Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Proving The Resurrection


Recommended Posts

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

An fellow student here at school is an agnostic, I'm pretty sure. She is looking for [i]her[/i] God. Her family is Christian and she was apparently brought up as so, but quickly dumped that upon entering college. I am in painting with her and she had blatantly said that she did not think Jesus was God. She believes in His message and those good things. She said that she also wanted someone to prove to her the Jesus rose from the dead, and not using proof from Scripture. She sees it as something that has been manipulated and changed over time to suit personal agendas.
So, can anyone provide proofs for the Resurrection without using Scripture?

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted (edited)

If the Resurrection was made up, either the Apostles were insane or they died for something they made up (which really does not make sense). I don't think a band of insane men could get as far as they did in building up the early Church. A mass delusion seems implausible as well. When a great amount of people believe that Jesus rose from the dead, something extraordinary must have happened. It is an understatement to say that this is not a routine occurence! People died holding this belief!

I think you could also talk about the authenticity of the scriptures too. I don't think it is reasonable to say they are a massive fabrication and we have all been duped. I don't see how they could be made up and then imposed on a bunch of people hundreds of years ago, brainwashing them into thinking that the events contained in scripture happened all along. They were written by believers near the time of the events they describe. If they were bogus, they wouldn't have gotten past the faithful.

God bless!

Edited by thedude
Posted

Ok, first of all, we have to establish our basis for our beliefs. This is in the bible. If she doesn't want you to prove her through the bible then good luck! That's impossible.
ok. So, the bible was written by eye witness testimonies to Christ, most of the new testement books were at least. The arguement that they apostles were 'lying' is not logical, because many of them defended their believes to the death. They died for what they believed in, they were persecuted, and they wouldn't do that all for a lie, for a figment of their imaginations.
Second of all, there are five very common arguements as to how Christ's body could have dissappeared, or to disprove that Christ didn't rise. If she is taking one of those approaches, it is quite simple to prove her wrong. For example, one of the arguements is that the guards that stood by Christ' tomb fell asleep and the apostles took His body in the night. Guards didn't sleep on duty, second of all, after His resurection the apostles were cowards, they wouldn't have done something so brave and bold. This was before Pentecost... so if she is taking one of those approaches its not hard to disprove her. However the Ressurection doesn't seem to be the issue here, she doesn't believe Jesus was SAVIOR. Jesus IS God. Most people believed because of the Ressurection, and that IS a true sign.
But, you didn't really give me much to argue with, I don't know her point of view. I'm sorry if this was all a pointless rant, but I don't really know where she stands thus far I can't argue her standpoint very well. I hope others can give you more insight, God Bless you,
-uruviel

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I see that there will be a problem if she does not except any of the Biblical details that come after His death. Does she believe it up until the Resurrection? Otherwise I am not sure what you have to work with if she doesn't even believe He was crucified, placed in a tomb, etc.

TotusTuusMaria
Posted

[center]J.M.J[/center]

[quote name='FutureNunJMJ' post='1249359' date='Apr 19 2007, 03:47 PM']An fellow student here at school is an agnostic, I'm pretty sure. She is looking for [i]her[/i] God. Her family is Christian and she was apparently brought up as so, but quickly dumped that upon entering college. I am in painting with her and she had blatantly said that she did not think Jesus was God. She believes in His message and those good things. She said that she also wanted someone to prove to her the Jesus rose from the dead, and not using proof from Scripture. She sees it as something that has been manipulated and changed over time to suit personal agendas.
So, can anyone provide proofs for the Resurrection without using Scripture?[/quote]

Well, at least she acknowledges that Jesus truly lived.

As for defending the Resurrection without using the Bible... one can do that by using logic and reason and a couple other documents.

I am curious to which argument she uses to prove that Christ did not resurrect. There are really only three.

1.) The Apostles conspired to steal Christ's body and then to pretend that they had seen the risen Christ.

