Red Knight Posted April 20, 2007 Posted April 20, 2007 Just thought I would share. [url="http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=OTIwYzMyZmQ1YzQ1MDNmZTMyYzQ1Y2U3YTU4YzNmNGE="]National Review Online[/url] April 20, 2007, 0:31 a.m. Signs of Intelligence? By Fred Thompson One of the things that's got to be going through a lot of peoples' minds now is how one man with two handguns, that he had to reload time and time again, could go from classroom to classroom on the Virginia Tech campus without being stopped. Much of the answer can be found in policies put in place by the university itself. Virginia, like 39 other states, allows citizens with training and legal permits to carry concealed weapons. That means that Virginians regularly sit in movie theaters and eat in restaurants among armed citizens. They walk, joke, and rub shoulders everyday with people who responsibly carry firearms — and are far safer than they would be in San Francisco, Oakland, Detroit, Chicago, New York City, or Washington, D.C., where such permits are difficult or impossible to obtain. The statistics are clear. Communities that recognize and grant Second Amendment rights to responsible adults have a significantly lower incidence of violent crime than those that do not. More to the point, incarcerated criminals tell criminologists that they consider local gun laws when they decide what sort of crime they will commit, and where they will do so. Still, there are a lot of people who are just offended by the notion that people can carry guns around. They view everybody, or at least many of us, as potential murderers prevented only by the lack of a convenient weapon. Virginia Tech administrators overrode Virginia state law and threatened to expel or fire anybody who brings a weapon onto campus. In recent years, however, armed Americans — not on-duty police officers — have successfully prevented a number of attempted mass murders. Evidence from Israel, where many teachers have weapons and have stopped serious terror attacks, has been documented. Supporting, though contrary, evidence from Great Britain, where strict gun controls have led to violent crime rates far higher than ours, is also common knowledge. So Virginians asked their legislators to change the university's "concealed carry" policy to exempt people 21 years of age or older who have passed background checks and taken training classes. The university, however, lobbied against that bill, and a top administrator subsequently praised the legislature for blocking the measure. The logic behind this attitude baffles me, but I suspect it has to do with a basic difference in worldviews. Some people think that power should exist only at the top, and everybody else should rely on "the authorities" for protection. Despite such attitudes, average Americans have always made up the front line against crime. Through programs like Neighborhood Watch and Amber Alert, we are stopping and catching criminals daily. Normal people tackled "shoe bomber" Richard Reid as he was trying to blow up an airliner. It was a truck driver who found the D.C. snipers. Statistics from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention show that civilians use firearms to prevent at least a half million crimes annually. When people capable of performing acts of heroism are discouraged or denied the opportunity, our society is all the poorer. And from the selfless examples of the passengers on Flight 93 on 9/11 to Virginia Tech professor Liviu Librescu, a Holocaust survivor who sacrificed himself to save his students earlier this week, we know what extraordinary acts of heroism ordinary citizens are capable of. Many other universities have been swayed by an anti-gun, anti-self defense ideology. I respect their right to hold those views, but I challenge their decision to deny Americans the right to protect themselves on their campuses — and then proudly advertise that fact to any and all. Whenever I've seen one of those "Gun-free Zone" signs, especially outside of a school filled with our youngest and most vulnerable citizens, I've always wondered exactly who these signs are directed at. Obviously, they don't mean much to the sort of man who murdered 32 people just a few days ago. — Fred Thompson is an actor and former United States senator from Tennessee. © ABC -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- National Review Online - [url="http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=OTIwYzMyZmQ1YzQ1MDNmZTMyYzQ1Y2U3YTU4YzNmNGE="]http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=OTIwY...2U3YTU4YzNmNGE=[/url]
Socrates Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Red Knight' post='1250203' date='Apr 20 2007, 12:31 PM']Just thought I would share. [url="http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=OTIwYzMyZmQ1YzQ1MDNmZTMyYzQ1Y2U3YTU4YzNmNGE="]National Review Online[/url] April 20, 2007, 0:31 a.m. Signs of Intelligence? By Fred Thompson One of the things that's got to be going through a lot of peoples' minds now is how one man with two handguns, that he had to reload time and time again, could go from classroom to classroom on the Virginia Tech campus without being stopped. Much of the answer can be found in policies put in place by the university itself. Virginia, like 39 other states, allows citizens with training and legal permits to carry concealed weapons. That means that Virginians regularly sit in movie theaters and eat in restaurants among armed citizens. They walk, joke, and rub shoulders everyday with people who responsibly carry firearms — and are far safer than they would be in San Francisco, Oakland, Detroit, Chicago, New York City, or Washington, D.C., where such permits are difficult or impossible to obtain. The statistics are clear. Communities that recognize and grant Second Amendment rights to responsible adults have a significantly lower incidence of violent crime than those that do not. More to the point, incarcerated criminals tell criminologists that they consider local gun laws when they decide what sort of