Lounge Daddy Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 Excuse me, the politically incorrect headline is: [quote][size=5][b][i]Muslim nuke engineer took software codes, details of control rooms and reactors to Iran[/i][/b][/size] Federal authorities are accusing a former engineer at Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station of [b]illegally taking software codes to Iran and downloading details of control rooms, reactors and designs of the nation's largest nuclear plant. [/b] Officers arrested Mohammad "Mo" Alavi, 49, in Los Angeles this month and charged him with one count of violating a trade embargo, which prohibits Americans from exporting goods and services to Iran. Authorities say there is no evidence to suggest the use of the software was linked to terrorists or the Iranian government, which has clashed with the U.S. over attempts to develop a nuclear program. "The investigation has not led us to believe this information was taken for the purpose of being used by a foreign government or terrorists to attack us," FBI spokeswoman Deborah McCarley told The Arizona Republic on Friday. "This does not appear to be terrorist-related."[/quote] [url="http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/0421nuclear0421.html"]from the Arizona Republic[/url] I love the part where the FBI tells us "it's all o-k, and every thing is cool." Iran is still that country ruled by Islamic radicals that has promised to eliminate the US and Israel, right? But every thing is ok.
Guest T-Bone Posted April 22, 2007 Posted April 22, 2007 This is treason. 30 years ago, this traitor would be shot.
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 Why do you keep posting slanderous propaganda? Time and time again you've been proven wrong, yet you still keep in your stubborn ways. Just a month or so ago, you tried to say that every Muslim that properly follows his/her religion properly was a terrorist, in which once you were proven wrong by nearly everyone that participated in the discussion, you went on to say that they were taking the terrorists side, when really they were standing for truth, not propaganda [in which you later admitted that you never read the Quran before, but that you knew it promoted terrorism, despite not having ever read it] [color="#FF0000"]Authorities say there is no evidence to suggest the use of the software was linked to terrorists or the Iranian government, which has clashed with the U.S. over attempts to develop a nuclear program.[/color] Just becausse the guy's a muslim, you wanna prosecute him? Take the situation of Yusaf Yee, a man that was accused of spying for Syria after Sept 11th [in which he was cleared on all charges]. He was accused just because his wife is Syrian and he made some minor mistakes. His close friend [who was also Syrian] was also charged as a spy for taking pictures of a Gitmo watch tower [in which he wasn't the only person that did it, lots of white people did it without charge]. He did it for soveneer purposes [as soldiers on submarines, etc. do for when they get older to look back]. He was charged strictly for being a Muslim, as this man. We don't know the details, but I can assure you, having been in the military, that he probably wasn't the only person doing it [hence why the FBI concluded that he didn't do it for Iran or others]. Reza
Mateo el Feo Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 Right now, this man is being prosecuted for violating a trade embargo, which is the "law of the land." Passing nuclear power plant designs to someone in Iran isn't "slanderous propoganda." As you may know (if you've been through any security training), espionage is real, and it can do great damage to our country. The US government is vigilant against any breaches of security caused by foreign espionage. If it were a Frenchman, a Russian, a Chinese, an Israeli, or whoever, stealing sensitive information, our government is going to prosecute them. And our [b]free press[/b] is going to report it. It is a bit disconcerting that he may have also leaked information which is related to our national security. That would be treason--not just a trade violation--if it were true.
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 That's not what he's being charged with, he's being charged with taking software that doesn't belong to him, which is classified. It says nothing about him passing it onto other countrys, beyond the fact that the FBI concluded that HE DID NOT GIVE IT TO IRAN AND OTHERS.
Lounge Daddy Posted April 23, 2007 Author Posted April 23, 2007 Rez, your not defending Jihadistan... again? This guy sent details of control rooms, reactors and designs of the nation's largest nuclear plant to Iran. But no problem. Right.
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 [quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1253863' date='Apr 22 2007, 10:45 PM']Rez, your not defending Jihadistan... again? This guy sent details of control rooms, reactors and designs of the nation's largest nuclear plant to Iran. But no problem. Right.[/quote] You don't know that as a fact, you're putting full faith in a propaganda source [Jihadwatch] in which has been proven to be flawed time and time again.
