite hobby. perhaps some clarification from a specific list would help. please tell me which is right or wrong, and why, -a statue of Shiva or Brahma (Hindu gods, for clarification). -a statue of Allah in some form, the one Islam god. -a statue of a bull representing Allah's power. -worshipping the golden calf. -worshipping the might of God in front of the golden calf. -worshipping the golden calf as the might of God. -worshipping God in front of the golden calf. -a statue of God the Father. -worshipping God in front of a statue of a father. -worshipping a statue of a father as God the Father. -a statue of Jesus. -a statue of Mary. -a statue of a lamb representing Jesus. -a statue of a the infinity sign (like a figure 8), representing God or God's infinite power. i'm thinking the difference is with worshipping *it* (whether as God or his might) and thinking it sacred, versus worshipping *in front of it* and thinking it not sacred? don't we view the crucifix in a church as sacred? another late night thought, when i see the love of God really show in someone, i adore it in them. i may be looking at them, but obviously i don't adore them persay, i am adoring the love of God *in* them. this i feel is ok. ===================== Exodus 32: 3 So all the people took off their earrings and brought them to Aaron, 4 who accepted their offering, and fashioning this gold with a graving tool, made a molten calf. Then they cried out, "This is your God, O Israel, who brought you out of the land of Egypt." 5 1 On seeing this, Aaron built an altar before the calf and proclaimed, "Tomorrow is a feast of the LORD." 6 Early the next day the people offered holocausts and brought peace offerings. Then they sat down to eat and drink, and rose up to revel. 7 With that, the LORD said to Moses, "Go down at once to your people, whom you brought out of the land of Egypt, for they have become depraved. 8 They have soon turned aside from the way I pointed out to them, making for themselves a molten calf and worshiping it, sacrificing to it and crying out, 'This is your God, O Israel, who brought you out of the land of Egypt!' ===================== NAB Footnotes: 32,5: The calf ... a feast of the Lord: from this it is clear that the golden calf was intended as an image, not of a false god, but of the Lord himself, his strength being symbolized by the strength of a young bull. The Israelites, however, had been forbidden to represent the Lord under any visible form. Cf Ex 20, 4. ===================== Edited April 19, 2007 by johnnydigit
thessalonian Posted April 19, 2007 Posted April 19, 2007 [quote name='Budge' post='1249133' date='Apr 19 2007, 11:04 AM']And that is why I preach against any use of images in a church. the second commandment doesnt have endless qualifers.[/quote] Cheribum over the mercy seat? There most sacred OBJECT! The Ark. Bronze serpant.... You must block things out that you don't want to acknowledge in the OT budge, rather than trying to figure out why some were allowed and some weren't. It's not the image that is bad budge or you shouldn't let your little kiddies play with dolls and should be protesting the toy store.
angelusdomini Posted April 19, 2007 Posted April 19, 2007 Here is another commentary for the same passage from the [url="http://haydock1859.tripod.com/id330.html"]Haydock's Catholic Commenatary, 1859 edition [/url] for the Douay-Rheims Bible. 3) And the people did what he had commanded, bringing the earrings to Aaron. 4) And when he had received them, he fashioned them by founders' work, and made of them a molten calf. And they said: These are thy gods, O Israel, that have brought thee out of the land of Egypt. 5) And when Aaron saw this, he built an altar before it, and made proclamation by a crier's voice, saying: Tomorrow is the solemnity of the Lord. 6) And rising in the morning, they offered holocausts, and peace victims, and the people sat down to eat, and drink, and they rose up to play. 7) And the Lord spoke to Moses, saying: Go, get thee down: thy people, which thou hast brought out of the land of Egypt, hath sinned. 