crime they will commit, and where they will do so. Still, there are a lot of people who are just offended by the notion that people can carry guns around. They view everybody, or at least many of us, as potential murderers prevented only by the lack of a convenient weapon. Virginia Tech administrators overrode Virginia state law and threatened to expel or fire anybody who brings a weapon onto campus. In recent years, however, armed Americans — not on-duty police officers — have successfully prevented a number of attempted mass murders. Evidence from Israel, where many teachers have weapons and have stopped serious terror attacks, has been documented. Supporting, though contrary, evidence from Great Britain, where strict gun controls have led to violent crime rates far higher than ours, is also common knowledge. So Virginians asked their legislators to change the university's "concealed carry" policy to exempt people 21 years of age or older who have passed background checks and taken training classes. The university, however, lobbied against that bill, and a top administrator subsequently praised the legislature for blocking the measure. The logic behind this attitude baffles me, but I suspect it has to do with a basic difference in worldviews. Some people think that power should exist only at the top, and everybody else should rely on "the authorities" for protection. Despite such attitudes, average Americans have always made up the front line against crime. Through programs like Neighborhood Watch and Amber Alert, we are stopping and catching criminals daily. Normal people tackled "shoe bomber" Richard Reid as he was trying to blow up an airliner. It was a truck driver who found the D.C. snipers. Statistics from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention show that civilians use firearms to prevent at least a half million crimes annually. When people capable of performing acts of heroism are discouraged or denied the opportunity, our society is all the poorer. And from the selfless examples of the passengers on Flight 93 on 9/11 to Virginia Tech professor Liviu Librescu, a Holocaust survivor who sacrificed himself to save his students earlier this week, we know what extraordinary acts of heroism ordinary citizens are capable of. Many other universities have been swayed by an anti-gun, anti-self defense ideology. I respect their right to hold those views, but I challenge their decision to deny Americans the right to protect themselves on their campuses — and then proudly advertise that fact to any and all. Whenever I've seen one of those "Gun-free Zone" signs, especially outside of a school filled with our youngest and most vulnerable citizens, I've always wondered exactly who these signs are directed at. Obviously, they don't mean much to the sort of man who murdered 32 people just a few days ago. — Fred Thompson is an actor and former United States senator from Tennessee. © ABC -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- National Review Online - [url="http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=OTIwYzMyZmQ1YzQ1MDNmZTMyYzQ1Y2U3YTU4YzNmNGE="]http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=OTIwY...2U3YTU4YzNmNGE=[/url][/quote] Amen! Fred Thompson's got my vote! While liberal politicians will predictably use this tragedy as an excuse to push gun control legislation, the undeniable fact is that if other people were armed on the campus, Cho would've been stopped long before the body count could reach 33! Edited April 21, 2007 by Socrates
Resurrexi Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 It would just freak me out to know someone in the same area as me was carrying a gun...
Knight of the Holy Rosary Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 [quote]While liberal politicians will predictably use this tragedy as an excuse to push gun control legislation, the undeniable fact is that if other people were armed on the campus, Cho would've been stopped long before the body count could reach 33![/quote] I agree wholeheartedly.
kujo Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1251103' date='Apr 20 2007, 11:56 PM']It would just freak me out to know someone in the same area as me was carrying a gun...[/quote] As the article mentions, it's commonplace in states like Virginia. People interact with gun-carrying citizens while performing the most mundane, routine tasks. Eventually, the unease would probably subside with you (and I) as well. Go FRED THOMPSON!!!
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted April 21, 2007 Posted April 21, 2007 What about the fact that throughout our government schools self-defence is punished exactly the same way as aggression. I'm not talking about retaliation, but genuine self-defence. If someone starts beating up on a kid on a playground he's expected to not fight back but to somehow get a teacher over to stop the fight. If the kid does fight back he may be able to end the pummeling quickly and perhaps send a message to the aggressor, but the punishment for retaliating is that you have to go to therapy and get suspended. I was bullied in elementary school and if I ever pushed back I was called into the principal's office along with the bully and we were dealt with [i]together[/i]. In other words, our physical actions were recognized as having the same level of violence and same intent. This neuters the self-defence instinct in children and they grow up to adulthood thinking that they should not fight back but to let the authorities arrive and they'll take care of it. Fighting back would make them just as much of a violent killer, at least by the moral standards that have been passed down to them by teachers. Fred Thompson has it right. Him, along with Ron Paul, I think are the only two men running for president who believe that government shouldn't and has no right to be trying to solve all our problems other than those that are directly addressed in the constitution. I think they'd make a great ticket together and would absolutely destroy Hillary in the general election.