Mateo el Feo Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1253794' date='Apr 23 2007, 12:15 AM']That's not what he's being charged with, he's being charged with taking software that doesn't belong to him, which is classified. It says nothing about him passing it onto other countrys, beyond the fact that the FBI concluded that HE DID NOT GIVE IT TO IRAN AND OTHERS.[/quote]You're reading between the lines and making new facts. 1) As far as "passing it onto other countries," the reports are clear: he was using a computer in Tehran. Therefore, he took the data out of the country. 2) The FBI did not "conclude" anything. They simply admitted that they have no hard evidence to suggest a connection to the Iranian Govt. 3) There is no blanket mention of "others". The FBI said that there was "no indication the plant employee had any terrorist connections." The facts on the ground: this man downloaded "details of plant control rooms and reactors" on a computer in Tehran. If you were a nuclear engineer in his shoes and an ex-employee of a nuclear power plant, can you understand how him accessing your former employer's computers, and downloading sensitive data in Tehran may be considered inappropriate? Hopefully, you can understand why this is much more than inappropriate. I can't see why you feel the need to avoid facts. [quote]You don't know that as a fact, you're putting full faith in a propaganda source [Jihadwatch]in which has been proven to be flawed time and time again.[/quote]Actually, these facts were reported on hundreds of websites (Google counted ~271). Both AP and Reuters reported these facts. Here's Google News' results: [url="http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ned=us&ie=UTF-8&q=iran+nuclear+Alavi"]http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ned=...n+nuclear+Alavi[/url] Jihad Watch "proven flawed"? In this case, Jihad Watch was simply quoting a Reuters article. Though they added few interspersed comments, they had no control over the Reuters article. So, if you have a problem with these facts, it would be more appropriate to question Reuters. Ironically, the most recent big reporting scandal related to Reuters happened last year, when one of their freelances was doctoring photos related to the 2006 war in Lebanon. I'll finish with a quote from Jihad Watch:[quote]For what purpose, exactly, would an individual take software codes, details of control rooms, reactors and designs of the nation's largest nuclear plant to Iran and deliver them to anyone?[/quote]
Mateo el Feo Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1254145' date='Apr 23 2007, 02:09 PM']can't all the codes just be reset or something?[/quote]The "codes" don't affect the operation of the plant, so that's not an issue. As far as his passwords go, I'm sure they've already corrected that.
Lounge Daddy Posted April 25, 2007 Author Posted April 25, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1254145' date='Apr 23 2007, 01:09 PM']can't all the codes just be reset or something?[/quote] Ya. It is the yellow button.
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 25, 2007 Posted April 25, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Mateo el Feo' date='Apr 23 2007, 10:36 AM' post='1254126'] You're reading between the lines and making new facts. [color="#FF0000"]No, I'm reading it for what it is... let me further explain in this post, since I'm aware that my wedding in the last wasn't the best.[/color] 1) As far as "passing it onto other countries," the reports are clear: he was using a computer in Tehran. Therefore, he took the data out of the country. [color="#FF0000"]He did take it out of the country, but he's not charged with the charge that you're suggesting, he's charged with: "He is charged with a single count of violating a trade embargo that prohibits Americans from exporting goods and services to Iran." He's not charged with giving "secretes to Iran" or nothing of that sort. He's simply charged with violating international law that prohibits trade with Iran for Americans. The charge would be no different then if I were to sell Iranians canned foods. During the Sanctions against Iraq, that resulted in over a million children starving to death, there were lots of American relief aids that did the same thing, just with food instead.[/color] 2) The FBI did not "conclude" anything. They simply admitted that they have no hard evidence to suggest a connection to the Iranian Govt. [color="#FF0000"]The FBI did conclude, as it didn't charge him with a crime of giving classified secretes to the Iranian Gov., etc. He was simply charged the same as Americans that sell canned foods to Iranians. No different...[/color] 3) There is no blanket mention of "others". The FBI said that there was "no indication the plant employee had any terrorist connections." [color="#FF0000"]In the original article it went further then that [as you can read above]. Here's a different quote, from one of the sources on your link.