KnightofChrist Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 (edited) [url="http://www.drudgereport.com/flash1.htm"]rate Marine in Ramadi Responds to 'War is Lost' Message[/url] Mon Apr 23 2007 13:07:1 ET From PatDollard.com: This Email To Me, Harry, And America, Direct From A Grunt On The Front Lines Of Ramadi, Is Just Hours Old. [img]http://www.drudgereport.com/5.jpg[/img] Corporal Tyler Rock, 1/6 Charlie Company, on the left, at my old home, Camp Hurricane Point, Ramadi. A view from OP Horea, “Most Dangerous Spot On Earth”, Downtown Ramadi. I no **** watched several terrorists die, on several different days, on this small strip of asphalt. We also took many IED strikes on it. This photo is from Corporal Rock. Today, from Corporal Tyler Rock in an outpost in downtown Ramadi. His first sentence is in response to an email from me: “yeah i know how you feel. its going to be very weird leaving this place and going back to america. weve been here for almost an entire year and have lived in the center of it the whole time. its crazy that when we got here it was so hectic and now its calmed down so much. so it was awesome to be able to see that turn out. yeah news worth reporting…. well ramadi was once dubbed by everyone as the worst city in the world. but we have done such a great job here that all the families in the area have worked with us on driving out the insurgency and that we work directly with the IA and the IP’s. the city has been cleaned up so well that the IP’s do most of the patrols now and we go out with them to hand out candy and toys to the children. you can tell that the people want us here to protect them from the thugs and gangs (insurgents). granted they would rather have peace and quit but they know that if we arent here they will be thrown around by the insurgents. a good example is this one mission we did. long story short we got blown up in multiple buildings and had to run into a families house. i spent my christmas holidays covered in ash from the mortar fire and the IED’s, sleeping under a dirty rug i found in the house. everyone was sleeping way to close for comfort just to stay warm. anyways. a family was there and they obviously didnt want us there. atleast at first. the daughters were very sick so our corpsman treated them. they didnt have electricity so we got them a generator for power, they were cold so we got them gas heaters, we got them food and water and then we gave them $500. by the end of the week long visit with them we were drinking tea with them. when we left we cleaned their house better than it was when we got there. i even have pictures with the family. they told us that they liked marines and they would help us as much as they could and they gave us some information on the insurgents in the area. we ended up catching a HUGE target down the road from there house because of it. [img]http://www.drudgereport.com/7.jpg[/img] Part Of A Weapons Cache Seized Recently In Fields Next To What Used To Be An Insurgent Claimed Hospital. Thanks To 1/6, The Insurgents Don’t Claim It Anymore. Zarqawi Had Reportedly Been Treated There. yeah and i got a qoute for that douche harry reid. these families need us here. obviously he has never been in iraq. or atleast the area worth seeing. the parts where insurgency is rampant and the buildings are blown to pieces. we need to stay here and help rebuild. if iraq didnt want us here then why do we have IP’s voluntering everyday to rebuild their cities. and working directly with us too. same with the IA’s. it smells of elderberries that iraqi’s have more patriotism for a country that has turned to complete **** more than the people in america who drink starbucks everyday. we could leave this place and say we are sorry to the terrorists. and then we could wait for 3,000 more american civilians to die before we say “hey thats not nice” again. and the sad thing is after we WIN this war. people like him will say he was there for us the whole time. and for messages back home. i have a wife back home who is going through a tough time. i just cant wait to be back home and see everyone. haha and i cant wait to go back home and get some starbucks. i love it when those people serve me. hahaha” Edited April 23, 2007 by KnightofChrist
Sojourner Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 I got a similar e-mail from my brother (a USMC Sgt.) who was stationed in Iraq for six months and will be going back in a year for another six months. He spent most of his time at a base near Fallujah but was also in Ramadi for a while. I asked him what he thought about all the anti-war talk and he sent the following e-mail: [quote]No it doesn't really bother me. Most of the people who oppose the war get their info from people who support their view, thus they are tragically uninformed. You can't make a judgement on something like this unless you are here and actually go out and see people here. These people have a [poopy]system that was run by an [person] who likes to see people suffer. They lived with this system for how many years? Yeah this stuff doesn't freakin' happen overnight. It doesn't take 5 years to dismantle and rebuild what took decades/centuries to build. While I don't agree with all the policies coming down the pipes, I do agree that someone has to fix this place. Someone has to protect the people here while those changes are happening. That would be us...Why?! Because every other country out there is full of WISHY-WASHY [KITTY CATS] that are too afraid to take some initiative. They would rather wait and argue about it because it is not their problem. Yeah politicians [are awful]. Anyways...get me all worked up why don't ya. I don't take offense because if we hadn't done something it wouldn't just be Sept 11. There would be many days in many months. Our role here will never be fully appreciated here, but I know I am doing what is right. These terror cells were just sitting pretty with all sorts of government support out here. Now we've disrupted their system. Yes they are still here and operating, but to a lesser degree than in Saddam's time. Once these people have a functional government, and active police force, and an effective army they can police their own so we don't have to. People who don't approve need to shut up or put on a flak and Kevlar get out here for six months and see for themselves. That's my $1.39 (I tend to ramble...costs more than $.02) lol[/quote] Not to denigrate the role these men and women play over there -- I am 100 percent supportive of our servicefolks, and am very very proud of the work my brother and so many others like him have done and will do -- but just because good things happen because we're there doesn't mean it is right for us to be there to start out with. Needless to say this is not a topic I brought up when hanging out with my brother after he got back, and frankly probably will not bring it up to him for a while, if ever. He can still kill me 13 different ways with his bare hands ...