Logic and reason disprove this one. The Apostles at the time were not the type of men to plan to carry out such a daring plan. They were cowering in their rooms, afraid to go out, full of despair at the death of their leader. Another thing is, they could not have rolled away the stone to the tomb, without awakening the guards. Next, they had nothing to gain, neither wealth nor power. Instead, ultimately, they gained only martyrdom. They just as simply could have realized when Christ did not resurrect that they were wrong, gave into their fear, repented, and returned to waiting for the Messiah. They did not though. Their belief was so strong in the resurrection that they lived a life of total poverty, servitude, and travel; in the end dying martyrs. Surley, if the time came out when they were faced with death for their beliefs, surely, at least one of them would have admitted it was a "conspiracy" to save their life. None did. Also, Roman soldiers were the best in the world. The normal complement of a Roman guard was sixteen men, with four on duty at all times. It is impossible that they would have been guilty of such a dereliction of duty as all to be asleep at the same time. Finally, St. Paul tells us that the risen Christ appeared to 500 people! Many of those people were still alive at the time he was writing. If we accepted the conspiracy theory, we have to assume that 500 people also were in the conspiracy and that none of them confessed also when even faced with martyrdom. Anyone with logic can see that the odds of that actually happening are none. Christ had to have arisen for all 500 people to be with such conviction as to die for it!

2.) Christ only pretended death and then left the tomb to appear to His Apostles, convicing them that He had truly risen.

After the torture He had undergone, it is impossible to believe that Christ had the strength to roll away the stone, elude the guards and then appear to His Apostles in such a way as to convince them that He had gloriously risen. Also, the Roman soldiers who crucified Jesus knew their business. They were not in the habit of allowing men still alive to be removed from the cross, and infact pierced Christ's heart with a lance to prove that He was certainly dead.

3.) The Apostles were seeing visions or hallucinations.

The halucination theory has no explanation for the empty tomb though. If there had been no empty tomb, Christ's enemies could easily have discredited the Resurrection by producing His body. They never did. Also, the material reality of Christ's appearnaces dispels doubt that they were imaginary. Surely this is why Christ ate and drank and encouraged the Apostles to touch his body. Also, again, we have the 500 witnesses St. Paul mentioned and the number and variety of other appearances. To account for these, we have to assume, that many people at different times were seeing the same hallucination. This is simply just not likely. Also, there is the nature of hallucinations themselves. It is a psychological fact that people usually see hallucinations of things they expect or fear or hope for. NOne of this applies to the disciples. None of them expected or even hoped for CHrist's resurrection. The fact that the women planned to anoint the body show that they truly expected that there would be a body to anoint. And people prone to hallucination are usually mentally unstable, highly imaginative, and sensitive. No description could be more unlike the Apostles. They were hard-headed, practical men (fishermen, a tax collector, etc.).

If one will not take the texts of the the Apostles as historical documents then there are other external, independent testimonies which have been taken as historical documents of the time of Jesus' resurrection that testify that truly SOMETHING had happened.

There was a Romanized Jewish historian by the name of Josephus who wrote a book called: The Jewish War.
In this book there is a passage that says: "It was at this time [when Pontius Pilate was procurator of Judea] that a man appeared-of 'man' is the right word-who had all the attributes of a man but seemed to be something greater. His actions, certainly, were superhuman, for he worked such wonderful and amazing miracles that I for one cannot regard him as a man; yet in view of his likeness to ourselves I cannot regard him as an angel either. Everything that some hidden power enabled him to do he did by an authoritative word...
"In the days of our pious fathers this curtain [in the Temple] was intact, but in our generation it was a sorry sight, for it had been suddenly rent from top to bottom at the time when by bribery they had secured the execution of the benefactor of men-the one who by his actions proved that he was no mere man. Many otuher awe-inspiring 'signs' happened at the same moment. It is also stated that after his execution and entombment he disappeared entirely. Some people actually assert that he had risen; others retort that his friends stole him away. I for one cannot decide where the truth lies."