8) They have quickly strayed from the way which thou didst shew them: and they have made to themselves a molten calf, and have adored it, and sacrificing victims to it, have said: These are thy gods, O Israel, that have brought thee out of the land of Egypt. ------------ [u]COMMENTARY:[/u] Ver. 4. [i]Received them[/i], "in a purse, (as Gideon did afterwards, Judges viii. 25,) he made a molten calf." (Jonathan) --- Perhaps he engraved on it the peculiar marks of the Egyptian idol, Apis; a square white spot on the forehead, and a crescent upon the side. For it is generally believed, that this calf was designed to imitate that object of worship, to which the Hebrews had been too much accustomed. (Acts vii. 39, 41.; St. Jerome in Osee iv.) The Egyptians adored not only the living ox, but also its image, which they kept in their temple. (Porphyr. Abst. ii. Mela. i. 8.) Some of the fathers think, that the head of a calf only appeared. (St. Ambrose; Lactant., &c.) The rest of the figure was perhaps human, as Osiris was represented with the head of an ox, as well as Astarte and Serapis. Monceau pretends that Aaron represented the true God, under the form of a cherub, in which he falsely asserts he had appeared on Mount Sinai, and that his fault consisted only in giving occasion of superstition to the people. But his opinion (though adopted by many Protestants, who excuse all from the guilt of idolatry, but papists; Haydock) has been condemned at Rome, and refuted by Visorius, &c. --- [i]Thy gods[/i], &c. Thus spoke the infatuated ringleaders. (Calmet) --- [i]And they changed their glory[/i], the true God, [i]into the likeness of a calf that eateth grass[/i], Psalm cv. 19. --- They forgot God, who saved them, (Psalm cv. 21,) and [i]forsook[/i] Him, (Deuteronomy xxxii. 18,) to adore the calf. (Worthington) Ver. 5. [i]The Lord[/i]. The most sacred name of God is prostituted, (Judges xvii. and xviii.; Wisdom xiv. 21,) and an altar is erected to this idol; though some pretend, that Aaron meant God to be adored under this similitude. His weakness was unaccountable, and God would have slain him, had not Moses interceded, Deuteronomy ix. 20. Those who undertake to justify him, enter not into the sentiments of God; and the offender himself pleads no excuse, but the violence of the people, ver. 23. (Salien.) --- [i]To-morrow[/i], when the 40 days expired, and Moses returned arrayed in terrors. (Haydock) Ver. 6. [i]They offered[/i], by the hands of Aaron, to whom the Septuagint refer all this. "He offered," &c., appearing at the head of the idolaters. A Lapide insinuates, that he wished to supplant his brother in the supreme command; and after a faint resistance, became the promoter of idolatry, to ingratiate himself with the people. The Scripture lays not this, however, to his charge. (Calmet) --- [i]To eat [/i]of the victims. --- [i]To play[/i], dancing and singing in honour of their idol, probably with many indecent gestures, as was customary on such occasions among the nations of Chanaan. (Haydock) --- Tertullian (de jejunio) understands impure play. The word means also to dance, and to play on instruments of music. [i]Ludere quæ vellem calamo permisit agresti[/i]. (Virgil, Ec. i) (Calmet) --- Sulpitius says, the people abandoned themselves to drunkenness and gluttony, or debauchery, [i]vinoque se & ventri dedisset[/i]. (Haydock) --- They might get wine from Madian. (Salien.) --- Foolish mirth is the daughter of gluttony, and the mother of idolatry. (St. Gregory, Mor. xxxi. 31.) (Worthington) Ver. 7. [i]Thy people[/i]. They are not worthy to be styled my people; and thou didst ratify the covenant with me, in their name, and as their interpreter. They have [i]sinned[/i], giving way to idolatry in thought, word, and deed. The italicised words are the points from which the notes begin with regards the verses. Some of the notes may be found to be a little polemical (i.e. v4)- no offence intended, just quoting the text as it is. Also notice how the idea that the Israelites were "really worshipping the True God" is already made aware to them even at that time (1850s). That's always a consolation to me, to know that whatever I encounter that I find to be troublesome, Holy Mother Church has already encountered and dealt with before. p.s. I have found generally that the notes from the NAB leave me...'scratching my head' (to say the least). So, for indepth study or even fruitful spiritual reading I found it better to skip the aformetnioned notes or switch bibles all together. pax et bonum Anne
Thy Geekdom Come Posted April 19, 2007 Posted April 19, 2007 The NAB commentary is often not particularly reliable. I use it mostly for points in the literal sense and typology (historical context, which verses are related to which, etc.) but often it tries to explain away spiritual or confusing matters with "rational" explanations.