toledo_jesus Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1254215' date='Apr 23 2007, 03:48 PM']I got a similar e-mail from my brother (a USMC Sgt.) who was stationed in Iraq for six months and will be going back in a year for another six months. He spent most of his time at a base near Fallujah but was also in Ramadi for a while. I asked him what he thought about all the anti-war talk and he sent the following e-mail: Not to denigrate the role these men and women play over there -- I am 100 percent supportive of our servicefolks, and am very very proud of the work my brother and so many others like him have done and will do -- but just because good things happen because we're there doesn't mean it is right for us to be there to start out with. Needless to say this is not a topic I brought up when hanging out with my brother after he got back, and frankly probably will not bring it up to him for a while, if ever. He can still kill me 13 different ways with his bare hands ... [/quote] your brother sounds awesome.
Akalyte Posted April 23, 2007 Posted April 23, 2007 My nephew is stationed in Korea and wants to go to Iraq..He said he really wants to go and help those people out..
KnightofChrist Posted April 24, 2007 Author Posted April 24, 2007 [img]http://ibdeditorials.com/IMAGES/CARTOONS/toon022007.gif[/img]
Lounge Daddy Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 Wow - I dig the cartoon. The only thing that the current war has in common with 'Nam is the liberals in congress politicizing the war to the point of cutting funding to our troops and abandoning (retreating)
Sojourner Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 Questioning the validity of our presence in Iraq does not in any way reflect on support for the troops. Saying that people questioning military presence in Iraq in some way do not support our soldiers (or are "stabbing them in the back") is a political ploy designed to dissuade attention from the issues at hand. It's not constructive to the discussion in any way, shape, or form.
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 Just because you don't support the war, and support a withdraw doesn't mean that you're "stabbing" the soldiers in the back. Rather most people that I know, that support a withdraw support the soldiers over there 100%, which is why they support a withdraw, so we don't lose more. Being a former soldier, that still talks with service men and women quite frequently, I can say that there's mass amounts on both sides of the spectrum. There's mass amounts that want to get out and there's mass amounts that want to stay the course. Most that I know, don't support having gone to war to begin with, but in regards to weather the military can straighten the situation out over there, is inbetween. I met one man [who's name I'll keep confidential] that said that it depended on the individual commanders on the ground. He said that some commanders treat the Iraqi citizens like sh*t, as if everyone's a terrorist, and those commanders develop a horrible reputation for the military and don't help the situation but cause the violence to increase, while other commanders are very good at helping the people understand that they're trying to help and make the situation better. A different soldier had told me that part of the problem that they had with the Iraqi forces running from [the bad guys] was that originally most of the Iraqi policemen and soldiers were only give 5 bullets [in the particular area that he was stationed] and told that everytime they fired a bullet, it was going to come out of their paycheck [it was equal to 5$ USD]. Therefore those particular policement/soldiers would rather run away then have to pay $5 a bullet. This was solved, when his commander told them if they were willing to fight for their own country, he'd give them as many bullets as they wanted. In the situation of the civil war [in which some of you disagree, that's your choice], some military service men have said that they know that some of the man/women that are part of the Iraqi police/Iraqi Army are infact playing both sides of the fence. Some of them are not only part of the Iraqi Police but also part of the Mahdi Army, and so allow alot of senseless murders and sectarian violence to go unpunished. This is the most difficult part to get solved. Reza
Ash Wednesday Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 Before this all turns into a debate -- here's a report from a Marine that is my particular favorite: [quote]Most Surreal Moment - Watching Marines arrive at my detention facility and unload a truck load of flex-cuffed midgets. 26 to be exact. I had put the word out earlier in the day to the Marines in Fallujah that we were looking for Bad Guy X, who was described as a midget. Little did I know that Fallujah was home to a small community of midgets, who banded together for support since they were considered as social outcasts. The Marines were anxious to get back to the midget colony to bring in the rest of the midget suspects, but I called off the search, figuring Bad Guy X was long gone on his short legs after seeing his companions rounded up by the giant infidels.[/quote] My prayers are with the troops. Carry on...