[/color] [color="#FF0000"][b]"According to court records, the software is used only for training plant employees, but allowed users access to details on the Palo Verde control rooms and the plant layout. In October, authorities alleged, the software was used to download training materials from Tehran, using a Palo Verde user identification. The FBI said there was no evidence to suggest the software access was linked to the Iranian government, which has clashed with the West over attempts to develop its own nuclear program."[/b][/color] [color="#FF0000"]Notice that this man had relatives in Iran, he worked for a Nuclear company in P. AZ. You don't know if he gave anything to anybody [which is what the trial will examine further]. It simply says that there was information downloaded in Iran, it could have been himself downloading it, as he did work for the company and alot of employees conduct business through the internet long distance, this isn't an abnormal thing. He might not have had permission [which was obvious] but that doesn't prove he's guilty, that simply proves that he did what alot of employees do, which is catch up on some extra work on their off hrs [which is a violation in most companys].[/color] The facts on the ground: this man downloaded "details of plant control rooms and reactors" on a computer in Tehran. [color="#FF0000"]That's true, but you don't know for what purpose. He worked for the company, and could have just been getting caught up on some extra work. Furthermore, as I'd mentioned, he wasn't charged with giving away secretes, treason, spying, nothing... simply selling goods to a country that Americans are prohibited from doing business with...[/color] If you were a nuclear engineer in his shoes and an ex-employee of a nuclear power plant, can you understand how him accessing your former employer's computers, and downloading sensitive data in Tehran may be considered inappropriate? [color="#FF0000"]Thou it's true, the man was a former employee, we still don't know the details, and to speculate is to completely miss the big picture, which is that the man wasn't charged with giving away anything that was classified [in which he could spend life in prison for] but rather for doing business with a country that is under sanctions. He also accessed information that all trainees of the company can access, the question that should be asked is, why is a corperation of that sort, giving ordinary people that sort of security clearance, even after they are not employees?[/color] [color="#FF0000"]In regards to Jihadwatch, they have a particular agenda that they continually push that doesn't reflect the truth most of the time. They twist the story to fit their agenda. Just the title of the website, spells that clear as day. People like D.L. use it to prove "all Muslims are evil" and fuel their hate for their fellow human being... If we're moderate beings, we should see things from the moderate view.[/color] Reza Edited April 25, 2007 by RezaLemmyng
Mateo el Feo Posted April 25, 2007 Posted April 25, 2007 [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1255966' date='Apr 25 2007, 05:36 AM'][color="#FF0000"]He did take it out of the country, but he's not charged with the charge that you're suggesting, he's charged with: "He is charged with a single count of violating a trade embargo that prohibits Americans from exporting goods and services to Iran." He's not charged with giving "secretes to Iran" or nothing of that sort. He's simply charged with violating international law that prohibits trade with Iran for Americans. The charge would be no different then if I were to sell Iranians canned foods. During the Sanctions against Iraq, that resulted in over a million children starving to death, there were lots of American relief aids that did the same thing, just with food instead.[/color][/quote]Why would you say that I am suggesting something, when I explicitly said the opposite? Quoting one of my previous posts:[quote]Right now, this man is being prosecuted for violating a trade embargo...[/quote]As far as "canned foods" being the same, I'm afraid you're wrong. In the case of Iraq (and I would think most US or UN embargos), food and medicine were exempted from the embargo. Quoting wiki (bold is mine):[quote]On August 6, 1990 the U.N. Security Council adopted Resolution 661 which imposed stringent economic sanctions on Iraq, providing for a full trade embargo, [b]excluding medical supplies, food and other items of humanitarian necessity[/b], these to be determined by the Security Council sanctions committee. After the end of the 1991 Gulf War, Iraqi sanctions were linked to removal of Weapons of mass destruction by Resolution 687.[/quote]I don't know how else to convey to you that leaking designs for a nuclear power plant is quite different from sending food to the needy. [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1255966' date='Apr 25 2007, 05:36 AM'][color="#FF0000"]The FBI did conclude, as it didn't charge him with a crime of giving classified secretes to the Iranian Gov., etc. He was simply charged the same as Americans that sell canned foods to Iranians. No different...