Red Knight Posted May 14, 2007 Author Posted May 14, 2007 [quote name='1337 k4th0l1x0r' post='1251568' date='Apr 21 2007, 11:28 AM']What about the fact that throughout our government schools self-defence is punished exactly the same way as aggression. I'm not talking about retaliation, but genuine self-defence. If someone starts beating up on a kid on a playground he's expected to not fight back but to somehow get a teacher over to stop the fight. If the kid does fight back he may be able to end the pummeling quickly and perhaps send a message to the aggressor, but the punishment for retaliating is that you have to go to therapy and get suspended. I was bullied in elementary school and if I ever pushed back I was called into the principal's office along with the bully and we were dealt with [i]together[/i]. In other words, our physical actions were recognized as having the same level of violence and same intent. This neuters the self-defence instinct in children and they grow up to adulthood thinking that they should not fight back but to let the authorities arrive and they'll take care of it. Fighting back would make them just as much of a violent killer, at least by the moral standards that have been passed down to them by teachers. Fred Thompson has it right. Him, along with Ron Paul, I think are the only two men running for president who believe that government shouldn't and has no right to be trying to solve all our problems other than those that are directly addressed in the constitution. I think they'd make a great ticket together and would absolutely destroy Hillary in the general election.[/quote] Well said.
jeffpugh Posted May 14, 2007 Posted May 14, 2007 [quote name='1337 k4th0l1x0r' post='1251568' date='Apr 21 2007, 12:28 PM']What about the fact that throughout our government schools self-defence is punished exactly the same way as aggression. I'm not talking about retaliation, but genuine self-defence. If someone starts beating up on a kid on a playground he's expected to not fight back but to somehow get a teacher over to stop the fight. If the kid does fight back he may be able to end the pummeling quickly and perhaps send a message to the aggressor, but the punishment for retaliating is that you have to go to therapy and get suspended. I was bullied in elementary school and if I ever pushed back I was called into the principal's office along with the bully and we were dealt with [i]together[/i]. In other words, our physical actions were recognized as having the same level of violence and same intent. This neuters the self-defence instinct in children and they grow up to adulthood thinking that they should not fight back but to let the authorities arrive and they'll take care of it. Fighting back would make them just as much of a violent killer, at least by the moral standards that have been passed down to them by teachers. Fred Thompson has it right. Him, along with Ron Paul, I think are the only two men running for president who believe that government shouldn't and has no right to be trying to solve all our problems other than those that are directly addressed in the constitution. I think they'd make a great ticket together and would absolutely destroy Hillary in the general election.[/quote] How about a Canadian perspective (coming from one who has not grown up with people all around carrying firearms--except for hunting of course ). I first want to recall my own instance in elementary school about bullying. I think that the authorities in the public school had the same idea--don't fight back or we'll deal with you. Some teachers can be messed up in the head. They have no idea what that rule does to a young child psychologically. It can create feelings of helplessness and fear of retaliation by going over the bully's head and being a "bigger person" by the teacher's standards instead of dealing with the problem yourself. My point is, kids should fight back, but they should remember the gospel message of "turning the other cheek", in other words, as the context goes, find a way not to fight back with fists, but do it if necessary (Jesus did say sell your cloak for a sword...). Now, pertaining to the gun law, I have this to say: It does sound like a good idea, but it is relying on a principle. That principal is trust that the fellow citizen will not use the firearm improperly. But, there is the fact that other people having firearms will keep the idea of mass murder down because the person will know he/she will get gunned down with the first shot. Now, the other side of it is, why not have weapons at all? Just be rid of them all.. I guess the answer is, killers don't use daddy's shotgun or handgun to kill, they use illegal weapons... My opinion is, the gun law should maybe have been rid of decades, maybe even a century ago... as far as I understand, the DoI had "the right to bear arms" to protect citizens against British subjects from retaliating against the new found country. Oh well. Nothing can be done now. I just pray for peace. If the gun law is needed, it is needed.
HeavenlyCalling Posted May 14, 2007 Posted May 14, 2007 Exaclty!!! Criminals can always get access to guns, the people gun laws deprive are law abiding citizens, and the state is taking away their right to protect themselves and their families. There are even laws in some areas that say if an armed person breaks into your house, you should try to escape, and not defend your home and family!!! I was talking about this with a marine friend a little bit ago. He said he was of the opinion that everyone on a plane should carry a gun. That way, if some one tried to take over the plane it would look something like this terroist pionts gun at people "I am taking over the plane!!" Every one pulles out gun and points it at the terrorist "No, your not" I found it rather funny at the time, but there is some truth in it.