Sojourner Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1254899' date='Apr 24 2007, 05:04 AM']Before this all turns into a debate -- here's a report from a Marine that is my particular favorite:[/quote]
Paladin D Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 You can be against the war, but how can you say you support the troops if you're [b]cutting funding for them[/b]? Now the Army will have to be cutting back on services because of this.
Sojourner Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 [quote name='Paladin D' post='1254978' date='Apr 24 2007, 09:42 AM']You can be against the war, but how can you say you support the troops if you're [b]cutting funding for them[/b]? Now the Army will have to be cutting back on services because of this.[/quote] Cutting funding for the war does not mean withdrawing support for the troops. One does not necessarily follow the other. Cutting funding for the war sends the message that the objective or the reason for being there is improper. It doesn't mean that the job troops have done is bad, or that they want troops to be vulnerable to injury or attack. Not that pulling out now is necessarily a wise idea. But I think that it is a big mistake to equate support for the war and support for troops. Accusing people who don't support the war (and want to cut funding) of not supporting troops is a below-the-belt attack that does nothing to further the actual analysis of the rightness or wrongness of us being in Iraq.
KnightofChrist Posted April 24, 2007 Author Posted April 24, 2007 I respectfully disagree. Congress stripping support for the duty of the troops while still supporting the troops themselves sound very much like an oxymoron. Cutting school funding has always been seen and not supporting students. There is no difference in this case. It would be like saying a city is burning (Iraq) and I support firefighters, but I do not support their job of putting out fires in that city, and I want to cut off their water supply and for the firemen to come home. Do I support the firefighters with this outlook? Not completely. Because I'm against them doing their duty. Do I support the people of that city, no not really because I would allow the flames to destroy them, or take them over. The "firefighters" are putting out the fires in Iraq, we my disagree of what route they took to get to the fire, and the way they are putting out the flames but they are there now, cutting off their "water supply" would not support them, it would embolden the enemy, undermined the duty of firefighting, and again betray the Iraqis as we did in the first gulf war. I apologize if any are offended, this is not meant to offend, but only state the reality of the issue.
Sojourner Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 Congress has the power of the purse in matters of military appropriation (Constitutionally given) as a check on the executive branch. (Article 1 Section 8, if you'd like to check). Cutting funding in Iraq (again, while not the best of ideas) is not a reflection on the job the troops are doing, or on the troops themselves, but on the policies enacted by the executive branch. School funding is not, I don't think, an adequate analogy, at least not as you've drawn it. Perhaps if you suggested that cutting funding was a reflection on teachers it might be closer. I think your firefighter analogy is more appropriate. I don't know how many fires you've witnessed. I've been on the scene at several over the years, and dated a firefighter for a while. There are times that firefighters need to be in the midst of the fire, and times that the chief recognizes that the firefighters are not doing any good being inside and that the situation is a lost cause. Sometimes the decision must be made to let it go, and turn your attention to other concerns -- that decision is made in part based on concern for the well-being of the firefighters. Now, if you want to argue that the firefighters are still doing good, and that the structure is salvageable, then go for it. But don't assume that the people arguing to pull the firefighters out of the situation are doing so without regard for the well-being of the firefighters. Sometimes when you get into a fire that's much bigger than you'd anticipated, the best way to support the guys on the front lines is to pull them back and let the fire burn itself out.
Ash Wednesday Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 Wouldn't it be better if they resolved the issue of cutting back the number of troops BEFORE cutting funding? I might be misinformed about this issue, but I guess it seems to me that as long as there are troops there, they should be well equipped. This coming from someone who didn't agree with how we went about war in the first place but am not cool with the idea of sending them to battle without sufficient funding.