[/color][/quote]The FBI simply doesn't have evidence. If anything, they concluded that they couldn't fully investigate the situation...I don't think they're holding their breath for the Iranian government to allow the FBI to travel to Tehran to conduct a thorough investigation. [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1255966' date='Apr 25 2007, 05:36 AM']Notice that this man had relatives in Iran, he worked for a Nuclear company in P. AZ. You don't know if he gave anything to anybody [which is what the trial will examine further].[/quote]Going back to my previous point, why would the trial need to examine this further if the FBI had already come to a conclusion? Do you see the inconsistency? [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1255966' date='Apr 25 2007, 05:36 AM']It simply says that there was information downloaded in Iran, it could have been himself downloading it, as he did work for the company and alot of employees conduct business through the internet long distance, this isn't an abnormal thing. He might not have had permission [which was obvious] but that doesn't prove he's guilty, that simply proves that he did what alot of employees do, which is catch up on some extra work on their off hrs [which is a violation in most companys].[/quote]Maybe you're not reading the article. How could he be "catching up on some extra work" if he isn't working there anymore? He had already quit. I promise you, downloading designs related to our nuclear plants in a foreign (and hostile) country is an "abnormal thing." As far as "proving he's guilty," Americans usually hold off on pronouncing guilt or innocence until after a trial. Before a trial, the standard is whether there is probable cause. [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1255966' date='Apr 25 2007, 05:36 AM'][color="#FF0000"]Notice that this man had relatives in Iran, he worked for a Nuclear company in P. AZ. You don't know if he gave anything to anybody [which is what the trial will examine further]. [/color] The facts on the ground: this man downloaded "details of plant control rooms and reactors" on a computer in Tehran. [color="#FF0000"]That's true, but you don't know for what purpose. He worked for the company, and could have just been getting caught up on some extra work. Furthermore, as I'd mentioned, he wasn't charged with giving away secretes, treason, spying, nothing... simply selling goods to a country that Americans are prohibited from doing business with...[/color][/quote] We don't know who he gave the information to. Which is why I quoted the blog:[quote]For what purpose, exactly, would an individual take software codes, details of control rooms, reactors and designs of the nation's largest nuclear plant to Iran and deliver them to anyone?[/quote][quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1255966' date='Apr 25 2007, 05:36 AM']Thou it's true, the man was a former employee, we still don't know the details, and to speculate is to completely miss the big picture, which is that the man wasn't charged with giving away anything that was classified [in which he could spend life in prison for] but rather for doing business with a country that is under sanctions. He also accessed information that all trainees of the company can access, the question that should be asked is, why is a corperation of that sort, giving ordinary people that sort of security clearance, even after they are not employees?[/quote]So you're now saying that we should really focus on blaming the power plant? Well, there was definitely a lapse in security for not immediately invalidating the passwords of an engineer on termination of employment. Regarding "giving ordinary people that sort of security clearance", he was an engineer who presumably worked with the very software that he downloaded. People generally have access to things they use. Regarding "completely missing the big picture," I myself have repeated what the charges were. To really miss the big picture, one would have to ignore the sensitivity of the information he compomised. [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1255966' date='Apr 25 2007, 05:36 AM'][color="#FF0000"]In regards to Jihadwatch, they have a particular agenda that they continually push that doesn't reflect the truth most of the time. They twist the story to fit their agenda. Just the title of the website, spells that clear as day. People like D.L. use it to prove "all Muslims are evil" and fuel their hate for their fellow human being... If we're moderate beings, we should see things from the moderate view. [/color][/quote]I realize you don't like JihadWatch. I had hoped to put this issue to rest by citing the fact that AP, Reuters, and hundreds of news sources reported this crime.