By this account (a totally independent account like your friend is looking for) this man lets us know that TRULY SOMETHING happened for the body to not be there. Reason and logic lead us to conclude that Christ resurrected. The author had nothing to gain by decieving anyone. He died a Jewish man, I believe. So, if anything he was not trying to help spread the cause for the belief in the resurrection. No one contradicted this account at the time, nor did anyone contradict the accounts of the Gospels when they were written. Even those who are mentioned in the Gospels, such as Joseph of Arimathea, never contradict that Christ resurrected. No people appeared to contest the data. We have no record that any of the Jewish leaders presented evidence proving the Gospels false. They simply tried to suppress the Christians. They never did try to disprove them... asking the question why makes one only assume that they simply could not because it was all true. If there were any such evidence, they certainly would have produced it because of the inroads Christianity was making among the Jewish people. Instead, all the Jews kept silent.

Hope this helps to convince your friend.

I got a lot of these refutes from a book called: Christ the King Lord of History: Anne W. Carroll. They are all sound and solid. Anne. W. Carroll is the wife of the founder of Christendom College. It is a very good book with MANY good points. Although it was written for young people in high school I think every person in the world should read it. It is a basic account of World History.

In Jesus and Mary,
Marie

Posted

Here is an interesting and rather straight forward essay/article on the issue: [url="http://www.scottmsullivan.com/courses/resurrection.pdf"]http://www.scottmsullivan.com/courses/resurrection.pdf[/url]

Admittedly, it does in some parts use the Gospels as evidence for substantiating the argument, but not exclusively; anyway, in here, is shown briefly the reliability of the Gospel accounts. God bless.

Posted

Less than one hundred years ago, the Blessed Mother of our Lord appeared to three shepherd children in Fatima, Portugal. She appeared on the 13th of every month and despite persecution for their claims, the children would not recant their visions. For this reason, they begged Our Lady of Fatima for a miracle so that the rest of the world might believe her message; that the world repent, do penance, and turn to our Lord, who is come in the flesh in his Catholic Church. The Blessed Virgin promised to give just such a miracle on the 13th of October (1917). Tens of thousands of people from diverse religious and occupational backgrounds, skeptics, scoffers, and believers alike - including journalists - gathered at the prophesied place at the prophesied time. It had been a gloomy day. The ground was soaked from rain as the people crowded on the mushy earth. Then the clouds rolled back like a scroll, the sun shining in suddenly clear skies. Then the sun began to spin and dance through the sky, finally seeming to hurdle toward the some 70,000 people gathered on the hill of the apparition. Everyone saw this miraculous vision - including people from as far as 14 kilometers away. Hearts were converted then and continue to be converted because of this miracle that Our Lady of Fatima obtained from our Lord. Furthermore, the Blessed Mother prophesied of Word War II and the spread of Communism. She also added that a great sign in the sky would precede World War II and such a sign was indeed recorded by scientists shortly before the war broke out.

The point is this: the miracle of the sun is contemporary and any explanation other than the supernatural is utterly ridiculous. Moreover, the vision and its message was distinctly Catholic and consequently proves the resurrection.

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

Thanks all. :) I'm not sure how I am going to go about this... I have no real way of making the topic come up in conversation again. Perhaps facebook will come into play for this one. I feel this all may make a dent, but not much may take immediate affect. She does not strike me as being quite open to Christianity, rather quite hostile towards it.
We shall see :) Thanks again!

Posted

[quote name='TotusTuusMaria' post='1249845' date='Apr 19 2007, 10:42 PM'][center]J.M.J[/center]
I got a lot of these refutes from a book called: Christ the King Lord of History: Anne W. Carroll. They are all sound and solid. Anne. W. Carroll is the wife of the founder of Christendom College. It is a very good book with MANY good points. Although it was written for young people in high school I think every person in the world should read it. It is a basic account of World History.

In Jesus and Mary,
Marie[/quote]
These, and other evidence for the truth of the Gospel accounts are presented in more detail in Warren Carroll's [i]The Founding of Christendom[/i], the first in his History of Christendom series. Recommended reading.

Posted

[url="http://www.thethinkingchristian.org/evidences.htm"]http://www.thethinkingchristian.org/evidences.htm[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...