Mateo el Feo Posted April 19, 2007 Posted April 19, 2007 [quote name='Budge' post='1249133' date='Apr 19 2007, 12:04 PM']And that is why I preach against any use of images in a church. the second commandment doesnt have endless qualifers.[/quote]Budge, this is not the Debate forum.
johnnydigit Posted April 24, 2007 Author Posted April 24, 2007 [quote name='Angelus_Domini' post='1249285' date='Apr 19 2007, 12:59 PM']The italicised words are the points from which the notes begin with regards the verses. Some of the notes may be found to be a little polemical (i.e. v4)- no offence intended, just quoting the text as it is. Also notice how the idea that the Israelites were "really worshipping the True God" is already made aware to them even at that time (1850s). That's always a consolation to me, to know that whatever I encounter that I find to be troublesome, Holy Mother Church has already encountered and dealt with before. p.s. I have found generally that the notes from the NAB leave me...'scratching my head' (to say the least). So, for indepth study or even fruitful spiritual reading I found it better to skip the aformetnioned notes or switch bibles all together. pax et bonum Anne[/quote] thanks! i will have to read that over a few more times as my brain is starting to hurt and my eyes are squinting. so basically the altar before it does them in, as well as the history of their worship with calves/oxen/egyptian worship, and that Aaron (or other persons) had been known to use the excuse of "it's for God" when it was not their real intention? ya i've heard time again about the NAB.. which leads me to question, why did they even change the "Hail, full of grace" to "Hail, favored one"? didn't they know about her Immaculate Conception by then? didn't they know how much significance those words have?
Aloysius Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 Ancient pagans worshiped images and statues in and of themselves. It is mostly due to Christian influence, or western secular influence (for the two often have the same insights, western secularism merely distorts those insights in dastardly ways to make for horrid interpretations of them) that the image starts to represent the thing they are worshiping instead of being the object of the worship itself. It is treated as 'animated' "To fashion the idol of a god, to install it in the sanctuary, to treat it as "animated," to anoint it: all of these became major rites...For some, perhaps for the majority, the idol is the god himself, and we can classify this as idolatry; for others, symbolical values are true values and the idol is nothing more than what it is in any form of cult in which the sacred is incarnate in some concrete form." Renou, Louis, ed. Hinduism 1962. George Braziller: New York: pp 31-32 When he says "perhaps the majority" he refers to the practices of folk Hinduism, which is real historical Hinduism; as opposed to the higher classes of Hindu society influenced by western philosophies who feel they are above all that. but it is very interesting and telling to me that he uses the word "incarnate"; because this was the reason Christianity accepted icons in the first place: because the Incarnation changed everything. God Himself represented Himself in visible form. God's presence came to dwell with the people; instead of the only place where one could fall down before the presence of God as it was represented in physical form being the ark of the covenant; now all creation could be ordered towards serving him in this manner. There is nothing new under the sun; the Church already figured out why Iconoclasm is wrong, but these protestant judaizers, attempting to put us back under the proscriptions of the Old Law for a pre-incarnational period, seek to UNDO the incarnation and make icons once again taboo; as if all creation had not been now redeemed. "The one who granted us the light of recognizing him, the one who redeemed us from the darkness of idolatrous insanity, Christ our God, when he took for his bride his holy catholic church, having no blemish or wrinkle (Eph 5,27), promised he would guard her and assured his holy disciples saying, I am with you every day until the consummation of this age (Mt 28, 20). This promise however he made not only to them but also to us, who thanks to them have come to believe in his name (Jn 17, 20) To this gracious offer some people paid no attention; being hoodwinked by the treacherous foe they abandoned the true line of reasoning, and setting themselves against the tradition of the catholic church they faltered in their grasp of the truth. As the proverbial saying puts it, they turned askew the axles of their farm carts and gathered no harvest in their hands. Indeed they have the effrontery to criticize the beauty pleasing to God established in the holy monuments; they were priests in name, but not in reality. They were those of whom God calls out by prophecy, Many pastors have destroed my vine, they have defiled my portion (Jer 12, 10). For they followed unholy men and trusting to their own frenzies they calumniated the holy church, which Christ our God has espoused to himself and [i]they failed to distinguish the holy from the profane (Ez 22, 26) ... To summarize, we declare that we defend free from any innovations all the written and unwritten ecclesiastical traditions that have been entrusted to us. One of these is the production of representational art; this is quite in harmony with the history of the spread of the gospel, as it provides confirmation that the becoming man of the Word of God was real and not just imaginary, and as it brings us a similar benefit. For, things that mutually illustrate one another undoubtedly possess one another's message." Nicaea II
johnnydigit Posted April 25, 2007 Author Posted April 25, 2007 very insightful! i'm "starting" to understand. as long as no one asks me to explain it back to them, which probably isn't going to happen since i stump most people with this..
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now