Socrates Posted May 15, 2007 Posted May 15, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1273362' date='May 14 2007, 05:59 PM']... My opinion is, the gun law should maybe have been rid of decades, maybe even a century ago... as far as I understand, the DoI had "the right to bear arms" to protect citizens against British subjects from retaliating against the new found country. Oh well. Nothing can be done now. I just pray for peace. If the gun law is needed, it is needed.[/quote] The right to bear arms guaranteed in the Second Amendment was not a temporary measure - otherwise it would not be written as an Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. It says nothing in there about retaliation of British subjects. And certainly the framers were aware that the British Crown was not the only force of tyranny in the world. The Constitution and the writings of the Founding Fathers had much against a tyranical central government. The framers invisioned a republic made of free, independent, and self-sufficient citizens - not a centralized beauracratic nanny-state busy protecting the citizens from themselves. Those who want to live in such a nanny/police state can . . . go move to Canada.
Norseman82 Posted May 15, 2007 Posted May 15, 2007 [quote name='1337 k4th0l1x0r' post='1251568' date='Apr 21 2007, 11:28 AM']What about the fact that throughout our government schools self-defence is punished exactly the same way as aggression. I'm not talking about retaliation, but genuine self-defence. If someone starts beating up on a kid on a playground he's expected to not fight back but to somehow get a teacher over to stop the fight. If the kid does fight back he may be able to end the pummeling quickly and perhaps send a message to the aggressor, but the punishment for retaliating is that you have to go to therapy and get suspended. I was bullied in elementary school and if I ever pushed back I was called into the principal's office along with the bully and we were dealt with [i]together[/i]. In other words, our physical actions were recognized as having the same level of violence and same intent. This neuters the self-defence instinct in children and they grow up to adulthood thinking that they should not fight back but to let the authorities arrive and they'll take care of it. Fighting back would make them just as much of a violent killer, at least by the moral standards that have been passed down to them by teachers. Fred Thompson has it right. Him, along with Ron Paul, I think are the only two men running for president who believe that government shouldn't and has no right to be trying to solve all our problems other than those that are directly addressed in the constitution. I think they'd make a great ticket together and would absolutely destroy Hillary in the general election.[/quote] THANK YOU! THANK YOU! THANK YOU! You just saved me the trouble of saying the exact same thing. And it certainly doesn't help if a criminal can sue for damages getting hurt while doing something he or she should never have been doing in the first place...like trespassing on public transit right-of-way while drunk and urinating on the third rail.
Tindomiel Posted May 15, 2007 Posted May 15, 2007 (edited) Basically, anti-gun laws are only going to be obeyed by law-abiding citizens. It's moronic to think that a simple law is going to make criminals stop and decide not to do something that they already know jolly well is wrong. On the other hand, it would kind of disturb me to live in an area where people carry guns around. Knowing the tendency of kids like my brothers to get into everything they see, that is. Edited May 15, 2007 by Tindomiel
Red Knight Posted May 18, 2007 Author Posted May 18, 2007 [quote name='Socrates' post='1273408' date='May 14 2007, 08:27 PM']The right to bear arms guaranteed in the Second Amendment was not a temporary measure - otherwise it would not be written as an Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. It says nothing in there about retaliation of British subjects. And certainly the framers were aware that the British Crown was not the only force of tyranny in the world. The Constitution and the writings of the Founding Fathers had much against a tyranical central government. The framers invisioned a republic made of free, independent, and self-sufficient citizens - not a centralized beauracratic nanny-state busy protecting the citizens from themselves. Those who want to live in such a nanny/police state can . . . go move to Canada.[/quote] The framers feared a tyrannical government so much that they amended the constitution to guarantee the people the ability to overthrow said government in the distant future shoulld the need arise. The second amendment is fundamental to the strength of our nation.
Guest T-Bone Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 [quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1273362' date='May 14 2007, 04:59 PM']. Now, pertaining to the gun law, I have this to say: It does sound like a good idea, but it is relying on a principle. That principal is trust that the fellow citizen will not use the firearm improperly. But, there is the fact that other people having firearms will keep the idea of mass murder down because the person will know he/she will get gunned down with the first shot. Now, the other side of it is, why not have weapons at all? Just be rid of them all.. I guess the answer is, killers don't use daddy's shotgun or handgun to kill, they use illegal weapons... My opinion is, the gun law should maybe have been rid of decades, maybe even a century ago... as far as I understand, the DoI had "the right to bear arms" to protect citizens against British subjects from retaliating against the new found country. Oh well. Nothing can be done now. I just pray for peace. If the gun law is needed, it is needed.[/quote] The same can be said for the freedom of speech. It should have been abolished a century ago. It is far to dangerous for ordinary citizens to handle. Only specially trained and screened government representatives should be allowed to write for papers, broadcast news reports, or publicly express opinions.
Paladin D Posted May 18, 2007 Posted May 18, 2007 Fred Thompson has some common sense, I like this guy.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now