Sojourner Posted April 24, 2007 Posted April 24, 2007 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1255235' date='Apr 24 2007, 01:06 PM']Wouldn't it be better if they resolved the issue of cutting back the number of troops BEFORE cutting funding? I might be misinformed about this issue, but I guess it seems to me that as long as there are troops there, they should be well equipped. This coming from someone who didn't agree with how we went about war in the first place but am not cool with the idea of sending them to battle without sufficient funding. [/quote] I think (and please correct me if I'm wrong) but the idea behind cutting funding is not that troops in battle would not have the appropriate equipment, but that they would be pulled out altogether and brought home. Funding would be cut for continuing with offensive actions. And for the record: I think pulling out now is not a good idea. I think our reasoning for being there is suspect, and we've gone about developing policies to achieve our "objectives" (whatever those may be) in such half-butt fashion that we've caused as many problems as we've solved. But, I think by pulling out now that we only make the situation worse. Iraq descends into civil war, the tenuous balance in the region becomes even more tenuous, etc. I think we need to come up with clearly articulated objectives and steps to reach those objectives, and stick it out and do it right. But, I also think that introducing the whole "people who want to cut funding are not supporting the troops" is a specious argument and does nothing to further the discussion on how we're going to conduct ourselves from here on out.
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 25, 2007 Posted April 25, 2007 Their actually not technically cutting "support" [funding] for the troops but cutting funding for the war and Mr. Bush. Right after Sept 11th, Mr. Bush went to congress and asked for what before there were even troops in Iraq? He asked for funding for his war. Even if they didn't give him funding, he was going to try and put the troops in Iraq anyways, so was it congress that cut support for the troops or was it congress that cut support for Mr. Bush and the war? Congress didn't interact directly with the troops, so support was cut for the war. It was donald rumsfeld that said to the troops directly, "you don't go into war with what you wish you had, but you go to war with what you got..." [in direct reference to troops addressinig the issue of their lack amount of equipment, which resulted in mass amounts of casualties, even after Congress approved Mr. Bush's funding].
Maggyie Posted April 25, 2007 Posted April 25, 2007 My brother is a Marine too! Not active duty yet, still in school. If the cut in funding does in fact actually result in a cut-back in programs and equipment, etc, etc, isn't it ultimately an expression of a lack of support? I mean, of course I understand that no one intends to send that message. But frankly, money usually does equal support. To continue the firefighter analogy, when the city council cuts funding for overtime and benefits, the boys in the firehouses don't get a "we disagree with the way your chief fights fires!" message. They hear, "we don't value your work."
RezaMikhaeil Posted April 25, 2007 Posted April 25, 2007 [quote name='Maggie' post='1255615' date='Apr 24 2007, 07:11 PM']My brother is a Marine too! Not active duty yet, still in school. If the cut in funding does in fact actually result in a cut-back in programs and equipment, etc, etc, isn't it ultimately an expression of a lack of support? I mean, of course I understand that no one intends to send that message. But frankly, money usually does equal support. To continue the firefighter analogy, when the city council cuts funding for overtime and benefits, the boys in the firehouses don't get a "we disagree with the way your chief fights fires!" message. They hear, "we don't value your work."[/quote] That's an "apples and oranges" situation. Firefighters are not occupying a different geographical area but rather are improving their own communities. Their job description also is completely different. Mr. Bush was going to put the troops in Iraq, with or without support, so who's putting the troops there without the proper gear? Donald Rumsfeld [even while having funding] made it clear that the troops didn't have the proper gear but said that you don't go to war with the equipment that you'd like but with the equipment that you have... Reza
Maggyie Posted April 25, 2007 Posted April 25, 2007 [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1255698' date='Apr 24 2007, 11:16 PM']That's an "apples and oranges" situation. Firefighters are not occupying a different geographical area but rather are improving their own communities. Their job description also is completely different. Mr. Bush was going to put the troops in Iraq, with or without support, so who's putting the troops there without the proper gear? Donald Rumsfeld [even while having funding] made it clear that the troops didn't have the proper gear but said that you don't go to war with the equipment that you'd like but with the equipment that you have... Reza[/quote] Oh, I completely agree with you about them being sent in without all that they needed! But it doesn't help to have Congress mess it up for them, too. They didn't have what they needed in the first place, and now we're going to cut an artery? I don't care whether it's the Administration or the Congress that does it. It doesn't seem right at all...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now