Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

My Very Rough Outline For Final Paper


Recommended Posts

Posted

Many of you know I have spent roughly a year not working on a paper with the contemporary filioque issue. I spent most of the time researching and doing my ano-bib.

Well, the next step was to get the thesis down, as well as a very-ver-very-very- rough outline to how I want to progress the paper. (did I mention it is rough) anyway, here it is for the phamily to see.

If I am stepping toooooooo far away from orthodox catholic doctrine let me know. I wanna include this in my application to FUS and it doesnt help if I sound like a bloody heretic

[quote]Thesis and Outline

Thesis (2 options, depending on what language you like the best)

The Augustinian love model of the Filioque can be interpreted to have an openness allowing for a viable non-heretical option for an eastern and western view of the Filioque

or

There is enough openness language in the Filioque to interpret the Augustianian love model in a way that can allow for a viable non-heretical option for an eastern and western view of the trinity

Introduction
-(setting self within current stage of argument)
-understand that root of the issue of division is eccesiological, but regardless of what Erickson suggests, I see the value in working towards a common theological ground and allowing the unity to progress from that although, in echoing Tarvard, the theology alone will not resolve the eccesiology. The NAOTC even suggests removing the issue theologically as far from the issue of eccesiology as possible
-(possibly) mention issues with “clarification” and the ambiguous stance that was taken in regards to the theological language. Perhaps suggesting openness, but not claiming it or working from it.
-(stating what I am contributing to the argument)
-Under the suggestion of Coffey the idea that the love model of Augustine can account for the monarchy of the father, I will push this even farther in suggesting that the love model of Augustine can be understood in a Greek context to fix other issues as well. There is enough openness in the language of the Filioque, within the guidelines of the creed, to allow an interpretation of Augustine's love model that is not only catholic, but also a non heretical, viable option for the east.
-(suggesting who I am set with, and against and how)
-suggestion by Del Colle is that the only solution is to work within the framework of both faith traditions, recognizing the dogmatic core of both (cites the Coffey model as a good start point-an encouragement for me to push on from it)
-other models mentioned by Dulles and the problems of those models and why the Augustine model is the best option available
-using Thomas' example of being academic yet aprophatic (as cited by Daley) respects the Cappadocian aprophatic concern, Thomas as a universal approach seen by east and west as common light (Daley) Also citing that Thomas saw issue as essential to underscoring God's redemptive design(a Greek concept) rather than a mental exercise
-citing Letham in understanding that neither side is able to capture the full complexity of the biblical witness
-eastern understanding within Filioque will solve western issue of modalism, western theology aids against eastern problem of tritheism.
-setting in aprophatic respect what we know and understanding our limits in what we can know and what is speculative, while still working within the 3 theological perimeters set by Letham
1st pt
-an outline of the Augustine love model
-understanding the limitations as set by Coffey
-1st and second stages of Love model
How is this model catholic?
-true to their biblical exegesis and systematic models
How is this model eastern?
-mystery allowed
-monarchy of father still present in the “principles” of the spirit
-son not elevated to position of the father
-handling issue of Sabellian modalism
-father still remains “sole principle, source and cause”
-east rejects if son is “co-principle” (ditheism, 2 sources of divinity)
-similarity of this and “through the son”


2nd pt
-dealing with the objections as set forward by Goltzin in how the east will react to an Augustinian model under the movement of eastern spirituality. Coming to show how the love model does not cause the problems Goltzin suggests, but rather is a viable option in dealing with these problems.
-deal also with the 3 objections that Letham has in the Filioque and how an eastern aprophatic Augustine love model can handle these issues. Including most important how the language and openness in the love concept with its explanation of the “principles” does not undermine the Cappadocian monarchy of the father
-Letham's understanding that the west used the Filioque to defend a teaching of the east,

3rd pt
-Augustine model in the proper context. Creed as primary, other models as theological reflection. Viable subjective theology, but non dogmatic. Respecting the apropathic nature of Greek theology. Although the love model can be understood as universally accepted, it only needs to be understood as non-heretical and an option within a viable openness Allowing a legitimate diversity within the faith, bound together by the creed as primary (Dominus Iesus example and Byzantine example)
-cite NAOCT in the plea for everyone involved to understand the limitations to make assertions of the inner workings of the trinity.
-note, as NAOCT says, that we understand the divinity and hypostatic identity of the Spirit to be dogmatic in both faith communities, but the manner of the spirit's origin still awaits full ecumenical understanding
-cite Daley and the argument for an openness in the language of the creed, the avoidance of explicit language. Thus allowing for various pneumtalogical expressions
-use Tarvard and the language discussion here to show possible openness as well
-Dulles and NAOCT asking for the removal of the Filioque from liturgical and educational documents, but keeping it as a possible and viable theological option
-NAOCT idea that the visible removal of the Filioque can contribute to a promotion of unity, and remove a serious obstacle in the way. But stress again that I am simply addressing the small theological part of a larger issue. A sense of modesty in what the dialog can produce.

Conclusion
- (I have argued “restate the thesis”)
-implications of the thesis
-common viable theological option for East and west
-removal of barrier to further unifying discussions
-only possible if love model is understood in proper openness with respect to both traditions[/quote]

Posted

sweet phatmass just shot my grammar and spacing to carp.

I feel exposed. I hope you guys like it so far.

Posted

Rev,

My loving opinion is that I am tired as heck and skimmed the outline and I'm very very impressed. :)

Paddington

Posted

that is the last thought in my mind before i head to bed..thank you

Posted

I know it is rough, but I would feel bad moving forward with this if I am presenting something that is heretical

phatcatholic
Posted

i don't see anything heretical. it all depends on how you develop your points. a flag goes up when i read about "openness" in the language of the creed, so that will be a section to be particularly careful with. also, i don't agree w/ the removal of the filioque from liturgical and educational documents as a means for unity.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...