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 26, 2007 Posted April 26, 2007 [quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1256083' date='Apr 25 2007, 10:40 AM']Why would you say that I am suggesting something, when I explicitly said the opposite? [color="#FF0000"]Because you were putting emphisis on the Nuclear situation, rather then on what he's actually being charge of...[/color] Quoting one of my previous posts:As far as "canned foods" being the same, I'm afraid you're wrong. In the case of Iraq (and I would think most US or UN embargos), food and medicine were exempted from the embargo. Quoting wiki (bold is mine):I don't know how else to convey to you that leaking designs for a nuclear power plant is quite different from sending food to the needy. [color="#FF0000"]The canned foods was probably a bad example, so lets say lawn furnature, if an American citizen was accused of selling that to Iran, the charge would be the same. I'm not sure if the Wiki source is accurate, because during the sanctions against Iraq, there were people beinging medical supplies into Iraq that were charged. Also if he were giving away free nuclear designs, etc. to people, he wouldn't be changed.[/color] The FBI simply doesn't have evidence. If anything, they concluded that they couldn't fully investigate the situation...I don't think they're holding their breath for the Iranian government to allow the FBI to travel to Tehran to conduct a thorough investigation. [color="#FF0000"]Obviously the Iranian gov wouldn't allow the FBI to travel to Iran, and it would probably be out of their jurisdiction anyways, but the point is that he isn't being chargd with leaking classified documents, but with the trade situation.[/color] Going back to my previous point, why would the trial need to examine this further if the FBI had already come to a conclusion? Do you see the inconsistency? [color="#FF0000"]No because at the trial, the situation of him leaking classified intelligence could be examined and contribute to his possible jail sentence if there was substantial evidence, even if no physical evidence. Just because there isnt physical evidence, doesn't mean that it isn't something you can be charged with in court.[/color] Maybe you're not reading the article. How could he be "catching up on some extra work" if he isn't working there anymore? He had already quit. [color="#FF0000"]It was just an example of the fact that we don't remotely know the full situation, and that we should focus on what he was being chargeed with, not feed into the propaganda of what he wasnt charged with...[/color] I promise you, downloading designs related to our nuclear plants in a foreign (and hostile) country is an "abnormal thing." [color="#FF0000"]It was information that all trainees at the facility were given. If it was so horrible, then why does the nuclear company in AZ allow previous employees to use their identification to still access the information? You'd think if it was so "classified" that they would have enough common sense to discontinue his employee identification, etc. Nobody is so stupid as allow employees in training to access classified information that could pose a real problem.[/color] As far as "proving he's guilty," Americans usually hold off on pronouncing guilt or innocence until after a trial. Before a trial, the standard is whether there is probable cause. [color="#FF0000"]There would be suspicious of guilt if he were being charged with treason, etc. thou but he wasn't charged with nothing but violating a trade agreement among American citizens, which is completely a diffferent charge.[/color] We don't know who he gave the information to. Which is why I quoted the blog:So you're now saying that we should really focus on blaming the power plant? Well, there was definitely a lapse in security for not immediately invalidating the passwords of an engineer on termination of employment. [color="#FF0000"]It's the powerplant that was giving the information to every trainee in their facility. You'd think that if this information was so valuable, that it would be protected by more then just a single password of a trainee wouldn't you think?[/color] Regarding "giving ordinary people that sort of security clearance", he was an engineer who presumably worked with the very software that he downloaded. People generally have access to things they use. [color="#FF0000"]If it's "super classified" material thou, the second that he is not employed there, it changes. I'd never heard of such a security leak as this simplly because it doesn't happen. That's why the whole situation is very fishy.[/color] Regarding "completely missing the big picture," I myself have repeated what the charges were. To really miss the big picture, one would have to ignore the sensitivity of the information he compomised. [color="#FF0000"]Surely but you put so much emphisis on what the charges were not, rather then what they are... the situation isn't the supposed classified nuclear software/passwords but him violating the trade laws. The whole situation of what materials he gave was just the medias way of putting emphisis on what wasn't important to this case. If it were important, then the FBI would have charged him with it, but it wasn't as the FBI concluded. There's lots of people being charged with the same crime as him, why aren't we reading about them? Because the media has a hidden agenda. I know lots of articles that are just as bias as this one from the other side of the spectrum, but if I were to post those people would be yelling "this is bad journalism with a particular agenda of..." what makes this article different?[/color] I realize you don't like JihadWatch. I had hoped to put this issue to rest by citing the fact that AP, Reuters, and hundreds of news sources reported this crime. [color="#FF0000"]No because even you mentioned that Jihad Watch added to the article themselves.[/color][/quote]
Mateo el Feo Posted April 26, 2007 Posted April 26, 2007 I guess I'll just sum things up by saying, Al Capone was only convicted of tax evasion. Yet, he was newsworthy for totally different, un-prosecuted crimes.
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 26, 2007 Posted April 26, 2007 [quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1256514' date='Apr 25 2007, 08:39 PM']I guess I'll just sum things up by saying, Al Capone was only convicted of tax evasion. Yet, he was newsworthy for totally different, un-prosecuted crimes.[/quote] Apples and Oranges...
Mateo el Feo Posted April 26, 2007 Posted April 26, 2007 [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1256609' date='Apr 26 2007, 01:37 AM']Apples and Oranges...[/quote]Why?
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 26, 2007 Posted April 26, 2007 [quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1256614' date='Apr 25 2007, 10:53 PM']Why?[/quote] Read about Al more indepth, everything that involved him and then compare it to this man, that had no corruption [police paid up, etc]. It's clearly apples and oranges.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now